Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Over wedding ceremony

140 replies

Biscuitsgalore18 · 21/01/2024 16:11

Hello,

We are getting married in August, lots of our family/friends are having to book accommodation to stay over and as we all know attending weddings can be expensive. We have planned a really lovely event, so that everyone would have a good time with live music, lots of food and a semi-free bar.

The issue is I have mentioned to a few people that we are having a celebrant wedding with a hand fasting, rather than traditional exchanging of rings etc. we had planned to visit the register a few days beforehand to complete the legal paperwork. So we will be legally married. However, people are saying this is fake, that our guests are being cheated out of attending ‘the real wedding’. Basically we are being completely unreasonable and tricking people and I have my parents and brother wanting to attend the registration office to see us ‘actually get married’ which wouldn’t be possible as we have just booked a £50 one where it’s a maximum 4 people, us and 2 witnesses.

Anyway they are suggesting we cancel the celebrant and arrange for a registrar to attend the venue. I am so upset, I have wanted a hand fasting ever since I was about 10 years old and watched Braveheart. I am 42 now!

AIBU for having a celebrant? Is this an unacceptable way to treat our guests?

OP posts:
RancidRuby · 21/01/2024 18:23

Tbh OP I agree with them, the meaningful bit of a wedding is the moment the legal contract is made between the bride and groom.

The meaningful bit, to you. For the OP the meaningful bit is the hand fasting. For a Muslim bride and groom, the nikah is the meaningful bit. Etc etc.

RowanMayfair · 21/01/2024 18:21

kintra · 21/01/2024 17:07

I understand not having two ceremonies on the same day, but why can't the registrar just do the legal bit in the middle (takes about 10 minutes) and the celebrant lead the rest of the ceremony? Our friends did this, the bride's brother acted as celebrant but they needed a registrar as he wasn't licensed.

Weddings need to be conducted in approved venues, you can't just get the registrar to come to where you are.

OP I did similar. We had the registry office at 10am with 15 family. Then a celebrant did the ceremony in the afternoon with a lot more guests. None of the guests who came to the afternoon only felt cheated: it was an amazing personal heartfelt ceremony that was well received by all guests.

TrixieFatell · 21/01/2024 18:17

We went to a handfasting ceremony a few years back. They had been legally wed at the registry a week before hand. Never felt that we had missed out on anything, we had a fantastic day celebrating their marriage. It was better then the typical wedding. It's your day, have the ceremony you want.

Simonjt · 21/01/2024 18:14

Do people not realise this is the norm in non-christian weddings in England? Would people really refuse to attend Jewish, Hindu, Sikh and Muslim weddings purely because stupid rules in England don’t see them as equal as Christian weddings?

CelebrateAndDream · 21/01/2024 18:09

Biscuitsgalore18 · 21/01/2024 17:10

@kintra i didn’t realise this could be an option! I will enquire with the celebrant and registry office tomorrow. Thank you

Just to pre-warn you so that you don't build your hopes up. Depending which county you are in, some Registrars won't do this. Where I am now the Registrars are great and we work together occasionally, but where I lived previously they wouldn't allow celebrants on the premises of the venue within a 2 hour 'window' (very odd rule 🤷‍♀️) Others won't attend at venues who even allow celebrants on their premises! Like we are some kind of rabid breed of dog!! 🤣🤦‍♀️

sprigatito · 21/01/2024 18:08

It's just not up to anyone else. You're not "tricking" anyone unless you're actually lying about what's going to happen Confused and nobody is being forced to attend.

I generally have very little tolerance for the egomaniacal behaviour of brides and grooms who make ridiculous stipulations (eg get rid of your breastfed newborn for the day or you don't love me) but in this case I can't see that you are doing anything wrong. Just stick to your plan and reassure people that they are free to decline the invitation if it isn't proper enough for them.

OneMomentPlease · 21/01/2024 18:04

Tbh OP I agree with them, the meaningful bit of a wedding is the moment the legal contract is made between the bride and groom. Anything else, however lovely it looks, is not a real wedding.

Doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t go ahead with your plans as you want them, but maybe you could consider changing your register office package so close family can attend? Or having the legal ceremony just with parents etc at the same venue on the morning of the celebration / arranging for the legal part to be incorporated into the celebration (presuming the venue is licensed).

People always refer to ‘doing the paperwork’ when they talk about the legal ceremony, but it’s not a paperwork exercise. The marriage contract is legally formed by the vows you exchange with each other. You need to sign one signature on one piece of paper but you are married before you pick up the pen!

CelebrateAndDream · 21/01/2024 18:01

Hi OP, Congratulations!! I am a celebrant and have conducted many ceremonies just like yours...honestly, once your guests are there and have taken part in your beautiful celebrant led ceremony, they will all wonder why they didn't have one themselves. It really will be wonderful, and so much more personal than any ceremony they have ever witnessed led by a registrar.

