Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he’s choosing to be homeless and it’s right that he doesn’t get a housing association property?

288 replies

Casparr · 21/01/2024 18:28

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

Man works 50hrs a week. At minimum wage that’s 27k and about £1900 take-home each month. He sleeps at friends’ houses or his ex-partner’s, presumably for free. Why can’t he just get a room in a house share (under £600 a month in Glasgow) and save up a deposit for a flat?

Daniel Thomson

I'm working but homeless and bottom of the housing list

A working father finds himself "sofa surfing" amid social housing shortages in Scotland's biggest city.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:36

The fact that they are now called the Wheatley Group and have taken the words "housing association" out of their name entirely tells you all you need to know

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:34

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 21/01/2024 22:33

Perhaps this relative availability of social housing is exactly why Glasgow’s had such an influx of refugees?

Yes. In the past Glasgow has had a very high availability of social housing. At one point over 50% of the rented sector.

This was, indeed, the rational for the home office "dispensing" asylum seekers to Glasgow from 2014 onwards.

This was controversial at the time because most refugees prefer to live close to their own ethnic/national communities and to the services that they need. (Be that as general as a Halal butcher or as specialist as counsellors for victims of torture).
And Glasgow at the time (while not by any means a monoculture) was not quite so racially mixed as some of the places asylum seekers were being dispersed from.

Nonetheless I would consider it a success. People have mostly integrated well with each other and the worst fears of racial tensions have not come to pass.

Since then the housing situation has deteriorated badly. Due to steady demolition of social housing by the largest housing association, the Wheatley Group (previously GHA).

Thanks. This context makes the article make sense!

OP posts:
İcantusethat · 21/01/2024 22:33

Well I also feel sorry for the man in the article. Housing is a difficult issue to solve.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 21/01/2024 22:33

Perhaps this relative availability of social housing is exactly why Glasgow’s had such an influx of refugees?

Yes. In the past Glasgow has had a very high availability of social housing. At one point over 50% of the rented sector.

This was, indeed, the rational for the home office "dispensing" asylum seekers to Glasgow from 2014 onwards.

This was controversial at the time because most refugees prefer to live close to their own ethnic/national communities and to the services that they need. (Be that as general as a Halal butcher or as specialist as counsellors for victims of torture).
And Glasgow at the time (while not by any means a monoculture) was not quite so racially mixed as some of the places asylum seekers were being dispersed from.

Nonetheless I would consider it a success. People have mostly integrated well with each other and the worst fears of racial tensions have not come to pass.

Since then the housing situation has deteriorated badly. Due to steady demolition of social housing by the largest housing association, the Wheatley Group (previously GHA).

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:32

@Macaroni46 people are not going to spend money on decorating a place if they are going to be made to move in a couple of years

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:32

İcantusethat · 21/01/2024 22:30

@Casparr Glasgow has "such an influx of refugees" because it is an Asylum Dispersal Area. Government policy.

And I am glad to say that they are welcomed by local people:

https://www.refuweegee.co.uk/

Well the downside of that is clearly that young men like the one in the article can no longer easily access social housing.

Personally I think that refugees should be prioritised over working single men, but you can see from this thread that not everyone does.

OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:31

@Macaroni46 The demolition and gentrification is more than playing its part Every time i see posts like yours i assume the poster is benefitting from these things in some way.

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:31

Divastrout · 21/01/2024 22:22

Wow??? Actual fucking Wow????
What have I just read there???
OP give your head a wobble.
WOW??

A PP said that Glasgow’s the place where the majority of Scotland’s share of refugees have been sent to be housed. It makes logical sense that places with shorter waiting lists would receive more refugees (whether this is actually policy I have no idea).

Don’t see what’s controversial about that?

OP posts:
İcantusethat · 21/01/2024 22:30

@Casparr Glasgow has "such an influx of refugees" because it is an Asylum Dispersal Area. Government policy.

And I am glad to say that they are welcomed by local people:

https://www.refuweegee.co.uk/

Macaroni46 · 21/01/2024 22:28

OhpoorMe · 21/01/2024 19:16

I there are a huge number of people who could afford to not be in council housing - you see posters on here all the time "I don't want to private rent as it's expensive". Meanwhile there's people trapped on the streets and in temp accommodation. The system is fucked

This. I don't understand why council tenants are not means tested every 3 years and made to move on if they no longer need a council property. Certainly the rules where a property can pass onto a relative seems wrong to me (not sure if that's still the case).

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:26

Posted by a ex housing officer on another thread

Criteria can also change. I know of one HA that found they had insufficient demand for their over-65s housing (flats and bungalows) while they were struggling to provide accommodation for younger single adults with alcohol and drug addictions and ex-offenders. They changed the criteria to "solve" the problem. It was an absolute disaster for the elderly tenants

Not just "nice" young adults either, alcoholics, drug addicts and ex-offenders, some straight from prison

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 21/01/2024 22:24

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/01/2024 22:03

Are you seriously suggesting he should have priority over somebody disabled or ill and homeless because he's fit and healthy?

Where did I suggest that? I didn't say anything remotely like that so I'm not sure where you've plucked that from. I said that he shouldn't be at the very bottom of the pile just because he's working.

