Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She said I am insinuating her 4 year old is a pervert

215 replies

Strawberrybubbble · 20/01/2024 11:04

Hello,

My 4 year old daughter has recently started using words to describe her private areas with words I have never used before.

In particular referring to her chest as boobies (not the most offensive I know but just not a word I or her father have ever used) and more grimly fanny.

I had a conversation with her last night just to find out where she had picked these words up - she said another 4 year old boy at her school (she used his name) kept asking her to show him her boobies and fanny. I told her she should not do this and they were hers and hers only.

Anyway, I told her father who has told his cousin immediately (he does have form for not keeping his mouth shut). Said cousin, is good friends with the 4 year old boys mum so it has now got back to her.

I was going to have a chat with her myself on Monday morning just to tell her what my daughter has said (I'd want to know - he has been saying this to 'all the girls' apparently).

Well, she has hit the roof. Said we are disgusting, we are implying her son is a pervert etc., we are wrong in the head, he is 4 years old.

That's absolutely not what we said - we questioned where they were picking up this language and where he had heard it.

Now, I know you can't take a 4 year olds word for certain every time but it is not anything we have ever said, she is not left to her own devices to watch anything unsupervised where she would have picked this up and is only ever looked after at nursery and by my parents (cannot imagine them using that language for a second). She was very clear in naming this boy.

Not sure where to go from here really. I would of liked to just let this mum know myself but my husband and his cousin have jumped in.

What would you make of this? My daughter is my oldest so not experienced this yet, not sure of a suitable reaction other than reminding her, her private parts are hers and hers only.

OP posts:
contrary13 · 20/01/2024 16:20

With regards to the other mother's angry messages - offence is the best line of defence. She thinks if she acts offended enough, you'll drop the whole thing - and she will have defended her child adequately. Unfortunately, that's not parenting. She ought to be wondering where her child has learned that asking a classmate to see parts of their body that kids are taught ought/need to remain private for their own protection, is "normal" (I know that if it were my child doing this... I would be horrified, not angry!).

School are the best ones to deal with it - and make sure you tell them that she has deliberately sought you out on social media to harangue you (show them the messages, too) because that's also a massive red flag when it comes to safeguarding. Something isn't quite right in this little boy's life - and it needs to be addressed for his own sake (not to mention your child and who knows how many others he's said this to, and they've actually done so...).

When my son (19) was in Yr 4, there was a boy in his class who was overtly sexual towards the other kids. Everyone, including the teacher, sort of turned a blind eye about the humping of girls if they bent over a table, the comments that the kids were actively telling their parents about that he was making to/about them, it was all fodder for the cliquey mums who don't like to rock the boat... but love to gossip. Well, the day my son came out of school and told me that this other boy had thrust his penis against my son's hip in class, in full view of everyone, and demanded to "see his package" whilst trying to grope his penis through his trousers - I hit the school office. Initiated safeguarding protocol (which they all seemed baffled by - but I was a university lecturer/taught kids younger than my son was on the weekend at a club, so I knew exactly what ought to be done) and was relentless about it. I would have done so when the tales first started drifting through the playground, but until it happened to my own child, it was hearsay. Gossip. I had no actual proof. The school weren't happy - tried to say that my son was lying... until I involved Children's Services (as a last resort, because I knew that this boy was picking it up from somewhere), at which point, an actual investigation took place.

The boy's teenage./young adult brothers thought it was funny to let him watch porn with them. Their mother was totally worn down (huge family, one baby pretty much after another for at least the twelve years that our sons were in the same schools/classes), had absolutely no idea - but would have reacted the exact same way, I daresay, as this boy's mother has done @Strawberrybubbble, because it's a primal maternal instinct to protect our babies... and was in an abusive relationship herself. I don't know the ins and outs of how it resolved itself, but the school did tell me that the boy was in counselling (I was genuinely concerned for his safety, as well as that of the other kids he was assaulting/harassing so that his 17 and 20 year old brothers could have a good laugh at his expense). My son was friends with this boy until they left school and I do know that he grew up to be staunch in standing up to other lads when they tried it on with disinterested girls.

I lost a lot of respect for some of the other mothers I'd made friends with in the playground for their lack of ability to step in and not exactly safeguard... just protect their own kids from this second hand abuse.

