Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
Mumoftwo1312 · 04/02/2024 18:57

This thread has reminded me of a pgce trainee teacher I mentored once, and his uni tutor. This was at a prestigious Eton group school so he was lucky to get it for his second placement.

He was so incompetent. He'd show powerpoints he hadn't even read beforehand and it'd be painfully obvious to the kids as every slide took him by surprise. He'd set them questions he couldn't answer himself. He never planned a lesson properly or marked anything on time. His subject knowledge was woeful. He never took my advice because he thought he knew better. He'd spend time reformatting worksheets instead of actually planning. Kids would misbehave and he wouldn't even see it, and argue with me afterwards when I told him during feedback.

The worst bit was this. The uni tutor was worse! Even more disorganised and generally gormless. Never held him to account. One time the tutor said to him "you probably need to spend 50% more time on planning a week as you do now." I said "maybe even double!" And the tutor corrects me "50% is more than double." This was a science subject...top pgce provider in the country... wtf.

He passed as well. I wrote him an 11 page report, recommending he should repeat the 2nd placement, with loads of feedback and analysis. But it's a shortage subject with govt quotas so they just waved him through.

honeylulu · 04/02/2024 16:38

Other incompetent colleagues:

Woman with terrible drink problem. Kept a half bottle of vodka in her handbag and would glug from it in the toilet cubicle. (This was Civil Service not law firm. ) Had worked there 20 years and was offered lots of help and support but then one day DROVE to work totally blotto, fell downstairs as could hardly walk, so she had to be fired. I veered between being horrified by the drunk driving and being sorry for her that her life was such a mess as she was a nice lady otherwise.

Had an office junior once who seemed to think the job was to entertain her. Would refuse to do anything that didn't interest her (until told sharply that she had to, then burst into tears about how "horrible" her supervisor was). Refused to make tea for one visitor as she "didn't like his face". Would regularly call in sick on Fridays but recover enough by the afternoon to drop by and pick up her pay packet... She did get a bit better (though not much) with some firm management.

Also not a colleague but a cleaning firm we used at home. I asked the manager if she could make sure the cleaners could sweep/ clean under the freestanding bath as lots of dust was building up. She was shocked I expected this and said that the gap was low down and could only be reached by bending right down. Well, yes, and perfectly possible- I had often done so myself. I was surprised that a cleaner considered it unreasonable to bend down to clean! When we moved house I ditched them and do my own cleaning again.

honeylulu · 04/02/2024 16:23

We had a trainee solicitor in our department once who never seemed to do any work. I'd give him a task as the other trainee already had plenty and find out a couple of days later that he'd foisted it onto her to complete as he was "too busy". No matter how many times I challenged him on this he always somehow found a way of passing his work to someone else to do.

Unfortunately several of the equity partners seemed to think the sun shone out of his arse. Quite astonishing as we have to record all our chargeable time and have minimum daily targets. So either he was falsifying his or they were willing to turn a blind eye.

He was one of those sickening people whose "face fits". Public school, swaggering, confident, funny, good looking, well dressed, could charm the birds from the trees. People with that sort of charisma get away with far more than they deserve. When he qualified they kept him on despite some loudly expressed concerns from colleagues. I think the view taken was that he was exactly the image the firm wanted to have and if he could just get his time recording sorted it would be perfect.

He's no longer with us but wasn't fired - got headhunted by another firm for vastly more money FFS.

logo1236 · 03/02/2024 19:20

I used work for a coding bootcamp. Most students were beginners so the teaching job required 2 skills - being good at coding and being good at explaining technical concepts in a very simplified way. Co-worker was a complete tech bro who owned a start up and was teaching on the side. I swear he would go out of his way to explain things in the most roundabout, complicated way an confusing all the students.

The kicker was he kept complaining to me about the students being dumb and not understanding anything. He even went off on the students once during a lesson basically calling them idiots. I was mortified as these students were paying like 10k for this course!

Another example is a co-worker who did not have English as her first language, her English was fine, but she kept using phrases the wrong way and sometimes translated them literally in e-mails to co-workers and clients (think translating taking the piss as peeing), which is not her fault, but she absolutely refused to listen when anyone would try to correct her. She insisted she was right and kept sending the e-mails.

