Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he’s choosing to be homeless and it’s right that he doesn’t get a housing association property?

288 replies

Casparr · 21/01/2024 18:28

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

Man works 50hrs a week. At minimum wage that’s 27k and about £1900 take-home each month. He sleeps at friends’ houses or his ex-partner’s, presumably for free. Why can’t he just get a room in a house share (under £600 a month in Glasgow) and save up a deposit for a flat?

Daniel Thomson

I'm working but homeless and bottom of the housing list

A working father finds himself "sofa surfing" amid social housing shortages in Scotland's biggest city.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Gonnawashmymouthout · 22/01/2024 17:21

Naptrappedmummy · 22/01/2024 08:52

Hang on, he’s earning a minimum of 25k if he’s truly working those hours (too many IMO but that’s a different matter), Glasgow housing is pretty cheap all things considered. He’s not paying any rent or bills so why can’t he save up the deposit? This flat for example looks within budget and reasonably nice

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/133721012#/?channel=RES_LET

That property has now been removed

also, Glasgow is a pretty big place: he would want to live near his work and daughter. If he relies on public transport then this flat may be a complete no go

Updownleftandright · 22/01/2024 15:54

I don't get how you could know someone's full finances just from reading a news article? If only that worked for our politicians 😂they'd certainly behave more.

NotMyFirstChoiceofName · 22/01/2024 15:14

MistressoftheDarkSide · 22/01/2024 13:19

Hold on - so which is it? Air BnBs are being converted to long-term lets, yet landlords are also moving to turn long-term lets into Air BnBs due to new legislation or selling up entirely? I know everything is a Paradox but surely this is extremely contradictory?

The Numbers of Serviced accommodation premises AND long term lets have both reduced, due to government policy.

Anecdotally, some SA providers have changed to PRS. But it’s only overall numbers that are documented, no one tracks what happens to each individual property then collates it all .

I didn’t say that that long term lets are being turned into serviced accommodation, that was another poster.

The Scottish Government ( in coalition with theGreens ) are trying very hard to piss off landlords. Which is pretty stupid when

you have a housing crisis
they house a fifth of the population
you have 60 refugees arriving every Monday
housing waiting lists are very long
landlords always have other options - the housing market is still booming in most of Scotland

capital is mobile

LakieLady · 22/01/2024 14:47

NotMyFirstChoiceofName · 21/01/2024 18:43

Don’t worry, he won’t get a housing association property. Glasgow has over 900 people in B and Bs and hundreds of them will have higher priority than a working single man.

Every Monday the list gets longer as the Home Office approve even more refugees and they all turn up and present as homeless. The Government only fund their accommodation for 7 days now the covid money has stopped and then it’s up to local authorities. Thats why they are going bankrupt - Glasgow City Council is more than £17M in debt.

Are the rules re housing refugees different in Scotland from those in England?

In England, refugees only get the same priority as any other homeless person else, ie only those with children, disabilities or who are especially vulnerable are entitled to be housed under homelessness rules.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 22/01/2024 13:19

Hold on - so which is it? Air BnBs are being converted to long-term lets, yet landlords are also moving to turn long-term lets into Air BnBs due to new legislation or selling up entirely? I know everything is a Paradox but surely this is extremely contradictory?

Crikeyalmighty · 22/01/2024 12:53

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia in many countries you cannot buy unless you have been resident for quite a lot of years abd that doesn't include buying by hastily arranged 'companies' - you cannot buy just to let it sit there or 'let out' - half the problems in this country are because we have become like the Wild West when it comes to being allowed to buy into UK assets- with minimal conditions or checks

NotMyFirstChoiceofName · 22/01/2024 11:49

VampireWeekday · 21/01/2024 19:14

It's actually not easy to walk into flashares in Glasgow. Lots of competition, deposits required, prices going up, many converted to air BnBs. I imagine it's the deposit holding him back.

I don’t disagree that there is a severe housing shortage in Scotland. But in fact over the last 6 months many air BnB have been converted to long term rents.

And yes of course deposits are required - that’s the law throughout the UK and most of Europe. Otherwise there would be no private rented properties at all and the government would have to find billions to build enough social rented properties and then devise a whole new system to house students, short term workers , new households, young people leaving home etc .

alpenguin · 22/01/2024 09:56

Naptrappedmummy · 22/01/2024 09:42

Well there at 40 odd flats for rent under £600 a month and there will be many many more house shares. So doesn’t have to be that one, but he should be able to rent something rather than be homeless shouldn’t he? I totally understand the economy/housing is crap in general in the U.K. but Glasgow isn’t the worst affected by any means. We all have to support ourselves at the end of the day, until such a time we can get the Tories out and vote in a government who has the appetite to change things. But throwing yourself on the mercy of public services and social housing when you do have other options doesn’t help, in fact it makes it all worse.

Have you read the comments from people who know what’s necessary to rent and how quickly properties go when they’re up for rent or are you basing your knowledge on rentals in the 90s and early 00s - times have changed drastically in the past four years.

Naptrappedmummy · 22/01/2024 09:42

alpenguin · 22/01/2024 09:39

That’s not Glasgow it’s bothwell/blantyre a 20 min drive and terrible nighttime transport for
work if you work in the city centre.

so much misinformation on this thread. I saw someone mention you could walk into a HA and be housed within days 12 years ago. That is not and never has been the case.
20 years ago my female friend had to live in dodgy homeless accommodation over 12 months before getting a LHA flat. She was a teen escaping racist abuse so at the time
top of the list! 30 years ago my then boyfriend also in a homeless accommodation had to wait 18 months.

These times are considerably better than now but it has never been days. It’s barely been under a year.

OP have you ever found yourself unhoused without family or friends options ? I feel unless you’ve been there you can’t really judge and you really are judging in complete ignorance here.

Edited

Well there at 40 odd flats for rent under £600 a month and there will be many many more house shares. So doesn’t have to be that one, but he should be able to rent something rather than be homeless shouldn’t he? I totally understand the economy/housing is crap in general in the U.K. but Glasgow isn’t the worst affected by any means. We all have to support ourselves at the end of the day, until such a time we can get the Tories out and vote in a government who has the appetite to change things. But throwing yourself on the mercy of public services and social housing when you do have other options doesn’t help, in fact it makes it all worse.

alpenguin · 22/01/2024 09:39

Naptrappedmummy · 22/01/2024 08:52

Hang on, he’s earning a minimum of 25k if he’s truly working those hours (too many IMO but that’s a different matter), Glasgow housing is pretty cheap all things considered. He’s not paying any rent or bills so why can’t he save up the deposit? This flat for example looks within budget and reasonably nice

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/133721012#/?channel=RES_LET

That’s not Glasgow it’s bothwell/blantyre a 20 min drive and terrible nighttime transport for
work if you work in the city centre.

so much misinformation on this thread. I saw someone mention you could walk into a HA and be housed within days 12 years ago. That is not and never has been the case.
20 years ago my female friend had to live in dodgy homeless accommodation over 12 months before getting a LHA flat. She was a teen escaping racist abuse so at the time
top of the list! 30 years ago my then boyfriend also in a homeless accommodation had to wait 18 months.

These times are considerably better than now but it has never been days. It’s barely been under a year.

OP have you ever found yourself unhoused without family or friends options ? I feel unless you’ve been there you can’t really judge and you really are judging in complete ignorance here.

Macaroni46 · 22/01/2024 09:15

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 22:31

@Macaroni46 The demolition and gentrification is more than playing its part Every time i see posts like yours i assume the poster is benefitting from these things in some way.

Nope, not benefitting at all. I earn about the same as the man in the article and pay my own way entirely.
However, I stand by what I said. Too much council housing is tied up by tenants who are living there for decades when they don't need to.

Naptrappedmummy · 22/01/2024 08:52

Bibsandrepeat · 22/01/2024 01:18

I think the real issue is that someone who works 50 hours a week cannot comfortably afford a home of their own. What has the world come to. Just because he's earning the 'living wage" doesn't mean it equates to the true cost of living. The housing and rental market is absolutely disgraceful, that's the real issue here.

