Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She said I am insinuating her 4 year old is a pervert

215 replies

Strawberrybubbble · 20/01/2024 11:04

Hello,

My 4 year old daughter has recently started using words to describe her private areas with words I have never used before.

In particular referring to her chest as boobies (not the most offensive I know but just not a word I or her father have ever used) and more grimly fanny.

I had a conversation with her last night just to find out where she had picked these words up - she said another 4 year old boy at her school (she used his name) kept asking her to show him her boobies and fanny. I told her she should not do this and they were hers and hers only.

Anyway, I told her father who has told his cousin immediately (he does have form for not keeping his mouth shut). Said cousin, is good friends with the 4 year old boys mum so it has now got back to her.

I was going to have a chat with her myself on Monday morning just to tell her what my daughter has said (I'd want to know - he has been saying this to 'all the girls' apparently).

Well, she has hit the roof. Said we are disgusting, we are implying her son is a pervert etc., we are wrong in the head, he is 4 years old.

That's absolutely not what we said - we questioned where they were picking up this language and where he had heard it.

Now, I know you can't take a 4 year olds word for certain every time but it is not anything we have ever said, she is not left to her own devices to watch anything unsupervised where she would have picked this up and is only ever looked after at nursery and by my parents (cannot imagine them using that language for a second). She was very clear in naming this boy.

Not sure where to go from here really. I would of liked to just let this mum know myself but my husband and his cousin have jumped in.

What would you make of this? My daughter is my oldest so not experienced this yet, not sure of a suitable reaction other than reminding her, her private parts are hers and hers only.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SmileyClare · 21/01/2024 11:36

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 21/01/2024 10:54

Looking forward to you being so sanguine when your daughter comes home and tells you her male classmate wants to look down her knickers.

Well yes I can understand why the parents (of both dc) have reacted emotionally with a “knee jerk” reaction, rather than calmly.

No doubt dds dad wants to protect his daughter and probably reacted in anger and fear (immediately telling his cousin- the best friend of this lad’s parents - will obviously get a message out)

A child or parent shouldn’t be demonised in what is a fairly common scenario with young dc.

What pp are pointing out is that posters are inflaming the highly emotive situation by calling this “Disgusting, appalling, “grim” a MASSIVE red flag,, something’s not right with that boy’s family” and so on.

I agree that it’s important to stay rational and let the school lead/advise on this.

Op sounds sensible enough. It’s a good idea to check the NSPCC advice on how to speak to your dd.
Assure her that it’s the right thing to tell her teacher if it happens again because We don’t ask to see what’s in our friend’s pants.
She doesn’t need to be made aware that this is any more of a bigger issue than that.

ilovebreadsauce · 21/01/2024 11:34

BloodyAdultDC · 20/01/2024 11:08

School. First thing on Monday. Don't engage with the other parent until after you've spoken to the safeguarding team at school - massive safeguarding red flag.

It really isn't.......

SerafinasGoose · 21/01/2024 11:23

LolaSmiles · 21/01/2024 08:52

But posters on the thread are on the ceiling about it being a 'safeguarding red flag' and 'inappropriate'.
Because it can be, which is why it's important to raise it with the safeguarding lead. It doesn't automatically mean a child has been harmed, but it is a possibility.

The basic principle of safeguarding is that abuse can happen anywhere and that concerns should be recorded.

KCSIE also says that child on child harassment can happen between children of any age and any sex, crucially that schools should not dismissing behaviour as just part of growing up. It's expected that there is a culture where it's not acceptable. Children have the right to go to school without peers asking to see their private areas.

As with many things in safeguarding, it could be nothing, it could be something but that's exactly why concerns should be recorded (rather than dismissed) so that those with the fuller picture can make decisions to keep children safe.

Edited

This is the measured post. It's a welcome change to see some balance on this thread, as opposed either to labelling children or dismissing known safeguarding red flags as 'puritanism'.

It could be curiosity. On the other hand it's a known indicator of sexual abuse. This is precisely why that risk should not be taken and the situation assessed, sensitively and appropriately, by the professionals.

OP's relatives handled it inappropriately. Labelling a child at such an early age is also inappropriate. This is why safeguarding procedures exist, and this is a text-book example of how important it is that the proper channels should be followed.

I'm really not sure how anyone could argue that this is a bad thing.

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 21/01/2024 10:54

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 10:44

Yes it might be and I already said somewhere else on this thread that its right to talk to the school

But we find ourselves now in a landscape where we are using terminology for quite small children like 'harrassment' and 'sexualised behaviour'. I hear it (and challenge it) all the time in meetings, usually coming from schools.

