Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
ThePure · 20/01/2024 16:19

I once had a months overlap with my incoming mat leave cover as a junior Dr. He was so incompetent that it was definitely a safety issue which I flagged to managers

He would disappear off for hours and be uncontactable which is obviously a safety issue. If challenged he would say his bleep must not be working as he had got no calls even when we had all been calling him. In actual fact he had switched it off. Accidentally he said.

He did precisely no work and let me do it all at 8 months pregnant. It soon transpired this was because he had no idea how to do anything at all. Not examining or interviewing patients, not prescribing or reviewing test results, nothing. He even fucked up writing some paracetamol on a drug chart. I did begin to wonder how he could have passed a medical degree.

Once he arrived back from an extended lunch break without the crash bleep which he was supposed to be carrying and being part of the resus team. We went back to look for it and I found it buried amongst the sandwiches in the canteen where it was merrily chirping away to itself (the crash team were definitely better off without him).

English was not his first language and he was comically bad. He asked me the word for something and was pointing in the vicinity of his knee. I started off with medical words like meniscus, cruciate ligament etc then went down to joint and knee cap and finally we established that 'leg' was the word he didn't know.

You will be relieved to know that they did fire him after about 2 weeks of this and got someone halfway decent.

RegardingMary · 20/01/2024 16:12

Ward work in the NHS.

30% of staff are new international nurses. Most are unable to read or write in English to an acceptable standard. Very little lnowlesge of infection control. No understand of consent, empathy or care at all.

Blatantly dangerous practice.

Complain and get told you're racist and unsupportive.

Chris002 · 20/01/2024 16:11

HermioneIsMyHomegirl · 20/01/2024 10:56

Had to train someone who had just finished a degree in the field but didn't know the first thing about it. After I went home mid afternoon (part time) one day, she apparently sat and cried because she didn't know how to open excel. Also didn't know how to switch on a computer. There have been many others (including one who shot up in the toilet!), but she was the one that caused me the most frustration!

Maybe the university hadn't given her any opportunity to do a work placement during her final year- or if they had may be she didn't take it up for some reason ?

KirstenBlest · 20/01/2024 16:09

@Cherrysoup Went for an interview involving typing speed once. The girl checking my work started to manually check for errors. I suggested she use spellcheck.

Spellcheckers don't find typos that are real words. They won't spot loose/lose, inn/in, pubic/public type errors.

AngryMoan · 20/01/2024 15:57

Me, as a waitress in uni. I was comically awful. My trial shift i flooded the kitchen, and it went downhill from there.

I worked at that restaurant all through uni, somehow. But having me as a waitress would ensure your tables would get Faulty Towers levels of service. People felt so bad for me that they tended to overtip, because they could see i was trying and genuinely sorry about all the mistakes. Once I'd worked there for 6 months customers were still regularly assuming i was a new starter because of my level of incompetence.

Redannie118 · 20/01/2024 15:57

Worked in civil service at a entry level clerical level years ago. Pretty much our only job was filing and pulling paper files kept in alphabetical order. Worked with a 40 something guy who didnt know the alphabet. As the senior staff member I had to follow him around and constantly correct his work( as in re file it).

In case you were wondering, English was his first language, no learning disabilities and extremely intelligent.Lovely, respectful chap to talk to, it was just infuriating.

None of the other clerical staff were allowed to say anything to him and this went on for years. Role was phased out with the advent of paperless offices and we all moved on.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/01/2024 15:56

If I'd asked somebody to type something as part of an interview process, I'd check it by reading it too. Spellcheck is not much good if you don't actually know how to spell. This is old but still relevant.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired
Depressedhusbandbringingmedown · 20/01/2024 15:53

Notellinganyone · 20/01/2024 14:55

@Depressedhusbandbringingmedown - I’ve been teaching for nearly 30 years and think learning objectives every lesson are daft.

I’m not sure I understand 🤔 if you’re a teacher, you’re teaching. What you are teaching is the objective, surely?

waterproofed · 20/01/2024 15:50

marthasmum · 20/01/2024 10:55

cherry i know about spellcheck but I wouldn’t use it. It Americanises things

You can set spellcheck for a specific language, for example British English, American English, Italian etc.

Alternat · 20/01/2024 15:46

If he is still in his probation period, don’t make the mistake of passing him through because he’s nice. It is much worse to have to put someone on a performance plan a year or so down the line when you like them more and they are more embedded but their errors make it impossible for you to keep them on.

You can extend a probation period and put concrete performance standards in place for them to meet by the end of the extended period. I cannot tell you how much I wish I had done this with a junior colleague I had to dismiss last year. Would have been better for both of us.

