Name changing in case someone recognises the company.
I worked in a big company that changed the way they hired for two key roles in the company, including mine. Most of us came from creative backgrounds, but they started pushing more and more for people with backgrounds in analytics. Now I’m not saying those skills weren’t important for the job, but they went to the extreme with it.
They'd hired this woman who was all about the analytics; they had really high hopes for her. Unfortunately, she was SO obsessed by analytics that she couldn’t apply any common sense. We had regular promotional campaigns that would run for an initial two weeks, which would then be extended if they worked and the promo was still valid. I was trying to explain to her that, in some cases, they could be extended indefinitely, as there were always new customers who’d meet the criteria.
She just kept looking confused and asking “But where’s your window? Your window for analysis? How can you ever compare two campaigns if they all run for different lengths of time?” I pointed out that we could compare the initial two week period if we wanted to do that, but she kept saying “But how would you ever assess whether a campaign was really effective compared to another one, there would be too many variables, how can you get any clear results?…” I snapped in the end and asked her whether she thought it would be a better idea to stop successful campaigns just because they’d reached an arbitrary date for analysis purposes.
They began filling the other role almost exclusively with people who came through the MBA graduate recruitment scheme. They were obsessed with MBAs - you could pretty much walk into any job in that company if you had one. Someone who got the role of Vendor Manager through the programme, with minimal experience, was floundering in his first few days and one of his colleagues (who didn’t have an MBA, but did have years of experience, and who wasn’t too thrilled at candidates with no background getting plum jobs) asked him if he’d actually spent much time working with vendors before. His reply? “What’s a vendor?”