Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
BrainsButNoSense · 22/01/2024 00:48

The most incompetent person in the world is probably ME !!

When I left school the head teacher told my parents I had brains, but no sense. Over the next 30 years, I proved him right. I had over 40 jobs in 30 years, and in virtually every job I was totally incompetent, and was either laid off, fired, or let go because of a change in organisation, reduction in funding, etc etc.

In addition to having no sense, I was a hard worker, always punctual, etc. Some supervisors tried to help, but my incompetence always won in the end.

Then, I got lucky. I was hired by a large organisation, which had the well-deserved reputation of being the sloppiest company in the country. This is the kind of company where, if an employee
a) shows up
b) on time
c) sober and not hungover
and
d) ready to work
then the company declares him employee of the month.

It was wonderful, and quite well paid too. After 10 years of well-paid idleness, I achieved nirvana... I was offered early retirement, with a partial, but adequate, pension.

Horriblescareydolls · 22/01/2024 00:20

We had a new business support/ administrator who needed instructions on how to type a basic word document. She kept putting calls through to me even though they were nothing to do with me. She kept going around the office making people cups of tea to avoid doing the things she couldn't do.
She was a lovely kind heart but just wasn't up to the job.

Mamanyt · 22/01/2024 00:03

Many years ago, my boss hired an office assistant for me. While I was a part of the interviewing process, he decided to hire without even reading my notes on the interviewees. THIS girl was one of the few that I had noted, "not able for even simple tasks." She was, however, VERY pretty. The second day on the job, I asked her to get a stack of bills ready to mail (envelopes stuffed, addressed, and postage applied). She brought me a stack of sealed envelopes with no addresses. She didn't know you had to write that on the envelopes. Had never received even a bill by mail. Her mama took care of all of that.

NewYearSameMe16 · 21/01/2024 23:46

Currently work with a young guy who’s a team assistant who turns up late most days, doesn’t finish any tasks to a good standard (if at all) and has said about ten words in the six months he’s been here. I get being shy but being virtually mute in a forward facing role is pretty ridiculous. We found out he had an identical twin and we’re convinced the twin did the interview!

Glasgowgal200 · 21/01/2024 23:06

Same here. Just feel so inadequate and useless

chaosmaker · 21/01/2024 21:41

Cathbrownlow · 21/01/2024 21:17

In all the places I've worked, most have been ok at their jobs, some have been fantastic at their jobs and a few were incompetent. It got me thinking some time back, that if this were the general spread of workers across all sectors, in some settings it may not matter that much apart from the unfortunate souls who have to work with the incompetent.

But in other settings, eg surgeons, Lawyers, Prime Ministers, it really does matter if you get a dud. It rings true to me what others have said here that often the useless are promoted to sort of get rid of them, or because they can talk the talk. This is such a dangerous situation. What can be done about this?

Care workers are really important and incompetence can mean death. Lowly paid though so we probably don't matter.

Cathbrownlow · 21/01/2024 21:17

In all the places I've worked, most have been ok at their jobs, some have been fantastic at their jobs and a few were incompetent. It got me thinking some time back, that if this were the general spread of workers across all sectors, in some settings it may not matter that much apart from the unfortunate souls who have to work with the incompetent.

But in other settings, eg surgeons, Lawyers, Prime Ministers, it really does matter if you get a dud. It rings true to me what others have said here that often the useless are promoted to sort of get rid of them, or because they can talk the talk. This is such a dangerous situation. What can be done about this?

LalaPaloosa · 21/01/2024 21:09

Yes. A temporary head of a funds team who had never worked in investment funds before. They couldn’t work out where various funds were domiciled. Just awkward all around and a very unpleasant person.

KirstenBlest · 21/01/2024 20:20

@G5000, it depends on how much you (don't) know you don't know.

I work with people who can write a document in Word but their formatting is pretty awful IMO, but they are competent for their job function. So what if they use paragraph marks for spacing ...

