Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 20/01/2024 12:04

In my profession the more senior management are notorious for failing upwards.

It seems a Vice Chancellor or College Principal can all-but bankrupt a university, or have highly dubious activities connected with their finances or personal behaviour, before moving on with a massive golden handshake, the next plush opportunity at another organisation (which given a few years they'll wreck just as spectacularly) and an elevation to the knighthood.

Sounds like hyperbole but I've seen it happen on more than one occasion.

MrsMarzetti · 20/01/2024 12:02

DomPom47 · 20/01/2024 11:15

I hear horror stories from
family members who are nurses about some of the nurses that they work with - there are some truly wonderful nurses but some who are totally incompetent and a danger to patients - simple things like not checking notes before drug administration and giving wrong medication 😭

That doesn't surprise me in the slightest. My Friends elderly father is Diabetic and has been on he Diabetes ward in hospital for months. One morning there was no Porridge for his breakfast so the nurse ( who had many times administered his Insulin) gave both him and the gentleman next to him jam on toast, when thy both said they couldn't eat that because it had full sugar jam on it her reply was it won't do you any harm !

exttf · 20/01/2024 12:01

There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in

If he can't speak the language and is avoiding taking calls as you have mentioned in another post I think you should report this ASAP to HR or to your manager. If he has lied about his language ability (or exaggerated it) then unfortunately he is not suitable for the post, no matter how nice he is!

Have you tried asking him directly about it? Or reminding him that he needs to answer calls as that is part of his job and does he "require more training" to be able to do that?

27Mankinis · 20/01/2024 12:01

Law firm

I worked with an assistant who could not be trusted to put the correct (already addressed) client letter into the correct (already addressed) envelope.

She also once walked into a meeting I was having with a client (in my office with a closed door) and wandered up to me, shoved her phone in my face and said; 'Look at the picture of the frost I took this morning', then wandered out. I was literally in the middle of explaining to the client he was likely going to be jailed for child sex offences.

Senior management were too weak to do anything about it.

IfOnlyYouWouldListen · 20/01/2024 12:01

One of the managers at my current job. The person he replaced booked an average of 4 days a month to the very important but non-chargeable stuff and was very good at it, got everything necessary done without constantly offloading to his team.
The new one (well he's been there for 18 months) books an average of 18 days a month to this, refuses to do any of the chargeable work as its "not his job" (it absolutely is), constantly claims there's far too much work in the non-chargeable aspect so he has to offload it to his team who are buried trying to cover the work he refuses to do on top of their own work, let alone the extra he wants to give them. The output from the non-chargeable work is no more than when the original person was in the role either
Can't really work out why he's still here, but recruitment is tricky at the moment so I suspect someone thinks better to have someone than not... something his team would beg to differ on!

KirstenBlest · 20/01/2024 12:00

@cremebrulait , Ah, Oui! I remember working with you. Maman said you were only jealous. Wink

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 11:59

OneMoreTime23 · 20/01/2024 11:53

I’m 46 and have been using Mac computers since I was 3.

DH is 2 years older and studied computer science at uni in the 90s. He absolutely had a computer at home as a teen.

You're a bit younger than I am, but I would suggest you are probably the exception rather than the rule. The cost of Mac computers alone would have ruled them out for most people back then, if they'd even heard of them.

cremebrulait · 20/01/2024 11:56

My manager who was a board member/owner hired a friend of a friend's daughter as my intern. She was 6ft tall and French and he was very tall dark and twice her age. He and many guys in the office were falling over her (she'd wear suit jackets with matching shorts or mini skirts, and not tights in winter and dramatically declare "Why are all these men looking at me? Have they never seen long legs?" as if she was deeply offended. Every day was a show or a parade depending on your view.

She'd apparently gone to a top business school in France but I've never worked with anyone so needy or needing so much hand-holding. I'd leave every day feeling like I had way more work to do trying to get her to do anything useful. I wasn't a mum yet but I felt like it! My manager was constantly flirting with her (and yes of course he was married!). He wouldn't get me a better laptop - but got her one! Her English was awful so he paid out of his own pocket for Business English courses. And he paid out of his own pocket to get her online marketing courses. He was obsessed with asked her to 'tweet things'. Her social media posts were pointless/non-sensical/and grammatically-challenged. She frequently told us what her Maman thought we should do. She was a nice young lady in many ways but ... well my manager had a reputation of shagging everyone and shag her he did! He was angered that I was not buttering her up and that I disapproved of his lifestyle choices. I swear up until this point I thought the whole shagging your way up was a hollywood phenomenon. But no, apparently this is how incompetent people get the full attention and mentoring by senior people and the recommendations to keep moving up. And when most of us have imposter syndrome and look to improve ourselves, they just flip up their legs in the air?