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 15:45

yforwankylol · 20/01/2024 15:41

Only if the language is set to US English…

I remember once using the editor function (the one that scores on readability) on a document - this was a type of document I regularly used and just tweaked and usually went straight to 99% - the score came out at 52% and I thought whaaat? Further investigation revealed it had, apparently randomly, reset the language part and was assessing the spelling and readability of my UK English document ... in Spanish.

yforwankylol · 20/01/2024 15:41

marthasmum · 20/01/2024 10:55

cherry i know about spellcheck but I wouldn’t use it. It Americanises things

Only if the language is set to US English…

Govangirl · 20/01/2024 15:39

When I was a sabbatical officer at uni, one of my fellow officers was completely incompetent and unfit for the role. He was an elected rep of a certain identity group (think disabled, mature etc) and during the election I remember so many people claiming he was fraudulently buying votes, cornering people, taking peoples voting devices off them to vote for himself, etc. Obviously I was also a candidate so I never confirmed, but he was definitely problematic. Post elections in our training, he either didn’t show up, or was very late and would just fall asleep, or would be on his phone. Lots of students that he represented complained and he was put on some kind of probation, but because he was elected it was different to a normal HR procedure I think. He made awful comments about his rep group, openly didn’t care about other identities, and would refuse to speak or even acknowledge women (be it staff or other officers). He was ‘removed’ from post after about 6 months, after he made a comment in a student space about not ”giving a shit” about black or Chinese students. He was genuinely a terrible person, and the most incompetent person I’ve met in my working or student life. He didn’t even know how to send an email.

Bridgertonned · 20/01/2024 15:36

@AbsoluteMoronsEverywhere I know you created it for the thread, but that's an excellent username!

Kwam31 · 20/01/2024 15:35

Hired a new courier, out on training days they were fine, first day alone got a call after 4 hours crying saying they'd only done 9 deliveries (should have done about 80) saying they couldn't understand odds and evens for street numbers ie one side is odd one is even!!! Yes, english speaking and in their 30s.

Bridgertonned · 20/01/2024 15:34

Colleague with substantial experience, in a professional role (ie had done a degree to get there) Young enough that it would all have been using computer systems rather than paper

He kept getting complaints that he never responded to people. Was adamant these were all malicious. Wasn't pulling his weight with joint work, claimed he wasn't aware when pulled about it.

Turned out that at some point he had accidentally changed his emails to filter by 'from' rather than 'date received'. Didn't question why there was a little number next to 'unread' that kept going up, or why he hadn't received an email in weeks when receiving 50-100 a day wasn't unusual. When shown how to change his emails back to display the hundreds of unread emails he complained that we used such a complicated system (it was Microsoft outlook) and asked for the rest of us to pick up some of his work because he had 'so many emails to get through'.

AbsoluteMoronsEverywhere · 20/01/2024 15:33

I've name changed 😂

Rocked in 20 mins late.
We went to the training room....
Trainee "I can't understand why we have to do this, I mean, it's obvious noone wants to do it"
Myself "you need to learn how to do your job"
Trainee "it's silly though really, isn't it. Most people don't want it"
Myself "I quite like being taught how to do things right"
Trainee "oh, weird"

Hmmmm.

PinkSkiesAtNight · 20/01/2024 15:33

We have a temporary TA, a lovely lady, but it's usually easier and quicker to do something yourself rather than ask, explain, check etc. Example: discussing a Science lesson for the following day, in which they would need melted chocolate, the teacher said, "Can you go and melt the chocolate while I do the lesson input?"
TA replied, "It's ok, I'll take the chocolate home and melt it the night before so it's ready...."

LightenUpTheRideIsShort · 20/01/2024 15:33

BMW6 · 20/01/2024 14:00

Of course I didn't use a calculator to work out 10%!!
She couldn't do it in her head and couldn't work her calculator to do it either.

So you FOTTFSOFAWYGTFOSM.🙄

@BMW6 I took @Wetandhorrible to be referring to your trainee you posted about.

AnnaBegins · 20/01/2024 15:26

Ooh yes when a lady was hired to cover my maternity leave, in a company with many legacy systems which didn't talk to each other but instead required multiple excel spreadsheets to be used as interfaces. So excel skills were really key and were tested at interview.
Day 1, I show her a spreadsheet and ask her to type a product name into a cell. What's a cell? How do I type? What do you mean click in the cell?
Turns out she was friends with one of the senior managers...

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 15:25

she had taken a gap year before gaining a Double First from Oxford

She must have been quite dedicated to the idea of teaching to choose a relatively low-paid profession when her qualifications could have opened so many more lucrative doors.