Its not appropriate to use terminology like that about a 4 year old. The behaviour is not abnormal in the sense of children discovering their genitalia and perhaps learning its different for boys and girls, but also could be an indicator for something else, so to immediately start using terms like that is not right

Children also ask to see each others bogeys, or can I cut your hair, or can I wear your coat/shoes, its part of normal curiosity.

Looking forward to you being so sanguine when your daughter comes home and tells you her male classmate wants to look down her knickers.

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 10:44

LolaSmiles · 21/01/2024 08:52

But posters on the thread are on the ceiling about it being a 'safeguarding red flag' and 'inappropriate'.
Because it can be, which is why it's important to raise it with the safeguarding lead. It doesn't automatically mean a child has been harmed, but it is a possibility.

The basic principle of safeguarding is that abuse can happen anywhere and that concerns should be recorded.

KCSIE also says that child on child harassment can happen between children of any age and any sex, crucially that schools should not dismissing behaviour as just part of growing up. It's expected that there is a culture where it's not acceptable. Children have the right to go to school without peers asking to see their private areas.

As with many things in safeguarding, it could be nothing, it could be something but that's exactly why concerns should be recorded (rather than dismissed) so that those with the fuller picture can make decisions to keep children safe.

Edited

Yes it might be and I already said somewhere else on this thread that its right to talk to the school

But we find ourselves now in a landscape where we are using terminology for quite small children like 'harrassment' and 'sexualised behaviour'. I hear it (and challenge it) all the time in meetings, usually coming from schools.

Its not appropriate to use terminology like that about a 4 year old. The behaviour is not abnormal in the sense of children discovering their genitalia and perhaps learning its different for boys and girls, but also could be an indicator for something else, so to immediately start using terms like that is not right

Children also ask to see each others bogeys, or can I cut your hair, or can I wear your coat/shoes, its part of normal curiosity.

LolaSmiles · 21/01/2024 08:52

But posters on the thread are on the ceiling about it being a 'safeguarding red flag' and 'inappropriate'.
Because it can be, which is why it's important to raise it with the safeguarding lead. It doesn't automatically mean a child has been harmed, but it is a possibility.

The basic principle of safeguarding is that abuse can happen anywhere and that concerns should be recorded.

KCSIE also says that child on child harassment can happen between children of any age and any sex, crucially that schools should not dismissing behaviour as just part of growing up. It's expected that there is a culture where it's not acceptable. Children have the right to go to school without peers asking to see their private areas.

As with many things in safeguarding, it could be nothing, it could be something but that's exactly why concerns should be recorded (rather than dismissed) so that those with the fuller picture can make decisions to keep children safe.

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 08:17

DonnaBanana · 20/01/2024 22:47

So is eating glue or crayons, drawing on the wall and breaking things, it doesn’t mean it’s good or right and shouldn’t be discouraged ASAP

Correct, you do discourage it and eating crayons, its just part of children growing up. But posters on the thread are on the ceiling about it being a 'safeguarding red flag' and 'inappropriate'.

LolaSmiles · 21/01/2024 08:14

This is healthy, normal curiosity for children. Anything that teaches you otherwise is puritanism. I really don't care what training you've had, I disagree with it as a clinical psychologist
I'd be concerned that any health care professional is quick to dismiss potential safeguarding concerns in this way to be honest.

It could be curiosity.
It could be a sign of abuse.

It's the role of safeguarding professionals to make that assessments.

Not every Tom, Dick and Harry with only one part of the situation and their own baggage and opinions.

The NSPCC runs the PANTS campaign to safeguard children and the central principles are that what's in your pants area is private and that if someone asks to see you can talk to a trusted adult.

IhateHPSDeaneCnt · 21/01/2024 00:33

I've been banned because I said children are being hypersexualised; for fucks sake and no pun intended

CJsGoldfish · 21/01/2024 00:11

And yes, it is WELL ESTABLISHED in the children's developmental literature WORLD WIDE that it is totally normal for children to ask to see each other's genitals. This is healthy, normal curiosity for children. Anything that teaches you otherwise is puritanism. I really don't care what training you've had, I disagree with it as a clinical psychologist

I feel sad for the children that have the influence of such reactive adults that cannot parse out the specifics of a situation and teach them healthy boundaries and support them in contextualizing their normal curiosity

@Lossilania

Thank you for your (measured) and well thought out posts. I am glad for the non inflammatory and sensible comments.

Of course it is normal childhood behaviour. Pretty sure 'playing doctor' (cringe) was a well known term for it.

The adult reactions will be the most potentially damaging to both children in this scenario. Already, by the husband and cousins actions, a path was set in motion which will be impacting both children involved. Of course, we can all kid ourselves that it is only affecting the adults but each child will be soaking it in.
Sex, bodies, feelings are all lifelong conversations. The OPs dd did nothing wrong but over reacting will not reassure her. Again, the incident must be dealt with, of course it should be, but not with the current lens

PiersPlowman11 · 20/01/2024 23:49

The four year old asked the OP’s daughter to show him her “Francesca”. Well she did - her half-wit father waded right in and shot his big mouth off!

WhatNoUsername · 20/01/2024 23:05

DonnaBanana · 20/01/2024 22:47

So is eating glue or crayons, drawing on the wall and breaking things, it doesn’t mean it’s good or right and shouldn’t be discouraged ASAP

No one’s saying that children shouldn’t be guided on appropriate behaviour but that needs to be done in the context of this being completely normal behaviour for this age group.

DonnaBanana · 20/01/2024 22:47

WhatNoUsername · 20/01/2024 19:35

This. You show me yours/I'll show you mine is perfectly normal behaviour in 4 year olds. I recall doing the same quite happily with zero sexual connotations at a similar age. You all need to take a breath and calm the fuck down.

So is eating glue or crayons, drawing on the wall and breaking things, it doesn’t mean it’s good or right and shouldn’t be discouraged ASAP

Fullofxmascbeer · 20/01/2024 22:27

Just go in calmly, say you don’t want to make a big issue of it as you know it’s probably just normal curiosity, but thought they ought to be aware of it so that they can perhaps do a bit of work on privacy and boundaries.

WhatNoUsername · 20/01/2024 19:35

Lossilania · 20/01/2024 14:34

@BlindurErBóklausMaður As someone who grew up partly in the US and partly in the UK, I really do understand the context of both. But your reading comprehension is clearly lacking, I would ask you to please reread the portions I wrote about the healthy settings of boundaries within specific contexts, which is the crux of the issue.

And yes, it is WELL ESTABLISHED in the children's developmental literature WORLD WIDE that it is totally normal for children to ask to see each other's genitals. This is healthy, normal curiosity for children. Anything that teaches you otherwise is puritanism. I really don't care what training you've had, I disagree with it as a clinical psychologist.

I feel sad for the children that have the influence of such reactive adults that cannot parse out the specifics of a situation and teach them healthy boundaries and support them in contextualizing their normal curiosity.

This. You show me yours/I'll show you mine is perfectly normal behaviour in 4 year olds. I recall doing the same quite happily with zero sexual connotations at a similar age. You all need to take a breath and calm the fuck down.

tianabiscuit · 20/01/2024 19:21

A lot of presumptions being made here.

Maybe the boy heard those words from home. Or maybe he heard them from another child at school and copied them.

Obviously asking to see the OP's daughter's private parts is not on.

This is why school is the right route to take, so they can trace where this began and educate where needed.

soupfiend · 20/01/2024 18:23

Daffodilsandtuplips · 20/01/2024 16:51

Op said the cousin has said he didn’t think of the repercussions of telling the boys mother. This is the problem, neither of the men did, ops husband didn’t think either.

The husband is entirely entitled and able to talk to a friend/family about something that has happened to him or his family.

It would have been better if the cousin hadnt mentioned it to the boys family but its not crime of the century, the usual name calling though is fairly standard here.

SerafinasGoose · 20/01/2024 18:20

Bearbookagainandagain · 20/01/2024 14:41

Na sorry. If your bestie comes and tell you that stranger X told Y that your 4 yo is asking to see kids privates, the normal reaction in a normal household is "WTF is that b saying about my kid!" (No offense to OP, I understand she didn't mean for her husband to gossip).

Actually thinking "oh gosh, why did he do that?" is a lot weirder unless there has been other issues in the past.

Coming for the school or even the parents themselves, it's completely different.

Not to suggest the cousin's behaviour was ideal: issues like this need to be dealt with through the appropriate channels. But of course a 'normal' first reaction is not to react defensively and immediately go on the offensive. That isn't my general mode of communication.

Actually thinking 'oh gosh why did he do that?' is indeed what would first spring to anyone's mind if they had any insight at all into these situations. I've worked with NOTA, am well aware of the flag system and what the warnings of safeguarding issues are, and would be very concerned here on two counts. One, that it's a potential indicator that my child could have been sexually abused. Two, that he might pose a potential risk to other children. Nobody, but nobody, wants their child to be either a victim or a perpetrator in these situations. And at four, he's too young for this kind of behaviour to have fallen out of the clear blue sky. If there's even the smallest possibility something might have prompted it, I'd want to know what that something was.

All the data held by NOTA at the time I worked with them suggests that if the flags do indicate any of the above, and if they are appropriately and professionally dealt with at a young enough age, the issues are treatable. If they were to progress into adulthood, the rehabilitation of sexual offenders is far more difficult if not impossible. Would anyone want this for their child, if the worst did turn out to be the case? And wouldn't you want to know for sure?

Denial helps nobody, and to suggest that such a response is 'weird' is the only weird thing here in itself.

cherrychapstickk · 20/01/2024 17:29

RedToothBrush · 20/01/2024 17:13

she said another 4 year old boy at her school (she used his name) kept asking her to show him her boobies and fanny.

I would not have spoken to anyone in the family. That's actively causing more issues not less. This is a straight red flag, do not pass go speak to the safeguarding lead at school.

to be fair to the OP, she did not reach out to anyone other than her husband.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 20/01/2024 17:27

scorpiogirly · 20/01/2024 11:19

You have to wonder where this boy is picking this up. At home I would guess, which is unacceptable.

4 year old boy, living with older siblings, girls even….nope …not unacceptable …normal if he’s observing breastfeeding (god forbid he may have asked to see the girls breasts if mpbf mum was using anatomical language with him) , or if he’s had to go into loo with mum and a sister who mum has been saying wipe your Fanny/willy..,,what the heck is family supposed to call these things! Having names, using them out is fine, not at all unacceptable. Worrying if kids don’t know what they’re called in fact.

it’s about him asking to see other child’s private body parts, that is unacceptable and he should have been educated on this by this age. Curiosity is normal, but not asking to see….thats the worrying bit . When I was young, years and years ago, children would often ask to look at each others genitals in playground in infants (were talking 4-6)…safeguarding and conversations with kids around bodily autonomy were not a thing then. I don’t think curiosity is abnormal, it is the lack of boundaries that is worrying in todays environment when parents and schools are more all over this.

RedToothBrush · 20/01/2024 17:13

she said another 4 year old boy at her school (she used his name) kept asking her to show him her boobies and fanny.

I would not have spoken to anyone in the family. That's actively causing more issues not less. This is a straight red flag, do not pass go speak to the safeguarding lead at school.

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 20/01/2024 16:58

Gazelda · 20/01/2024 15:32

OP, if I were you I'd send an email to the Designated Safeguarding Lead today, saying that you will be at school on Monday and would like to meet with her/him at 8.30 (or whatever time).

Don't leave it until Monday morning and then ask the admin team if anyone is available for a chat. Make it clear that this is a formal request for a meeting on a safeguarding issue.

Sadly, you may need to be ahead of the other parent who might want to sling mud at your family for spreading rumours. You sound level headed, so get in with the facts first.

I'd agree with this. And, as I said before, make sure the meeting is held confidentially and most definitely without the parent of the boy present.
Then the OP has done what needs to be done, and the professionals can deal with it leaving her to do exactly as she has been, protecting her child and teaching her bodily autonomy and that if she feels uncomfortable because of what a boy wants her to do, she says no, and tells her mum.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 20/01/2024 16:51

soupfiend · 20/01/2024 16:35

I dont think the husband has done anything wrong here, not sure why there is the usual jump to insult him and call him names (usual MO on this forum)

Op said the cousin has said he didn’t think of the repercussions of telling the boys mother. This is the problem, neither of the men did, ops husband didn’t think either.

Goldbar · 20/01/2024 16:35

While this sort of thing should be treated seriously (it may/may not be a red flag that something untoward is going on), it should also be dealt with quietly and discretely for the sake of all the children involved.

Your husband and his cousin have gone about this entirely the wrong way. I don't blame the mum involved for being annoyed and defensive. Had someone (ideally in authority, so nursery etc) had a quiet word with her rather than rather publicly putting her on the spot, I imagine her reaction would have been rather different. As it is, the whole thing has been dealt with very inappropriately especially given the young ages of the children involved.

soupfiend · 20/01/2024 16:35

I dont think the husband has done anything wrong here, not sure why there is the usual jump to insult him and call him names (usual MO on this forum)