Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to explain why we're moving (without sounding superior)

117 replies

wouldthatbeworse · 21/01/2024 08:13

It's a secondary school one. Secondary schools where we are very mediocre. (e.g. Progress 8 of 0, 30% 5 or above in English and Maths). Behavioural issues seem no worse than anywhere else, so by no means terrible schools but not exactly what anyone hopes for their kids.

We are in the very fortunate position (through hard work and saving but also through luck) to be able to move into the catchment of a much better state secondary. It's not far away and we will transport DS back for the rest of Y5 and Y6. It's a chunky jump in house price. His friends will almost all go to one of the local schools we are moving to avoid.

How should I explain this move to my son in a way that doesn't make him sound like we are superior to any of his classmates (he will likely repeat a version of what we say to his friends). Is there any way I can tell the other parents without coming across like a twat. I don't think we are "better" than any of his friends and their families, just luckier. But by moving we are effectively saying what's good enough for your little Perry isn't good enough for our Kevin.

I am also aware that there is no guarantee my kid will be happier or or get better grades at the 'better' school. I just feel if we don't move then I'm not doing my best for him.

OP posts:
Teenagehorrorbag · 22/01/2024 22:47

GreyhpundGirl · 21/01/2024 08:19

Quite, and progress 8 scores are often an indicator of the socio-economic profile of the intake than wonder-teaching.

Progress scores reflect how much the children have improved over the five years. So a school in a deprived area may get low scoring kids in, and if they are a brilliant school they can achieve good results and have a high Progress score.

A school in an area of high performing primary schools may get a lot of bright kids in, but their P8 scores could end up lower because the gap is smaller anyway, if that makes sense?

So you could maybe disregard a lower P8 score in the second scenario, but a high P8 score is always going to be a good thing because it means the teaching has pushed the pupils beyond the results indicated by their SATs.

Bear in mind also that several years were affected by Covid and SATs were not taken, so some data may be historic?

ftp · 22/01/2024 22:05

Definitelylivedin · 21/01/2024 08:31

Why drive DS back for Y6? Far better that he gets to make friends in the new area before secondary.

Agree with this. I work in Y5 and we have had 2 new children and lost one this year. Primary age tend to adapt to new folks better than secondary.

Your intended secondary will have a multi-primary intake and streaming will be based initially on Y6 SATs, so DC may be at a disadvantage if current school is not pushing. Also there tends to be some cliquing based on primary school, so DS may be the outsider.
Does he go to cubs? You could change packs instead, which will get him to know new area boys if you do not change schools

ChanelNo19EDT · 22/01/2024 22:02

I didn't read it like that. I think when you ''move up a rung'' it can be complicated because you can lose friendships. Maybe they were only situational friendships. I'm not at the top of any food chains oh boy oh no but when I was a single parent (not working) I made a couple of friends in similar boats. One of them I've lost because she was angry when I got a full time job. Stupid as she had all day free and I envied that sometimes. Anyway, I wouldn't assume that ''how can I phrase this'' is an automatic brag.

Jewel52 · 22/01/2024 21:57

DietrichandDiMaggio · 22/01/2024 20:48

You can't have been here long if this counts as the most braggy thread you've seen.

This op isn’t posting because she’s bothered about what others will think about her son moving schools - seriously nobody ever demands a reason why a family move because that’s their business. This is an exercise in self congratulation - the endless reference to “affluent area, more middle class” zzzzzzzzz

Sennelier1 · 22/01/2024 21:46

@Definitelylivedin absolutely, but maybe they can drive him back the rest of Y5 ánd encourage him to get to know the new neighbours' children. He'll probably prefer walking to school with them instead of being shuttled to his old school, and then maybe even ask himself to go to the local school!

angela1952 · 22/01/2024 21:17

Notsoadmirablecrichton · 21/01/2024 08:28

You say you will travel back for Y5/6 but it may be easier to consider a school move too so DC is going to secondary school with new local friends. Ultimately, you choose the school but by 10 or 11 DC are more vocal about their wants so if they are at the old primary school still then your current local secondary will be a big draw as it will represent going with friends.

