Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Over wedding ceremony

140 replies

Biscuitsgalore18 · 21/01/2024 16:11

Hello,

We are getting married in August, lots of our family/friends are having to book accommodation to stay over and as we all know attending weddings can be expensive. We have planned a really lovely event, so that everyone would have a good time with live music, lots of food and a semi-free bar.

The issue is I have mentioned to a few people that we are having a celebrant wedding with a hand fasting, rather than traditional exchanging of rings etc. we had planned to visit the register a few days beforehand to complete the legal paperwork. So we will be legally married. However, people are saying this is fake, that our guests are being cheated out of attending ‘the real wedding’. Basically we are being completely unreasonable and tricking people and I have my parents and brother wanting to attend the registration office to see us ‘actually get married’ which wouldn’t be possible as we have just booked a £50 one where it’s a maximum 4 people, us and 2 witnesses.

Anyway they are suggesting we cancel the celebrant and arrange for a registrar to attend the venue. I am so upset, I have wanted a hand fasting ever since I was about 10 years old and watched Braveheart. I am 42 now!

AIBU for having a celebrant? Is this an unacceptable way to treat our guests?

OP posts:
YorkBound · 21/01/2024 20:54

@BananasInThreePieceSuits
With an attitude like that I'd imagine the happy couple might be more than happy that you didn't attend.

YorkBound · 21/01/2024 20:52

It costs a lot more for the registrar to come to your venue. Lots of people do things just as you have planned. Hand fastings are a beautiful part of a ceremony, it all sounds wonderful. Please do your wedding your way and don't let some miserable twonk taint your joy. Congratulations @Biscuitsgalore18

CuriousMoe · 21/01/2024 20:19

Do what you want. We had two “weddings”, one at a church for family and the wedding party and the other was a massive bash in France, all accomodation, food, drinks paid for by us. My MiL was our celebrant in France, we all wrote our own parts. Not one person complained. If anyone had said they didn’t want to come because of it, we’d have said that was fine and not held it against them. Marriages are personal things first and foremost in my view and our French wedding was by far the most moving and personal one even though it wasn’t the “legal” one.

BananasInThreePieceSuits · 21/01/2024 20:17

TempleOfBloom · 21/01/2024 20:15

Would you feel the same about a Muslim or Hindu wedding that you were invited to?

Yes.

TempleOfBloom · 21/01/2024 20:15

BananasInThreePieceSuits · 21/01/2024 20:10

I would not consider this a real wedding, and no I would not be wasting money on attending it.

Would you feel the same about a Muslim or Hindu wedding that you were invited to?

TempleOfBloom · 21/01/2024 20:13

OneMomentPlease · 21/01/2024 18:45

Well, really, becoming legally married is the meaningful part of any ceremony, otherwise you’re not actually married, no matter how ‘meaningful’ your non legal ceremony felt to you…

Many religious people, for example, do not feel this.

If you attend a big Muslim wedding, the Nikkah, that will very much be considered ‘the wedding’, with the ‘civil wedding’ havjng bern undertaken as a formality a couple of days earlier. Same with many Hindu weddings. It is a privilege of our establishment that Christians who see marriage as being in the eyes of God rather than the Registrar can nevertheless have their religious ceremonies legally recognised.

Yes, the legal bit is crucial, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it is the most meaningful bit for many couples.

MarshaMarshaMarshmellow · 21/01/2024 20:13

Obviously it's up to you what you invite people to, and up to them to accept and decline.

But I do see it their way. I would feel like I was being treated to a show, not witnessing a wedding. Maybe a "show" and free dinner is a nice way to spend a day, but it's not the same thing as watching my loved one get married.

BananasInThreePieceSuits · 21/01/2024 20:10

I would not consider this a real wedding, and no I would not be wasting money on attending it.

Rosebyanothername19 · 21/01/2024 20:07

Wedding venue owner here! (Who is licenced for legal weddings)

I've seen some beautiful celebrant led weddings. They add a different element to your wedding and are much more personal, as the celebrant takes time to really get to know the couple. Registrar led weddings are nice but they are all incredibly similar.

I always suggest celebrant led weddings to couples and explain that it is a bit like registering the birth of a child and having a Christening. One is legal, the other symbolic.

Your Wedding will be a celebration of your marriage so you can just word it like that and no one can get upset!

At the end if the day, it is your wedding, your marriage and your commitment to each other which is important. So make sure it is perfect for you!

Wishing you and your Fiancé all the best for your future together! Xx

Mairzydotes · 21/01/2024 20:01

People seem to be forgetting, although it's nice to see the actual ceremony, it's not necessary and only 2 witnesses are required to make it legal .

The mistake of OP was to actually mention the handfasting and legal ceremony were on different days . You should have kept it all quiet.

Dh and I ' eloped ' to Gretna Green for a hand fasting when we got engaged. It's a fond memory.

BobbyBiscuits · 21/01/2024 19:55

How rude of them to say such nonsense. I'd un-invite anyone who doesn't like it. Who gives a stuff whether its 'legally binding' or not, it's your way of celebrating your commitment. Anyone else can shove their pointless opinions.

ActDottie · 21/01/2024 19:44

It’s so normal now days for people to get married before their actual wedding.

The last wedding we went to they got married the day before, but did a ceremony at the wedding still they just couldn’t get married there because the venue was her parents farm. I know people as well who got married before having their wedding abroad etc. it’s so common. You are definitely not being unreasonable.

Genevieva · 21/01/2024 19:37

Do what you want. If you don't explain they won't notice. Just say you are looking into it until they forget.

Probably not your thing, but the traditional Book of Common Prayer church ceremony has handfasting. I know because we had this when we got married. And a vicar can do both the hand fasting and the legal bit. Surely, there are registrars who do both.

