Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
RavenhairedRachel · 21/01/2024 18:00

My last manager absolutely dire. She was the same level as us ( not much good at that job either ) but got the management role as she had a degree. The first thing she did was offload a lot of her tasks to other staff. She hadn't an actual base and worked around a network of branches that was ideal as she could hide and claim she'd no phone signal or WiFi. No one knew where she was or what she did. Under her watch more people left in 2 years, me included than the previous 17 years put together. Well eventually the regional manager who was as useless as her left and his replacement sussed her out and she left too.

Xmasdaft2023 · 21/01/2024 18:00

This makes me laugh so much because a few years ago now a young trainee was employed with us, she retained zero information from the day she started til the day she was let go… my boss to this day swears she was complete opposite in interview and wondered if there was a twin sister interviews instead 🙈. Honestly, I do not know how she’d be employable anywhere, nothing and I mean nothing was retained.

Ilovecleaning · 21/01/2024 17:59

Kwam31 · 21/01/2024 17:42

@Ilovecleaning
I had someone argue they were left handed whilst holding up their right and refused to be corrected!!

🤪
Unbelievable!

DrJackDaniels · 21/01/2024 17:50

I worked with a women I was meant to train up. Apparently she’d been a project manager at Cable & wireless for over 10 years and the company I worked for was another telco. She didn’t even know how to scroll down on a computer screen, how to minimise a window and literally did the complete opposite of what I told her to the point I thought I was actually going mad!!

One day I told her ‘under no circumstances send that router to the customer’ an hour later, she’s trying to send the router to the customer.

my boss asked me what the hell was happening with me, (thinking I was just not training her or being awkward etc) I told her she was untrainable and never even seen a laptop let alone been a PM for million pound customers. My boss took over training and fired her after a week - completely as baffled as me as to how she had even got the job!

pineapplesundae · 21/01/2024 17:48

Let us know what you find out!

WinterDeWinter · 21/01/2024 17:44

Agree · 20/01/2024 18:16

I'm in exactly this situation as a patient who was treated dangerously by a 'nurse' who patently could barely speak English and was abusive and harmful to me, making life and death errors. I don't believe for one minute she's even qualified in anything, she can't possibly be.

I know when I complain how careful I'll have to be not to come off as racist.

As awful as this woman sounds, it’s right that you should take care not to come across as racist. We all should, surely?

Kwam31 · 21/01/2024 17:42

@Ilovecleaning
I had someone argue they were left handed whilst holding up their right and refused to be corrected!!

Doyoumind · 21/01/2024 17:41

Thinking about it, the most damaging incompetency has been from senior management. I've been made redundant or chosen to leave a job a number of times where the redundancies or downward trajectory of the business could certainly have been avoided with better management.

I had one boss who almost never did any work and one who believed a total lack of experience in or knowledge of the sector wouldn't be a hindrance. Both businesses failed completely.

Ilovecleaning · 21/01/2024 17:40

HerLadySheep · 20/01/2024 09:44

A trainee solicitor who didn't know the alphabet and couldn't find files!

How can you not know the alphabet!

Duckingella · 21/01/2024 17:34

This one has an amusing ending.

DH went to work for a company;he did a 4 on 4 off shift pattern.

The person who shared the job role and worked the opposite shifts was an arse;let's call him Dick.Dick was there years;he refused to go on the books as a PAYÉ employee and work as a self employed sub contractor for the company instead.He also refused to sign the sub contractor agreement as well.

Dick would regularly blow out on shifts meaning my husband would have to cover them as well as his own.

Why would Dick cancel his shifts?sometimes it would be because he couldn't be bothered to work,sometimes it would be because he'd taken work elsewhere on that day.

Dick also refused to work Christmas meaning DH would instead which was rubbish;it would have been nice if DH got at least boxing day off if he couldn't get any other time off but no Dick wouldn't even cover a single day.

