Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
HillyHoney · 20/01/2024 23:28

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 20/01/2024 23:22

I have to stand up for Track Changes. My editor can comment on and make changes to my manuscript - I can see what she's done, approve the changes and comment back again. It just simply wouldn't work to print out an entire 80,000 word novel manuscript and post it to one another!

(But they can still be bloody annoying)

I will die on the hill of Track Changes....I'm actually surprised how few people use it, based on this thread - it's one of my most-used Word features, definitely.

On another note, @SerafinasGoose, I am 100% with you...I know there's clearly incompetency outside the HE and FE sectors but good grief there's some gormless people within it, and they never seem to get their comeuppance!

2024GarlicCloves · 20/01/2024 23:27

LightenUpTheRideIsShort · 20/01/2024 23:11

The posters keen to say they expertly used computers in the 70’s & 80’s are ruining this thread tbh.

Yes. Afaict, a poster said that her MS Office skills were limited due to lack of early exposure, but extrapolated that to all people of her age. It's been done to death now.

Judging by the number of times I (age 68, btw) am asked to volunteer for computer skills outreach projects, she isn't wrong to generalise but of course there are exceptions, whether literally or in principle. I didn't grow up with computers, but was an early adopter. It isn't worth nitpicking over.

I'm far more shocked that 21st-century school kids aren't being taught to use it! Why the hell not?

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 20/01/2024 23:22

I have to stand up for Track Changes. My editor can comment on and make changes to my manuscript - I can see what she's done, approve the changes and comment back again. It just simply wouldn't work to print out an entire 80,000 word novel manuscript and post it to one another!

(But they can still be bloody annoying)

LightenUpTheRideIsShort · 20/01/2024 23:11

The posters keen to say they expertly used computers in the 70’s & 80’s are ruining this thread tbh.

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 23:08

pikkumyy77 · 20/01/2024 21:13

This was really my point. The original comment seemed to imply that adults over 40 could not be expected to know how to ise computers. I was simply pointing out that at 63 though I started university and grad school pre computer (desktop that is) I have been using them professionally now since I was 22. All the programs in use at this point are all much easier and more user friendly when I started. Anyone, even old coots like me, should be expected to be able to master this crap.

The original comment seemed to imply that adults over 40 could not be expected to know how to ise computers.

Sorry, but that is a ridiculous interpretation of my comment that people older than their mid-40s wouldn't have grown up with modern-style (i.e. Windows) computers.

nonumbersinthisname · 20/01/2024 23:02

Fortunate that the worst colleagues I’ve worked with were merely mildly incompetent but did satisfactory/useful work when sidelined into less critical roles that were within their limited capabilities.

Although having said that I’ve got a new client who wants me to work alongside an independent consultant they’ve been employing for a while and to say I’m less than impressed would be an understatement. This work is going to be tricky to navigate (“your consultant is shit, ignore them and listen to us instead” won’t go down well with the client for a variety of reasons) but luckily my boss is of the same opinion so we can tag team the politics. I’m better at the work than managing tricky clients, I’m far too blunt. Grin

OutingPosts · 20/01/2024 22:43

Worked for a family owned engineering company making very niche products. The owners decided to employ their unqualified children as directors. Their 25 year old daughter had been working behind a bar and they made her head of sales.

In our very first meeting she announced she was going to reduce the size of all products because it would save money on materials, oblivious to the fact that our customers had already designed the products these components would go into.

She then announced that she was the only person who was allowed to speak to customers.....some of the designers had been there twenty years and had excellent working relationships with them. She actually refused to take a call from one person because they had a funny name 😳

All but one of our team of seven left within a couple of months.

Winterday1991 · 20/01/2024 22:23

CryptoFascist · 20/01/2024 10:03

Agreed @icelolly12 , our interview process gets longer and longer as we try to weed out the malingerers, the agitators, bullshitters, and those who will accept the job but then think they can amend the hours, days of work and salary during the recruitment process.

Is this not just part of a normal negotiation process though before formally accepting a job role and signing contracts?

Toberlerone · 20/01/2024 21:54

WavingCatsandDogs · 20/01/2024 15:04

Long time ago, I'm sure systems set up to stop this getting through but two men I managed in my team, I caught both of them looking at porn!

That reminds me of *another" incompetent person I worked with.

Got in early to 'beat the traffic' but was never at their desk when I got in early. Found out after a while from office gossip they had been in a bank of computers used by a set of contractors in another part of the building, but the computers were never needed till much later in the day. I think they must have accidentally left one logged in on porn and one of the contractors found it (this is before home internet/broadband.) But the incompetent person kept their job.

They were also incapable of making decaffeinated tea with clearly marked decaffeinated teabags. And so the poor colleague who asked for decaffeinated got the shakes when incompetent person made a round.

Incompetent person also screwed up a database on a project of mine and I'm embarrassed to say I shouted at them and made them cry. I've never done it again but I had got to the end of my tether with them screwing up my data. I learnt to write my own databases after that just to cut them out of the picture and save my blood pressure. They tried to add me on LinkedIn a while ago. Absolutely no way I want to be linked to that incompetence!!

HurryUpHilda · 20/01/2024 21:46

I interviewed a young lady for a fairly basic admin job, school exam office; email, word, excel, telephone. Willingness to get hands dirty, to make it work, to get the job done, reasonable pay, nothing too onerous, shortlisted in five from over twenty five applicants.

She was private school, GCSEs 6-7-8, A Level B-C-D, a 2-1 degree in Business Studies from a reasonable University (not Russell but certainly in the second tier).

I set up a fairly basic practical exercise to use Excel to draw up a hypothetical seating plan. First task was to arrange the candidates in alphabetical order, she faffed about for five minutes, then cried, she said her Excel skills needed more work and walked out.

Narrow escape, the person I hired was great. 2-1 in Business Studies and couldn't use Excel?

ComingUpTrumps · 20/01/2024 21:45

Patrickiscrazy · 20/01/2024 11:28

To be honest with you, apart from crying in front of others, I can completely relate. I also have an university degree. Worked for about two years in my life and then stopped. Sorted myself out through a lucrative marriage, child free and that's it. Now at almost fifty, I don't need anything from life anymore and ... I'm happy with it! 😃 Different people, I guess!

A ‘lucrative marriage’ @Patrickiscrazy … how very shrewd of you.

Livingtothefull · 20/01/2024 21:35

Moonwatcher1234 · 20/01/2024 21:07

wow, cold. People don’t choose when to go through a life crisis you know.

I know many people who have gone through truly gruelling personal situations and have held it together at work as best they can. I have a lot of sympathy for anyone going through tough times, I have been through some myself. And I think employers should be as supportive as they can, I don't want to work for any who are not. I agree you can't choose when these crises happen; but as I said, if you are going through a personal crisis it is probably not the time to take on a new and demanding job.

I didn't cover all details of the situation in my post. We tried to talk to and work with this employee, suggested having some time out to recover and offered to arrange a new start date after a few months with the next batch of trainees. She wouldn't listen, wouldn't work with us to try to resolve it.....just kept trying to come into work although she was obviously incapable.

Trying to manage induction training in these circumstances (with the other people involved in this and pulled from their other duties) was a nightmare. There were also other people at that workplace including some who we knew were going through difficulties themselves, we had to think about the impact on others of having these repeated situations at work. It was just not sustainable.

Sorry you think it is cold however as a business you do what you reasonably can to support people at work and you can't do more.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/01/2024 21:30

Universities had email long before most other organisations. My husband first used it when working in an IT job at a university in 1985. I was working in accountancy at the time and we didn't have it. I went on maternity leave in 1992 and we still didn't have computers on desks or email or anything like the internet. Audit papers were written longhand. Letters, memos, tax calculations and so on were written out by hand or dictated onto a dictaphone, and given to a word processor operator to type up. Endless process of checking drafts, marking up corrections, waiting for it to be re-typed, checking again. Could take days to finalise a simple letter or memo.

Jovacknockowitch · 20/01/2024 21:16

Papyrophile · 20/01/2024 20:01

Another one here of even greater age (nealy 68). My first computer (in NYC in 1984) was basic, but we writers were still supposed to use secretaries, who were in the scheme of things, not all quick on the uptake. We swiftly learned how to use GML tags to personalise company notepaper and many more complicated tasks. I have used a PC for so many years through Lotus Notes and WordPerfect before Word and my first email address (about 1992) was all numeric apart from the @ and compuserve. And track changes has been in use since the early 2000s.

MS Office is a doddle compared to its forebears.

In one of my first IT jobs in the late 80s we used "green screen" apps in a suite called Uniplex - it had a Word Processing app and a Spreadsheet (which we used). We could share and send docs and sheets to each other, and we had a form of e-mail - although that only worked in-company, it was possible to message people at any branch. We even had an instant messaging facility (like an early slack/teams).

pikkumyy77 · 20/01/2024 21:13

Papyrophile · 20/01/2024 20:01

Another one here of even greater age (nealy 68). My first computer (in NYC in 1984) was basic, but we writers were still supposed to use secretaries, who were in the scheme of things, not all quick on the uptake. We swiftly learned how to use GML tags to personalise company notepaper and many more complicated tasks. I have used a PC for so many years through Lotus Notes and WordPerfect before Word and my first email address (about 1992) was all numeric apart from the @ and compuserve. And track changes has been in use since the early 2000s.

MS Office is a doddle compared to its forebears.

This was really my point. The original comment seemed to imply that adults over 40 could not be expected to know how to ise computers. I was simply pointing out that at 63 though I started university and grad school pre computer (desktop that is) I have been using them professionally now since I was 22. All the programs in use at this point are all much easier and more user friendly when I started. Anyone, even old coots like me, should be expected to be able to master this crap.

Livingtothefull · 20/01/2024 21:12

Sewannoying · 20/01/2024 20:09

See, I strongly disagree with “tell me about a time when…”. My job is so fast paced and varied I simply can’t remember specific examples. Once it’s done I forget about the details. But ask me how I would deal with something, and I can reel it off, because I’m good at my job.

I agree, when recruiting I prefer the 'What would you do if...?' questions. You can raise situations that have actually occurred and see if their approach to resolving this situation complies with best practice. I agree that when you have dealt with countless situations it can be hard to recall a specific one. Paradoxically it can be easier for less experienced candidates to answer specific instances as they have fewer to recall. But if you are asked how to deal with a situation effectively then it is easy for a skilled person to answer.

Moonwatcher1234 · 20/01/2024 21:07

Livingtothefull · 20/01/2024 12:41

A woman was hired at a place I used to work and had her first breakdown on her 2nd day. She was obviously going through some personal crisis at the time.

Distraught, sobbing loudly, crying that she couldn't cope with her life or work....it could be heard across the office down the corridor from the room she was in.

During her first 4 weeks or so she was away far more often than she was in. She had 2 more breakdowns just like the first one, involving several managers, HR staff, first aiders, a paid taxi ride home and more sick days. Next to no work done by her. All the other staff were transfixed.

She had to be let go. I have every sympathy with someone going through a crisis but really it isn't the time to take on a challenging new job. Quite different from a long standing employee with a track record who needs & deserves support during a difficult time.

wow, cold. People don’t choose when to go through a life crisis you know.

Galatine · 20/01/2024 21:01

MalingeringMary · 20/01/2024 18:22

The Mac wasn't launched until 1984....

The AppleMac was introduced in 1984. The Apple II predates it (1977).

Gingernaut · 20/01/2024 20:59

@SmilingMoon

The worker may be working but not be at home

They may not be in an 'information secure' area and still be sending confidential emails

They may not have security features enabled, giving anyone access to the email account

People are allowed to work from home only after an assessment and breaching those conditions could be an act of misconduct

Realdeal1 · 20/01/2024 20:49

@ChampagneLassie I can't figure out how you think you're proud of being that person!

Sausagedognamedmash · 20/01/2024 20:49

When I was a bar supervisor back in the mists of time, had a new girl start, apparently had experience behind a bar and was good to go on her first shift with me after being shown the till system etc. 10 minutes into the shift she'd wasted a ton of beer unable to pour properly, then asked me what was in a vodka cranberry, she lasted a week.

Sandunesandseashells · 20/01/2024 20:49

Papyrophile · 20/01/2024 20:01

Another one here of even greater age (nealy 68). My first computer (in NYC in 1984) was basic, but we writers were still supposed to use secretaries, who were in the scheme of things, not all quick on the uptake. We swiftly learned how to use GML tags to personalise company notepaper and many more complicated tasks. I have used a PC for so many years through Lotus Notes and WordPerfect before Word and my first email address (about 1992) was all numeric apart from the @ and compuserve. And track changes has been in use since the early 2000s.

MS Office is a doddle compared to its forebears.

MS Office is now huge by comparison and of course easier to navigate than originally starting from DOS (appox.1989? I’m 63). Our first PC was on loan from Wiltshire County Council because my ex needed it to work from home. We’d never had a lesson but we found the drop down menus and function keys so logical and easy to understand we worked it out quickly. I bought the ex a Star Trek game for Xmas but it never finished loading to be able to play!

In 1994 our first PC was built for us when we started a business and it had 200mb memory which we were told was top spec and we would never need more. 😂

I bloody loved WordPerfect in the 90’s! We ran it alongside Word for as long as possible because things like printing labels and envelopes were sooooo much easier.

Apologies for the derail, this thread is sending me down memory lane 😍

Keepingitmoving · 20/01/2024 20:41

A temp senior lawyer (hired from an agency at eye watering daily rates) who could not grasp how to open a client file despite 4 different people walking her through it! Her work followed a similar pattern 😳

ChampagneLassie · 20/01/2024 20:39

I was once the incompetent one. Hired as a secretary when I was 18 in a very traditional office…beating two older ladies with experience because the boss wanted some eye candy. I’m dyslexic and didn’t have a clue about basics of the job. I tried my best, but it really was round peg, square hole. A number of staff were very bemused by me. Boss allowed me to set my own hours and I didn’t do much work as long as I brought him tea and wore skirts and perched on his desk to tell him what I was up to. I did realise after not long, but I really needed the money so stayed for almost 2 years!

merryhouse · 20/01/2024 20:29

Sewannoying · 20/01/2024 20:09

See, I strongly disagree with “tell me about a time when…”. My job is so fast paced and varied I simply can’t remember specific examples. Once it’s done I forget about the details. But ask me how I would deal with something, and I can reel it off, because I’m good at my job.

I hate that question because I literally can't answer it. I have on three separate occasions stared at the interviewer and thought "no, I've never done that". (The first time I actually said so. The other two times I bullshitted. I didn't get any of those jobs.)

Every job I've ever had I've been really good at. But I can't answer Behavioural questions. (My current job I only got because they pitched it as an apprenticeship so only asked about Strengths Grin)

Unfortunately the trend is away from asking your managers how good you are (because that's not fair on the people with shitty managers) so my main aim over the course of this apprenticeship is to gather some Examples for the next set of interviews...