Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Over wedding ceremony

140 replies

Biscuitsgalore18 · 21/01/2024 16:11

Hello,

We are getting married in August, lots of our family/friends are having to book accommodation to stay over and as we all know attending weddings can be expensive. We have planned a really lovely event, so that everyone would have a good time with live music, lots of food and a semi-free bar.

The issue is I have mentioned to a few people that we are having a celebrant wedding with a hand fasting, rather than traditional exchanging of rings etc. we had planned to visit the register a few days beforehand to complete the legal paperwork. So we will be legally married. However, people are saying this is fake, that our guests are being cheated out of attending ‘the real wedding’. Basically we are being completely unreasonable and tricking people and I have my parents and brother wanting to attend the registration office to see us ‘actually get married’ which wouldn’t be possible as we have just booked a £50 one where it’s a maximum 4 people, us and 2 witnesses.

Anyway they are suggesting we cancel the celebrant and arrange for a registrar to attend the venue. I am so upset, I have wanted a hand fasting ever since I was about 10 years old and watched Braveheart. I am 42 now!

AIBU for having a celebrant? Is this an unacceptable way to treat our guests?

OP posts:
Nokiu · 22/01/2024 00:03

I've not been bothered at UK weddings I've attended before- at Hindu weddings for example it's totally normal for the legal bit to happen early in the week of celebrations.
In that sense I don't think you're being unreasonable.

It's not really relevant to OP but the situation I did get a tad annoyed about was when I went to an abroad wedding that really was just an excuse for a piss up with a five minute 'ceremony'. I knew they were having the legal bit before but they ended up making a big deal out of that too and having a lunch for 30 after, which made me a bit perplexed as town hall and lunch for 30 would be many people's idea of a nice wedding. The three day bender in a vineyard in the middle of nowhere abroad really was just a party and I wouldn't have dragged the kids along if I had been clued in!

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/01/2024 23:54

but the reality is that it is not more meaningful in the pursuit of becoming legally married which is the whole point of a wedding

Really? If thats true, people would not have religious or big weddings, they would just go to the registry office and do the bare basics. A lot of people dont because this is not the most important thing to them.

you don’t risk there being any bad feeling on the day itself.

Anyone who would whip up 'bad feelings' because they dont approve of the way the couple organized their day is a twat.

OneMomentPlease · 21/01/2024 23:27

Ok, to clarify, I understand that a hand fasting may feel more meaningful to the couple, but the reality is that it is not more meaningful in the pursuit of becoming legally married which is the whole point of a wedding. Humanist /pagan ceremonies can be lovely, but they are not actual weddings no matter how much you wish they were.

OP if you go ahead as planned it’s best to be open with your guests in advance. That way you will know that everyone who attends is on board and you don’t risk there being any bad feeling on the day itself.

MarshaMarshaMarshmellow · 21/01/2024 22:35

@SerafinasGoose I agree those weddings sound like a massive ball ache. Your wedding sounds lovely. It's not one or the other. It's just that not all guests will consider that they are witnessing a wedding when it has no legal standing. FWIW for me, the irritation comes from the same place - the sense that I'm supposed to really care about the couple's personal feelings and beliefs, rather than simply wish them well in a universal and important rite of passage, and enjoy a knees up. I feel that with Instagrammy weddings too, believe me!

TheShellBeach · 21/01/2024 22:29

Snugglemonkey · 21/01/2024 21:44

Usually someone's Avington hello, or good bye, or enjoying music. Fuck all to do with this post though.

?

SleepingStandingUp · 21/01/2024 22:29

I think it's fine
A good friend of mine had a fasting on her farm. Her, hubby, bro and sil had popped off to the Lakes the week prior and done the paperwork stuff. We got to see their personal vows. We got to sing their song choices. We got to see them make a dedication to each other about love rather than legalities.