The ones that bug me are the ones who need a level of expertise but don't.

G5000 · 21/01/2024 20:11

ToMeToYouAndBack · 21/01/2024 18:28

I am competent in Word and I did not know this, so maybe they aren't that bad?

How do you define 'competent in Word'?

Densol57 · 21/01/2024 19:43

Many years ago ( 1983) I worked in a legal dept in a massive insurance co, with an incredibly sly and lazy girl ( same age as me )
She was ALWAYS late with wilder and wilder excuses to explain why she rolled in at midday. The most bizarre excuse was that an old man had pooed himself on the tube and it had rolled down his trousers onto her shoes so she had to return home and change 🤣

She then left to join the marketing dept where she and her boyfriend created false invoices for pretend companies and stole £200,000. She went to prison for 2 years. Before she was caught she would pretend her boyfriend was a black cabbie to explain all this new wealth when she popped back to brag 😂

NotMyFirstChoiceofName · 21/01/2024 19:38

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 11:33

An effective selection process can identify incompetent candidates but it can't unfortunately weed out candidates with a bad attitude; they are effectively incompetent as they have no intention of doing the work they are being paid for.

One ex-employer hired an overnight security guard. It came to light that instead of guarding the workplace as he was paid to do, he was just bedding down for the night on the couch in the sick room; even brought a duvet and pillow from home which he kept tucked away in the office.

I have tried to put some basic misogyny and racism traps in my interview processes (tow types of bad attitudes we don’t need in our company ).

Of course they only catch the more stupid ones. But you’d be amazed how many that is, in our typical interviewee list of (mostly) men aged 30 - 50 with postgrad degrees.

Topsyturveymam · 21/01/2024 19:33

Yep - now! Both doing same role and same pay. I’m doing twice as much work as they can’t be allocated anything significant due to incompetence. They talk total bull about how experienced/skilled they are … and have an irritating tendency to repeat everything you’ve just said in a more confusing way … and as if it was their idea.
Im looking for a new role!

Jackwiththelazyeye · 21/01/2024 19:01

I had a part time bar job, a new evening manager was hired.

One particularly busy shift I asked her to open a bottle of red wine, she got really flustered when the top would not unscrew. It was a bottle with a cork. I politely suggested she use a corkscrew. She looked very blankly at me - she had absolutely no idea what a corkscrew even looked like let alone know how to use one.

Even now when I think about it I feel lost for words.

newtoallthisshizzle · 21/01/2024 18:58

I’m afraid I was once this incompetent lol. Worked in an office as a temp and was asked by some external clients (who were using the office for a while until their meeting) to send a fax to someone. I put their paper in the machine and stood next to this machine for a good 20 minutes. The clients asked if the fax had gone and I assured them it was going. After about 45 minutes another girl came running over and said oh this fax machine isn’t working, let me show you the one that is. She then told me I had been standing next to a printer (that wasn’t even plugged in). I’m forever thankful to her for saving me and it gave me the 😱 kick up the arse I needed to be more assertive and proactive.

anon666 · 21/01/2024 18:56

So many. I had underestimated how blatantly some people lie.

One guy claimed to be a qualified accountant from another country, but although he brought a photocopied certificate it was a common name and we found it difficult to validate with his professional body abroad.

We only tried to validate once it became obvious he had never used a computer. 🤔

Our HR department, in their wisdom, told us that even though he had lied about his proficiency in MS Office on his application (amongst the raft of other untruths) that we should have tested anything essential at interview 🤔.

My boss wasn't having that thankfully and confronted him in a meeting about the lies. He agreed to resign.

These were the days (early 2000s) where we were desperate for people, and he was a hasty decision made in desperation from a very weak field. But still...... He lasted 3 days.

I don't mind people who are motivated and thick, a bit lazy as last ng as they're intelligent, but pathological liars are my worst fear. They can honestly mess with your sanity.

