Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 20/01/2024 13:59

About 15 years ago I was going to be involved with an interview to which the essential skills stated "needs to be fully competent with most of Microsoft Office".
I had an email from someone who told me she was totally perfect for the job but just wanted to check that we didn't use Microsoft Word much as she found it too difficult to use. Upon enquiry, she didn't know that Microsoft Office had anything other than Word on it, and certainly hadn't heard of Excel or even the term "spreadsheets".
Thankfully she didn't get the job.

SamW98 · 20/01/2024 13:55

I worked as a team leader in investment banking years ago and we took on a temp with a brilliant CV showing a 20 year history working in the industry.

On the first day the team member who was showing her the ropes called me to one side she said ‘I’m not sure she’s ever done this before she’s looking at me blank when I go through even the most basic stuff’

So next day I made time to do some training myself. I started showing her how to input the Foreign Exchange and money market trades and she said ‘let me make notes. So what does FX and MM mean?? And this is a woman who claimed to work in banking for 20+ years.

Im sure she was using someone else’s CV

AnnBerlin24 · 20/01/2024 13:55

TellySavalashairbrush · 20/01/2024 09:24

A co worker who had high functioning Asperger’s and used to self medicate with alcohol and we suspected illicit drugs. He was dealing with safeguarding vulnerable children and families and would regularly disappear when he felt under any pressure- often spotted sitting drinking in the local pub. He resigned before being pushed, but now jumps from one local authority to another in the same role , never lasting more than 6 months apparently.

Why mention his autism? How is this relevant?

Benchbythesea · 20/01/2024 13:54

Student, rather than employee, who felt it was ok to message me 4th day in to placement to say that she was 'working from home'. And continued to do so for the majority of days for the next couple of weeks, until I could get a meeting together with their tutor.

The first four weeks were shadowing only, in a healthcare setting. Not sure what she thought she could pretend she was working on at home, she had zero work to do other than be physically with other staff observing them.

Also worked in a setting where we supported young people in the care system. Had a member of staff whose primary role was to answer the phone, take messages etc. They always seemed to panic and tried to put every call through. We repeatedly stressed to them that they had to filter the calls and take messages if people were busy, and only put them through/escalate if they were genuinely urgent.

Said person then started asking every caller 'is it urgent'. Those of you who have teenagers will know their definition of what is urgent can be a little different to ours - they escalated a call all the way up to a member of the executive team who was pulled out of their meeting, only to discover that the 'urgency' was because a teenager was refusing to leave the chair at a salon wanting to have their eyelashes done and the beautician wasnt prepared to do them without parental consent.

madroid · 20/01/2024 13:54

I hired a young man who on the afternoon of his first day was found internet shopping looking at shoes on the work computer. When asked what the hell he thought he was doing, he said in his previous job it was allowed, like a sulky teenager.

Another person couldn't make a cup of tea and had to be 'trained'.

We've had several people, all under 50, who can't copy and paste, don't know to press return instead of the ok button, don't know what a browser is... the list goes on.

And the most common one is being reluctant to speak on the phone. This is people who will talk shit all day long to their colleagues in the office, but ask them to ring a company and make a simple enquiry and you'd think you were asking them to present a tv programme to an audience of millions.

It astounds me how little pride a lot of people take in at least being competent in their jobs. I'm embarrassed for them.

coxesorangepippin · 20/01/2024 13:52

An engineer asking for a protective cover for her high-viz jacket.

Mind. Boggled.

NotFastButFurious · 20/01/2024 13:49

I handed over a temporary role to a guy who by the 3rd day I had to pull the boss aside to ask if HR had actually validated his qualifications and experience because for all he on his CV it was like he'd never used a computer before. Even my mid 70's dad who struggles with such things can use a mouse better than this guy! I would have expected someone who's selling themselves as an experienced data analyst would know how to save a copy of a file in Excel 🙃

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 20/01/2024 13:45

I’ve worked with a conveyancing solicitor we hired at our law firm. I didn’t directly work for him but on the few occasions I did type things for him (overflow typing) it was clear he wasn’t following up on basic areas (eg when searches were done, writing report on title) and he was trying to wing it. We’d employed a locum solicitor who was shit hot at her job, both she and her colleague were employed to look into his work and went through his files when he was either off sick or on annual leave. Then he was fired and the agency we used to hire him got a bollocking and no commission. All us legal secretaries could tell he was useless within his first week or two of starting!

Friend of mine, her boss hired someone above her who can’t do simple things in his role which he should be expected to do at his age and seniority, tries to palm tasks off on her and worked at Home Office for many years and then a charity for a year before joining friend’s company.

Wetandhorrible · 20/01/2024 13:40

BMW6 · 20/01/2024 08:42

One of my trainees couldn't work out 10% even with a calculator. Remarked "but this job doesn't involve much maths does it!"

This was in HMRC.

She failed probation and was most indignant about it.

If you work at HMRC and need a calculator to find ten percent,then you're in the wrong job, let alone with one!!!

moomoomoo27 · 20/01/2024 13:39

Hired someone who had 10 years current experience of spreadsheets. Asked them to add some basic numbers to our finance spreadsheet. They scoffed at it and said they were used to working with much bigger and complex things and it would be super easy for them. Said person didn't get basic additions right so the numbers we needed to submit to HMRC were all wrong.

My partner wrote a basic script that that returned a "yes" or "no" in each column to automatically show whether the row was added up correctly or not. Explained to the person this was what he'd done and how they could easily identify mistakes if it had a "no," and that it needed to be a "yes".

Said person just continued to submit the spreadsheet with "no" boxes clearly there. Just didn't care. After the third time of explaining patiently how it worked, said person had an absolute meltdown and posted all over Facebook about how they were being asked to do too much at work and it was making them ill.

Another person we hired barely spent any time in the room, always taking calls and having to leave because of his daughter (for some reason his partner who he lived with wouldn't talk to the nursery or look after their kid), was then off 3 months because his uncle died, was back two weeks, was then off because another relative died. As soon as he was going below full sick pay, he was magically back in again. Afterwards was found public photos of him on Facebook posted by his friends during these grieving periods, of nights out at him at bars and clubs with a big smile on his face.

Sallyh87 · 20/01/2024 13:37

My first job was cleaning hotel rooms, I am by far the most incompetent person I have worked with?

MadCatLady27 · 20/01/2024 13:35

Not my recruitment as I wasn't important enough to have such powers but I was given him to train

He was calling a customer and I was sat listening

The customer gave their email address. It had an underscore in. He actually wrote the word underscore. I was trying to correct it without the customer hearing. I think he then deleted it while trying to correct it, and had to take it down again. I don't think he could copy and paste either.... And I think ended up deleting the notes he'd made

There were other things too but I can't remember them. Pretty sure they hated me because I said I was struggling with training him!!

It was a call centre so computer based role...

SamW98 · 20/01/2024 13:33

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 13:25

The production director who emailed her scheduling ‘spreadshit’ to our biggest client.

I nearly sent someone a 'daft report' a few weeks ago (draft report).

Years ago we had an offshore team member who typed ‘unidentified funds received in a c**t’ instead of account. Then copied and pasted down to all of the unmatched lines on the rec.Then download a report to PDF and sent out to the client - a huge wealth management company 😱

Blackcats7 · 20/01/2024 13:32

When managing a day centre for adults with complex disabilities a new support worker who was transferred from home care was asked to give 1:1 support to a young man who could not swallow or chew food and needed everything liquidised. He had severe learning disabilities and uncontrolled epilepsy so required constant supervision. She was given clear guidelines on his needs but twice put food ( first time an apple and second time peanuts) in his pockets “to take home”.
She objected hugely and brought her union rep in to argue her case when at the second occasion I had to give her a written warning.
This young man could have choked to death from her incompetence.

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 13:32

We had a sinclair zx81 in the early 80s, used for playing Manic Miner, Jet Set Willy and Pong.

We had one of those! Complete with a '1k RAM pack'!

LoobyDop · 20/01/2024 13:30

I’ve worked with two contractors in the last few years whose lack of competence had to be seen to be believed. Both getting paid at least £400/day. The first one wittered on a lot about taxonomy, and after he’d been sacked we found he had spent most of his time creating spreadsheets that listed all the data items in the drop down fields of the off the shelf software he was supposed to be writing requirements for. The other did literally nothing and couldn’t describe the product we were delivering after six weeks in the job. Both had a long history of working for local councils- I get the impression a lot of people manage to hide in public sector roles for a long time.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 20/01/2024 13:28

OneMoreTime23 · 20/01/2024 11:53

I’m 46 and have been using Mac computers since I was 3.

DH is 2 years older and studied computer science at uni in the 90s. He absolutely had a computer at home as a teen.

I think you're probably quite unusual in having been using a mac since you were 3. I'm a year older than your husband. We had a sinclair zx81 in the early 80s, used for playing Manic Miner, Jet Set Willy and Pong. After that my sibling had a commodore 64 which I was only rarely allowed to use. It was only used for games. None of my friends had computers, we were unusual and the computers we had were for games and nothing else. I certainly wouldn't have learnt how to use software like excel on them.

In the last year of primary school we had a go on a BBC computer about once a week, but it was one computer shared between the whole class so we only got a couple of minutes on it. Next touched a computer in 6th form when I chose to do some basic computer skills classes which were offered and that was the first time I used excel and word. Didn't touch them again until I got a job which involved all day computer use a couple of years after I left university, and from them on had to self teach myself.

EverleighMay · 20/01/2024 13:28

I find a huge difference between the convincing bullshit said at interviews compared to reality, especially amongst younger people/school leavers.

E.G 'I'm an Excel Expert' in the interview but in reality they can't create a basic formula.

Another example 'in my last job I did a presentation for 100 people' but then refuses to ever speak or contribute to anything as they're too shy to talk in a group of more than 3 people in a meeting - this was a training co-ordinator vacancy!

People are getting so good at acting their way through interviews then are hopeless once the job starts.

And, don't get me started on sick leave......

ExpressCheckout · 20/01/2024 13:25

One had the misfortune of being managed by someone recently awarded an OBE. I had my doubts about their experience when they were recruited but also wanted to give them a chance because of their background.

Wind on two years and they'd gone, leaving a real mess behind them, a wrecked team and reputation. They were as I thought - strong on photo ops and virtue signalling (usually their own) but no management skills.

This person has now moved on to a gullible public sector organisation and is, as far as I can see, repeating the same process again - overpromising, virtue signalling, doing all the PR etc. They'll move on again no doubt.

On reflection this person was possibly one of the least equipped and most entitled people I have ever had the misfortune to cross paths with. But they ticked the PR boxes and looked good in a photo.

Now I am not saying this person is like those in the Horizon scandal, but we do have a tier of empty headed climbers in this country who cycle around these jobs - see also the Lucy Letby/Chester hospital crowd.

We now have someone in place who is actually qualified for the job, doesn't have the OBE, doesn't virtue signal and only ticks boxes that are relevant to the job.

I'm pretty average in my job, BTW, and wouldn't actually want the job they were given. I just think that we deserved better, and an OBE doesn't mean that you are necessarily good or suited to the role you've been given.

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 13:25

The production director who emailed her scheduling ‘spreadshit’ to our biggest client.

I nearly sent someone a 'daft report' a few weeks ago (draft report).

cloudsdrifting · 20/01/2024 13:25

I know someone who used to work for a big international firm. She said overseas applicants who couldn't make it to head office were interviewed remotely, as you might expect. Some applicants would find at the start of the interview they had 'camera/video issues' so no visuals for the interviewer. If they interviewed well they'd be taken on despite this. On more than one occasion successful applicants they hadn't 'seen' at interview didn't make it through probation. They were so incompetent the suspicion was they were not the person interviewed.

LookItsMeAgain · 20/01/2024 13:24

@SlightlyJaded - can I do that job for you?
I'd actually read the scripts and put the correct sticker on the front and give my feedback too?

CombatLingerie · 20/01/2024 13:23

Thanks for the thread OP @Peteryourhorseishere that made me laugh. Also love the sticky label on the typewriter roller. The script guy who used all the colours of stickers 😂. Anyway yes I have worked with some incompetent people. What PP’s have said about people who can spout BS is true. Until they then have to do the actual job and the wheels come off. I saw it many times throughout my career. The most blatant was an ‘inspirational headteacher’. They were employed by our LA at great cost. Their job was to inspire us less than inspirational teachers. This would then turn us into inspirational teachers. Except it turned out they were not even a teacher let alone a headteacher.

NotMyFirstChoiceofName · 20/01/2024 13:18

CryptoFascist · 20/01/2024 10:03

Agreed @icelolly12 , our interview process gets longer and longer as we try to weed out the malingerers, the agitators, bullshitters, and those who will accept the job but then think they can amend the hours, days of work and salary during the recruitment process.

Same here. We are small family business and can’t afford to hire anyone who can’t do the job. We nearly went bankrupt because we hired someone who couldn’t do the most fundamental part of the job. We found this out during the first week, then he went off sick and claimed disability discrimination . It took us a year to get rid of him and we had to pay him all that time to sit at home and do nothing.

Meanwhile our other two staff were rushed off their feet , customers complaining and we couldn’t afford to hire anyone else as well as as paying the other guy.

It was something as basic as “ I can’t climb ladders because I have an ear problem which makes me dizzy “ when we are a firm of roofers*

Yes we asked for medical reports, which he refused. He claimed that this ear problem started the exact same week he started working for us. What a coincidence.

( details changed to protect the guilty )

Supersimkin2 · 20/01/2024 13:18

The production director who emailed her scheduling ‘spreadshit’ to our biggest client.

She was awarded Employee of the Year.

By the guy who insisted I input bad grammar into a cover piece for a mag, then reported me for illiteracy to the MD. (I kept his marked up paper just in case).

The MD married the lying jerk. Some businesses shouldn’t survive, sadly. It didn’t.