I'd say anyone offended at not seeing the official bot is missing the point

SerafinasGoose · 21/01/2024 22:21

This is the reason we eloped, and why I never attend a wedding if I can possibly help it. Everyone with an opinion on how things should be done (when presumably they organized their own weddings the way they saw fit), the pressure to conform with an identikit ceremony, completely predictable itinerary, 'unique' themes that are really a small variation on a very narrow set of ideas, and the tedium of a tried and tested format because it's 'tradition', and because relatives and others expect that's the way it will be done.

But apparently it's a-okay to leave people standing around for hours whilst endless photos are taken, or expect half the guests to bugger off and entertain themselves whilst the others eat, or indulge in other inconsiderate ways to treat guests because 'it's our day', as long as Tradition is followed to the letter. I'd far rather attend a wedding where the couple actually behaved as hosts and considered the guests who are doing them the favour by attending, rather than the other way round.

Frankly, a hand fasting ceremony and something a bit different would be a welcome relief in comparison with any of the above. In memory they all look the same after a while.

Nothing turns me off faster than the word 'tradition'.

Ellysetta · 21/01/2024 22:13

You have different beliefs. To you, the hand fasting is the real marriage and the registry office is just the legal bit, unimportant.

To them, and me, the legal marriage is the important bit and the hand fasting is just a party with a fake ceremony in it.

Neither of you are wrong, you just have different beliefs, BUT if you ask people to spend money to see you get married, imo you ought to let them see you get married. Seeing a hand fasting means nothing to me and it seems they feel the same.

If possible I would suggest you rearrange so that the registrar marries you while your family are there.

2024namechange · 21/01/2024 22:10

@itsgoingtobeabumpyride that’s so cheeky! See my earlier post for my views one destination weddings but to not even get legally married at all, what was the point?

itsgoingtobeabumpyride · 21/01/2024 21:57

Lots of people do this and you're entitled to get married however you choose.
However, I went to a destination wedding a couple of years ago, a boutique hotel (converted monastery) in the middle of nowhere, forced to eat and drink at the VERY expensive hotel, no alternative as it was too far away from any town, cost an absolute fortune only to find out it wasn't a "real" wedding but a blessing.
The couple were planning on having a registry office wedding on their return.
I was pretty p'd off as I was happy to pay to attend their "wedding" but it wasn't a wedding.
Two years later and they've still not had the official ceremony 🙄

DelilahsHaven · 21/01/2024 21:53

We had a humanist celebrant, and had already had our legal ceremony at the registrars office with two witnesses only, none of our guests expressed anything other than happiness for us. I think our neice and her husband did the same. No big deal, it's your day.

Snugglemonkey · 21/01/2024 21:51

BananasInThreePieceSuits · 21/01/2024 20:10

I would not consider this a real wedding, and no I would not be wasting money on attending it.

How very unpleasant of you.

Snugglemonkey · 21/01/2024 21:49

Namerequired · 21/01/2024 17:35

It’s up to you to do what you want, but I would be upset if I missed my son actually get married and that for me would be the legal ceremony. I’m not even in to wedding/marriage but I still would feel cheated to miss the main part of it. Can you at least change the ceremony to include parents and siblings?

To op, the hand fasting is the actually getting married. The paperwork is sorted separately. You would be missing nothing.

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · 21/01/2024 21:44

I've never been at a wedding that was separate to the actual marriage part. I do think I'd feel a bit "cheated". Your guest will go to expense to be there, probably expect to give you a gift etc - and I think, for a lot of people the marriage is the actual event that they want to witness. So the legal bit. The rest is just a party.

I think as a previous poster mentioned, you probably should have done it your own way, just not actually told anyone that was what was happening. Nobody would have noticed on the day. As a matter of interest, what will your anniversary be? The date of your marriage, or the date of your celebration?

Snugglemonkey · 21/01/2024 21:44

TheShellBeach · 21/01/2024 16:59

What is hand waving?

Usually someone's Avington hello, or good bye, or enjoying music. Fuck all to do with this post though.