ErinBell01 · 21/01/2024 18:55

I was a fairly new teacher in a secondary school when I was told that I had to split a class on Wednesdays and I’d take the girls and a new male teacher would take the boys. On Friday I taught the whole class. Obviously it only worked if said male teacher got through the allocated work with the boys that I was teaching the girls Fridays were so stressful when the boys told me they’d done nothing in his class. Every week I had to confront this older teacher and he’d say nothing, just look at me with slight amusement. I complained to HOD, he suggested I help him! Told deputy head who said his hands were tied. Told boys to complain to parents they weren’t being taught and would fail exam. Lo and behold said teacher mysteriously disappeared and we settled down again. What a horrible incompetent lazy swine he was.

DungballInADress · 21/01/2024 18:35

A former boss.

I was involved in the interview process. At interview he seemed really together, lots of experience in the right areas etc.

It turned out what he was really good at was looking busy and talking to the right people. I soon discovered was that he started lots of things, and finished none of them. He spent a lot of time talking to every single person who came into our office about nothing work-related; his old football team and "funny" things he had created for them, an ongoing dispute with a neighbour, projects he had delivered and had turned out exceptionally well. Meanwhile, I was in a junior role dealing with absolutely everything else. He also had a glorious habit of just as I was about to finish a significant piece of work, he would ask to review it then deliver everything I had done as his own.

He was there for about 18 months before the business closed. I'm absolutely certain he spent 12 of those months doing the sum total of fuck all.

Canuckduck · 21/01/2024 18:30

We had someone, recent Masters level graduate with different but significant prior work experience. Took an exceptionally long time to complete training and then would not move forward to actually working. Constantly worried about getting things wrong even though it was explained that nothing was permanent/ all fixable. Was there 3-4 months. Very critical of others, needed constant, immediate feedback.

Always asking for more training but would not put themselves out to get it. Wouldn’t leave their area to travel to another city although they claimed to have studied there. I wondered about severe anxiety, agoraphobia but did not disclose anything even though workplace would’ve provided accommodations.

In the end they left instead of doing 3 days training. Claimed toxic environment.

ToMeToYouAndBack · 21/01/2024 18:28

Medsy · 20/01/2024 09:22

Using track changes to accept/review

I am competent in Word and I did not know this, so maybe they aren't that bad?

megmums · 21/01/2024 18:25

Someone I worked with in NHS contract management. Told us she had a maths degree and had taught maths in secondary school. Did not know how to work out a percentage! Could not use excel atall. Didn’t understand how to create an agenda or take meeting minutes. I wasn’t involved in interviewing her but I understood she interviewed very well. Put contractor meetings in her diary, disappeared for hours, then would remove said meetings from diary.

Loopylemon2 · 21/01/2024 18:11

Aydel · 20/01/2024 09:01

Yes, I had someone who was more concerned with his status than actually doing any work. He also had a very high opinion of himself and was not amenable to any kind of constructive criticism at all.

This… I hired a junior and as soon as his probation was over he thought he had all the answers.

Trinity69 · 21/01/2024 18:06

NotDoingOk · 20/01/2024 08:51

I had someone who couldn't work out how to switch on the laptop or connect it to WiFi

My BOSS called me when she was WFH and asked me how to connect to Wi-Fi. Yes people, my boss.

Xmasdaft2023 · 21/01/2024 18:03

And she wasn’t actually that young either! She’d had a local shop job for a few years from leaving school. She had a dimwit “chef” of a boyfriend - he worked in the local fast food shop!
i shouldn’t laugh but it really really was unbelievable how incompetent she was

LifesTooShortForYourNonsense · 21/01/2024 18:02

The line manager hired above me. They were full time managing 2 part timers. She couldn’t use our main software (Adobe), didn’t manage our workflow. Lost both part timers (the whole team) within 6 months, one of which went to tribunal for constructive dismissal and was paid off. The line manager was gone in under two years- whole exercise seems utterly pointless.