Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
Mysterian · 20/01/2024 15:18

I work in a nursery and have worked as bank staff so have seen many terrible things!
The sheer amount of staff who seem to not like children always gets me. When we do interviews we ask them to go into the room with the children before the sit down chat with the boss bit. So many so them just sit there refusing to interact with the kids. They often get jobs anyway because nurseries are so desperate for staff they'll take anyone.

CharlieBoo · 20/01/2024 15:17

Many moons ago I was PA to a director and also helped out her direct reports. One of them was just hopeless. Forgot everything, couldn’t even book holiday in SAP, work out his expenses, needed constant reminders for deadlines etc. At the time his salary was huge and I used to wonder why he was doing the job he was doing.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 20/01/2024 15:14

A guy who was obsessed with status (he was in an admin job on the bottom rung). Absolutely drove everyone nuts because he was incapable of following teh simplest instructions. In an open plan office, we once all listened to his manager telling him very very carefully what he had to do. Twice. She then went off to a meeting. Within three minutes, he'd come over and asked someone else what he should be doing. On another occasion he was working on something with a different manager and asked her 'Are you helping me with this, or am I helping you?' She replied 'We're working TOGETHER, A.'

Evvyjb · 20/01/2024 15:12

I am a teacher. We end up responsible for training trainees (who pay the uni a significant fee, of which we individuals see not a jot).

I have one who is incapable of explaining basic vocabulary. Wants paperwork read to them. Confuses key plot elements of GCSE texts which they claim they studied at uni. Cannot meet deadlines in any way, shape or form. Expects resources to be brought to them.

And is CONVINCED they are doing well.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/01/2024 15:11

Notellinganyone · 20/01/2024 14:55

@Depressedhusbandbringingmedown - I’ve been teaching for nearly 30 years and think learning objectives every lesson are daft.

There can't be many teachers still in the profession who qualified before the National Curriculum and associated changes came in. I had children at primary school in the 1990s and I was a school governor. Also, my mother was a primary school teacher who qualified in the early 1950s and took redundancy/early retirement in the late 1980s. She kept in touch with former colleagues for many years. From what I learned from all of this, I would say that it took a long time for changes to bed down. Many older teachers absolutely loathed having to teach the National Curriculum, accept having members of senior and middle management observe their lessons, go through Ofsted, prepare children for SATs, endure performance management/appraisals, and deal with the endless paperwork that now seems such a feature of teaching. None of this was standard before that time. When my mother was teaching, a teacher's classrom was her castle. Many teacher went through their entire career with nobody else observing or assessing what they were doing. There were obvious risks to this, but the autonomy was marvellous for a good teacher, and many of us who were at school in the old days probably have fond memories of lessons that nowadays would be rated as substandard where the teacher went off piste but taught us things that weren't on the curriculum but were really interesting.

Sharontheodopolodous · 20/01/2024 15:10

Oh and the lady who's favourite phrase was 'that's not in my job description'

I work the kind of job,that if its in front of you,then just deal with it

She did the same job as me,and she refused to actually do it-she refused to do table service,cleaning,checking the loos,dealing with teenagers or grotty customers-you name it,she refused to do it

She did a lot of standing around and chatting though and would do the till if forced

The last straw was when a young lad fell off his bike just outside the store and hit his head-she refused to go get a manager or stay with him while i went as 'that's not in my job description'

I have a phobia of blood so that was fun,trying to stem the blood gushing out of his face while shouting to get someone,anyone to notice us and get a manager themselves for me

I complained about her-all she had to do was walk ten yards and alert someone,so they promoted her and gave me a bollocking for staying with an unconscious teenager who was laid,spark out in the middle of a busy road-I should have got a manager myself apparently

Thankfully she left not long after but I never want to hear those bloody words ever again

I do wonder what was in her bloody job description though

Ariela · 20/01/2024 15:09

AnneLovesGilbert · 20/01/2024 09:53

I worked with someone who couldn’t stuff an envelope. She kept taking the strip off the sticky bit before putting the magazine in. Lost a handful of expensive magazines which had the back torn off, got in a strop and walked out.

There are some things you can’t help people with if you’ve shown them several times and they don’t get it.