Hang on, he’s earning a minimum of 25k if he’s truly working those hours (too many IMO but that’s a different matter), Glasgow housing is pretty cheap all things considered. He’s not paying any rent or bills so why can’t he save up the deposit? This flat for example looks within budget and reasonably nice

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/133721012#/?channel=RES_LET

Check out this 1 bedroom ground floor flat for rent on Rightmove

1 bedroom ground floor flat for rent in Clyde Avenue, Glasgow, G71 for £595 pcm. Marketed by Lets Let, Hamilton

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/133721012#/?channel=RES_LET

Saschka · 22/01/2024 08:52

Dissimilitude · 21/01/2024 23:47

There are many countries in the world which don't have this problem. It is largely a planning issue in the U.K. which could be tackled by a determined government.

You are correct in that there are plenty losers in a world with more housing. But it still needs doing.

A price crash would be bad. A well engineered, long period of flat prices against rising incomes, on the other hand, is what’s needed. And that is very doable.

Unfortunately the property developers who fund the Tory party don’t want that, so it looks like Sunak is planning to over-heat the market again before he leaves, with Help to Buy on steroids.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/jan/21/99-per-cent-mortgage-scheme-uk-housing-market-ministers

Ministers’ 99% mortgage idea could overheat UK housing market, say experts

Scheme to support first-time buyers that would appeal to young voters reportedly being considered by No 10

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/jan/21/99-per-cent-mortgage-scheme-uk-housing-market-ministers

Naptrappedmummy · 22/01/2024 08:50

iLovee · 22/01/2024 07:45

What a busybody. You sound thoroughly unpleasant

For having an opinion on a news story?!

iLovee · 22/01/2024 07:45

What a busybody. You sound thoroughly unpleasant

MistressoftheDarkSide · 22/01/2024 07:41

@JMSA

Well, as beggars can't be choosers, this may be my last resort. Whether my parents would want me to is the first issue. My SM owns the house outright. The only available room is the downstairs front room, which has been kept as a shrine to her late parents. The house has no central heating and they live on the first floor. One complication is that while they have been together approximately 42 years, and are now married, before he died her DF set things up to ensure my Dad wasn't a gold-digger, so her will stipulates that my Dad can live in the house until he dies if she goes first, then her Northern family will inherit (Cousins and their children who I have never met).

Part of my SMs condition is paranoia. She is convinced my poorly 84 year old Dad is having affairs left right and centre and regularly uses her position as a weapon, in fact she threw it at him in hospital on Thursday when it was clear it was a safeguarding issue for her to go home without a care package in place. Oh, and she is convinced he has three other children .... absolutely not possible.

As she is deemed as still having capacity (which may change today after a long needed assessment), it would be up to her as to whether i could move in, and while if I pander to her every whim, it might fly, however, she went for both me and my Dad physically on Thursday .... oh it's very complicated.

There is no POA in place, so my Dad is a bit insecure. And I would be too. I imagine her illness would make her very pleased to have two people under her control.

I mean as far as the authorities are concerned it would be a win - I would be a live in carer so less input required from them. I could claim Carers Allowance but if she wanted rent I don't think I could claim for that.

This isn't my first rodeo when it comes to dementia. My MIL lived with me and my DP for 18 months and I was her main carer.

This is my current reality in case anyone thinks I'm making it up. It sounds unbelievable to me too, but alot of my life has been quite left field, so I should be used to it by now.

Maybe it's because I was born on a Wednesday?

Anyhow, must crack on and get down to see my Dad, make sure he's made it through the night and his cold isn't heading towards pneumonia or anything, then brace for today's round of National Hell Service roulette..... dutiful daughter to the rescue....

JMSA · 22/01/2024 05:45

@MistressoftheDarkSide

I'm so sorry for your predicament.
Is moving in with your parents an option? Flowers

Thecompleteposter · 22/01/2024 04:04

There are many threads on here from posters who want help in avoiding death duties on their parents wealth and homes. Cheating the situation is commonplace.
We need migrant workers and they need to be housed. Rising divorce rates puts pressure on local authorities to house single families.
I don't think anyone has a solution. I feel desperately sorry for those people waiting to be housed. The housing crisis is not going to be solved any time soon. If anything it will get much worse.

