Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are some people anti Ai

37 replies

NedLuddlite · 21/01/2024 01:33

The comparison between modern-day concerns about artificial intelligence (AI) and historical Luddites provides a fascinating lens through which to examine societal reactions to technological advancements. The Luddites were a group of English textile workers in the early 19th century who protested against the industrialization of their craft, fearing that new machinery would replace their jobs and disrupt their way of life. Drawing parallels between their concerns and contemporary apprehensions about AI reveals both similarities and differences.

Similarities:

Job Displacement:

Luddites: The primary concern of the Luddites was the displacement of skilled workers by automated machinery. They feared that the introduction of power looms and other mechanical devices would render their craftsmanship obsolete, leading to unemployment.

Modern-day AI: There are parallel concerns today regarding the impact of AI on employment. Automation and AI technologies have the potential to replace certain jobs, especially those that involve repetitive tasks. The fear is that as AI systems become more sophisticated, they might encroach upon a wide range of professions, leading to job displacement.

Economic Inequality:

Luddites: The Luddites were also motivated by concerns about economic inequality. They believed that the benefits of industrialization would be concentrated in the hands of factory owners, leading to the impoverishment of the working class.

Modern-day AI: Similar concerns exist in the context of AI. Questions about who controls and benefits from AI technologies, as well as the potential for increased economic inequality, are prominent in discussions. Issues such as the concentration of AI development in certain corporations or countries and the potential for job losses among the less-skilled workforce contribute to these concerns.

Resistance to Change:

Luddites: The Luddites resisted technological change, viewing it as a threat to their established way of life and livelihoods.
Modern-day AI: There is a parallel resistance to the widespread adoption of AI technologies. This resistance can be rooted in concerns about job displacement, ethical implications, and the broader societal impacts of AI. Some argue that the rapid pace of AI development may outstrip society's ability to adapt responsibly.
Differences:

Nature of Technology:

Luddites: The Luddites were primarily concerned with the introduction of specific machinery in the textile industry.

Modern-day AI: The concerns about AI are more diverse, encompassing a broad range of applications from autonomous vehicles and natural language processing to machine learning algorithms used in finance, healthcare, and more. The scale and scope of AI's potential impact on various aspects of society set it apart from the specific technological advancements faced by the Luddites.
Global Impact:

Luddites: The Luddite movement was localized to specific regions in England and was largely a response to the changing dynamics of the textile industry in that era.

Modern-day AI: Concerns about AI have a global dimension. AI technologies are being developed and implemented worldwide, raising questions about international collaboration, regulation, and ethical standards on a global scale. The implications of AI extend far beyond the borders of any single country.

Acknowledgment of Benefits:

Luddites: The Luddites were skeptical of the benefits of industrialization, seeing it primarily as a threat.

Modern-day AI: While concerns exist, there is a broader recognition of the potential benefits of AI, including increased efficiency, advancements in healthcare, and solutions to complex problems. The discourse around AI often involves a nuanced evaluation of both its risks and rewards.

In conclusion, the comparison between modern-day concerns about AI and historical Luddites reveals shared anxieties about job displacement, economic inequality, and resistance to technological change. However, the differences in the nature and global impact of the technologies highlight the complexity of the AI discourse. It is crucial for society to engage in thoughtful and informed discussions, considering the ethical, economic, and social implications of AI while also recognizing its potential contributions to human progress.

OP posts:
parietal · 21/01/2024 05:12

AI is also a fancy search engine.

I work in science/tech and I'm also with the luddites on this. Current AI is biased and error prone and there are big risks with its use.

Vegetus · 21/01/2024 04:38

LittleGreenDragons · 21/01/2024 01:40

I couldn't read all that but I do urge you to read about the DPD AI that was naughty, and the one that gave away a brand new car for a dollar...

Chats bots are not really AI, They are more like a fancy search engine.

heartofglass23 · 21/01/2024 03:27

The terminator is coming.

2024GarlicCloves · 21/01/2024 02:34

Visions of a hi-tech utopia proposed, not unreasonably, that humanity would be freed of unwanted and unsatisfying labour, enabling us all to do whatever we feel enhances our lives in safety and economic security. Societies would run on AI-driven automation, anticipating and meeting our needs in a timely, efficient manner.

It could still happen. But it won't. We should have been moving away from 'jobs' and 'wages' for the 70-odd years since this has been apparent. We should've been gradually restructuring economies so that funds became less concentrated among the owners of technology (in general) and more thoughtfully distributed among the majority.

Instead, the world's richest 0.01 per cent have amassed more and more of the world's wealth since the 1970s, while hundreds of millions more ordinary people have fallen into extreme poverty.

There isn't much time left to prevent this developing into the kind of hi-tech dystopia we now see in science fiction: a tiny group living in unimaginable comfort, with everyone else scrabbling desperately to survive in vile conditions. The concerns are similar to those of the Luddites, magnified to a global scale. Not a single industry in a few countries, but all 99.9% of human lives worldwide.

You might want to ask your chatbot, @NedLuddlite, what answers it proposes to this impending problem.

Why are some people anti Ai
steff13 · 21/01/2024 02:17

Is this a paper you've written? Did you want suggestions on editing or...?

WandaWonder · 21/01/2024 02:08

It's one great conspiracy spread by the robotic zombies who are trying to take over the world one hallucination medication at a time

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2024 02:08

araiwa · 21/01/2024 02:04

People have seen Terminator

Enjoy...

Why are some people anti Ai
araiwa · 21/01/2024 02:04

People have seen Terminator

EBearhug · 21/01/2024 01:52

I have a lot of sympathy with the Luddites - gave presentation about the 4th industrial revolution and mentioned the Luddites at some length. My background is history, with a focus on the industrial revolution, but I've worked in IT for over a quarter of a century.

We are right to be wary of AI - it's not necessarily bad, but rushed implementations are likely to be. We all know of poorly tested systems (The PO and Horizon?) and there have been plenty of systems based on AI which didn't do all that was hoped - one of the tech giants developed a recruitment system, training it on existing employees - so it learnt that the ideal employee was male etc - confirming and compounding the bias and imbalance that already exists in IT, so the opposite of what was hoped for.

We also see with Tata Steel that despite plenty of notice that this was likely to happen, the government has done bog all to ensure any sort of retraining or alternative jobs, in an area that has already been hammered by the loss of mining. AI will bring changes to the job market, and like the Luddites, lots of people will become redundant because of new technology. We could plan for this, but I don't see many signs this will happen.

Plus many people simply have no idea of how AI works, and Hollywood has fed us plenty of tales about robots going rogue, so people worry based on that sort of understanding.

LittleGreenDragons · 21/01/2024 01:40

I couldn't read all that but I do urge you to read about the DPD AI that was naughty, and the one that gave away a brand new car for a dollar...

Coyoacan · 21/01/2024 01:37

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2024 01:35

I'm assuming you wrote that with AI.

Very meta.

Hahaha

And the Luddites were right to be concerned

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2024 01:35

I'm assuming you wrote that with AI.

Very meta.