Gosh, I used to help my Dad in the summer holidays from about age 8 doing this sort of thing. I soon fathomed the easiest way was to get a stack of envelopes, turn back side up and flip out all the flaps. Then stuff the lot into another pile, then fan them out 10 or so at a time so all the gum sides were showing use a sponge to dampen all of the flaps, then quickly seal each one before the gum dried and stack in a different pile.

maddiemookins16mum · 20/01/2024 15:05

I work with a lady who is 7 years older than me….I’m 60 this year.
We are Admin support roles. Slightly different responsibilities but part of the same overall team.
When she started (over 15 years ago), a lot of the job (she still does) involved paper, paper files etc. Times have changed, our customers have changed, the business has changed. For example, even as recently as 2018 many of our customers would post us documents - now they upload them. Which then need opened, saved and named on their online record.

Despite many, many attempts to train (over at least a four year period) her she cannot (this means will not) do the following.

Use Teams. She is literally offline on Teams all day, despite us using it as a big part of communicating during the working day. We have to open it for her. When there is a Teams meeting she ignores it or moves to try and listen (lip read) at another desk or will ask to plug her headphones in to their lap top.

Cannot transfer a call on the phone system. Will tell the caller that she’ll pass the message on and then walks two floors up to verbally inform the person.

Cannot upload documents to the Onedrive.

Cannot rename a folder. Just keeps clicking on it in an exaggerated way so it opens instead of once so she can change the name of it.

Cannot compose a simple email properly, for example it is either sent without a subject heading or the message is in the subject heading. Never signs it off.

Cannot set an out of office.

Cannot order anything online, so will not use our work account to order stationery etc from our supplier (very simple website).

Won't use Excel at all, even open it and update a very basic spreadsheet. She does not need to create formulas, just add some figures and date.

There are more examples I could give, like not being able to book her annual leave using our in-house system. I do it for her.

Her argument is she was originally employed to only deal with incoming/outgoing post and do filing, not all this ‘computer stuff’.

It’s exhausting. Unfortunately she has said she doesn’t want to retire yet either as she lives alone and we’re her only company.

WavingCatsandDogs · 20/01/2024 15:04

Long time ago, I'm sure systems set up to stop this getting through but two men I managed in my team, I caught both of them looking at porn!

Notellinganyone · 20/01/2024 14:55

@Depressedhusbandbringingmedown - I’ve been teaching for nearly 30 years and think learning objectives every lesson are daft.

SummitOfMountWashmore · 20/01/2024 14:55

Not me (genuinely!) but our local smll convenience supermarket...

Hired a guy who would give you the total back rather than the change. I dont even know how E.g. if you spent £17.50 and paid with a £20 note, after ringing it through the till (and I'm talking a proper supermarket, it was either a tesco express or a sainsburys local, can't remember which, not a little corner shop with a basic system), instead of giving you £2.50 change, he'd give you £17.50 back. And it wasn't even a one off, it happened to me several times over about a 2 week period, so God knows how many people he did it to.

He wasn't there for very long 😂

willWillSmithsmith · 20/01/2024 14:49

ThanksAntsThants23 · 20/01/2024 08:56

Probably me! I can work fine on my own but as soon as there are people around I get anxious and start making really stupid mistakes, like the example of someone not knowing how to work out 10% or do something basic on a computer, something like this I could do absolutely fine while I was alone but if I was with someone else and they asked me to do it I would just panic and not be able to do it.. I’m self employed now 😂

Are you me?😁 I came on the thread to say I was probably the most incompetent person I’ve worked with and like you it’s always when someone is hovering around. I’m incapable of carrying out the most basic function if I’m being watched or not left to my own devices, god help me when the phone rang at such a time 😬😁 When I’m on my own I’m super efficient and capable. I used to share an office with just one other person, I really liked them but when they weren’t there I was so happy to be in there on my own.

104c · 20/01/2024 14:48

Ex-boss (managing director) hired someone as a "junior" version of my role after realising he'd basically loaded three peoples worth of work onto me as the business expanded. Then found out I'd have to train her as well. Supposedly she had 40 years of office experience though, so NBD.

We had a 5% price increase and maintained an Excel list of all prices. (Approx 5 or 6 sheets - v small company and no proper "systems"). 10min job for someone who vaguely knows their way around Excel. I asked Junior to add in a column with a calculation for the new price increases. She laughed at me and said "oh no that's not how I do things", copied and pasted the spreadsheets into a Word document (?!), printed them, and sat for 5 hours manually calculating each one on her calculator and writing it down in pencil. (I had stopped her after she went to the printer and said "it's OK if you don't know how to do the formula, excel can be tricky, did you need me to show you? It's far quicker". I got back "no, ill work how i prefer to work thanks") office manager HOWLING at this point.

She handed me the paper towards the end of the day and I sweetly smiled, pushed it back and said "yep, now on the spreadsheet. we need it in that format. Thanks!"

This was one of SO MANY examples.

Glad her 40 years experience served her well. Found out she was being paid more than me just because she was older and as boss said, a "proper adult" (I was 21, married and had just bought a house). Handed him my notice, told him id got a "proper job" with a 35% pay rise and substantially better benefits, and never looked back.

stayathomer · 20/01/2024 14:43

ThanksAntsThants23

Probably me! I can work fine on my own but as soon as there are people around I get anxious and start making really stupid mistakes, like the example of someone not knowing how to work out 10% or do something basic on a computer, something like this I could do absolutely fine while I was alone but if I was with someone else and they asked me to do it I would just panic and not be able to do it.

Same here and I remember talking to a girl who said she couldn’t believe they’d kept her so long and everything she said resonated. I try my very best though and go above and beyond for people and was lucky to hit the jackpot with coworkers who let me take a bit of time to remember how to do things and figure myself out

Cathbrownlow · 20/01/2024 14:39

I once had to work closely with this bloke who seemed very pleasant at first. We discussed which parts of the work we'd take responsibility for , all good. I went away and did my part and a couple of times I asked him how he was doing and the answer always came back 'fine'. I'm sure you can see where this is headed...

  • didn't do any of the tasks he had agreed to do
  • lied and said he was doing them
  • Decided to make up his own task and do that instead?? (badly)

I was so angry because it was my reputation on the line as well as his. He jumped before he was pushed and apparently secured a similar type of job in the same sector where I know he would have fucked it all up again.

I don't understand some people.

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 14:37

Havanananana · 20/01/2024 14:31

@TheLogicalSong "The thing is, no one in their mid 40s or older would have grown up with a computer in the remotely modern sense of the word (might have had something like a Sinclair Spectrum if they grew up in the 80s) or had access to Excel at university."

Really? Computers might not have been in every home, but they were certainly common (and vital) in many industries by the 1990s

I did a computer programming course at university - in 1975. I'd even done some at school before that. From this alone you can work out that I'm well over 60.

I worked in offices that had computers from the mid-1980s and in the newspaper industry that had computerised typesetting, admin and accounting in the 1980's.

From the mid-1990s computers were a part of daily office life everywhere I worked. Amazon on-line shopping was founded in 1994. People who were even just in their 20s in 1994 would be over 50 today.

Did you miss my caveat in the remotely modern sense of the word? What I meant by that is that you wouldn't have been using Microsoft Office in the 70s and 80s. As I mentioned, we had computers at work in the mid 90s, they'd had them since the early 80s, but not running Windows - that wasn't adopted until about 1999 - and this was a large organisation.

moggerhanger · 20/01/2024 14:36

I work in a support function in an NGO. We recruited a deputy for my role - lovely girl, interviewed well, but turned out to be lights on but nobody home. One example: we needed a new policy. I found a decent template and gave it to her to customise. Told her specifically to remove references to directors and replace with trustees, change customers to beneficiaries/grant recipients etc, take out square brackets. She gave it back to me with no changes other than to put our organisation name at the top of the first page. And said she'd spent hours on it!

She was still in the probation period so was told sorry, not the job for you. She then brought a grievance that she'd raised some donations for our org at a family event, so should have kept her job.

MagpiePi · 20/01/2024 14:33

The company I worked for took on an autoCAD technician to produce highway design drawings. He didn't understand basic concepts like scale, model space and paper space and drew everything by eye rather than using the required precise measurements. He lasted about a week.

Bridgertonned · 20/01/2024 14:32

Colleague started a role caring for vulnerable people who needed 24hr support. The role was clearly advertised as a rotating shift pattern, 8-4, 10-6, 2-10, and it specified that nights were covered by a separate team.

Colleague started, did office hours for the induction, then 8-4, then asked me and a colleague to swap the next two weeks when she was down to do 10-6 and 2-10. I was a bit surprised at being asked to swap a whole week of shifts and asked why; she matter of factly described that she had to do the school run, cook tea, housework etc. She had a husband at home but these all appeared to be her jobs (possibly cultural factors)

I explained I'd be willing to help out in an emergency but not to swap all my shifts and asked whether she understood the people we helped needed 24hr care and so the job required working the hours they needed. She said she'd assumed that she'd been able to choose the shifts and that she only wanted to work 8-4.

I asked who she thought would choose to work permanently 2-10 (given there was no enhancement) and she said 'young people', which is why she'd asked me (I presume she meant no children)

She then complained to the manager that me and the other worker had 'refused to swap shifts without good reason'.

Needless to say she didn't last long. Bizarre that you could go all the way through the process for that type of role and assume you could just choose when you wanted to work!

Havanananana · 20/01/2024 14:31

@TheLogicalSong "The thing is, no one in their mid 40s or older would have grown up with a computer in the remotely modern sense of the word (might have had something like a Sinclair Spectrum if they grew up in the 80s) or had access to Excel at university."

Really? Computers might not have been in every home, but they were certainly common (and vital) in many industries by the 1990s

I did a computer programming course at university - in 1975. I'd even done some at school before that. From this alone you can work out that I'm well over 60.

I worked in offices that had computers from the mid-1980s and in the newspaper industry that had computerised typesetting, admin and accounting in the 1980's.

From the mid-1990s computers were a part of daily office life everywhere I worked. Amazon on-line shopping was founded in 1994. People who were even just in their 20s in 1994 would be over 50 today.

reesewithoutaspoon · 20/01/2024 14:30

my unit hired a data entry clerk to assist my research post. They claimed to have 15 years of experience. I was on leave when they recruited and the person recruiting knew jack shit about the job role.
My clerk didn't know how to turn on their PC or shut it down safely.
They literally asked constant questions and didn't understand drop-down lists. drove me mental repeating the same data entry errors again and again, then we got our data validation back, and 90% of what they had inputted needed re-verification.
Flagged it up immediately and was told to give them time as their references were excellent! Obviously used to get rid of them , as it was the Public service sector, so impossible to get rid of them any other way.
I left the job in the end because they added instead of took work away.

NotFastButFurious · 20/01/2024 14:15

@EbonyWood I don't think that's probably uncommon. The more senior, the less competent in basic tasks IME because they have people to do stuff like that for them and spend most of their time talking in very important meetings. Our business manager asked me for help with a spreadsheet he was having trouble with and i thought it was going to something really difficult.....no, he'd seen other people with graphs with 2 lines on and wanted to know how he could do it too. A man who is responsible for a couple of hundred staff, 2 buildings, and a multi-million pound annual turnover......makes you wonder how they manage to analyse the data that leads to business decisions!

EbonyWood · 20/01/2024 14:09

one of the directors at my small company didn’t know how to filter a excel document.

Benchbythesea · 20/01/2024 14:08

Oh just remembered another one - working in a role that requires professional registration that the individual pays for, very standard. Frequently in the job when you have to sign declarations to confirm that you are professionally registered and therefore able to make that decision.

Colleague lost their registration because their payment bounced. More than once. Had been working for a considerable time without being registered, no one else knew (I believe there's since been a change where the body notify the employer when someone's reg lapses)

When it came out, colleague instead of being mortified and trying to rectify the situation as you might hope, instead just ranted indignantly about how the 'problem' was because of the CMS that he had to pay his ex.

When he eventually left (annoyed that he didn't succeed in getting promoted) we found out that there was loads of stuff that he'd just failed to do at all. Eg he'd be telling us things were in hand with a certain long term piece of work, chairing regular meetings etc, and when the new worker contacted the same professional group who told us they hadn't heard from him for six months or so.

BMW6 · 20/01/2024 14:00

Wetandhorrible · 20/01/2024 13:40

If you work at HMRC and need a calculator to find ten percent,then you're in the wrong job, let alone with one!!!

Of course I didn't use a calculator to work out 10%!!
She couldn't do it in her head and couldn't work her calculator to do it either.

So you FOTTFSOFAWYGTFOSM.🙄