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 19:17

@chaosmaker , I always vote for who I'd think would make the best constituency MP. I live in a 'safe seat' constituency and the choice is usually Red or Blue.

I have lived in another safe seat and didn't vote for the safe seat candidate as he was new and it would go against the grain for that party.

The next town along has an excellent constituency MP in a safe seat. Despite having never voted for the party that candidate represents, I might if I lived there, but it would go against the grain to vote for that party. I suspect I could safely not vote and the incumbent would get voted in anyway.

Wouldyouguess · 03/02/2024 19:06

Used to work in various hotels while at uni as a waitress, one of the best was a guy on the team who would come and literally refuse to do anything as it was 'not a part of his job'. No one knew what was as he only liked to serve tea and coffee.

chaosmaker · 03/02/2024 19:01

I cannot fathom who to vote for this election, let alone understand how anyone thinks a tory vote is good, given their record, lies, selling off anything not nailed down, lies, robbing the country by given contracts away to friends, incompetence, lies, freeports, lies, etc. oh and lies

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 16:53

@Ilovecleaning , it amazes me that people voted for him. Not just the constituency but the party and the general electorate.

I have friends who live in 'safe seats' and they won't vote for anyone who's not a Tory.

logo1236 · 03/02/2024 16:49

ThePure · 20/01/2024 16:19

I once had a months overlap with my incoming mat leave cover as a junior Dr. He was so incompetent that it was definitely a safety issue which I flagged to managers

He would disappear off for hours and be uncontactable which is obviously a safety issue. If challenged he would say his bleep must not be working as he had got no calls even when we had all been calling him. In actual fact he had switched it off. Accidentally he said.

He did precisely no work and let me do it all at 8 months pregnant. It soon transpired this was because he had no idea how to do anything at all. Not examining or interviewing patients, not prescribing or reviewing test results, nothing. He even fucked up writing some paracetamol on a drug chart. I did begin to wonder how he could have passed a medical degree.

Once he arrived back from an extended lunch break without the crash bleep which he was supposed to be carrying and being part of the resus team. We went back to look for it and I found it buried amongst the sandwiches in the canteen where it was merrily chirping away to itself (the crash team were definitely better off without him).

English was not his first language and he was comically bad. He asked me the word for something and was pointing in the vicinity of his knee. I started off with medical words like meniscus, cruciate ligament etc then went down to joint and knee cap and finally we established that 'leg' was the word he didn't know.

You will be relieved to know that they did fire him after about 2 weeks of this and got someone halfway decent.

If he was foreign it is possible he falsified his degree

Ilovecleaning · 03/02/2024 15:55

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 03/02/2024 14:55

He was interviewed before being placed as a candidate, surely? Or did he get parachuted in on the back of being high profile?

I think you’re right: parachuted in…

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 15:15

@CrabbiesGingerBeer , probably parachuted in.

@logo1236 , do you mean that you never had an interview where you didn't have a test, never had an interview or never had an interview where you were tested?

Caroparo52 · 03/02/2024 15:14

New gardener job was to mow the lawn. When asked why it looked exactly the same he said he was "tickling the tops of the grass"
🤣🤣🤣🤣

Kazzyhoward · 03/02/2024 15:13

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 03/02/2024 12:35

@Kazzyhoward , I think this is also an interviewing fail. I work in a field where people with my qualifications may have absolutely no idea how to work in a different area to the one they’ve always worked in despite technically being qualified.

It’s part of the application / interview procedure to check whether people either have sufficient experience or whether they need training (which the business may or may not be prepared to offer).

I think the owner was "blinded by the light" that someone from a top firm wanted to join his small firm and didn't have the confidence to ask/check his actual ability/experience.

Probably both at fault as the job advert/description was pretty clear the job was a wide scope including "incomplete records" work, VAT returns, payrolls, as well as accounts preparation and tax returns. The firm wasn't a registered auditing firm so the applicant must have known his years of doing nothing but audits wasn't a particularly good match.

