Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to take the money my parents have offered?

60 replies

ChristmasPudding83 · 21/01/2024 11:55

This revolves around a big house/ area move (sorry it’s a long one). I do realise we are in a good position in lots of ways and this is probably a low ranking problem on a world scale, but it’s doing my head in!

I’ve pretty much always lived in the same area, where my parents are about half an hour away and we see them a lot, and many friends from school plus others made along the way. My OH has lived around here for 30 years but didn’t grow up here. It’s a famously expensive and unaffordable town for buying houses but because we have both been on the property ladder for years and had some help from parents do own a house which is worth quite a lot though it is a fairly small terraced house with a small garden (it’s a nice looking house in a nice area). We have two children who go to a really good local primary school, though secondary school options are iffy but we’re not there yet.

About a decade ago, my husband and I started a quite unusual ‘rural’ business. It was hard work and is never going to be massively lucrative but we have been successful and enjoy what we do, and now do earn enough for things not to feel really tight. However we need a very specific kind of premises to run the business - most people who have this kind of business live there. We started ours by renting somewhere else to run it at, which is 20 minutes drive away, but we have really outgrown the place we rent and for other reasons too it increasingly feels like time to move on from there. However because of the area we’re living in, buying or even renting somewhere else to do the business is proving totally unviable (believe me we have looked!) - there aren’t many properties that would work and when there are they go for way way over our budget.

For the amount we have in our current house and savings plus what we can get for a mortgage we COULD completely relocate and buy a bigger house/ property where we could live and run the business, but it would mean moving far away: realistically Wales or Scotland (which would be 4-6+ hours from where we are now and my parents) to get the size of house we’d want to be able to have people to stay.

However my parents came into some money a few years ago and have offered to give us quite a large sum out of that to help us make this move possible. If we accepted this money, our budget still wouldn’t be enough to stay in the area we live now but would mean we could probably be more like an hour or two away. They have said this would be effectively me getting my inheritance early (and in fact they will change their will if we do it). They want to be supportive of our business which we’ve worked hard to get where it is now and say they’d like to see us enjoy the money while they’re still around.

However I feel very uncomfortable about taking the money. I have three siblings and while they have all had help in the past to buy houses etc I know my parents couldn’t afford to give us all the same amount of money they are talking about giving me before they die. My siblings seem fine with the idea of us getting the money now but I worry about what might happen in a few years time if something changed (and are they REALLY fine with it deep down? I’m not sure I would be). My dad has also alluded in passing to other projects/ charity contributions they won’t be able to do if they give us this money . I also think it just ‘feels wrong’ and would make me feel like I should get them to approve wherever it is we choose or want to move to and that we owed them too much, and really I’d much rather feel like we’d done the move standing on our own two feet.

I feel quite torn though. Moving that far away when my parents are getting older feels a bit wrong and while a big part of me feels it would be a really exciting adventure to start a new life somewhere else (I never thought I’d be the kind of person to live all my life where I grew up!), part of me also worries about things like making new friends and what impact this might have on the children.

The third option is to stay put but then we couldn’t carry on with the business long term so it would mean dreaming up a new career for both of us. I’ve put a lot into studying and building up networks etc for the job I’m doing now and it is something I’m passionate about. Plus I love the flexibility of having our own business. But maybe the sacrifice of moving far away is too much for a job, however much you like it!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ariela · 24/01/2024 14:06

You need some specialist advice. I would talk to an agricultural business advisor on this, it may be advantageous to set up a business partnership with your parents as investors. There are certain advantages in inheriting an agricultural business as some agricultural assets can benefit from relief from Inheritance Tax, eg land that is used for growing crops. or for intensive animal rearing. This might benefit your siblings in the long term too if they can inherit a proportion w/o inheritance tax. Definitely worth investigating, but you need specialist advice on how to go about it.
(I also think that it might be a good argument that it's not deprivation of assets (for care home fee purposes) eg if they are investing in the business and can be shown to make share of the profit. Again that might benefit your siblings too)

Definitely seek proper specialist advice on this.