Snugglemonkey · 21/01/2024 21:39

Fuck that. You have invited them to come and share the bit that is important to you. Anyone disrespecting that is a dick.

kintra · 21/01/2024 21:37

Handfastings were traditionally sort of like an engagement, a 'marriage' to bind the couple for a year and a day and then they'd go through with the legalities (I'm talking hundreds of years ago), so I'm not sure why anyone (especially non-Celts) would view it as the 'real' ceremony

Tiggles · 21/01/2024 21:23

I went to a handfasting wedding. Sure the couple got married earlier in the registry office but it was obvious the handfasting ceremony was the 'really wedding for them, even if it technically wasn't the legal bit.
Your guests are strange.

MarshaMarshaMarshmellow · 21/01/2024 21:23

SerafinasGoose · 21/01/2024 21:08

It's not 'fake'. Hand fasting has real, spiritual meaning to some people. And if this is the case for the bride and groom, they are not selling guests short whether or not it has similar meaning to them.

Congratulations on your forthcoming marriage, OP. Hope your day is everything you wish it to be.

Yeah, but a legal wedding has real legal meaning to everyone, whether they like it or not. I have no particular interest in watching people partake in their own spiritual beliefs. I want to see where it actually happens - the actual legal change - not something subjective and internal between the two people involved.

(I mean, I'll still come, and I'll enjoy the celebrations and food and drink - don't get me wrong 😅).

FWIW I also have no interest in the idea of having people watch me undergo something which has spiritual meaning to me but not to them. Like, they can come, but I don't expect it to mean the same to them.

SussexLass87 · 21/01/2024 21:19

I'm a wedding Celebrant...so I am a bit biased!

It's like registering a birth, which is then followed by a christening...you don't see anyone wanting to come to the registering of the birth. They do however all want to come to the christening!

OP - your wedding sounds wonderful, and that you've made it very special for yourselves.

I can almost guarantee that after the ceremony they'll all be saying how wonderful it was. I'm often told by guests that they hadn't been sure about a Celebrant wedding but are now converted after seeing how personal, funny and emotional the ceremony was.

bobomomo · 21/01/2024 21:16

Sorry but I'm not keen on not inviting people to the real wedding but having a fake ceremony instead either. Why not have a registrar come then have the humanist afterwards.

LorlieS · 21/01/2024 21:13

@Alwaysalwayscold You are religious so I'm assuming you would have had a religious ceremony in the holy building of your religion e.g. if you are Christian you would have been married in a church.
Likewise my husband and I have no religion so did not believe it appropriate for us to marry in a religious ceremony in a religious building; we married in a very small civil ceremony in a local pub. For me, I was not comfortable with making promises to a God I have no belief in.
I'm baffled when you say: "So in reality neither of your ceremonies are actually weddings to me."
Why was your ceremony an "actual" wedding but mine not? Surely we both married according to our own personal values and beliefs?

SerafinasGoose · 21/01/2024 21:08

It's not 'fake'. Hand fasting has real, spiritual meaning to some people. And if this is the case for the bride and groom, they are not selling guests short whether or not it has similar meaning to them.

Congratulations on your forthcoming marriage, OP. Hope your day is everything you wish it to be.

MarshaMarshaMarshmellow · 21/01/2024 21:01

Greensleevevssnotnose · 21/01/2024 20:57

I think most people don't tell. That's your problem. I married overseas twice and the legal but was town hall two guests then a fake wedding few days later for the guests

But people will often work it out later. Then you have the drama of "Auntie Eileen just told me that it doesn't count legally if you marry on a beach, so I said "That can't be right, what about my Melanie's wedding?", but she looked it up on Google and showed me, so what was that all about?!". Why not just be upfront and let people make an informed decision?

Greensleevevssnotnose · 21/01/2024 20:57

I think most people don't tell. That's your problem. I married overseas twice and the legal but was town hall two guests then a fake wedding few days later for the guests