Salacia · 21/01/2024 19:25

Biscuitsgalore18 · 21/01/2024 17:02

Thank you for all the replies. To answer a few questions.. we are in England. Our venue recommended just doing 1 ceremony otherwise guests would get bored and become restless. Hence why we were not having the register come on the same day.
Yes totally the Braceheart thing is cringe, but I was 10 and sometimes childhood dreams stick.

The legal bit is really short so not sure why the venue is worried (unless the handfasting is quite long? Never been to one…). My friend got married last year and literally only had the bare bones of the legal service - no readings, music etc - just vows and signing the register- we must have been through it in about 10/15 minutes. I can’t see how that plus a handfasting would be much longer than half an hour or so which seems perfectly fine for a ceremony (and less than many traditional religious services).

I’ve been to few weddings (mostly post covid) that were separate from the legal bit and they’ve been fine. The only one I didn’t like was an hour plus and outdoors with no plan b for the unseasonably cold June weather. That I thought was a little self indulgent/the couple should have maybe rearranged some of the people speaking etc to do so in the marquee before the meal etc rather than part of the ‘ceremony’ seeing as they were already legally married so it’s not like any of it was essential to be said at that designated time.

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 21/01/2024 19:18

I wouldnt even entertain the comments. I'd say something like, I'm sorry you feel that way....thankfully my guests dont/If you've changed your mind about attending please let me know by the end of the week so I can extend the invitation to someone else.

ETA- guests re being invited to the event you are organising, the arentbeing invited to plan it or offer an opinion. They can take it or leave it.

RowanMayfair · 21/01/2024 19:07

chopinwaltz26 · 21/01/2024 18:59

My niece is doing something similar in May.
If I am totally honest, I don't really want to go to some kind of "performance". I would far prefer, as her aunt, to attend the actual legal wedding.
However, this is not my choice, so I go with the flow because I love her and her intended.
Both options entail a flight and hotels, if anyone is interested.

Edited

A humanist celebration isn't a 'performance'.

chopinwaltz26 · 21/01/2024 18:59

My niece is doing something similar in May.
If I am totally honest, I don't really want to go to some kind of "performance". I would far prefer, as her aunt, to attend the actual legal wedding.
However, this is not my choice, so I go with the flow because I love her and her intended.
Both options entail a flight and hotels, if anyone is interested.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/01/2024 18:55

the meaningful bit of a wedding is the moment the legal contract is made between the bride and groom.

No, it really isn't. It may be to you, but there are lots of countries where the legal bit is dont privately and then there is a big ceremony which is seen as the really important bit.

IcouldbutIdontwantto · 21/01/2024 18:54

I agree with the majority saying to do what you want, but I'm not sure about the not telling people as it could create some confusion/ concern on the day! My sibling did this, and it was lovely... but one of the guests was an ex-registrar friend of my parents, who discreetly took me aside after the ceremony, very concerned that they weren't actually married - she was fine once I'd explained that the legal bit had been done a few days before, but she was genuinely worried they'd been 'had'.

OneMomentPlease · 21/01/2024 18:45

Well, really, becoming legally married is the meaningful part of any ceremony, otherwise you’re not actually married, no matter how ‘meaningful’ your non legal ceremony felt to you…

Girlontherailreplacementbusservice · 21/01/2024 18:37

CelebrateAndDream · 21/01/2024 18:09

Just to pre-warn you so that you don't build your hopes up. Depending which county you are in, some Registrars won't do this. Where I am now the Registrars are great and we work together occasionally, but where I lived previously they wouldn't allow celebrants on the premises of the venue within a 2 hour 'window' (very odd rule 🤷‍♀️) Others won't attend at venues who even allow celebrants on their premises! Like we are some kind of rabid breed of dog!! 🤣🤦‍♀️

Presumably because of the rules of English civil wedding ceremony not being allowed to contain any 'religion'. Obviously humanists shouldn't fall into this category but it may be that some regions interpret handfasting etc as pagan and regard pagan as a religion.
I know a few people that have clearly not religious music/reading declined because they contain 'oh god' 'hell yes' 'heaven' (meaning perfection) etc.

RowanMayfair · 21/01/2024 18:32

RowanMayfair · 21/01/2024 18:30

Yes I was replying for the sake of the OP really. In England you can only marry in certain places, and she said she was in England. I didn't want her to get her hopes up about an option that wasn't there.

Better info here https://www.gov.uk/marriages-civil-partnerships/plan-your-ceremony

Marriages and civil partnerships in England and Wales

How to get married or form a civil partnership in the UK, giving notice of marriage at a register office, visas, paying fees.

https://www.gov.uk/marriages-civil-partnerships/plan-your-ceremony

RowanMayfair · 21/01/2024 18:30

kintra · 21/01/2024 18:25

If you read my posts I did acknowledge this may be the case, and that OP should check with the venue. It isn't the case in my area

Edited

Yes I was replying for the sake of the OP really. In England you can only marry in certain places, and she said she was in England. I didn't want her to get her hopes up about an option that wasn't there.

Over wedding ceremony
kintra · 21/01/2024 18:25

RowanMayfair · 21/01/2024 18:21

Weddings need to be conducted in approved venues, you can't just get the registrar to come to where you are.

OP I did similar. We had the registry office at 10am with 15 family. Then a celebrant did the ceremony in the afternoon with a lot more guests. None of the guests who came to the afternoon only felt cheated: it was an amazing personal heartfelt ceremony that was well received by all guests.

If you read my posts I did acknowledge this may be the case, and that OP should check with the venue. It isn't the case in my area

Daisies12 · 21/01/2024 18:23

That’s very common. And sorry but you were stupid to tell anyone. I didn’t tell anyone about what was happening at our wedding. Who cares what they think. I only wanted one ceremony which was the legal one, but personal choice.