Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he’s choosing to be homeless and it’s right that he doesn’t get a housing association property?

288 replies

Casparr · 21/01/2024 18:28

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

Man works 50hrs a week. At minimum wage that’s 27k and about £1900 take-home each month. He sleeps at friends’ houses or his ex-partner’s, presumably for free. Why can’t he just get a room in a house share (under £600 a month in Glasgow) and save up a deposit for a flat?

Daniel Thomson

I'm working but homeless and bottom of the housing list

A working father finds himself "sofa surfing" amid social housing shortages in Scotland's biggest city.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TempestTost · 21/01/2024 23:58

Divastrout · 21/01/2024 22:56

There's really nothing controversial about that. The issue is that homelessness goes right back to the Thatcher years when social housing was sold for Tory votes. Since then no government has at all invested in social housing on any scale at all. We all hear the talk especially at election time.
But there is still a lack of affordable social housing and BTL landlords are sometimes bowing out.
The issue of Asylum seekers etc really does not impact on lack of affordable housing as such.
I live in Scotland and my town has had an influx of Asylum seekers and believe me they are not generally receiving social housing.
Rather as the government has failed to provide social housing we are seeing increasingly people being put in temporary accommodation sometimes for years.
These people Are Not Asylum seekers but people who may or may not with sometimes disabilities or down on their luck.
So your leap to Glasgow Asylum seekers is still WOW!!

I'm not sure this is totally true.

What is true is that housing has not kept up. Whether council owned or otherwise, and there are various approaches that can work, clearly it is not working.

And it isn't just down to Thatcher, in the sense that this seems to be a problem across many countries, even places where in the past there wasn't the tradition of publicly owned housing that the UK has. Housing isn't keeping up even with domestic populations. Canada, NZ, the US, Australia, all have the same problem.

However, adding thousands more people, in a single city, besides the domestic population is of course going to necessitate even more housing and cause more of a pinch.

I am very skeptical of governments now saying this isn't so. Canada has had the same approach for years, accepting a very large number of migrants of different kinds (refugees, economic migrants, family members, students) and when people suggested it was contributing to housing problems, they were called racists. It now turns out that several years ago the PM received an official report warning that immigration levels were going to cause a housing crisis.

Dissimilitude · 21/01/2024 23:47

Ap24 · 21/01/2024 23:41

I agree there's a lack of housing but who would build this amount of houses and flood the market? Labour, land and materials are expensive. Companies want the max return on investments. As a business modal it makes no sense.

I can't see the government deciding to build that amount of affordable homes because it wouldn't be popular with voters. So much personal wealth is tied up in property, people don't want to pay increased taxes etc.

That's without even considering the land issues, lack of trained tradesmen etc.

There are many countries in the world which don't have this problem. It is largely a planning issue in the U.K. which could be tackled by a determined government.

You are correct in that there are plenty losers in a world with more housing. But it still needs doing.

A price crash would be bad. A well engineered, long period of flat prices against rising incomes, on the other hand, is what’s needed. And that is very doable.

Ap24 · 21/01/2024 23:41

Dissimilitude · 21/01/2024 23:18

The distinct lack of social housing is just a subset of the underlying problem - a distinct lack of housing, full stop.

Every problem is downstream of this. If we build lots and lots of housing:

Rent gets cheaper.
Private buying gets cheaper.
Councils can buy social stock more cheaply.
etc etc.

Build. More. Houses.

I agree there's a lack of housing but who would build this amount of houses and flood the market? Labour, land and materials are expensive. Companies want the max return on investments. As a business modal it makes no sense.

I can't see the government deciding to build that amount of affordable homes because it wouldn't be popular with voters. So much personal wealth is tied up in property, people don't want to pay increased taxes etc.

That's without even considering the land issues, lack of trained tradesmen etc.

Casparr · 21/01/2024 23:28

Divastrout · 21/01/2024 22:56

There's really nothing controversial about that. The issue is that homelessness goes right back to the Thatcher years when social housing was sold for Tory votes. Since then no government has at all invested in social housing on any scale at all. We all hear the talk especially at election time.
But there is still a lack of affordable social housing and BTL landlords are sometimes bowing out.
The issue of Asylum seekers etc really does not impact on lack of affordable housing as such.
I live in Scotland and my town has had an influx of Asylum seekers and believe me they are not generally receiving social housing.
Rather as the government has failed to provide social housing we are seeing increasingly people being put in temporary accommodation sometimes for years.
These people Are Not Asylum seekers but people who may or may not with sometimes disabilities or down on their luck.
So your leap to Glasgow Asylum seekers is still WOW!!