Divastrout · 21/01/2024 22:22

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:09

I think this must be a regional thing. @unlimiteddilutingjuice has pointed out that until recently, this man would have swiftly got social housing. This is absolutely not the case where I am, or anywhere I’ve lived, and hasn’t been within living memory.

Perhaps this relative availability of social housing is exactly why Glasgow’s had such an influx of refugees?

Wow??? Actual fucking Wow????
What have I just read there???
OP give your head a wobble.
WOW??

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 21/01/2024 22:21

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 22:11

Well the examples I gave my friend was kicked out of her home after her husband died with her 2 children. Friend works so is contributing. I don't think we should see children on the street? I think they should go above him.

Other example - young woman has a mental breakdown and is made homeless after her child is put into foster care. She was also a LAC. So incredibly vulnerable. Can't get her Dzc back without a home. I think she should go above him.

OK but no one said that he should be above them, did they? No one is saying he should be given priority over a child. There are people who ahould rightly be given priority over him ie severely disabled, children etc.

What I said was that it's unfair that he is at the very bottom of the heap because he works and doesn't have 'issues' ie substance misuse.

Your two examples make absolutely no difference to the fact that he shouldn't be at the very bottom of the list for housing.

MissingMoominMamma · 21/01/2024 22:17

Summerhillsquare · 21/01/2024 19:03

How did we get to a point where we are picking apart the life of a young working man because he has the temerity to complain about the utterly broken housing market?! In what shitty world should an adult not be entitled to a home of their own?

Exactly! 👏 👏

BabaBarrio · 21/01/2024 22:15

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:11

Everyone who wants help should be helped. But there has to be a priority order.

The only reason there has to be a priority order is because there isn’t enough social housing. If there were enough, there would be no need to ration it and no need for priority orders.

Sort of like the world wide infamous NHS waiting list each with its own priority orders.

Priority orders are a symptom of a public service in crisis.

Gonnawashmymouthout · 21/01/2024 22:13

If he’s an involved father, he will want to live very near his ex and his daughter to be involved in her day to day life (schools pick ups, drop offs etc)

I have a family member in a similar situation in Glasgow. And you know what, it pisses me off. In the part of Glasgow he lives in there are literally no private rentals. Last time I saw one last year is was £800pcm for a 2 bed ex council. And it was a rough area.

so these young men go out and earn money and pay tax, but aren’t entitled to social housing? Seriously, fuck off

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:13

@BabaBarrio
In 1991 (back in the mists of time before i met DH when i was 18 and still living with my parents) i went with a friend to the local council office who needed to find a flat. She was single. I still remember what was said to her all these years later. "Im sorry but there arent many available at the moment if you had a baby things would be different but we cant help you at the moment.

I met DH in 1992 and we moved into a small bedsit and lived there for two years and 3 months before we moved to the one bedroom flat where we are now.....

Single men WERE more likely to be housed than single women or couples (all this is without children) It was assumed that women would meet a man and move in with him. (this obvs meant a higher risk of abuse.

The final straw was when my best friends ex beat her yet again She finally gave him the boot and this violent druggie was rehoused within THREE DAYS. While women were being told Sorry we cant help unless you have a child

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 22:11

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 21/01/2024 21:55

I'd argue that he's directly contributing by way of his taxes towards council housing whereas not all of the ones you've mentioned are. However, if for arguments sake, we say all of them, including him, are 'contributing', then why is he the one at the bottom of the pile? Why is the one who is working hard the one that gets shat on when it comes to needing a little help?

Well the examples I gave my friend was kicked out of her home after her husband died with her 2 children. Friend works so is contributing. I don't think we should see children on the street? I think they should go above him.

Other example - young woman has a mental breakdown and is made homeless after her child is put into foster care. She was also a LAC. So incredibly vulnerable. Can't get her Dzc back without a home. I think she should go above him.

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:11

BabaBarrio · 21/01/2024 22:09

That is horrible. They should be helped.

Everyone who wants help should be helped. But there has to be a priority order.

OP posts:
BabaBarrio · 21/01/2024 22:09

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 22:01

Young women are not helped by my city council. Only if they have children who live with them.

That is horrible. They should be helped.

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:09

I think this must be a regional thing. @unlimiteddilutingjuice has pointed out that until recently, this man would have swiftly got social housing. This is absolutely not the case where I am, or anywhere I’ve lived, and hasn’t been within living memory.

Perhaps this relative availability of social housing is exactly why Glasgow’s had such an influx of refugees?

OP posts:
Workworkandmoreworknow · 21/01/2024 22:05

snowmobileon · 21/01/2024 21:36

Why does he need to be on the housing list as a working man ?

Presumably because his low paid job just isn’t cutting it with private rents? Because he wants somewhere safe he can take his child to?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/01/2024 22:03

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 21/01/2024 21:55

I'd argue that he's directly contributing by way of his taxes towards council housing whereas not all of the ones you've mentioned are. However, if for arguments sake, we say all of them, including him, are 'contributing', then why is he the one at the bottom of the pile? Why is the one who is working hard the one that gets shat on when it comes to needing a little help?

Are you seriously suggesting he should have priority over somebody disabled or ill and homeless because he's fit and healthy?

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 22:01

BabaBarrio · 21/01/2024 21:45

Women can also be sex trafficked, so younger women are usually a higher priority than older women and all men for government homeless aid as they are more vulnerable.

Young women are not helped by my city council. Only if they have children who live with them.