Crushed23 · 20/01/2024 11:55

Gobbolinothekitchencat · 20/01/2024 11:10

Not a hyperbolic statement but an entire department within an LA. I work in an intermediary role between them and the ‘customer’ but they are hopeless. Fail to communicate, fail to meet legal deadlines, regularly ignore/forget/lose/eat documents required for decisions resulting in legal consequences being taken. When they do get in touch, it’s all promises and no action. Complaints not being recorded despite going to heads of departments because the complaints manager wasn’t copied in. An absolute disgrace and yes, most are contractors so there’s no accountability, just move to another LA. I am looking for a new role as it is soul-destroying supporting these ‘customers’.

Similar to this, the front of house staff of a Central London clinic are the most incompetent bunch of imbeciles I have ever come across. Like, a whole team, all as terrible as each other.

Got my date of birth wrong, lost my insurance authorisation on two separate occasions - “can you forward it again”, can’t speak English properly, get doctors mixed up and sent me to the wrong waiting area so that I almost missed my appointment, discuss sensitive matter out loud:

Me: are you going to email me the referral letter?
Them: “what is the referral letter for”
Me (whispering): um… therapist <name>
Them: OH, FOR THE SEX THERAPIST, WELL THEY MIGHT CONTACT YOU DIRECT

I kid you not

I feel so sorry for the doctors who work there, having their reputation eroded by these utter idiots. Luckily my doctor divides her time between clinics so I will definitely be going to her other clinic if I have to see her again.

RageAgainstThePrinterMachine · 20/01/2024 11:55

A home carer who didn't follow basic health and safety procedures, was verbally abusive to difficult or more physically impaired clients and influenced new staff members they worked with to do the same so it became their way of doing things too. Management never did anything because this carer has been in the job a long time and was quick (you can be very "efficient" if you're rough with vulnerable clients and don't follow proper procedures even if it could cause harm) and would pick up extra shifts when they were short handed.
Reader, They were always short handed.

It didn't matter how many times they were reported by good staff, those staff would simply be paired with others instead and management would state that they were investigating the accusations. I always wonder if a family member ever caught them on video. I hope so.

edgeware · 20/01/2024 11:55

I am good with Excel but completely self taught. It is not hard to just google ‘how to do X’

OooPourUsACupLove · 20/01/2024 11:54

I find this a lot with men. I get partnered to work on something with a bloke who doesn't seem to know his arse from his elbow, then suddenly all over it when there's a promotable or profile-raising opportunity. Fuckers. 🤬🤬🤬

OneMoreTime23 · 20/01/2024 11:54

I did start a finance job in 2000 where the team were doing the sums on calculators and then entering the figures into massive excel spreadsheets. That was a £4bn public sector budget. You can imagine the revolution when in week 2 I set up formulas!

OneMoreTime23 · 20/01/2024 11:53

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 11:37

The thing is, no one in their mid 40s or older would have grown up with a computer in the remotely modern sense of the word (might have had something like a Sinclair Spectrum if they grew up in the 80s) or had access to Excel at university.

Windows wasn't even installed on the office computers when I started work in the mid 90s. When I first saw Excel I didn't have a clue what it was for, it just looked like the computer equivalent of 'squared paper'. I have never received any formal training on Excel. I ended up buying 'Excel for Dummies' around Y2K to try to make sense of it, and taking the approach of asking people 'can you show me how to do that please'.

I'm still not great compared to many of the younger people - I often end up having to Google for step-by-step instructions on how to do things on Excel.

I’m 46 and have been using Mac computers since I was 3.

DH is 2 years older and studied computer science at uni in the 90s. He absolutely had a computer at home as a teen.

SamW98 · 20/01/2024 11:50

Had another one who strolled into work 2 hours late one day with the excuse he’d had to wait for the bookies to open and collect his winnings as he didn’t have enough money for his train fare otherwise

SunflowerSeeds123 · 20/01/2024 11:50

Too many over the years. We have a very attractive renumeration package so we do get the odd lazy, incompetent, tardy but smug one that's fallen through HR's recruitment cracks. Then it's up to my local management to try and whip them into shape, when really they shouldn't be in the job in the first place. They think yay! Paid well, do bugger all. It's very hard to fire them too, because we're heavily unionised.

Then again, I've made some atrocious mistakes and I think my managers (who unfortunately I get on well with) are too polite to say, actually, Sunflower, you fudged up. But I learn, or try to, from those incidents.

OneMoreTime23 · 20/01/2024 11:47

A long long time ago (I would have been about 18) and managing a hotel restaurant. A woman slightly older than me was recruited. She genuinely thought that if she ran out of forks whilst laying up she could just use whatever was in her right hand instead - knives or spoons - rather than fetch more forks.

She was asked to refresh the bud vases on the tables and put out Budweisers.

She would regularly wear two left or two right shoes.

