Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to broach personal hygiene to friend?

84 replies

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 06:49

A group of us have a friend who has had some serious issues over the last 20 years which have resulted in some mental health issues. This lady is mid 40's and has a lot of pets. Unfortunately they keep breeding and toilet all over the house, including on her clothes. It has reached a point, has been for several years, where you can smell her before you can see her. Our friendship group seem to be "too nice" in that no one has directly mentioned it. However we were out and a passerby said loudly "OMG what is that terrible SMELL?" as they went past her, which she seems to have heard. She did ask the group directly but none of us fessed up and was honest, making excuses like "oh I have a cold at the moment" or blatantly lying. I really don't know what to do for the best and whether talking to the group about taking some sort of action is the best way forward. We've just let her get on with her own thing and not wanted to sound rude in the past but the direct questioning of it made me realise that she doesn't actually know, which I think we all assumed she did and it was a choice. She fell out with a friend recently by arguing that she washes and does self-care "just for men" and became very judgemental, to the point the friend now won't speak to her. I don't want to approach this in the wrong way. She has access to hot water, mum lives nearby, friends offer facilities. Is she just happy doing her own thing or should we be doing more as friends?

OP posts:
newyearnewnothing · 21/01/2024 08:33

Tell her it was her that smelled.
Tell her you didn't say anything at the time as you didn't want to mention it in a group situation.
Ask her if she needs help.'tell her you will let her know quietly in the future if she smells so she can quickly and quietly address the situation.

NotQuiteNorma · 21/01/2024 08:32

Your only other option is to all tell the truth which risks alienating her from the group but if you put your heads together could be done in a smart way that doesn't hurt her feelings. It's never easy. We assume we would all know if we stank but some people are in denial and others line your friend are so used to the ming that they become blind to it. It's like my plug ins, I get so used to them I can't smell it but everyone else comments how lovely or strong it smells.

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:31

@NotQuiteNorma a lot of the animal sheltered are full. Even though these are young animals they don't have space. She also sells some of them where she can. The neutering is an issue but short of us all paying for them all to be done and hoping that ends it (dubious as if strays are found the neighbours take them to her) which doesn't seem to be in line with personal choice. Her mum is not poor either but hasn't done this.

OP posts:
NotQuiteNorma · 21/01/2024 08:28

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:25

@duckpancakes essentially yes. Which is why I feel uncomfortable and have asked. It doesn't feel like we are being good friends if we can't be honest but I'm not really sure she wants honesty.

I expect this has all got so out of control that honesty would probably be seen as a personal attack. I would be looking at other ways of tackling it, like helping reduce the hoard of animals. There will be charities that can take on some if she's willing. If she's not willing then you have to accept she's choosing this to a degree.

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:27

@NotQuiteNorma the friend she fell out with did used to take her with the animals to get them neutered when the free spaces came up at the vets. RSPCA have been round and seem satisfied. The house is not sanitary but I guess they aren't too worried about that as the animals are all healthy.

OP posts:
Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:25

@duckpancakes essentially yes. Which is why I feel uncomfortable and have asked. It doesn't feel like we are being good friends if we can't be honest but I'm not really sure she wants honesty.

OP posts:
NotQuiteNorma · 21/01/2024 08:24

What about dealing with the source and addressing the hoarding of animals? Perhaps get her some help and advice about rehoming and neutering. Maybe it has got so out of control she just doesn't know how to re-home so many or have the finances to neuter. That way you're dealing with it without making it a 'her' issue and risking defensiveness. She only smells because the hoarding of pets has got out of control. Maybe if she had less of them they won't be pissing everywhere.

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:23

@Moonshine5 so you think just leave her to it, as we have been, and let it continue is the kindest thing to do?

OP posts:
duckpancakes · 21/01/2024 08:22

She asked you if it was her that the stranger was commenting on and instead of saying I think it might be your outfit does smell quite animally today you all lied??

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:22

@JMSA that's how the friend who used to help out a lot feels. She can certainly be judgemental of others but doesn't like the same back. I suppose that is why none of us feel comfortable bringing it up.

OP posts:
Moonshine5 · 21/01/2024 08:22

But it's her life and we are allowed agency.

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:21

@Moonshine5 but does that make it OK? When strangers comment it can't be nice to know other people smell it a lot more?