Thecompleteposter · 22/01/2024 03:56

The housing stock in the uk is disgraceful. However, building new houses is expensive and bankrupt local authorities cannot afford to build unlimited new homes. There was a Panorama about a year ago that looked at the practice of taking a small townhouse and turning it into eight single room studios with a shower and loo in one corner and the most basic kitchen in the other.. They were cramped and substandard but shifted people off the housing list.
Allocation of homes is unfair and there is little effort to monitor whether changing circumstances of tenants would result in houses being taken away. I have a friend who has a beautiful two bedroom garden flat. She owns three houses. Her mother and her aunt have both died and left houses to her and her ex husband is living in the family home in Cyprus. She has sold two of the houses and given the proceeds to her grandchildren. The local authority is committed to housing her until she dies.There must be many many women like her abusing the system. Although to be fair she has done nothing illegal.

Bibsandrepeat · 22/01/2024 01:18

I think the real issue is that someone who works 50 hours a week cannot comfortably afford a home of their own. What has the world come to. Just because he's earning the 'living wage" doesn't mean it equates to the true cost of living. The housing and rental market is absolutely disgraceful, that's the real issue here.

Saschka · 22/01/2024 00:48

MrsMarzetti · 21/01/2024 18:57

He is making the point that as a working man here in Scotland he has no chance of getting on the housing list and is way below people that haven't paid a penny into our system.

But the point of the housing list is not to give a house to anyone who wants one, regardless of income. Or I’d be in a council house myself. It’s to house people who cannot house themselves, and he could easily house himself if he wanted to. Yes it used to be different in the 60s, but social housing hasn’t been an option for most working adults for decades.

“What immigrants get” or who has paid in most, is irrelevant. If it went on contributions, a wealthy city lawyer would be well above him on the list, and I’m sure he’d think that was unfair too.

Divastrout · 22/01/2024 00:44

To be fair upto that point I was completely in despair

Divastrout · 22/01/2024 00:43

TempestTost · 21/01/2024 23:58

I'm not sure this is totally true.

What is true is that housing has not kept up. Whether council owned or otherwise, and there are various approaches that can work, clearly it is not working.

And it isn't just down to Thatcher, in the sense that this seems to be a problem across many countries, even places where in the past there wasn't the tradition of publicly owned housing that the UK has. Housing isn't keeping up even with domestic populations. Canada, NZ, the US, Australia, all have the same problem.

However, adding thousands more people, in a single city, besides the domestic population is of course going to necessitate even more housing and cause more of a pinch.

I am very skeptical of governments now saying this isn't so. Canada has had the same approach for years, accepting a very large number of migrants of different kinds (refugees, economic migrants, family members, students) and when people suggested it was contributing to housing problems, they were called racists. It now turns out that several years ago the PM received an official report warning that immigration levels were going to cause a housing crisis.

Thank you.
You are agreeing with what I said earlier.
That the issue is really about governments and the people we vote for??
It's not about Asylum seekers or refugees.
I am sorry that this poor man and others cannot get housing. But I was also homeless, couch surfing etc but I was very lucky that my family clubbed together to be my guarantor's and give me the deposit that I needed

TempestTost · 22/01/2024 00:09

Dissimilitude · 21/01/2024 23:18

The distinct lack of social housing is just a subset of the underlying problem - a distinct lack of housing, full stop.

Every problem is downstream of this. If we build lots and lots of housing:

Rent gets cheaper.
Private buying gets cheaper.
Councils can buy social stock more cheaply.
etc etc.

Build. More. Houses.

This is true but it's not completely straightforward either.

Materials and labour costs are high.

Some of the stuff people want to build fast is frankly quite shit, and will be poorly planned.

Circumventing planning process makes things quicker, but it means developers, who are almost always mainly out to make a lot of money, are the ones driving the decisions, which will turn out badly.

There are reasons we don't want people to build everywhere, in wetlands, on good agricultural land, etc.

My town has recently had a controversy because in the interest of building quickly, they decided to place a massive seniors center in a town center neighbourhood. Basically taking up their whole green space. The neighbourhood is complaining that they weren't consulted, rightly, and will likely prevail, but only because they are part of a historically marginalized community and the town doesn't want to look bad in that way. If they were a wc white community they'd not have the same leverage.

Of course the seniors still need a place to live, and in the main part of town makes sense for access to services. No one really wants it in their neighbourhood's green space though.