Ignore them, you don't even need to explain...just rinse and repeat, this is how we wish to celebrate our day and we would love you to join us, but understand if you'd rather not.

Have the best of days ❤️

2024namechange · 21/01/2024 17:53

On the fence with this one.

On the one hand I want to be open minded and say it’s the bit that is important to you that counts.

On the other I would probably also be miffed if someone close to me (like a sibling) did this and I missed the legal bit.

It wouldn’t bother me if it was a friend and I would happily attend.

I would appreciate the couple being up front that I am invited to a symbolic ceremony, although it wouldn’t affect my attendance if in the UK.

I tend to object for destination weddings though for this reason. All the expense and time off work and faff of going abroad and the couple are already married - but I don’t really see the point of destination weddings unless you are from that country so happy to just be called a Scrooge on that one.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/01/2024 17:50

They are being knobs. How awful to have arranged something so personally meaningful and have this response. Tell them the plan is the plan and not changing and that they will be there for the bit you find more meaningful.

mindutopia · 21/01/2024 17:50

They are being absolutely ridiculous. This isn’t all that unusual. Dh and I had a humanist wedding with a legal ceremony the morning of the wedding with just a few close family. We have several family who have done the same. None of them ever felt like anything other than a wedding. Actually several people have said our wedding is still the best they’ve ever been to because it was so different. And nearly everyone needed to stay over night of the wedding as too rural. Several family and friends came from New Zealand and the US.

gabsdot45 · 21/01/2024 17:48

They're being ridiculous. I went to a wedding like yours recently. They had a legal ceremony with just 2 witnesses and then a few weeks later hand the wedding. It was a pagan ceremony including a tying the knot piece. It was beautiful and very meaningful for them.
It's your wedding so do it your way.

Delphiniumandlupins · 21/01/2024 17:45

If your venue is licensed for marriages the actual legal bit takes minutes, including the signing. You need a qualified person for that. The rest of your ceremony can be anything you want - so long as venue and the qualified person agree. So registrar can do the "I do" bit and someone else the rest.

TempleOfBloom · 21/01/2024 17:42

People are so rigid minded.

Namerequired · 21/01/2024 17:35

It’s up to you to do what you want, but I would be upset if I missed my son actually get married and that for me would be the legal ceremony. I’m not even in to wedding/marriage but I still would feel cheated to miss the main part of it. Can you at least change the ceremony to include parents and siblings?

Donahelen · 21/01/2024 17:32

My sister did exactly the same as you. I seem to remember that there were some similar mumblings before the wedding day re. the wedding day not being "real" bc they would already be technically married.

On the day it was absolutely beautiful, the hand-tying ceremony offered everyone something a bit different to the usual wedding, the love was clear and there wasn't a single person who said anything negative.

Just go ahead with what you want - it's your wedding! ❤️

Delphiniumandlupins · 21/01/2024 17:31

Move to Scotland. Humanist celebrants are qualified to carry out legal marriage ceremonies, including a handfasting if you want. Possibly independent celebrants can be qualified too.

PickledPurplePickle · 21/01/2024 17:28

It's your day, do what you want

blackpanth · 21/01/2024 17:26

Yanbu

Lwrenagain · 21/01/2024 17:26

RubaiyatOfAnyone · 21/01/2024 16:42

Smile, nod, say “uh-huh”.
”Anyway, as i said, you’re invited to our wedding celebration on xxx date. If you don’t want to come let me know asap so i can invite some more friends who do. Thanks!”
then ignore their waffling. They can design their weddings the way they think they should be.

Perfect response 👌🏻

burnoutbabe · 21/01/2024 17:24

I kind of agree with them. Not that I'd moan its bride.

I want to see the legal bit. That nervous "I do"
It jeans not much if it's not legal or already done.

So if you are doing legals another day make it clear it's not a wedding but a celebration. Then it's up to people whether they attend or not without any deception.

One friend had a big overseas wedding (I didn't attend) but I did attend the low key legal ceremony a few months later.

CatamaranViper · 21/01/2024 17:23

Just make sure your guests know what to expect

TempleOfBloom · 21/01/2024 17:21

Invite people to witness and celebrate your hand fasting ‘the ceremony in which we will make our vows and affirm our our commitment’.

NinaGeiger · 21/01/2024 17:20

This is what my brother did a couple of years and no one batted all eyelid. It was a lovely day and everyone was very positive about it.
I think your guests who have an issue with this are being ridiculous.

Shodan · 21/01/2024 17:18

I wonder what the reaction would be of those that are whining already, if you do as kintra suggests and had the registrar slip the legal bit in the middle of your hand-fasting ceremony?

I would hope that they'll immediately shut their traps, having got what they wanted, but I suspect they'll find something else to complain about.

Do your wedding whichever way you want, OP. @C00k is quite right- Guests will whine anyway.