Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to stay in marriage with issues when biological clock ticking?

83 replies

barrelclip · 20/01/2024 11:44

I am 33 (and a half), DH is 35, we’ve been together 10 years and married for 2.

Over the past 6 months we’ve been struggling and I’ve been having serious doubts about our marriage. About a month or so ago this blew up a bit and we came the closest we had done to splitting up but decided to keep going. We haven’t had counselling (I suggested it but he wasn’t keen) but in the past month both of us have made changes and feel like we are making progress - although the anxiety remains.

I really want children in my life. DH does not actively ‘not’ want them and always says yes he’s happy to have kids in the future…but is significantly more ambivalent and tends to in general not look ahead more than 2-3 weeks in the future at a time. This is one of the major sources of the issues in our marriage. For a year or so we’ve not been using protection but it’s not really been TTC - it’s been pretty infrequent and not timed around ovulation, he’s never been a real ‘partner’ in me trying to conceive, he says he’d be happy if I was pregnant (which I guess is evidenced by him occasionally having unprotected sex) but he’s never going to be with me pushing for it. This came up after we married because we’d both always talked idly in the future about having kids, it’s when I started wanting to get going and he was more vague/ambivalent about it that our different views became more clear.

I have PCOS and don’t expect conceiving to necessarily be easy. He knows this.

In our blow up a month ago I communicated all of the above and he said he knew he’d been a dick and would change. It’s hard to ascertain right now if that’s true or not as we are emphatically NOT TTC anyway because of the marriage issues in general and I suspect probably won’t get there for a few months.

Despite everything said above, I love DH, I love our life together, divorce would devastate me, I’m not confident I’ll find someone else. Not to mention the financial/practical impact of leaving. In an alternate universe where I knew children were guaranteed whatever happened, I know that I would give this marriage a good go before leaving, probably at least another 6 months - year.

So my question is, if I want children…. What do I do?

A) (YABU) Leave now as I’ll never be younger than I am currently, potentially throwing away chance of children ever if I don’t find someone else?

B) (YANBU) try and forget about biological clock at present and give the marriage a proper go for 6 months - a year or so with a defined end point to either be actively TTC or leave (this is definitely what I’d do if I was younger?)

Thoughts welcome

OP posts:
HousePlantNeglect · 20/01/2024 14:15

CrispAppleStrudels · 20/01/2024 14:05

Such a tricky one, OP. I have PCOS - first baby took 2 years, lots of precise tracking and fertility treatment (ovulation induction, not IVF) to conceive when i was 35. Prior to beginning TTC at 33, i had already been seen in the endocrinology clinic, so I had a good plan for managing the PCOS and getting things on track. Second baby was conceived naturally after around 9 months of TTC at 37. So not impossible, but i certainly wouldnt want to be wasting time if your DH cannot make a decision.

Whilst it wasnt as difficult a process as IVF, it was still pretty unpleasant for both me and DH. I had lots of test, internal scans, blood taken and at one point was going to have to have an HSG as well. The drugs caused some very horrible hormonal side effects for me. DH was amazingly supportive and i absolutely needed him to be on board 100% - would you be able to say the same about your DH?

If you and your DH did split up and you do want to have children, how would you feel about needing to go down the donor route (if you didnt meet a new partner) or being childfree? Not that these are reasons to stay in an unhappy marriage, but you do need to be honest with yourself about how you would feel about it. You say your DH didn't want to talk to a therapist but you could see one yourself and explore some of these thoughts independently of him?

I would also say that the first year of a new child is unbelievably difficult even for a happy, solid couple. Our first baby was very poorly at birth and then i had PND. It put a massive strain on us, on top of all the normal sleep deprivation / life change of a newborn etc. If he isn't committed, it will be so hard for you and any resentment will just grow.

Not an easy one - do you have anyone in real life you can talk to?

Edited

I wanted to share almost exactly the same. I also have PCOS and it took me three years to get pregnant the first time. Happy to say I now have three and it got easier each time but it is much more of a rocky road than for your average couple. I had to religiously track my cycle, have sex at the right time, have a lot of sex, and I thought about TTC constantly. Me and DH were in a good place but it put an enormous strain on our relationship and our sex life, and it took us a long time to recover emotionally.

So, what I'm saying is do consider how it will work going into this with someone who is unsupportive.

If he won't have counselling would you consider it for yourself? So that you have someone to talk it through with.

ringmybe11 · 20/01/2024 14:10

To add to what I posted earlier and having read other responses I think you should separate the trying to conceive and what he'd be like as a husband and parent. I've already said that you taking the lead on conceiving in my opinion is ok, but what is your DH like round the house, does he contribute to the household, what's his attitude towards finances etc if you are on mat leave/reduced income? Is he kind and considerate of your feelings, do you think he would share parenting with you - night feeds, nappies, entertaining a small person and reduce the time he spends on his own hobbies and interests?

My opinion seems to be in the minority but im conscious that I think I would have received similar advice if I'd written this post a couple of years ago and it's all worked out for me. My husband just needed a nudge in the right direction and I'm unsure whether you are in a similar situation or whether bigger issues are at play.

CrispAppleStrudels · 20/01/2024 14:05

Such a tricky one, OP. I have PCOS - first baby took 2 years, lots of precise tracking and fertility treatment (ovulation induction, not IVF) to conceive when i was 35. Prior to beginning TTC at 33, i had already been seen in the endocrinology clinic, so I had a good plan for managing the PCOS and getting things on track. Second baby was conceived naturally after around 9 months of TTC at 37. So not impossible, but i certainly wouldnt want to be wasting time if your DH cannot make a decision.

Whilst it wasnt as difficult a process as IVF, it was still pretty unpleasant for both me and DH. I had lots of test, internal scans, blood taken and at one point was going to have to have an HSG as well. The drugs caused some very horrible hormonal side effects for me. DH was amazingly supportive and i absolutely needed him to be on board 100% - would you be able to say the same about your DH?

If you and your DH did split up and you do want to have children, how would you feel about needing to go down the donor route (if you didnt meet a new partner) or being childfree? Not that these are reasons to stay in an unhappy marriage, but you do need to be honest with yourself about how you would feel about it. You say your DH didn't want to talk to a therapist but you could see one yourself and explore some of these thoughts independently of him?

I would also say that the first year of a new child is unbelievably difficult even for a happy, solid couple. Our first baby was very poorly at birth and then i had PND. It put a massive strain on us, on top of all the normal sleep deprivation / life change of a newborn etc. If he isn't committed, it will be so hard for you and any resentment will just grow.

Not an easy one - do you have anyone in real life you can talk to?

laclochette · 20/01/2024 14:05

He doesn't sound like a supportive partner.
He isn't taking your goals seriously. That would entail sitting down and figuring out together what it will take from you both to achieve a supposedly stated shared goal, in this case, having a family. He sounds both avoidant and ambivalent.
Is he like this about other areas of your life?

SeaToSki · 20/01/2024 14:04

I would suggest you both need proper counseling to dig into all of these issues in your marriage. What about asking him to participate in at least 6 sessions with you to show that he meant that he wanted to change. Also, your first counsellor might not be the best fit, so it might be worth you doing a few solo session first to find someone you think will mesh with you both and hold you both accountable.

MrsMarzetti · 20/01/2024 14:02

So you are happy to bring a child into a rocky relationship ? Why on earth would you do that ?

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 20/01/2024 13:57

If you have kids with him I think it's very likely that you'll end up doing all the parenting yourself and if you try to call him up on it he'll tell you that you're the one who wanted kids not him. If kids are your priority you can go solo for IVF with a donor. A friend of mine did it.

SwordToFlamethrower · 20/01/2024 13:52

Don't have kids with a man that isn't fully committed to kids as well.

Trust me.

He won't do his share either the kids or to you or to the home.

He will put it all on you because YOU wanted them, so not his problem.

Get rid and cut your losses.

AnnaTortoiseshell · 20/01/2024 13:46

If you have children with this man then they’ll be half his. Would you be happy for him to have sole care of your children up to half the week if you split up? Would you be happy to be away from them that long? Would your parenting styles match up enough? Children really put pressure on a relationship and if he’s a bit lazy before you have kids it’ll be a real issue afterwards.

With the TTC we didn’t have to do this but I’m sure if we had to put the effort in it would have been led by me entirely. But I’m the one in our relationship who would know when I’m ovulating so that makes sense. Do you initiate sex when you’re in your fertile
window? Does he actually know what TTC entails? He may not…

Grilly · 20/01/2024 13:41

If you want to separate, then separate. But to be honest it sounds like you love him but you’re bored in a long-term relationship and making dramas and ultimatums and unnecessary problems out of nothing.

Grilly · 20/01/2024 13:37

I don’t really get what your problem is. Are you tracking your ovulation and initiating sex at the right times? Are you managing your PCOS, taking supplements and having any necessary tests?

It sounds like neither of you can be bothered to have sex and that’s why you’re not having children.

montysorry · 20/01/2024 13:17

It sounds like you have a few issues rather than just the baby issue.

You seem to have sex very infrequently for a couple not long married and without kids. This may suit you both, but be sure it does.

You don’t seem to communicate well as you felt you’d discussed TTC before marriage when he clearly wasn’t on the same page. DH and I talked about how long we should enjoy marriage just us and how much we needed to save so we had a rough month in mind to start TTC a certain time after marriage. We also talked about what would happen financially and in terms of jobs-who, if either of us, would go p/t and for how long. How we’d need to have joint finances if one of us did go p/t or SAH et.

The world is full of women whose husbands were ambivalent about having a baby or didn’t want to do it, ‘yet’. They then wasted their fertile years trying to change his mind. Sadly, those men often then leave their wives in their late 40s or early 50s and have babies with a women in her 30s leaving the ex wife single and childless with no hope of motherhood left.

Good luck

Blahblahblahblahblahurgh · 20/01/2024 13:08

Howsoon23 · 20/01/2024 11:53

In my experience if a marriage has problems before kids - kids are likely to make it worse

This. If he is very 'meh' about the direction of the relationship now, imagine absolutely everything involving a child falling on you. Every night feed, nappy, decision.

I would bet my house that if you did have kids with this man your relationship would crumbled within about six weeks at best.

onlyforeignerinthevillage · 20/01/2024 13:03

OP, what are the other issues in your relationship? I note you mentioned having sex 10x in 12 months, which could be perfectly fine but could also be relatively infrequent and a sign of something else in the relationship.

onlyforeignerinthevillage · 20/01/2024 13:01

Outthedoor24 · 20/01/2024 12:15

I think you need to chat together. Does he want kids or not?
What lengths are you both prepared to go do?

GP would consider you've been TTC for 12 mths. I'd try and get a referral into fertility unit at least. These things are never fast - very low on the NHS priority list.
PCOS - doesn't mean a baby can't happen naturally. But it's wise to get the ball in motion.

I know 6 baby's born to mums with PCOS. 2 natural, 4 were fertility babies of the 4 (3 IUI, 1IVF)

Just to add, I have PCOS and got pregnant naturally so it is definitely possible. I was told by an obs/gynae that The way PCOS affects fertility is how it affects your cycle and leads to no periods. Are you having regular periods, OP?

barrelclip · 20/01/2024 12:54

ringmybe11 · 20/01/2024 12:44

We would not have DS if it wasn't for me tracking my cycle and making sure we DTD at the right time. DH said he would be happy to be a dad but wouldn't have ever been proactive about it. I was 38 and him 45 when we conceived so time wasn't on our side either. DH is the most wonderful dad and adores DS completely. If your DH is happy to be a dad but you're the one instigating things does it really matter? It depends whether there are other issues outside this which you need to be honest with yourself about.

Thanks - this is helpful perspective. There are definitely other issues, but this is the ultimate issue which the others pretty much also are related to or stem back from (general sex not being that frequent, general his lack of forward planning, me working too much/throwing myself into social life when in denial to face my feelings about the situation etc).

OP posts:
cheezncrackers · 20/01/2024 12:49

to be fair, after our big blow up last month he did say ‘yes, I want a baby with you’ (including saying that if I left him I’d never have a baby…) but as we haven’t TTC since obviously have not put this to the test.

In that case, why not call his bluff and say 'I want us to start trying now' and see what he says?

barrelclip · 20/01/2024 12:47

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 20/01/2024 12:37

Your DH is 35 and still ambivalent which in itself is telling that he probably doesn't really want kids. He told he will change but I would want to know does he actually want kids or is he not fussed, because having kids with a man who doesn't want them is a recipe for disaster. And take this from someone who's been through stillbirth and miscarriage - if things are tough (none of us know til we are pregnant or trying how it will go for us and you say things might be tougher with PCOS), you need a really strong support foundation from your DH when you're doing this, and if he isn't going to be that for you, I'd really consider whether this is the right thing.

In DH mind he’d be just as happy if he had kids and if he didn’t and is happy to see which option life throws at him. I used to think that would be enough…

to be fair, after our big blow up last month he did say ‘yes, I want a baby with you’ (including saying that if I left him I’d never have a baby…) but as we haven’t TTC since obviously have not put this to the test.

OP posts:
ringmybe11 · 20/01/2024 12:44

We would not have DS if it wasn't for me tracking my cycle and making sure we DTD at the right time. DH said he would be happy to be a dad but wouldn't have ever been proactive about it. I was 38 and him 45 when we conceived so time wasn't on our side either. DH is the most wonderful dad and adores DS completely. If your DH is happy to be a dad but you're the one instigating things does it really matter? It depends whether there are other issues outside this which you need to be honest with yourself about.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 20/01/2024 12:37

Your DH is 35 and still ambivalent which in itself is telling that he probably doesn't really want kids. He told he will change but I would want to know does he actually want kids or is he not fussed, because having kids with a man who doesn't want them is a recipe for disaster. And take this from someone who's been through stillbirth and miscarriage - if things are tough (none of us know til we are pregnant or trying how it will go for us and you say things might be tougher with PCOS), you need a really strong support foundation from your DH when you're doing this, and if he isn't going to be that for you, I'd really consider whether this is the right thing.

barrelclip · 20/01/2024 12:34

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/01/2024 12:31

Would you be happier single no kids or divorced with kids?

One of my big conundrums, I guess I can’t imagine if I had a child I would regret having that child even if I ended up a single co-parent.

I also in general have never lived alone and the idea scares me even short term (I’ve been with DH since I was 23, and even before that I had another long term ex from 19 - 22). The idea of being in 40s, alone, without children terrifies me.

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 20/01/2024 12:31

Would you be happier single no kids or divorced with kids?

AgentJohnson · 20/01/2024 12:27

To be honest it sounds like you are flogging a dead horse. The six month deadline is more about you saying you’ve tried when the reality is your H doesn’t sound at all bothered about improving the situation.

I’d be interested in understanding why you got married, especially since this very important topic doesn’t appear to have been discussed in any detail?

barrelclip · 20/01/2024 12:18

Outthedoor24 · 20/01/2024 12:15

I think you need to chat together. Does he want kids or not?
What lengths are you both prepared to go do?

GP would consider you've been TTC for 12 mths. I'd try and get a referral into fertility unit at least. These things are never fast - very low on the NHS priority list.
PCOS - doesn't mean a baby can't happen naturally. But it's wise to get the ball in motion.

I know 6 baby's born to mums with PCOS. 2 natural, 4 were fertility babies of the 4 (3 IUI, 1IVF)

Thank you - I think one of my big fears in all of this is I just can’t imagine a scenario where if we went through IVF etc he’d be a supportive partner in that (although maybe I’m being unfair, and need to give him more of a chance).

Although technically a GP may consider it’s been 12 months, to put in perspective in that 12 months we’ve probably had sex 10 times with only 2 or 3 in a part of a cycle where I’ve realistically had a shot of conceiving / him finishing… so I don’t really consider myself as having properly TTC tbh, however my cycles aren’t regular so I’m sure I probably will need help.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 20/01/2024 12:17

I would cut your losses and go tbh. It’s clear that he is at best lukewarm about having children and isn’t committed to trying to conceive properly, and, furthermore, that you seeking to accelerate this process will irritate him.

Actually having children puts an often intolerable burden on marriages anyway (just under half don’t survive). Strong marriages are frequently destroyed by the grind of raising children. It’s very tough and you need to be aligned on what you want before getting into this to have a chance.

Yes it’s possible that you won’t find another partner to have children with (though equally possible you will). But that’s not a reason to double down on something which is already dysfunctional before the most egregious stress point has been introduced. If you want children above all else you can do it on your own.

Whatever you do I would insist on counselling as a dealbreaker. If he can’t explore these fault lines in the relationship properly like an adult and confront the dilemma you aren’t going to be able to make these important decisions.