What you mention is a national issue. As I’ve said earlier in other parts of the UK (mine for instance) a man in the same scenario would be given the same response, and would have been for decades. Single young working man is at the bottom of the list for social housing is a obvious fact here, not a news story. I don’t expect anyone in his shoes in the south of England would even bother to try, to be honest.

As @unlimiteddilutingjuice points out, the man in the article has grown up in a place where, not so long ago, a man in his situation could expect to be housed. Now he can’t. That’s why it’s newsworthy to him (and probably other Glaswegians).

What seems to have changed is the main housing association demolishing properties, reducing stock, at the same time as there being a increase - into a very specific regional area - of refugees who are eligible to apply for that limited stock (@unlimiteddilutingjuice mentions two thousand incoming). I’m sure there are other factors which could be included too such as rising divorce rates or long Covid or major companies closing down or the death of the high street.

I’m not saying ‘refugees are stealing all our houses!!!!’ but you can’t deny it’s likely to be one factor that’s impacted the likelihood of the man in the article getting the property he wants.

OP posts:
Dissimilitude · 21/01/2024 23:18

The distinct lack of social housing is just a subset of the underlying problem - a distinct lack of housing, full stop.

Every problem is downstream of this. If we build lots and lots of housing:

Rent gets cheaper.
Private buying gets cheaper.
Councils can buy social stock more cheaply.
etc etc.

Build. More. Houses.

Thecompleteposter · 21/01/2024 23:16

No one has yet responded to my point that women are increasingly choosing to live alone after divorce or separation even if their adult kids have left home.
If nearly half of all marriages end in divorce in the uk, imagine the pressure on the housing market to provide homes for these people. See the thread below for some thoughts about housing and homes.

Given a choice, I wonder whether a lot of women would prefer to live on their ‘own’ whilst remaining in a relationship? www.mumsnet.com/Talk/relationships/4986280-given-a-choice-i-wonder-whether-a-lot-of-women-would-prefer-to-live-on-their-own-whilst-remaining-in-a-relationship

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 23:14

@MistressoftheDarkSide Oh God i hope things get better very soon Thats a LOT to go through Flowers

Divastrout · 21/01/2024 23:09

Mybootsare · 21/01/2024 23:00

Hear hear! Completely agree.

My point exactly

Naptrappedmummy · 21/01/2024 23:08

There’s 2 issues at play here:

  1. Austerity/terrible policies/crap economy
  2. A needy public who require so much support to do the most basic things and feed into problem number 1 by not paying tax to replace the money spent on them
MistressoftheDarkSide · 21/01/2024 23:04

@JenniferBooth

Hopefully tomorrow the various agencies who have been passing my Step Mum round like a bloody hot potato will have sorted some respite for my Dad. She has complex issues encompassing long term mental health issues pre-cognitive impairment and probable vascular dementia. She developed hyper delirium shortly after New Years when she had some sort if seizures, was awake for up to 60 hours at a time ransacking the house and all sorts. Eventually her community nurse suggested possible UTI but it was impossible to get a sample so her GP advised 999 and A&E. I was there with her for 13 hours on Tuesday and then have been in every day except Friday with my Dad who is waiting for treatment for atrial fibrillation- he's 84 - and now he has a dreadful cold. He's immuno compromised as had his spleen removed due to splenic lymphoma which means he can't be treated until his GP has checked with his cancer specialist. Oh it's all fun and games....

Had to fight to prevent an unsafe discharge of SM on Thursday - they told her she was going home before us so she kicked off aggressively and the staff tried to imply it was a family issue at play not her condition. It's been a complete bloody nightmare and we're hoping she'll be transferred for respite somewhere so long term plans can be made.

Have had to put my life on hold in the meantime and am worried my Dad will deteriorate - he's exhausted.

Anyway that's potentially a whole other thread, and apologies to the OP for the de-rail.

Thank you for your kindness though x

Mybootsare · 21/01/2024 23:00

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 21/01/2024 20:31

Why do housing threads bring the racists out?

The foreigners who should be booted out are the rich overseas people who buy flats and houses here as investments to let them out and siphon the rent, which is British money, overseas. Not refugees, who by definition have fled war, famine, and inhumane treatment from their own governments.

Edited

Hear hear! Completely agree.