Yes, my DS and DIL did this, leaving a London borough where the secondary schools were pretty poor to live in Surrey near much better schools. They moved to a primary school in the new areas and the girls have made lots of friends who will move through secondary school with them. They were very behind at the new primary school when they arrived, even though their London primary was considered to be good.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 22/01/2024 20:57

As someone who did a similar move at the start of year 5, and who works in year 6, I would say stick with your original plan of keeping him at his current school if it is not particularly inconvenient.
Most children who arrive with us in year 6 settle in fine and make friends, but I think if they can do all those year 6 things with friends they've had all through primary they enjoy them more.
My son went to a different school to all but one person in his primary and had no problem making new friends at secondary school.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 22/01/2024 20:48

ChihuahuasREvil · 22/01/2024 18:15

lol, this is about the most braggy thread I’ve ever seen on here, and that’s some stiff competition. I was going to write humble braggy but there’s nothing humble about it.

You can't have been here long if this counts as the most braggy thread you've seen.

LawfulSearch · 22/01/2024 20:35

Stop overthinking it. I doubt anyone will ask. Just say I wanted a smaller/bigger/lighter/darker/ modern/old fashioned kitchen. Job done.

JuniperKeats · 22/01/2024 19:18

I’d move his primary school before he starts yr7 so he has an opportunity to make new friends for beginning secondary.

WonderingWanda · 22/01/2024 19:05

Everyone will know you've moved for catchment anyway so I wouldn't worry about it.

Mistlebough · 22/01/2024 18:25

The bigger picture is doing the best for DC. Years from now it won’t matter what people thoughtof your move. But to be sensitive yes focus on house pluses. Re moving Y6. We moved area and deliberately chose to move for last two terms of Y6. It was heartbreaking to leave the amazing primary behind and all the extra special things about Y6 traditions like residential etc when they've shared history together through the school. But it did help with transitioning to secondary.

DC was given great welcome in new school and all her friends went on to the same secondary and continued friendships for a good while. It’s a tough one to call. Once you find a house, can you give DS the choice of moving and making new friends for secondary or staying or will he definitely choose the familiar?

Puffthemagicdragongoestobed · 22/01/2024 18:20

We did the same move as you a few years ago. I think when we talked to our eldest about it we focused on both the house (bigger garden) and also emphasised an aspect of the school my kids wouldn't have had at the local school - this aspect was very particular to us as a family (MFL offering), but less so for the other families in our previous area.
I never moved my eldest in year 5 or 6, and I am glad I didn't. His friendship group at his junior school was established since reception, and I think it would have been a shame spending year 6 at a school where he had no friends. He made a lovely group of new friends in year 7/ year 8 at his secondary - I really don't think moving him in year 5 or 6 would have made a big difference in that respect.

ChanelNo19EDT · 22/01/2024 18:16

Very diplomatic of you imo.
I was conscious of who sent their children to private school without criticising the local schools!! It is an art!

Could you say you fell in love with the house, got the calculator out and decided to splurge on the house and save elsewhere.

Or say it's near your cousin. School friend. Brother..

ChihuahuasREvil · 22/01/2024 18:15

lol, this is about the most braggy thread I’ve ever seen on here, and that’s some stiff competition. I was going to write humble braggy but there’s nothing humble about it.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 22/01/2024 18:09

Friendships definitely shift in year 7 (I’ve had 3 go through that; youngest in year 8 now). All mine would have been really upset to miss out on year 6 in their established school. Stick with your original plan.

Lurkermumofadults · 22/01/2024 18:07

Our near neighbours did this as there was one school that all the more middle class parents sent their kids to and she was an absolute snob (we fell out over this amongst other things). Imagine her surprise when my son was offered a place at the same school without us moving! But as it turns out, nearly all the children who went to the local 'sink' school have all done very well in life, the school now has a much better reputation locally and in fact would probably have suited my son more as he wasn't very academic and had more friends at this school. So be careful what you wish for!

ScottishWaylander · 22/01/2024 18:01

I'd keep him where he's happy in primary school and wait for year 7 to leave his friends. It will be hard to establish a friendship group in year 6 and then have to do it again in year 7. Moving school is a big thing so to do it an extra time when he's happy seems a shame.

As a year 7 form tutor, I found that most kids drifted away from their friends from primary school in the first term- as they found 'their tribe' in the bigger pond. I'd rather make friends in year 7 where everything is up in the air than try to 'break into' established friendship groups that have been through primary school together.