Often, all it takes to protect a child in need, is one adult to stand up and say "something isn't right here...".

Blueink · 20/01/2024 16:13

That’s a good update OP glad they accepted responsibility including a peace offering to the Mum.

soupfiend · 20/01/2024 15:48

Its right to raise it with the school but it is normal for children (who have just learned about differences in particular) to want to show or be shown body parts, its part of normal curiosity as well as being a worry if its coming from a place where the child is exposed to inappropriate behaviour.

But no one knows this until its looked at.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 20/01/2024 15:45

As others have said definitely highlight with school. Some kids are interested in others, we ve definitely had lads looking at/comparing 'willies' in the loos and as a school reinforce private body areas etc with no further issues
BUT
there may be other concerns already, there could be previous events with Siblings/family or with this child and this information could be used to format plans/actions.

Gazelda · 20/01/2024 15:32

OP, if I were you I'd send an email to the Designated Safeguarding Lead today, saying that you will be at school on Monday and would like to meet with her/him at 8.30 (or whatever time).

Don't leave it until Monday morning and then ask the admin team if anyone is available for a chat. Make it clear that this is a formal request for a meeting on a safeguarding issue.

Sadly, you may need to be ahead of the other parent who might want to sling mud at your family for spreading rumours. You sound level headed, so get in with the facts first.

Menomeno · 20/01/2024 15:26

Yayayyay · 20/01/2024 15:20

Saying bum and then giggling is totally different to a boy harassing girls by asking them to lift their tops up and show him their chests. OP needs to speak to the school.

I don’t know how many times I have to repeat myself. I agree that children should be taught that it’s completely inappropriate to ask other children to expose themselves. OP should definitely talk to the school about.

My comment was in relation to pp being horrified by the language used.

DontGoGran · 20/01/2024 15:26

haveyougotamin · 20/01/2024 14:52

Minnie is a stupid word for it, wouldn't have a clue what the child was talking about. At least with fanny most people understand and it's not a terrible/grim word fgs.

Obviously not the point of the thread but adding my thoughts!

This.

Our DD says vulva, and penis. Much better that a child is understood rather than these ridiculous euphemisms.

DD has a toy Minnie Mouse, could be very easily misinterpreted.

Yayayyay · 20/01/2024 15:20

Menomeno · 20/01/2024 13:19

Absolutely! Where I live it’s on a par with saying ‘bum’ or ‘willy’. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I’m really shocked that people have such a strong reaction to this.

Saying bum and then giggling is totally different to a boy harassing girls by asking them to lift their tops up and show him their chests. OP needs to speak to the school.

Thehamsterthatcametotea · 20/01/2024 15:11

Just to reassure you @Strawberrybubbble I think that you are dealing with this well. Don’t be tempted to engage with the other family and as you’ve already stated, speak with the school.

huggyduggy54 · 20/01/2024 15:09

Some posters on here need to familiarise themselves with the Brook traffic light tool.

Mischance · 20/01/2024 15:03

The point is not whether the words are rude or not, but that they are not the ones the OP's child uses, so she knew it must have come from some interaction with another child/person in which those words were used.

soupfiend · 20/01/2024 14:58

scorpiogirly · 20/01/2024 14:44

I don't see 'fanny' as a normal child term for this. I find it quite rude. We use Minnie for my 5yr old dd. She doesn't know penises exist so we don't have a name for them yet.

Regardless of what he is calling these parts, saying to girls to 'show me your fanny' is not normal for a 4 year old in my opinion.

This is ridiculous. It refers to the same part of the body and you decide one is 'rude' and one isnt

They're both ridiculous words

Menomeno · 20/01/2024 14:52

scorpiogirly · 20/01/2024 14:44

I don't see 'fanny' as a normal child term for this. I find it quite rude. We use Minnie for my 5yr old dd. She doesn't know penises exist so we don't have a name for them yet.

Regardless of what he is calling these parts, saying to girls to 'show me your fanny' is not normal for a 4 year old in my opinion.

Maybe it’s a regional thing. ‘Minnie’, ‘Mary’ and ‘Fanny’ are used where I live. Plus any other random girl’s name.