I think she lasted a week.

iffyi · 20/01/2024 11:47

Sofabum · 20/01/2024 09:27

I work with a man that embodies all the negative stereotypes of gen z. He hardly seems to work, always on 'wellbeing days' turns up to work late, turns up to all meetings late, doesn't ever do any work,always saying he will make a plan or a trello board to manage a project but after making it nothing gets done. Explains he doesn't know how to do things which is why things don't get done but these are simple things that just require initiative e.g. can't book a room for a meeting, so ask around and find out which system you need. Don't know who Mr X is? Ask someone ffs or use the Internet (profiles are all online!)
He's on a PIP but said he felt bullied by it and it impacted his sense of self apparently. He won't be fired so I'm praying he quits.

surely this is just laziness and not anything to do with being a young person? you sound adultist.

AffIt · 20/01/2024 11:46

About ten years ago, I worked as a consultant on a project with a government agency.

The experts were amazingly intelligent and driven people, but the attitude of some of the CS staff was unbelievable.

There was one woman in particular on the project team who was a 'lifer' - joined the CS at 16 and had been there ever since, getting slowly promoted over 20 years to a senior role. She openly admitted that she was only there for the pension.

She was genuinely one of the dullest, least motivated and downright dangerously incompetent people I've ever met and to this day, I am still utterly baffled by how she managed to get away with it.

SamW98 · 20/01/2024 11:45

@Toberlerone

Oh i had one of those who was absolutely useless by far the weakest link in the team but self assessed himself as exceeding expectations in every category on his appraisal.

When we did his 1-2-1 he argued with everything we said, stood up from his chair and paced the room shaking his had shouting ‘unbelievable’ and accused us of prejudice and victimisation- because middle aged white men are obviously a marginalised minority 😫

The 1-2-1 scheduled for an hour lasted 3 and he refused to sign his appraisal and raised a grievance case to HR. Thankfully it went nowhere and even more thankfully he took voluntary redundancy the following year

Nevermind31 · 20/01/2024 11:44

Secretary who couldn’t file… after a while we just got used to finding M under W…
she didn’t last her probation though

Mumoftwo1312 · 20/01/2024 11:39

Toberlerone · 20/01/2024 11:28

Someone working with data who didn't even know how to do simple things in Excel. Like copy + paste special + transpose data. Turns out growing up they didn't have a computer and their degree didn't require computer skills above typing essays. So we brought in basic Microsoft skills tests at interview to make sure employees at least had the basics. A very clever and competent person generally. But no Excel skills and no aptitude to learn them.

It's just not taught in schools as standard any more. I've added it to my scheme of work for year 13 - I don't teach IT but I've found a particular single lesson where I can work in most excel features. 17/18yo, selective school, and they don't even know how to click and drag to copy cells.

Squiblet · 20/01/2024 11:37

They even did a personal performance review and gave themselves 10/10 for everything! I told them even I didn't get 10/10 on everything and they said maybe they should be the project manager then 🤣

Lol this made me laugh more than anything else on this very funny thread! It sounds like something a five-year-old would do.

(Other highlights have been "sorry I can't come in today, it's too windy" and "why yes I'd love to work in your vegetable processing factory, just don't ask me to use a knife")

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 11:37

Toberlerone · 20/01/2024 11:28

Someone working with data who didn't even know how to do simple things in Excel. Like copy + paste special + transpose data. Turns out growing up they didn't have a computer and their degree didn't require computer skills above typing essays. So we brought in basic Microsoft skills tests at interview to make sure employees at least had the basics. A very clever and competent person generally. But no Excel skills and no aptitude to learn them.

The thing is, no one in their mid 40s or older would have grown up with a computer in the remotely modern sense of the word (might have had something like a Sinclair Spectrum if they grew up in the 80s) or had access to Excel at university.

Windows wasn't even installed on the office computers when I started work in the mid 90s. When I first saw Excel I didn't have a clue what it was for, it just looked like the computer equivalent of 'squared paper'. I have never received any formal training on Excel. I ended up buying 'Excel for Dummies' around Y2K to try to make sense of it, and taking the approach of asking people 'can you show me how to do that please'.

I'm still not great compared to many of the younger people - I often end up having to Google for step-by-step instructions on how to do things on Excel.

Toberlerone · 20/01/2024 11:33

However the absolute worst was someone who was unconsciously incompetent. You'd point out they'd done something incorrectly and they would argue their way was right. Despite it being obviously wrong to everyone e.g. writing a report in a conversational/informal style because the information had been given to them through conversations. They couldn't understand why they were supposed to write in a more formal style to report to the project board! Verbatim comments in quotation marks to illustrate your point, yes. Pages and pages of 'as if off the top of their head' prose didn't cut it. But they honestly wouldn't be told. I even went on a constructive feedback training session to improve how I gave the feedback (although none of the other project members struggled with my suggestions for improvements or development areas). But nope they wouldn't be told. They even did a personal performance review and gave themselves 10/10 for everything! I told them even I didn't get 10/10 on everything and they said maybe they should be the project manager then 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread