Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
MeadStMary · 20/01/2024 20:26

Sewannoying · 20/01/2024 20:09

See, I strongly disagree with “tell me about a time when…”. My job is so fast paced and varied I simply can’t remember specific examples. Once it’s done I forget about the details. But ask me how I would deal with something, and I can reel it off, because I’m good at my job.

Ugh I hate the "tell me about a time when..." approach. You can anticipate what the questions are likely to be and think up a few anecdotes in advance. But then you'll get a question that you didn't prepare for and have to try and scramble to quickly remember something that has happened that fits the question. Of course you're going to get people making up bullshit stories because they panic.

Asking how you would deal with a specific situation is much better imo. It encourages the candidate to use knowledge and experience to answer, and can often then lead to them remembering a similar situation organically, and talking about what they did. It just flows so much better and puts less pressure on an already nervous person.

Skigal86 · 20/01/2024 20:23

Lecturer who said wildly inappropriate things to students, marked assignments based on his personal feelings about the students, unpleasant to women (boss, wider team, students), and then engaged in some very bizarre behaviour when challenged about this. He also failed to do some pretty basic things involved in his job which left us with an absolute shit show. He lasted about 6 weeks.

Squiblet · 20/01/2024 20:22

Beadyeyes91 · 20/01/2024 19:05

I once worked in a call centre. A new member of staff asked "do we have to answer the phone every time it rings?"

To which you answered, "No, just put them on hold"

chickensadsikky · 20/01/2024 20:19

ThanksAntsThants23 · 20/01/2024 08:56

Probably me! I can work fine on my own but as soon as there are people around I get anxious and start making really stupid mistakes, like the example of someone not knowing how to work out 10% or do something basic on a computer, something like this I could do absolutely fine while I was alone but if I was with someone else and they asked me to do it I would just panic and not be able to do it.. I’m self employed now 😂

Also me!!! I turn into such a clumsy dick under pressure 😂

Str8talkin · 20/01/2024 20:16

This reply has been deleted

This was started by a persistent troll.

Sewannoying · 20/01/2024 20:09

prh47bridge · 20/01/2024 19:33

Get the candidate talking early. That helps them to relax.

Best way to see if someone can do the job is to get them to do it. Obviously, you can't do that completely in an interview situation, but giving them a practical test, getting them to do the kind of thing they would be doing in the job, is useful - much more so than a theoretical test. You want people who can apply their knowledge/skills.

Know what attributes you want from the candidate and question them about times in the past when they have demonstrated those attributes - "tell me about a time when...". Drill into their answer, don't just take it at face value. That is far more useful than hypothetical questions - "what would you do in this situation". Those who try to bullshit their way through interviews often struggle with this. If they try to invent examples, their story often falls apart when you try to drill into it.

Check their qualifications. Some candidates will claim to have qualifications they don't.

I like to get someone they will be working with who isn't part of the interview panel to take them out to lunch if possible. That gets the candidate in a situation where they may be more relaxed, so gets another perspective on them.

Remember that, no matter how careful you are, you will recruit the occasional dud. Make sure that you set up probation to find the duds and weed them out quickly. If staff tell you that the person you're recruited is not up to the job, listen.

See, I strongly disagree with “tell me about a time when…”. My job is so fast paced and varied I simply can’t remember specific examples. Once it’s done I forget about the details. But ask me how I would deal with something, and I can reel it off, because I’m good at my job.

Str8talkin · 20/01/2024 20:04

This reply has been deleted

This was started by a persistent troll.

KirstenBlest · 20/01/2024 20:01

I often see job descriptions where the required skillset is really two skill sets, and unlikely to be something one person will have.

Papyrophile · 20/01/2024 20:01

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 18:20

I doubt your desktop in 1982 was running Microsoft Office.

Another one here of even greater age (nealy 68). My first computer (in NYC in 1984) was basic, but we writers were still supposed to use secretaries, who were in the scheme of things, not all quick on the uptake. We swiftly learned how to use GML tags to personalise company notepaper and many more complicated tasks. I have used a PC for so many years through Lotus Notes and WordPerfect before Word and my first email address (about 1992) was all numeric apart from the @ and compuserve. And track changes has been in use since the early 2000s.

MS Office is a doddle compared to its forebears.

TortolaParadise · 20/01/2024 19:59

Jovacknockowitch · 20/01/2024 19:56

Excellent point - so many jobs I see advertised in my niche area of IT are actually the work of 3 people......

Absolutely, speaking from someone who is currently doing the work of three people - it is madness.

Jovacknockowitch · 20/01/2024 19:56

TortolaParadise · 20/01/2024 19:19

Sometimes it is not necessarily that people are incompetent; sometimes people over overworked and corners get cut. Some roles are simply unrealistic.

Excellent point - so many jobs I see advertised in my niche area of IT are actually the work of 3 people......

coldcallerbaiter · 20/01/2024 19:33

I think we all must remember that we were all the new kid in the past.
If someone is new to the job or just new to working, I know that doing is learning, no amount of theory equals just letting them do the job until the pennies drop and it is second nature.

That said, really stupid stuff gets on my nerves. Had a trainee recently break all his words with hyphens when he reached the end of a line, to keep the lines straight. I told him to use the full word, stop the hyphens. Kept doing it, letters to clients looking embarrassing. Wrote dumb things too like un-mitigating circumstances instead of mitigating. He had to go, I felt so bad…..

prh47bridge · 20/01/2024 19:33

SilverGlitterBaubles · 20/01/2024 18:33

It is just so hard to determine the true nature of a person from a 2 stage interview process. Interested to hear from those with lots of hiring experience as to how they weed out the potential wasters that might come actually say all the right things in interviews and look ok on paper.