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:52

@BlindurErBóklausMaður Your inability to understand the nuance here is stunning. Children exhibit this behavior whether you want them to or not. This is fact. How we support children is by teaching them to assess their own boundaries and assert them, and on the other side of the interaction, to assess their actions empathetically, as to whether what they say and do negatively affect their friends and playmates.

Calling me an apologist for sexual inappropriateness is ridiculous. I advocate for children learning their own healthy boundaries and asserting them, and teaching children to pick up on nuance and context for where they express their curiosity and considering their playmates empathetically. Clearly you didn't even read the link I posted either, dismissing it outright. I feel sorry for any children you interact with. You aren't protecting children, you're controlling them.

Edit: clearly stated I know the difference between fanny in the US and fanny in the UK. You are being purposefully obtuse here.

haveyougotamin · 20/01/2024 14:52

Minnie is a stupid word for it, wouldn't have a clue what the child was talking about. At least with fanny most people understand and it's not a terrible/grim word fgs.

Obviously not the point of the thread but adding my thoughts!

MeridianB · 20/01/2024 14:52

Glad you’re going to the school on Monday, OP.

This behaviour needs flagging urgently. Block the mother - anyone with half a brain would know that children shouldn’t be asking others to show them their private parts.

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 20/01/2024 14:50

And a clinical psychologist who has lived in both the UK and the US but doesn't know the difference in the meaning of fanny?

You're pulling my plonker.

Welcome to MN though.

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 20/01/2024 14:45

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:34

@BlindurErBóklausMaður As someone who grew up partly in the US and partly in the UK, I really do understand the context of both. But your reading comprehension is clearly lacking, I would ask you to please reread the portions I wrote about the healthy settings of boundaries within specific contexts, which is the crux of the issue.

And yes, it is WELL ESTABLISHED in the children's developmental literature WORLD WIDE that it is totally normal for children to ask to see each other's genitals. This is healthy, normal curiosity for children. Anything that teaches you otherwise is puritanism. I really don't care what training you've had, I disagree with it as a clinical psychologist.

I feel sad for the children that have the influence of such reactive adults that cannot parse out the specifics of a situation and teach them healthy boundaries and support them in contextualizing their normal curiosity.

And I feel sorry for the children exposed to apologists for sexual inappropriateness.

We'll just have to differ I guess.

But I know which side of the line I'm happy to be on. The one protecting the children I work with.

You stick with your apologists.

scorpiogirly · 20/01/2024 14:44

Menomeno · 20/01/2024 13:05

Why is it unacceptable for a four year old to have been exposed to the words boobies and fanny? Jeez, I didn’t realise it was 1950! They’re normal childlike terms to describe body parts. It shouldn’t be a taboo subject.

The only unacceptable part of all this is the kid asking to see another child’s boobs and fanny, and he needs to be taught that this is wrong.

I don't see 'fanny' as a normal child term for this. I find it quite rude. We use Minnie for my 5yr old dd. She doesn't know penises exist so we don't have a name for them yet.

Regardless of what he is calling these parts, saying to girls to 'show me your fanny' is not normal for a 4 year old in my opinion.

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:43

@BombaySamphire, look I understand that to you the word is sexually charged. That's fine, in the UK it is. But the emotional reactivity that comes from hearing a child speak something sexually charged is something you really need to question yourself about. This is world over common behavior, either from overhearing adults, siblings, people on the street, whatever, and the child will explore with natural curiosity. Reacting emotionally, saying that you'd be appalled by it, is a sign of a deeper issue with you, and how you understand children and sexuality. This is why I say it is puritanism and sexual dysfunction, because your emotional reaction to it is out of proportion to the actual situation without knowing more details.

Bearbookagainandagain · 20/01/2024 14:41

SerafinasGoose · 20/01/2024 13:27

In this mother's shoes I'd be terrified for the wellbeing of my son and would not rest until I'd got to the bottom of it.

Na sorry. If your bestie comes and tell you that stranger X told Y that your 4 yo is asking to see kids privates, the normal reaction in a normal household is "WTF is that b saying about my kid!" (No offense to OP, I understand she didn't mean for her husband to gossip).

Actually thinking "oh gosh, why did he do that?" is a lot weirder unless there has been other issues in the past.

Coming for the school or even the parents themselves, it's completely different.