Dick would regularly trot out "I'm a self employed sub contractor;I can pick and choose when I work".

This eventually bit Dick hard on the bum.

My DH was promoted twice;he became Dick's "Upline manager".Dick was annoyed by this and wanted to know why he wasn't promoted (well promotions are for employees).

DH then calculated that Dick over a 6 month period had only covered 50% of shifts he'd been allocated.

Well the business expected sub contractors to cover the shifts they'd been allocated;if a subcontractor couldn't do meet businesses needs then their services would no longer be used and a different subcontractor would be used in their place.

Well Dick wasn't meeting the businesses needs and there his subcontractor services were no longer required.

angela1952 · 21/01/2024 17:32

We once advertised a clerical job which said we required computer literacy and one of the people who turned up didn't even know how to turn the computer on, or read a floppy disk (it was a while ago!). His CV had said he was computer literate.
It turned out that his local Job Centre had told him to apply for the job and also told him what to put on his CV. Needless to say, his interview was a short one as it started with us giving him a task to do on the computer.

AskNotForWhomTheBellCurves · 21/01/2024 17:06

Oh my god it was me, when I briefly worked as an event coordinator. It was an internal role - I was new to the company and didn't really understand what the job entailed as it had some vague wanky title, but for some reason someone or other in senior management who'd never met me in person decided I was the one for it and I was strongly encouraged to apply, despite expressing my doubts even at that stage. They must have been absolutely desperate, as I missed the application deadline by a week then told them honestly in the interview that I had almost zero experience of event planning, was rubbish at anything involving organisation or admin, wouldn't be able to deal with any external suppliers because my grasp of the local language was poor, tended to avoid conflict and hated speaking in front of people, and they hired me anyway Confused I spent about six weeks being unsurprisingly rubbish at it, endured the surreal nightmare of hosting a whole-company dinner (for which I initially managed to turn up at the wrong location, despite being the person who organised it) and promptly quit, to everyone's great relief.

Chris002 · 21/01/2024 15:45

Mycatmyworld · 20/01/2024 10:06

Vegetable preparation warehouse trainee told to slice the carrots a certain way for the client and box them as shown in the prep leaflet, I can’t do that, she said I don’t like knives. Really!
started at 6 30 gone by 7

I wonder if the company / agency gave the trainee any induction training ?
Vegetable preparation - she could have thought this meant washing and peeling spuds for example - company need to give out job description listing what It required in job description. Saves everyone's time and energy then.
My husband worked for an agency as a fork lift driver - a few times he turned up at the site to be told he was also expected to operate machines with cutting tools and do carpentry skills as well which he wasn't comfortable doing.
It should have been explained to the trainee beforehand that the job involved using knives to chop veg.

SquirrelHash · 21/01/2024 15:26

I have a colleague who is nearly 80 years old. They can't make her retire.

She often loses things, accidentally deletes things, can't find anything in an electronic sense, forgets instructions etc, and takes up a lot of my time asking questions she's asked before and forgotten the answer to.

I do love her though! 😭

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 15:26

fetchacloth · 21/01/2024 14:57

You should have had more training and support before working on the shop floor.
Being able to interact with customers is a must but comes with confidence and experience.
Shoplifting is a difficult one though. Sadly there is little or no enforcement available to stop it. I have much sympathy with retailers trying to combat this.

That's very true, with the right support it could have been a lot easier. This job (like others mentioned) date from the early 80s when I was just starting out, in those days I think there was much less awareness of mental & emotional health issues and lack of self-confidence was more likely to be perceived just as a character flaw. It is a shame that bad experiences like this can colour a young person's outlook for a long time.

I see young adult workers talking openly about their mental health challenges & disabilities, I am really glad that they feel able to do this. However I know that horrible workplaces still exist.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 21/01/2024 15:14

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 14:11

I worked for an MD as a PA a few years ago which put me off being a PA for life.

I would come into work find my desk littered with post-it notes of tasks to do, which my boss Mr Important had left. Not just one or two....dozens.

If I dared make a single mistake such as a letter typo (eg one space instead of two after a full stop) he would scream at me in front of everyone who was there; colleagues, customers etc. For a baritone he could make a really good stab at screaming.

He would tell me to 'get customer so and so on the phone for me' so I would have to ring them and explain this, and ask them to hold before I transferred them to Mr Important. By then Mr Important would be doing something/talking to someone else and I had to wait to transfer and explain the delay to the increasingly irate customer, who would be questioning why their time was deemed less important than that of Mr Important.

Once he asked me to get a client on the line who (he had somehow found out) had just flown in that day from the Far East. I rang the poor man who was in his hotel room recovering from jet lag, and he was extremely annoyed: 'How did Mr Important know I was here? What does he want?' I transferred the call and could hear them arguing, it ended with the boss screaming 'Fuck off!' and slamming down the phone.

Some colleagues shared with me that the company was suffering due to Mr Important falling out with everyone. But of course nobody dared to say this to his face.

This is why I hate being a PA/EA sometimes! Some bosses are awful to work for.

fetchacloth · 21/01/2024 14:57

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 11:43

I was useless in my first job as a department store assistant. I was really shy when I was young so didn't want to engage with customers, tried to stick to tidying & stacking shelves and hoped I wouldn't be noticed by anyone.

One customer said to me 'This job isn't your forte is it?'

Once another customer approached me & said she had spotted someone shoplifting. I freaked & didn't know what to do, far too scared to tell my supervisor. I think the thief escaped.

Horrible knowing that you are doing a rubbish job and being desperate to avoid being disapproved of or sacked.

You should have had more training and support before working on the shop floor.
Being able to interact with customers is a must but comes with confidence and experience.
Shoplifting is a difficult one though. Sadly there is little or no enforcement available to stop it. I have much sympathy with retailers trying to combat this.

lieselotte · 21/01/2024 14:36

If I dared make a single mistake such as a letter typo (eg one space instead of two after a full stop) he would scream at me in front of everyone who was there; colleagues, customers etc

I had a boss who once swore at me because I used one space instead of two. I ended up crying in the toilets and then sulking through a departmental lunch. Not his finest hour, but not mine either.

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 14:11

I worked for an MD as a PA a few years ago which put me off being a PA for life.

I would come into work find my desk littered with post-it notes of tasks to do, which my boss Mr Important had left. Not just one or two....dozens.

If I dared make a single mistake such as a letter typo (eg one space instead of two after a full stop) he would scream at me in front of everyone who was there; colleagues, customers etc. For a baritone he could make a really good stab at screaming.

He would tell me to 'get customer so and so on the phone for me' so I would have to ring them and explain this, and ask them to hold before I transferred them to Mr Important. By then Mr Important would be doing something/talking to someone else and I had to wait to transfer and explain the delay to the increasingly irate customer, who would be questioning why their time was deemed less important than that of Mr Important.

Once he asked me to get a client on the line who (he had somehow found out) had just flown in that day from the Far East. I rang the poor man who was in his hotel room recovering from jet lag, and he was extremely annoyed: 'How did Mr Important know I was here? What does he want?' I transferred the call and could hear them arguing, it ended with the boss screaming 'Fuck off!' and slamming down the phone.

Some colleagues shared with me that the company was suffering due to Mr Important falling out with everyone. But of course nobody dared to say this to his face.

Springcleaninginsummer · 21/01/2024 14:07

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 13:39

I agree with this to the extent that I don't set a lot of store by glowing references that tick all the 'excellent' boxes. The main use of references imo is to ensure that people are who they purport to be; that they really were working 5 years for X Company in Y role as on their CV, and weren't doing something else (eg they worked only 3 months there in a much more junior role).