OP posts:
JMSA · 21/01/2024 08:20

I think you need to stop pussyfooting around. If she's vocal about hating people who wear make-up 🙄, then she's surely able to hear that she fucking stinks.

If she turns her back on you then that's on her. To be honest, she sounds like a pain in the arse to me.

Moonshine5 · 21/01/2024 08:18

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:16

@Moonshine5 exactly and this is why none of us have bought it up. She is educated and doesn't seem to care what other people think which is why we all have given up suggesting things.

She has a lot of self confidence, despite all of this and is certainly not a danger to herself. It was just a stark realisation that she can't smell what we can, which can be quite eye-watering and the directness made some of us question why we don't feel able to be honest.

Maybe she can smell it but does not have the same reaction as you show. Thinks it's ok.

Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:16

@Moonshine5 exactly and this is why none of us have bought it up. She is educated and doesn't seem to care what other people think which is why we all have given up suggesting things.

She has a lot of self confidence, despite all of this and is certainly not a danger to herself. It was just a stark realisation that she can't smell what we can, which can be quite eye-watering and the directness made some of us question why we don't feel able to be honest.

OP posts:
Advicetohelp · 21/01/2024 08:10

The problems are animal related and she has had RSCPA called on her before. She is getting mental health support and it is poverty related. The problem with telling her directly is that when the other friend who she now doesn't talk to used to try to help her she has turned on her. Now it feels as though she is happy being as she is (there was a whole discussion about "not giving a fuck" and she openly despises people who wear make-up). The animals pee on her bag, for example, which she knows so now only uses cloth bags so she can wash them. So she is aware to a point but none of us know where the line of personal choice ends.

OP posts:
Kittylala · 21/01/2024 08:09

Lodevis too short for this nonsense. Move on and let herself work it out.

JMSA · 21/01/2024 08:07

But not as a group ... one designated person.

Moonshine5 · 21/01/2024 08:06

You mind your business. She is your friend and entitled to live her life how she wants. We shouldn't inflict our views on others. Is she a danger to herself or others? No. It's just a smell. Is she a good person?

JMSA · 21/01/2024 08:06

Cruel to be kind ... you've got to tell her.

wonkywardrobes · 21/01/2024 08:04

You mentioned that she'd asked you but you all just pretended you had a cold etc...I think she's actually given you the perfect opening line.

If she's asked she must be secretly thinking about it, so perhaps you could go round and say gently that you're all desperate not to hurt her feelings which is why the other day when she asked, you bluffed. But now you've thought about it, as a friend you care for her and feel you need to tell her.

At that point you could give her the choice and say you know it's a very sensitive, private matter and you're happy to continue talking with her about it, giving some examples but if she doesn't want to talk about it, you're happy to leave the conversation there. That way you've given her the option.

Does she work? I would assume if she works, this would be a problem in her job too? Ultimately you want to spare her the pain of more people saying cruel things.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 21/01/2024 07:45

Just pull her aside next tim you see her and tell her you & the others have noticed her coat/ clothes smell a bit.... but than I am quite direct.

I once had to pull someone at work up on their personal hygiene. Not a great conversion at all.
But, it turns out that person was in a house share with limited access to washing machine.... a chat with good solutions turned it round within 24 hours. (Have to say this person was ony 18 and had very little 'adult support' outside work.)

Somethingintheloft · 21/01/2024 07:38

Sometimes you have to be cruel to be kind. But not actually cruel if you see what I mean. Talk to her kindly and explain that you noticed her clothes smelling of animal urine etc and wandered if she would like some enzyme treatment and bring some with you!

Ask her if everything is OK in calm and safe environment. Maybe she just needs a friend

SparkleyMud · 21/01/2024 07:35

I don't think you need to approach this as a group, I can't see how that would go well. That would make her feel like you've all been talking behind her back.

I think it's best just to mention it one to one. If you say it in a matter of fact way then she's mess likely to feel embarrassed if you approach it all top toey and awkward your feelings are going to run off on her and give her reason to feel embarrassed.

Good advice above has been given about saying that it's a particular clothing that smells as that will be less personal.

AhhhThereWeAreThen · 21/01/2024 07:32

A true friend would find a way to gently tell her and work with her to find a solution, not leave her this way for so long.

Swipe left for the next trending thread