ChristmasPudding83 · 24/01/2024 13:12

just wanted to say thank you so much for all the comments, it’s been a bit like reading the inside of my head written down in front of me LOL!! What I didn’t say before also is that I do have some close family elsewhere in the UK (ditto my OH’s parents) so we could potentially end up closer or close to them.

what I am coming away thinking is that it isn’t all or nothing whatever we do. So yes getting a business loan/ grant to help with some costs is something we should look into again (I’m wary of taking on too much debt in the business and making life stressful but I guess it is all a matter of how much). Plus maybe we could consider a much smaller amount from my parents and make that a loan instead.

And I think people who have said about what if the business fails? make a good point, it needs to be a move we’d be happy to make anyway and I think that needs to be higher on the priority list than whether the new place is perfect for the business.

and yes, to think more about different ways we could achieve the same outcome. And to think better about what alternative work I could do if the move doesn’t prove doable on a budget we can afford, so we are prepared.

really, really appreciate your comments and thoughts, thanks so much xxx

OP posts:
ChristmasPudding83 · 24/01/2024 13:03

Yes the idea of a big adventure does actually appeal to me. I wonder if we would be considering a move even we weren’t at this point with the business to be honest - I still go to the same pubs I did when I was 16 and sometimes I just feel quite bored by the area (and annoyed by how expensive and oversubscribed everything in the SE is).

OP posts:
ChristmasPudding83 · 24/01/2024 12:51

Haha very true!

OP posts:
ChristmasPudding83 · 24/01/2024 12:49

It’s just about affordability really…the closer we stay to where we are now the more expensive it’ll be so the less our money can buy. You’re right it isn’t binary and there are ways we can compromise to potentially stay nearer but our budget will go furthest if we’re prepared to move at least 4 hours away….

OP posts:
Thingamebobwotsit · 24/01/2024 08:44

You sound really lovely OP. Lots of people wouldn't have given this, this much thought. Good luck whatever you decide.

Muchof · 24/01/2024 08:42

I really don’t understand why you need to move four hours away if your parents don’t loan you money and it does feel like you are hanging it over them as a threat, but dong a fair job of convincing yourself you aren’t.

If your business is viable then you should be looking into business loans not parents. If you need your parents to support your business and housing needs, then yes you probably should be looking for new careers as this isn’t genuinely viable.

DisforDarkChocolate · 24/01/2024 08:41

I'd be really torn. It's not just the money, because I think there are ways to do this fairly, it's the moving.

A big move, feels like an adventure for the whole family, a more local move may end up being not far enough. You may all feel too close to make local connections and end up doing lots of travelling back and forth because it's expected as they paid to keep you close.

Daskier · 24/01/2024 08:40

I think moving to an hour or two away could be a yoke around your necks. It might seem fine now when you're doing "nice" visits but it's enough to be a real slog on top of a FT day job if they start needing help to hospital visits, daily care needs etc. No one starts out planning to impose but there's a sort of scope creep as people get older, and if they have given you that money to keep you "in the area" you are likely to feel an obligation to help much more so than if it had been your own decision and money. It could turn into the worst of both worlds.

As a PP said if this is building on a successful business, shouldn't business loans be the first port of call rather than bank of mum and dad? Is there another option, could you keep house and business separate and rent the land?

Muchof · 24/01/2024 08:39

Outthedoor24 · 22/01/2024 15:18

The siblings got money to help them buy their first properties too so they can't moan too much.

So did the OP. Says so in the first post.

PrivateClub · 24/01/2024 08:37

No point taking the cash if you have to move 1-2 hours away anyway.

bobomomo · 24/01/2024 08:29

1-2 hours is nothing, we go for Sunday lunch regularly at my parents 90 mins away and many people commute that daily. If care needs arise being only that distance will be a huge plus. If your siblings are resentful and the estate is likely to cover at least similar amounts then go for it. You could always get a clause put into the will that if there's not enough to split between your siblings then you get nothing.

ChristmasPudding83 · 24/01/2024 07:23

Thank you, this is really interesting to hear and food for thought….

OP posts:
ChristmasPudding83 · 23/01/2024 22:10

Sorry if I wasn’t clear, it is what we both do full time for a living (and we also employ people). It’s basically a diversified farming business - so we would be looking to buy a small farm or large smallholding. I had a profession job before this which I did part time for the first few years in this business but haven’t done for a while now and the thought of going back gives me the heebie jeebies!! It was a very rigid and stressful job with no work from home and unless I worked full time I’d be worse off financially and unable to do school drop offs and pick ups. I would definitely work out something else to do for a job if I have to but I do really enjoy my work now, which I have not always felt about jobs by any means!