Get the candidate talking early. That helps them to relax.

Best way to see if someone can do the job is to get them to do it. Obviously, you can't do that completely in an interview situation, but giving them a practical test, getting them to do the kind of thing they would be doing in the job, is useful - much more so than a theoretical test. You want people who can apply their knowledge/skills.

Know what attributes you want from the candidate and question them about times in the past when they have demonstrated those attributes - "tell me about a time when...". Drill into their answer, don't just take it at face value. That is far more useful than hypothetical questions - "what would you do in this situation". Those who try to bullshit their way through interviews often struggle with this. If they try to invent examples, their story often falls apart when you try to drill into it.

Check their qualifications. Some candidates will claim to have qualifications they don't.

I like to get someone they will be working with who isn't part of the interview panel to take them out to lunch if possible. That gets the candidate in a situation where they may be more relaxed, so gets another perspective on them.

Remember that, no matter how careful you are, you will recruit the occasional dud. Make sure that you set up probation to find the duds and weed them out quickly. If staff tell you that the person you're recruited is not up to the job, listen.

listsandbudgets · 20/01/2024 19:26

the office junior who didn't know her alphabet and couldn't *?wouldn't ) make tea.. not great for someone whose main jobs were filing and making tea!! she also refused to answer the phone because it was "frightening"

I was ever quite clear how she ended up with the job but she didn't pass her probation

KirstenBlest · 20/01/2024 19:23

@G5000, I find Track Changes almost impossible to read.

G5000 · 20/01/2024 19:21

If someone printed out a document nowadays and scribbled their notes on it, instead of doing track changes in shared document like all the rest of the people working on it, I'd probably post about them on this thread. It really isn't that hard and no it really isn't easier for people who then need to read and implement the scribbles.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 20/01/2024 19:20

Mumoftwo1312 · 20/01/2024 11:39

It's just not taught in schools as standard any more. I've added it to my scheme of work for year 13 - I don't teach IT but I've found a particular single lesson where I can work in most excel features. 17/18yo, selective school, and they don't even know how to click and drag to copy cells.

Yes, it's really concerning. I spend a bit of time each year teaching my science students how to use basic formulas like sum and average and get Excel to generate a graph.

I don't understand why we're teaching teenagers to code when they can't use basic microsoft programs. Obviously coding is useful but I think more people use Excel in their jobs?

Every job I've ever had, including temp jobs at uni, I've used Excel in some way/shape/form!

TortolaParadise · 20/01/2024 19:19

Sometimes it is not necessarily that people are incompetent; sometimes people over overworked and corners get cut. Some roles are simply unrealistic.

LadyEloise1 · 20/01/2024 19:19

Catinknickers · 20/01/2024 10:14

Wow I just googled the bloke I referred to above. He now holds a senior role in the Cabinet Office and has blatantly lied about his previous roles! FFS why don’t they check. He is useless!

😮😮😮😡

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/01/2024 19:13

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 18:56

Thank you - I'm not sure why people are taking issue with my basic point that in general, people born in the 1970s didn't grow up using computers as we know them today, and particularly not using Microsoft Office.

I don't take issue with that, but I was born in the early 1960s and had colleagues a lot older than that who all learned to use Office and other computer systems when our jobs and personal interests required it. A willingness to learn and a bit of initiative go a long way when it comes to IT in the workplace.

We once interviewed an older woman who had worked in the NHS for decades, never rising above the lowest admin grade. She seemed to have been moved from one department to another at regular intervals, which was a bit concerning, but could have been just bad luck. We could see from her CV that she had minimal educational qualifications but that wouldn't have mattered if she'd given any sign of being bright and capable, and having good basic literacy and numeracy. She didn't. My line manager asked her how she felt about learning how to use new software. She sighed, pulled a face and said sadly 'Well, you don't like it, do you, but you gotta do it these days'. Hmm Same woman, asked how she would keep track of her workload, given that she would have several jobs on hand at any one time, looked nonplussed. 'Well ... I mean ... I just look at my desk and I can see what I've got to do.' She didn't get the job.

KirstenBlest · 20/01/2024 19:12

@Crinkle77 , she was probably checking. Abbreviations can mean several things.

@TheLogicalSong , grew up in the1970s and used WordPerfect and Lotus 123 in the late1980s. I can remember this new thing called Windows.

Namechangeforname · 20/01/2024 19:10

Nurse who point blank refused to do mouth-to-mouth on a mannequin in basic life support training.
Ended up in an awkward stand-off with the instructor refusing to sign her off unless she did it. It was really embarrassing.

ETA this was many years pre-covid

Crinkle77 · 20/01/2024 19:06

LightenUpTheRideIsShort · 20/01/2024 17:32

@Tribblesarelovely unless of an age, or a nurse prescriber (she wouldn’t be), many wouldn’t know tbh, especially if newly qualified. That’s not incompetence.

You're joking aren't you. Surely HRT is a commonly known acronym. I'd be concerned if a nurse hadn't heard of that.

Beadyeyes91 · 20/01/2024 19:05

I once worked in a call centre. A new member of staff asked "do we have to answer the phone every time it rings?"

Galatine · 20/01/2024 19:04

I had a colleague who was a phenomenal bullshitter. To hear him you would have thought that he was the only one doing any work. In fact he did almost nothing. He had been moved around three departments after being rumbled by each one in turn. The odd thing was that he was quite competent, just very lazy.

I had a cheap pocket calculator, bought from TESCO for about £1. it went wrong so I put it in our electrical scrap box for disposal. One afternoon he spent three hours getting it to work. He was so proud of himself and very miffed when our manager enquired whether he thought the time spent was an appropriate use of his energy!