Codlingmoths · 21/01/2024 22:57

I feel very sorry for him. It’s quite possible he moved out knowing his daughter needed to stay with her mum as her primary carer and have a roof over her head. That doesn’t mean he doesn’t pay support and doesn’t desperately want her to stay overnight, as a full time working man it must be very depressing that these things don’t even seem to be options.

Divastrout · 21/01/2024 22:56

Casparr · 21/01/2024 22:31

A PP said that Glasgow’s the place where the majority of Scotland’s share of refugees have been sent to be housed. It makes logical sense that places with shorter waiting lists would receive more refugees (whether this is actually policy I have no idea).

Don’t see what’s controversial about that?

There's really nothing controversial about that. The issue is that homelessness goes right back to the Thatcher years when social housing was sold for Tory votes. Since then no government has at all invested in social housing on any scale at all. We all hear the talk especially at election time.
But there is still a lack of affordable social housing and BTL landlords are sometimes bowing out.
The issue of Asylum seekers etc really does not impact on lack of affordable housing as such.
I live in Scotland and my town has had an influx of Asylum seekers and believe me they are not generally receiving social housing.
Rather as the government has failed to provide social housing we are seeing increasingly people being put in temporary accommodation sometimes for years.
These people Are Not Asylum seekers but people who may or may not with sometimes disabilities or down on their luck.
So your leap to Glasgow Asylum seekers is still WOW!!

PepperIsHere · 21/01/2024 22:53

Wow you're really working hard to be offensive. Gross.

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:53

Christ. Cheeky fuckers!

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 21/01/2024 22:50

The fact that they are now called the Wheatley Group and have taken the words "housing association" out of their name entirely tells you all you need to know

It fucks me off that they named themselves after John Wheatley, a socialist politician who must be rolling in his grave.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 21/01/2024 22:49

And thank you @icantusethat x

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:48

@MistressoftheDarkSide sorry if this isnt much help but have to tried to get help for your parents. You cant do it all

MistressoftheDarkSide · 21/01/2024 22:47

Thank you @JenniferBooth x

Looking back those days seem like a long forgotten dream.

İcantusethat · 21/01/2024 22:47

@MistressoftheDarkSide that sounds awful, I'm so sorry 😞

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:44

@MistressoftheDarkSide Im really sorry to hear that I remember you from some of the Covid restrictions threads, Flowers

MistressoftheDarkSide · 21/01/2024 22:42

Christ this thread is depressing.

I'm going to be homeless in the next few months as my landlord is selling up. I was widowed two years ago, have struggled to keep my business afloat leaving me in 10k worth of debt. I'm currently trying to liquidate but am also trying to get my elderly parents sorted out as they have both hit massive crises this week and I'm an only child.

I'm 55 and my only source of comfort is my cat which I may have to give up. My credit rating is shot, I have no one to be a guarantor. I am absolutely fucked as rents in my affluent South coast town are pretty much in the London bracket. You can't even view with an agent down here unless you pass the credit check first.

I've spent my life having my career prospects regularly interrupted by urgent caring responsibilities. Getting a full time job right now is unfeasible as I have to get rid of pretty much all of my possessions because if I'm lucky I might get temporary accommodation, plus with the dire state of care for the elderly, it looks like I'll be up to my neck in dementia and heart problems with my poor parents for the next few years.

I was hoping to find a way to relocate to a cheaper area, but apparently Universe says no.

So this chap absolutely has my sympathy. As they say, don't judge another till you've walked in their shoes.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 21/01/2024 22:40

Actually, the Home Office is currently in the process "batch processing" a big old backlog of asylum cases so it's expected that around 2,000 newly minted refugees will soon be in a position to make applications for housing in Glasgow. And a similar number will be destitute and homeless having been knocked back.

In a city where the largest housing association has been steadily demolishing housing for a decade.

The council have declared a "housing emergency"

MissersMercer · 21/01/2024 22:38

He's choosing not to rent in the hope he'll get housed. Imagine if every single working person did that.

SD1978 · 21/01/2024 22:38

Costs wise it doesn't break down what he has to pay. He should be paying CSM on that. Depending on where he is staying, there are transport costs, and you'd hope he's chipping in with the gas/ electric wherever he's staying. Food costs, since he doesn't have a base, would be takeaway type food for lunch and I'd assume dinner is provided- but also he very may well not want to eat a chippie every night for his tea. Without the article (invasively) going into his costs breakdown, there is no way to know. I'd imagine on a minimum wage, and a need to stay near his low paid job, the options aren't great. And if he has no money, he can't move elsewhere to secure accomodation as won't have the deposit.