OP posts:
BarnacleBeasley · 23/01/2024 13:40

My friend's DF lent him money to buy a house (instead of a mortgage), had all the legal documents drawn up and held a charge on the property. So it was clear to everyone it was a loan not a gift, and he did pay it back, but interest free and over a long term, so it was much cheaper than a normal mortgage. Would something like that be a possibility? If I recall correctly when the DF died, the outstanding balance was part of the estate so most of the friend's share of the inheritance was getting the loan written off.

ABlueFolder · 23/01/2024 13:21

My in-laws have also done this, given quite a large sum to one of their children. My husband and I didn't know it was happening until some time after the transaction was complete. Like you, this money has been to help expand a business. In my in-laws' will it's specified that their other children get a larger portion of their estate when they die to compensate. This can, of course, be subject to change depending on what life throws at them in the later years.

Because they are not my parents I don't feel as though I have any grounds to complain. Also, if we were in any financial difficulty, I know my in-laws are currently solvent enough to help us out. So circumstances, in this respect, are slightly different to yours.

My friends are pretty horrified by all this and have said if it was one of their siblings being helped out by such a large extent (we are talking a substantial amount of money, well into 6 figures), they would want the equivalent. We don't actually 'need' the money, although it would improve our life if we were able to invest it, make improvements to our house or give it to our kids as deposits for their houses when they're ready to buy.

We have not fallen out with the sibling who has gained the money at all, it has never been discussed between us, but if I'm being completely honest, it stings a little to see the photos of their nice holidays etc on social media when we haven't had the time or additional cash to go on one for years.

I don't think we will every fall out over this while my in-laws are alive but, depending on what is left at the time of their death and what is specified in their will, we may arrive at that. I have watched a similar situation unravel in my own family and it wasn't pretty.

purplecorkheart · 23/01/2024 10:19

Honestly this sounds like a recipe for disaster. As one of the siblings I would be very very unhappy with it but would probably not feel I could say something about it.

I don't think I would be happy with them investing in the business either tbh. While you are confident that the business will be successful in a new location that is not certain.

JaneKatSuttonGoals · 23/01/2024 10:12

Can they invest in the business and then should the need arise in the future your siblings inherit the investment and you look at refinancing if they want out?

MercanDede · 22/01/2024 23:32

This situation is what business loans are for. Have you tried securing financing to scale up and relocate your business premises?

I would not sink personal money into scaling up a profitable business.

housingplanningquestion · 22/01/2024 23:23

The idea of moving your family so far away, and away from a well established social life and connected wider family life sounds a little bonkers. It's a bit like moving to Australia.

Is this being driven by a desperation to keep the business going? Would you be bereft at giving it up? Do you have day jobs? Could you find other work? Sadly, is the business not actually viable without free premises (property as capital, funding a business expense)? Could you continue it as a hobby?

How relatively disadvantaged would your sibs be if you took the money? Could you pay some of it back from a profitable business?

Outthedoor24 · 22/01/2024 15:18

The siblings got money to help them buy their first properties too so they can't moan too much.

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 22/01/2024 10:55

I would be resentful if I was a sibling. You may think they're agreeable but if I've learnt anything from MN it's that people are rarely truthful (in person) when it comes to matters of inheritance.

Outthedoor24 · 22/01/2024 00:11

Surely deprivation of assets can only go back so far, ie the same 7 years as inheritance tax?
Or nobody would ever be able to give anything away or pay for anything for someone else.
It can't be that unusual for parents to help adult children with house deposits, new cars and wedding bills.

Foodie68 · 21/01/2024 22:29

@BorgQueen Agree but another issue is if the parents require care in the future and there is insufficient funds left over, deprivation of assets could apply and a claim made by the local authority.

Timetodownsize · 21/01/2024 22:23

Also "Scotland" is a large place - I live in the north of Scotland and am a 3 hour drive from my DD and she is also in Scotland and not next to the border.