He'll also have a better chance of keeping up a friendship long term with a best friend from primary if he finishes year 6 with them.

mamamamamamamamamamachameleon · 22/01/2024 18:01

Not quite what you asked, I know, but in my experience it's rare for primary school friendships to outlive the move to secondary - even the same secondary - by much more than a year or so anyway. It's incredible how children find new friendship groups when they move up - mine stay in touch via on-line chats with a couple of primary friends but the ones they moved up with they hardly see now (they are 14 and 17), though of course are on friendly terms. So just zoning in on that aspect of your question, don't worry, and good luck with the move x

wouldthatbeworse · 21/01/2024 19:59

RootVegAndMash · 21/01/2024 17:41

The place where you've all really got me thinking is moving schools for Y6. I was planning on hopefully moving younger DS, currently in year2, when the older one started secondary. I hadn't really considered moving my older son

Everyone told me to move ds1 when we moved. Everyone. Family, friends, mumsnet. He, being 10, begged to stay at his existing school for Y6 and we unfortunately listened.

We didn't move him and instead ferried him back and forth in Y6 then he started comp alone. It's honestly one of the biggest regrets I have in my life (sounds dramatic but true). He struggled so much to fit in. Hated that everyone in his form knew at least some people and therefore grouped together and he knew no one. Really, really struggled until Y9.

He's now in Y11 and it's all worked out fine, he's found his crowd and has a good social life. But he's kept the memory of Y7 and Y8 and openly says he wishes he'd moved in Y6.

Ds2, who we DID move in Y6...he was awfully upset at the move initially. He was then thanking us for moving him before the Christmas holidays of Y6.

Thank you. I do appreciate the opinions even if they're not what I want to hear. DS is so excited about a lot of the Y6 traditions he's seen at his current school - particularly the residential. BUT none of that is worth years of misery after.

On other boards there is a lot of chat about all the friendship groups resetting at year 7 but I imagine people do stick to those they know in the first few weeks/months/longer.

OP posts:
RootVegAndMash · 21/01/2024 17:41

The place where you've all really got me thinking is moving schools for Y6. I was planning on hopefully moving younger DS, currently in year2, when the older one started secondary. I hadn't really considered moving my older son

Everyone told me to move ds1 when we moved. Everyone. Family, friends, mumsnet. He, being 10, begged to stay at his existing school for Y6 and we unfortunately listened.

We didn't move him and instead ferried him back and forth in Y6 then he started comp alone. It's honestly one of the biggest regrets I have in my life (sounds dramatic but true). He struggled so much to fit in. Hated that everyone in his form knew at least some people and therefore grouped together and he knew no one. Really, really struggled until Y9.

He's now in Y11 and it's all worked out fine, he's found his crowd and has a good social life. But he's kept the memory of Y7 and Y8 and openly says he wishes he'd moved in Y6.

Ds2, who we DID move in Y6...he was awfully upset at the move initially. He was then thanking us for moving him before the Christmas holidays of Y6.

wouldthatbeworse · 21/01/2024 13:38

Daisypod · 21/01/2024 13:34

Check the admittance for the secondary schools you want too. Where we live they have to have been in the feeder school from the Easter of year 5 otherwise they do t get in. Worth checking

Thanks. There's no official feeder schools where we live. This is one of reasons I'd originally thought against moving DS in Y5 as it's possible half the kids in the new primary would go on to different secondaries. The new area is more affluent and a proportion of people will go private despite the excellent comp. Their choice of course!

OP posts:
Daisypod · 21/01/2024 13:34

Check the admittance for the secondary schools you want too. Where we live they have to have been in the feeder school from the Easter of year 5 otherwise they do t get in. Worth checking

NoHunsHereHun · 21/01/2024 13:28

wouldthatbeworse · 21/01/2024 13:08

The place where you've all really got me thinking is moving schools for Y6. I was planning on hopefully moving younger DS, currently in year2, when the older one started secondary. I hadn't really considered moving my older son.

In other mumsnet threads people have often cautioned against moving a happy child. Older DS is very happy and has a lovely group of friends. I expect he would be very resistant but it may well avoid problems down the line. I will speak to the LEA about what is available to at least make an informed decision.

If you have a younger DS then I would definitely try to move them both, ideally at the same time. In practice this isn’t always possible but your LEA will be able to advise best. You’ll be able to build relationships with parents in your younger DS year which will also likely help with your elder DS settling in.

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 13:20

I had a slightly similar experience in that my DD was offered our catchment school and I went to appeal to get her into a better school. When I spoke about it to other parents who's DC (had no choice) would attend the school, I just said the other school would meet Dd's needs better rather than criticise the school. But in your situation I wouldn't mention the school as anything to do with moving.

Swipe left for the next trending thread