I wasn't party to the job interview nor his CV, so can't comment on what was actually discussed or what he claimed on his CV.

logo1236 · 03/02/2024 15:05

NotFastButFurious · 20/01/2024 13:49

I handed over a temporary role to a guy who by the 3rd day I had to pull the boss aside to ask if HR had actually validated his qualifications and experience because for all he on his CV it was like he'd never used a computer before. Even my mid 70's dad who struggles with such things can use a mouse better than this guy! I would have expected someone who's selling themselves as an experienced data analyst would know how to save a copy of a file in Excel 🙃

As a data analyst I find this wild because I never had a job interview and not had to demonstrate my skills in a technical test, but a few times I have heard of people getting hired by lying in the interview when actually they haven't analysed data a day in their life. They are always men.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 03/02/2024 14:55

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 14:30

@Ilovecleaning , the point is that he was democratically elected into the position.
This thread has pointed out some of the failings in recruitment by interviewing.

He was interviewed before being placed as a candidate, surely? Or did he get parachuted in on the back of being high profile?

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 14:30

@Ilovecleaning , the point is that he was democratically elected into the position.
This thread has pointed out some of the failings in recruitment by interviewing.

Ilovecleaning · 03/02/2024 14:11

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 12:57

Johnson was voted in as an MP. He became PM because people voted for him to be party leader, and the public voted for his party.

Winning votes doesn’t mean he’s not incompetent.

KirstenBlest · 03/02/2024 12:57

chaosmaker · 03/02/2024 10:48

Such a shame there isn't an international register of incompetent people with big red marks against them. They do such damage when they are that high up, just look at Johnson becoming PM.

Johnson was voted in as an MP. He became PM because people voted for him to be party leader, and the public voted for his party.

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 03/02/2024 12:35

@Kazzyhoward , I think this is also an interviewing fail. I work in a field where people with my qualifications may have absolutely no idea how to work in a different area to the one they’ve always worked in despite technically being qualified.

It’s part of the application / interview procedure to check whether people either have sufficient experience or whether they need training (which the business may or may not be prepared to offer).

folkjournals · 03/02/2024 11:57

@Kazzyhoward How/why did he end up at your firm?!

Kazzyhoward · 03/02/2024 11:12

The firm (small accountancy practice) that I worked at in the 90s took on a qualified chartered accountant who'd trained and qualified with Ernst & Young (one of the UK's biggest accountancy firms), as "partner designate", i.e. on fast track to becoming a partner. He was mid-late 20's and had been qualified a few years, so not a rookie.

He hadn't a clue how to prepare basic sets of accounts for small businesses like pubs, shops, etc, he didn't know how to do a VAT return! He'd spent all his working life "auditing" big firms, so had never come across "carrier bags" full of random screwed up invoices and unopened bank statements. He knew all the theory, the international accounting standards, etc., but didn't even know where to start when there wasn't a set of balanced books done by a book-keeper.

He lasted about a month, as he was so far up his own arse that he wanted other staff to do the basic book-keeping elements for him.

We all knew it was a problem on his first day when he was given a crisp box full of invoices to work through and his first question was "where's the nominal ledger"!!

chaosmaker · 03/02/2024 10:48

Such a shame there isn't an international register of incompetent people with big red marks against them. They do such damage when they are that high up, just look at Johnson becoming PM.

InkySplott · 02/02/2024 16:15

@moggerhanger

You find this in the Care system and retail management too , they just go from place to place often just before they get taken on a disciplinary for incompetence .

moggerhanger · 02/02/2024 15:58

At the other end of the incompetence scale was an ex-CEO of mine. He came in originally as a non-executive director (NED) to a company I'd only just joined. The company itself was small but had some really interesting technology, and appeared to be going places. But it became apparent that it was in fact a basket case and had been terribly badly run. The NED basically orchestrated to get the original CEO out, and then changed the strategy to merge with other companies in an effort (so he said) to achieve synergies 🙄with the other companies' products and our tech. He managed to wring a huge salary and options deal out of the RemCom. Initially I thought it was a good move, given how badly run the co had been in the past. But unfortunately ex-NED/new CEO couldn't run a pissup in a brewery either, so things went from bad to worse. After a hideous stressful 18 months I walked out, telling them they would go bust in 2 years or less, and if they wanted me to work my notice period, they'd have to sue me.

Reader, they went bust in 2 years and a day.

I occasionally google his name and can see that he's gone to various other companies around the world, pulling the same scheme and leaving chaos in his wake. But very well remunerated, I have no doubt.

Zonic · 30/01/2024 17:25

@Ilovecleaning

This sounds like a thread in inself