Toberlerone · 20/01/2024 15:21

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 11:37

The thing is, no one in their mid 40s or older would have grown up with a computer in the remotely modern sense of the word (might have had something like a Sinclair Spectrum if they grew up in the 80s) or had access to Excel at university.

Windows wasn't even installed on the office computers when I started work in the mid 90s. When I first saw Excel I didn't have a clue what it was for, it just looked like the computer equivalent of 'squared paper'. I have never received any formal training on Excel. I ended up buying 'Excel for Dummies' around Y2K to try to make sense of it, and taking the approach of asking people 'can you show me how to do that please'.

I'm still not great compared to many of the younger people - I often end up having to Google for step-by-step instructions on how to do things on Excel.

Sure. This person was on the graduate scheme in around 2009. So early 20s and openly admitted they had no interest in computers as they hadn't had one in the house growing up. Hadn't made full use of the computer suite at uni. Just didn't really engage with computers. They now do a job that doesn't particularly require more than basic working knowledge of computers (I did a reference for them and highlighted if computer skills were required then this may not be the best candidate. The person got the job and got in touch to say I was absolutely right with my reference and thank goodness their new job didn't really need it!)

twoshedsjackson · 20/01/2024 15:20

Not exactly a colleague, but very close to entering the teaching profession.
Our school regularly participated in the PCGE course run by a local college, so the students we had were graduates on a one-year course. By the time they came to us for their teaching practice, they were a few short months away from being in charge of their own (primary) class. Mostly, they fitted in quickly, with the support of their tutors, but this student seemed unable to take advice or instruction on board. I wasn't her supervising tutor, but I showed how I personally tackled planning and organising as she seemed so hapless, but......
Having left her with the class, I retreated to the staff room to do some marking, only to realise that I'd forgotten the marking key. Cursing myself quietly, I tried to slip back into the classroom discreetly, apologise for distracting if detected, retrieve the book and slip out again. I needn't have worried. She was so preoccupied with talking to one child that a punch-up had escaped her attention; just about understandable, except that the protagonists had climbed up on a table to get better space for fist-swinging, and had attracted an interested audience.
A few days later, I once again retreated, leaving her in charge, while I, at the headteacher's request, busied myself preparing for a school event with the stalwarts of the PTA. Basically just over an hour, end of morning break up to lunchtime. After half an hour, a message reached me, "Could you come back and take over? I've run out of things for them to do!" Once again, I tried to talk to her about planning, but it wasn't really my place to do so.
We were not that far apart in age; I'd gone straight to teacher training college from school, she had taken a gap year before gaining a Double First from Oxford, so I almost felt as if I were snitching, but it would not have been a kindness to her or any potential class to let her through.

justlonelystars · 20/01/2024 15:19

@cloudsdrifting write over the permanent market with non permanent. Wipe off, should take both off. Or just use acetone to clean it off.

CherryShirt · 20/01/2024 15:18

Name changing in case someone recognises the company.

I worked in a big company that changed the way they hired for two key roles in the company, including mine. Most of us came from creative backgrounds, but they started pushing more and more for people with backgrounds in analytics. Now I’m not saying those skills weren’t important for the job, but they went to the extreme with it.

They'd hired this woman who was all about the analytics; they had really high hopes for her. Unfortunately, she was SO obsessed by analytics that she couldn’t apply any common sense. We had regular promotional campaigns that would run for an initial two weeks, which would then be extended if they worked and the promo was still valid. I was trying to explain to her that, in some cases, they could be extended indefinitely, as there were always new customers who’d meet the criteria.

She just kept looking confused and asking “But where’s your window? Your window for analysis? How can you ever compare two campaigns if they all run for different lengths of time?” I pointed out that we could compare the initial two week period if we wanted to do that, but she kept saying “But how would you ever assess whether a campaign was really effective compared to another one, there would be too many variables, how can you get any clear results?…” I snapped in the end and asked her whether she thought it would be a better idea to stop successful campaigns just because they’d reached an arbitrary date for analysis purposes.

They began filling the other role almost exclusively with people who came through the MBA graduate recruitment scheme. They were obsessed with MBAs - you could pretty much walk into any job in that company if you had one. Someone who got the role of Vendor Manager through the programme, with minimal experience, was floundering in his first few days and one of his colleagues (who didn’t have an MBA, but did have years of experience, and who wasn’t too thrilled at candidates with no background getting plum jobs) asked him if he’d actually spent much time working with vendors before. His reply? “What’s a vendor?”