I think the 'Would you re-employ?' question is a good one but need to ensure the response isn't misleading....some ex-employers may reply 'No' and what they mean is that the role the person was doing no longer exists, not that the employee wasn't any good. So this may need teasing out.

Yes, I have worked at places where they would never rehire because they always thought their next shiny new hire would be the making of the team. (Usually bitter disappointment set in when new person turned out to be just like the rest of us!)

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 21/01/2024 13:59

lieselotte · 21/01/2024 13:51

I can use track changes but would struggle with a pivot table. Track changes is easy!

I also think a lot of employers are too lazy to train people properly.

As for computers, when I started university they only had BBC Microcomputers. I only used a computer with DOS and Word when I worked on the student newspaper and had a technically minded boyfriend who taught me a lot.

I've not worked with anyone who's been as useless as the examples in this thread but I have worked with particularly unpleasant people who should have had some management and softs kills training.

I can use track changes now but when I first saw it, it scared me. Yes, stupid I know. Most packages I can use now after training myself but there’s so much, too much in terms of packages and new ones, in my opinion. In Teams I learned Planner over lockdown. Then One Note.

A few people I’ve worked with in the past aren’t proactive and/or lack common sense. Want an important legal document signing (I got this done in 2 days in one job in one non law firm) then chase it! My boss was impressed and pleased I’d got it signed so quickly but 8 years of being a legal sec and having to be proactive made this easy for me.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 21/01/2024 13:53

Ahhh this now reminds me. My ex solicitor boss dealt with divorce/matrimonial cases, but he said he thought women were stupid and had no empathy whatsoever. One of our clients had to come and see us and got upset during and after the appointments. He did nothing to console her, was left to me to do.

A new partner then joined who was good at the matrimonial/divorce side, very empathic and a good listener. However, his admin skills including typing letters, emails and submitting the right forms on time were very poor. He was always submitting important forms late which isn’t great when you’re awaiting your decree nisi or absolute. We thought he wasn’t organised enough. He got lots of complaints to us, Law Society and via Google. My boss offered me and the other legal sec to him to help him out (incompetent man would have had to pay us) but he refused this offer.

lieselotte · 21/01/2024 13:51

I can use track changes but would struggle with a pivot table. Track changes is easy!

I also think a lot of employers are too lazy to train people properly.

As for computers, when I started university they only had BBC Microcomputers. I only used a computer with DOS and Word when I worked on the student newspaper and had a technically minded boyfriend who taught me a lot.

I've not worked with anyone who's been as useless as the examples in this thread but I have worked with particularly unpleasant people who should have had some management and softs kills training.

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 13:39

PurpleBrain · 21/01/2024 13:20

@StockpotSoup

Most employers don't really care about references unless they are for jobs where you have to be highly vetted such as working with vulnerable people.

Employers can get rid of you easily within two years anyway . Plus they only need to ask an ex employer one question: Would you re - employ , yes or no ? There is only going to be the choice of two answers .

I agree with this to the extent that I don't set a lot of store by glowing references that tick all the 'excellent' boxes. The main use of references imo is to ensure that people are who they purport to be; that they really were working 5 years for X Company in Y role as on their CV, and weren't doing something else (eg they worked only 3 months there in a much more junior role).

I think the 'Would you re-employ?' question is a good one but need to ensure the response isn't misleading....some ex-employers may reply 'No' and what they mean is that the role the person was doing no longer exists, not that the employee wasn't any good. So this may need teasing out.

Namechangesab · 21/01/2024 13:25

I do think some of these are just a case of if you've never learnt or been taught something, how do you know? I am a good contracts lawyer (if I do say so myself) but I didn't learn what a noun or a verb was (let alone anything like an adverb, adjective etc) until I was in my 20s. Because I was never taught it. I know how to write perfectly well and am a bit of a grammar Nazi but can I name all the technical definitions? Nope.

I'm also a tech/software lawyer who can't set up her own laptop.

Wondering if any of these posts are about me now 😅