BombaySamphire · 20/01/2024 14:36

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:24

@BombaySamphire being appalled at an innocuous word because of your concept of its sexual nature is sexual dysfunction and puritanism. Context is important. Fanny is completely silly and meaningless in America for example. It's just a word.

Bollocks to your diagnosis of my sexual dysfunction and Puritanism.
Jesus…
The word being innocuous in a completely different culture is utterly irrelevant as well 🤷🏻‍♀️

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:34

@BlindurErBóklausMaður As someone who grew up partly in the US and partly in the UK, I really do understand the context of both. But your reading comprehension is clearly lacking, I would ask you to please reread the portions I wrote about the healthy settings of boundaries within specific contexts, which is the crux of the issue.

And yes, it is WELL ESTABLISHED in the children's developmental literature WORLD WIDE that it is totally normal for children to ask to see each other's genitals. This is healthy, normal curiosity for children. Anything that teaches you otherwise is puritanism. I really don't care what training you've had, I disagree with it as a clinical psychologist.

I feel sad for the children that have the influence of such reactive adults that cannot parse out the specifics of a situation and teach them healthy boundaries and support them in contextualizing their normal curiosity.

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 20/01/2024 14:26

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:24

@BombaySamphire being appalled at an innocuous word because of your concept of its sexual nature is sexual dysfunction and puritanism. Context is important. Fanny is completely silly and meaningless in America for example. It's just a word.

It has a different connotation in tone in the UK and refers to the vagina.

Are you actually trying to say that in the US, it's ok for boys to ask girls to show them their vaginas?

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 20/01/2024 14:24

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:03

I find the amount of sexual puritanism here really disturbing. So many people are reacting strongly and deciding it's bad or "not normal" behavior to ask to see another child's genitals.

It is not worrying behavior, it is not abnormal for a 4 year old, boy or girl. This is well established in the literature on child development as part of the normal curiosity of children when it comes to their bodies.

Many of us have experiences of parents reacting badly to these things in our young years and that often saddled us with guilt and sexual difficulties later in life, which is likely where these strong responses come from I surmise.

There is definitely an issue here where the boy needs a loving and compassionate talk about boundaries. It might be that both children were willingly engaged in curiosity about this, but if not, it needs to be made clear to him that his curiosity and interest is totally okay, but that simply asking that we without considering context and empathy for the other child is not healthy and can hurt his friends/playmates. That's all.

I believe this reductive emphasis on 'privacy' and 'yours and yours only' is a slippery slope that can lead to the same sexual dysfunction I've encountered from many people. Children have trouble understanding nuance, and a black and white lesson like this can affect them negatively into adulthood. It is important to teach context, assessing their feelings, and determining their boundaries situationally.

It is important to speak to our children about boundaries in a healthy way that doesn't fall into black or white thinking.

I don't believe the school is always equipped to deal with this either, and we are giving away our parenting responsibilities to schools far too often.

OP, I think you need to do your best to mediate with the other mother, try to connect with her on the fact that you are simply concerned and want to work it out together, apologize for the transgressions of your husband, and de-escalate the situation so that you two can discuss this like human beings. You both care about your kids, and you want to make sure they grow up healthy and happy, socially adjusted, without any guilt or shame associated with their bodies and the curiosity that will develop into their adult sexuality.

That being said there is a small chance it could signal something more nefarious, but jumping to that conclusion right away with emotional responses like I've read here makes more of a problem than a solution.

I'll leave this link here.

https://www.healthychildren.org/English/ages-stages/preschool/Pages/Sexual-Behaviors-Young-Children.aspx

Edited

Your link is from the US.

Those of us who have undergone extensive safeguarding training of minors in the UK do not, on the whole, equate a child using sexually inappropriate language in order to look at the genitals of another child with puritanism.

If you look up UK safeguarding of minors, you'll discover that what the OP's child has disclosed about the other child is deeply concerning and one of the first, and most basic red flags out there.

There are enough apologists for sexual abuse on this thread as it is. We really don't need any more.

NB: for the hard of comprehending, no, I don't think the child is a sexual predator. Yet. But, call me old-fashioned, I like to think our 4 year old girls can go to school without being asked to show their genitalia just because the boy in their class might be living with one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread