Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
Missingmyusername · 23/01/2024 22:04

Admin role. Started job, said they can’t answer the phone, makes them anxious. FFS.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 23/01/2024 21:51

orangeleopard · 23/01/2024 16:59

this is a different take, but I was that incompetent employee. When I was 19, I needed to get a part time job whilst in college and I was desperate so I was applying for everything regardless if it was something I wanted to do or really could do. I passed an interview, somehow, and managed to get this job working in a quite fancy pub. Anyway, it was my first real job and being very introverted and socially awkward, I was not set out for this type of work. I don’t remember much of the work, but I vividly remember this one day where I was getting all flustered carrying things from the table, I knocked a candle all over my hand and the wax had hardened by the time I could remove it. It made me even more flustered and I managed to drop the tray with glasses on in the process.

Safe to say I quit shortly after and never went back to that field of work again.

We've all been there, different when it's your first job and are learning.

I think incompetent as in someone who's meant/claims to be good but isn't.

Also at 19, I took a job in a kitchen thinking I could wing it. Except, it was an industrial kitchen with everything bigger than normal.
Struggled to carry the big pans, even the mop was huge and heavy.

I cried into the sink as I washed the pans, a supervisor saw and helped me.
Turned up next day as I was desperate for a job and they hadn't cancelled me (agency) as probably thought I wouldn't turn up.
Was instead sent to one of the shops the kitchen supplied. Left the agency and stayed there for 4 years thanks to that supervisor's kindness.

orangeleopard · 23/01/2024 16:59

this is a different take, but I was that incompetent employee. When I was 19, I needed to get a part time job whilst in college and I was desperate so I was applying for everything regardless if it was something I wanted to do or really could do. I passed an interview, somehow, and managed to get this job working in a quite fancy pub. Anyway, it was my first real job and being very introverted and socially awkward, I was not set out for this type of work. I don’t remember much of the work, but I vividly remember this one day where I was getting all flustered carrying things from the table, I knocked a candle all over my hand and the wax had hardened by the time I could remove it. It made me even more flustered and I managed to drop the tray with glasses on in the process.

Safe to say I quit shortly after and never went back to that field of work again.

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 16:49

Sorry for derailing the thread.@JadziaD, you are probably pretty swish at Word.
I wouldn't say I was an expert but I have probably used it to expert level.

I don't like using Track Changes.

I think the most useless colleague I had was one who never did anything wrong whereas most of the team was criticised for making the tiniest mistake.
We had sussed him out but the manager hadn't.
The reason he never did anything wrong was he never did anything.

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 16:44

If I've been using WordPerfect in the early 1990s I'm hardly young.

I get asked to create a template. Someone then uses the new document and puts in their formatting, usually line breaks to create new paragraphs and page breaks, changing font etc and claim my template is rubbish. Hmm

The worst ones are either older men who have been quite high-level managers or young whippersnappers who have written a dissertation so know everything.

JadziaD · 23/01/2024 15:53

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 15:38

@JadziaD , I've been using Word since the 1990s and before that I used WordPerfect, but I've been using it for fairly expert things, not just say typing letters or straightforward documents.

Not sure how you can do things without knowing the terminology, but maybe I'm thinking too deeply. I've used it for creating multiple document books and things.

I'm self-taught but have had training in related subjects/applications.

For example, I've used styles to a greater or lesser extent. Not always completely efficiently, but I do it and it works etc. However, until this thread, if you'd asked me what it was called - I wouldn't have known. When you first started talking about it, I intuitively realised what you meant and went to check that I was right.

OP - sorry we've derailed this thread with some random chit chat about the use of Word. Apologies. But I'm always interested in how much more advanced (or less advanced) people are on Word. KirstenBlest's competence is astonishing seeing as I've met people who can barely save a document and wouldn't know how to do basic formatting if their life depended on it - and as she (or someone else?) pointed out, it's not us Oldies! I had to have words with an intern once who didn't think it was a problem to send a client a press release draft with multiple fonts in it and no headings.

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 15:38

@JadziaD , I've been using Word since the 1990s and before that I used WordPerfect, but I've been using it for fairly expert things, not just say typing letters or straightforward documents.

Not sure how you can do things without knowing the terminology, but maybe I'm thinking too deeply. I've used it for creating multiple document books and things.

I'm self-taught but have had training in related subjects/applications.

JadziaD · 23/01/2024 14:51

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 14:18

@JadziaD , the way you worded your post suggested that you didn't have a clue.
A document doesn't necessarily need a lot of styles but the structure needs to work.
I don't really care how 'GREAT' a document looks but it needs to be structured correctly, be readable and the content needs to be right.

I definitely don't have a clue about the correct terminology - because I've learnt all this stuff as I go. To your original point (or maybe it was another poster?) I've been using Word since the old Word Perfect days and have learnt and expanded my skills organically rather than with formal training.

But my documents are 100% structured correctly, and are readable. And the content better be right - that's where I make my living! Grin

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 14:18

@JadziaD , the way you worded your post suggested that you didn't have a clue.
A document doesn't necessarily need a lot of styles but the structure needs to work.
I don't really care how 'GREAT' a document looks but it needs to be structured correctly, be readable and the content needs to be right.

Lorac23 · 23/01/2024 14:14

Current boss. She's a major reason I'm leaving, yayyyyy. The senior management think she poos sunshine though and she makes sure she's a rep for every daft HR initiative going. I'm grateful to hear for reminding me how not to manage.

JadziaD · 23/01/2024 14:09

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 14:04

@JadziaD , if you are struggling with styles and consistency in formatting then you probably aren't a slick user of Word, and goodness knows what your templates are like. The mind boggles.

This made me laugh. I PROMISE, my documents look GREAT and I am the one who is usually fixing other people's weird formatting issues.

Admittedly, even long documents that I work on are fairly simple. So no need for 10 different styles in a document or lots of images etc, so that does make it easier I guess than if I was doing something that was more complex.

And to clarify my consistency in formatting comment - I always get it right, I just know that if I used Styles more consistently it would be quicker/easier.

nonumbersinthisname · 23/01/2024 14:06

Although knowing what Styles are and how they are used still puts you further ahead than the majority of users I help.

plenty of YouTube and other help guides out there (I prefer written instructions to video but ymmv.)

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 14:04

@JadziaD , if you are struggling with styles and consistency in formatting then you probably aren't a slick user of Word, and goodness knows what your templates are like. The mind boggles.

JadziaD · 23/01/2024 13:53

nonumbersinthisname · 23/01/2024 08:35

It’s probably ironic that those of us who have been using Word in all its versions since the first days of Windows are much more proficient than younger colleagues who are assumed to just “get it” but can be quite derogatory about the older colleagues general capabilities. Word is actually a very powerful programme but there are so many people out there who still treat it as an electronic typewriter, even when writing long reports. I’m currently dealing with a 35 page document where the writer didn’t use the proscribed Styles and as a consequence there’s no headings and a blank navigation panel. It’s making review very difficult.

I’ve demonstrated functionality like the navigation panel or split screen and had reactions like it’s some kind of witchcraft. My personal bugbear is doing lots of carriage returns to force a heading to go on to the next page, or even a page break or worse a section break, because then when text is added up page it all goes wrong. I’ve shown people “keep with next” instead but apparently it’s too difficult.

i actually don’t mind being given a messy document to fix, i find it quite satisfying and I usually slip in a “next time did you know about this functionally”. Just don’t fuck the same document up a second time and expect me to fix it again.

Mmm... I am pretty slick at Word overall but I have always struggled with styles and consistency in formatting and I'm sure I'm doing something wrong. I had someone else set up my original template for me, but I don't think she did it quite right either and I realised when I got a new computer that the ONE thing that didn't transfer over was the old template. Oops.

It's on my list of things to figure out at some point! I work around it by creating templates but without the correct "styles" usage. Must Do Better.

Icarushasfoundyou · 23/01/2024 13:43

We had somebody in a role where they had to be diplomatic and get the cooperation of people working for another organisation. First thing they did was completely piss off one of the people over there who we had always had a good relationship with.

They lied about where they were going and what work they were doing - and were caught out more than once. Always talked themselves out of it though.

Toberlerone · 23/01/2024 13:27

nonumbersinthisname · 23/01/2024 08:35

It’s probably ironic that those of us who have been using Word in all its versions since the first days of Windows are much more proficient than younger colleagues who are assumed to just “get it” but can be quite derogatory about the older colleagues general capabilities. Word is actually a very powerful programme but there are so many people out there who still treat it as an electronic typewriter, even when writing long reports. I’m currently dealing with a 35 page document where the writer didn’t use the proscribed Styles and as a consequence there’s no headings and a blank navigation panel. It’s making review very difficult.

I’ve demonstrated functionality like the navigation panel or split screen and had reactions like it’s some kind of witchcraft. My personal bugbear is doing lots of carriage returns to force a heading to go on to the next page, or even a page break or worse a section break, because then when text is added up page it all goes wrong. I’ve shown people “keep with next” instead but apparently it’s too difficult.

i actually don’t mind being given a messy document to fix, i find it quite satisfying and I usually slip in a “next time did you know about this functionally”. Just don’t fuck the same document up a second time and expect me to fix it again.

I had some colleagues who were shit at this. I used to offer to work from home on a Friday when it was all written and spend the day sorting out the formatting. Very therapeutic when I knew it was going to be me doing it and I had set time aside to do it. I then got a template signed off by the project board so everyone had to do it a certain way. I gave training sessions and I would say most reports were 70-80% satisfactory formatting wise. Then I could do spot training with certain people on the certain functions they hadn't got to grips with.

Before I took this approach I would throw my hands up in the air at the casserole they'd make out of basic Word formatting. This new approach lowered my blood pressure considerably 🤣

KirstenBlest · 23/01/2024 10:59

@nonumbersinthisname , that's pretty similar to my experience.
Font size and bold to create a heading, paragraph marks for spacing etc.

I love formatting documents.

What bugs me is if I am allocated an assistant to tidy up documents but they have no idea of things like how to use styles or anchor graphics. It's more work for me.

An annoyance is when someone insists that they have created a template when they have created an example document. That didn't take them long and they usually fail to grasp that creating an actual template takes me much longer.

With Excel, I think that 'Pivot Table' sounds a lot more complicated than it really is. A bit like when people say they just don't understand algebra or percentage but use it in daily life without realising.

tanstaafl · 23/01/2024 10:57

Over 20 years ago we started using a new technology in IT.
Experience in the technology was thin on the ground.
We had one guy on site from the vendor doing all the work.

One Monday two contractors turned up apparently vetted by the vendor to help the guy out.

Both of them were gone a month later when the vendor’s guy said if they turned up on Monday he was walking out.

Turns out neither had any experience in the technology.
One begged to stay saying he’d work for free just to learn.
Both were binned.

That maybe a level beyond incompetence.

Soporalt · 23/01/2024 10:22

About 30 years ago we had a trainee (big 4) who was so useless we couldn't use him. We gave him the job of wrapping the secretaries' Christmas gifts, 10 boxes of chocolates. He presented us with two parcels of 5 boxes each. He had a PhD! Recruitment processes have since been significantly improved.

TeabySea · 23/01/2024 09:05

Many years ago (in the 80s) in an admin role I gained a new colleague at the same level. We used to do filing, sort and frank post, bit of basic data entry, make tea, that sort of thing.
Colleague was shown filing system (hard copy documents in labelled cabinets). Sang the alphabet song every single time to try to work out what got filed where. Couldn't cope and shoved a load of stuff under x "because it means we don't know".
Colleague was shown franking machine and how to operate. Demonstration was given to them by taking an item of post, weighing it, setting machine to that item weight and producing a label for postage. They franked every single item of post that day at the same rate "because you weighed that one there and told me to set it at x price."
Made one cup of tea. For themselves. "Because I couldn't remember what anyone else said."
Went to post office to send stuff then went shopping."Because it was nearly lunchtime" (it was 10.30).

They weren't stupid, just used weaponised wilful incompetence.

AStrangeStateofMatter · 23/01/2024 09:00

I worked with a social worker once who sat and cried when a child was talking about their life- bad idea because it inhibits the child as they tend to feel guilty for upsetting you.

She would also start singing sarcastic songs at children if they were worked up- not in a distracting a toddler tantrum way, but with teenagers with trauma who were shouting etc- I asked her why she did it once (because clearly taking the piss out of them isn’t helpful or appropriate)… she said it was because she had a degree in preforming arts.

Also had a manager who was studying for a MA part time on the side… He rang me once in a rage to cancel a meeting because he had finished his masters thesis, was supposed to submit it by 12 that day, except his laptop had died and HE Didn’t HAVE A BACKUP COPY ANYWHERE! He hadn’t emailed it to himself, didn’t have it on a memory stick, nothing. He was hysterical with anger. I, having worked with him for a year, was not the least surprised by his incompetence.

nonumbersinthisname · 23/01/2024 08:35

It’s probably ironic that those of us who have been using Word in all its versions since the first days of Windows are much more proficient than younger colleagues who are assumed to just “get it” but can be quite derogatory about the older colleagues general capabilities. Word is actually a very powerful programme but there are so many people out there who still treat it as an electronic typewriter, even when writing long reports. I’m currently dealing with a 35 page document where the writer didn’t use the proscribed Styles and as a consequence there’s no headings and a blank navigation panel. It’s making review very difficult.

I’ve demonstrated functionality like the navigation panel or split screen and had reactions like it’s some kind of witchcraft. My personal bugbear is doing lots of carriage returns to force a heading to go on to the next page, or even a page break or worse a section break, because then when text is added up page it all goes wrong. I’ve shown people “keep with next” instead but apparently it’s too difficult.

i actually don’t mind being given a messy document to fix, i find it quite satisfying and I usually slip in a “next time did you know about this functionally”. Just don’t fuck the same document up a second time and expect me to fix it again.

IlsSortLaPlupartAuNuitMostly · 23/01/2024 08:10

Word is so tricky because people hardly ever get trained in it. It's pretty routine for people to get a bit of Excel training, or to have someone show you how to do a specific piece of work which will include some ad hoc "now select that area and copy it over there: this is quicker if you use Control-Shift" And you learn a lot by seeing what formulae people have used on spreadsheets you've inherited.

But in Word its very simplicity tends to make people discount it as something you have to learn. Anyone over the age of 17 is just told "write X". The "in Word" is silent. It's no wonder there are so many terribly formatted documents out there, and so many of us make a hash of Track Changes.

ruffler45 · 23/01/2024 07:53

G5000 · 21/01/2024 20:11

How do you define 'competent in Word'?

I have found that the most number of functions you need to use in any program for 90% of the time is about 20 to 30. The rest you might need to use once in a while you look up on the help screen. Got me through 30 years of using a computer in an office and I never got to touch typist standard...

DimplesToadfoot · 22/01/2024 21:25

@NannyOggsWhiskyStash

* How on earth did they win the tribunal?*

I don't know how, but I think it was down to timing, it was not long after some big disability bill, where disabled people were given more rights and protection.

The boss was that unhappy he threatened to close the company and move to Spain he had a yacht there I left not long after. The company is no more and lord knows where he is now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread