Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
PurpleBrain · 21/01/2024 13:20

@StockpotSoup

Most employers don't really care about references unless they are for jobs where you have to be highly vetted such as working with vulnerable people.

Employers can get rid of you easily within two years anyway . Plus they only need to ask an ex employer one question: Would you re - employ , yes or no ? There is only going to be the choice of two answers .

SilverGlitterBaubles · 21/01/2024 13:10

An effective selection process can identify incompetent candidates but it can't unfortunately weed out candidates with a bad attitude; they are effectively incompetent as they have no intention of doing the work they are being paid for.

Agreed, in most instances I find candidates show their true self within the first 2-3 weeks of starting. The CV description of the dynamic, passionate, enthusiastic, hardworking person with excellent organisational skills blah blah blah bares zero resemblance to the reality. The issue is when employers will persist with training when the fundamentals such as attitude, work ethic and self discipline are just non existent.

Seadreamers · 21/01/2024 13:07

Two colleagues in my team simply couldn’t keep up with the workload, weren’t proactive, couldn't use the computer systems without constant help, couldn’t think outside the box (which the job required), and for some odd reason each had one of the biggest retailer accounts to look after.

They were lovely people, but just simply couldn’t manage the role and so the rest of us were constantly given their work to do. This was all widely known in the company. At the company Christmas party they announce employee of the year and runners up, but managers cannot have any input into nominations for anyone in their team. So, the sales team thought these two were great despite knowing that everyone else was also heavily working on these retailer accounts too.

These two got employee of the year and runner up due to Sales voting them, and the rest of our team was beside themselves. The morale and atmosphere just plummeted. Later in January our Manager called us all in one by one and said that “certain people were given awards that they should not have been,” and as a consequence we would all receive an additional % bonus at year end April, and to acknowledge and thank us for all our hard work supporting these colleagues.

ilovepixie · 21/01/2024 13:00

Havanananana · 20/01/2024 14:31

@TheLogicalSong "The thing is, no one in their mid 40s or older would have grown up with a computer in the remotely modern sense of the word (might have had something like a Sinclair Spectrum if they grew up in the 80s) or had access to Excel at university."

Really? Computers might not have been in every home, but they were certainly common (and vital) in many industries by the 1990s

I did a computer programming course at university - in 1975. I'd even done some at school before that. From this alone you can work out that I'm well over 60.

I worked in offices that had computers from the mid-1980s and in the newspaper industry that had computerised typesetting, admin and accounting in the 1980's.

From the mid-1990s computers were a part of daily office life everywhere I worked. Amazon on-line shopping was founded in 1994. People who were even just in their 20s in 1994 would be over 50 today.

I'm 55 I didn't see a computer till 1984 and even then it was a fleeting glance. We then got a Sinclair spectrum but just played games on it. Computers weren't part of my education, until I did an ECDL, in the early 2000's when I bought a home computer.

Globetrote · 21/01/2024 12:57

Quite a few over the years..

The standout one was a woman who was absolutely useless - constant mistakes, no work ethic, lazy, no concept of timekeeping and deliberately snuck off early all the time, came in hungover regularly, dressed like she was at the gym (corporate dress policy), you name it she was it. She got promoted which shocked everyone, then a few weeks later she resigned which our manager was gobsmacked at as she was managers pet. The day before her replacement was due to start no one had cleared her desk or personal items (of which she left behind a huge amount), so I volunteered to do it as I felt sorry for the state the desk was in for the new starter.

Well, amongst the bikinis, make up, loan statements, SanPro, condoms, medications etc was her latest annual performance review, all signed and dated a few weeks before she was promoted. It was dire - she got a score of 4 out of a range of 1 to 5 (5 being you’re basically sacked), and the comments and feedback from senior staff and customers were just appalling. It was an utterly shameful review and the colleagues comments were basically “he e hee I must try harder.” How the actual f!@k both our manager and HR could justify the promotion was beyond me. I lost all respect for the company.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/01/2024 12:51

I've just remembered the man I worked with once, only briefly thank goodness, who on being handed some letters that had just arrived dropped them straight into the bin. I don't know whether he was doing this for effect or genuinely. He thought he was very funny. He had a very high opinion of himself, in fact. The rest of us thought he was a pain in the neck and a waste of space. Anyway, when asked what on earth he was doing he said if anything was really important they'd send it again. Hmm

Every morning he'd arrive at about 9.15. The rest of us would be there by 9am. Every morning his wife would ring on the dot of 9am and a colleague would explain he hadn't arrived yet. She'd ring again once he was there and he would often be required to talk to his daughter and tell her off for not using her potty, or similar. It was grim.

He was a qualified chartered accountant working for one of the top firms in the world. I often wonder what happened to him.

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 12:44

StockpotSoup · 21/01/2024 12:35

I’m always shocked at how many MNers don’t get this. If there’s ever a thread where someone has said something like “My boss has been treating me like shit for years; AIBU to coast through my notice period?”, there will be horrified cries of “But what about your reference?”, with no concept that most just say “I can confirm person X worked in role Y between [insert dates]”.

This is true, I can't recall a single time when anything negative has been stated on a reference regardless of the circumstances of the person leaving.

However it is worth mentioning that although ex-employer references can't be defamatory they can be factual. So if the employee is eg dismissed for gross misconduct, or resigns during a formal disciplinary process, they can actually state that in the reference if they choose. In practice most employers probably won't go there, unless there is a particular reason eg if there are safeguarding concerns which a future employer would need to know about.

StockpotSoup · 21/01/2024 12:42

NotMyFirstChoiceofName · 21/01/2024 09:01

Lots of companies now do short screening interviews by zoom / teams to check for some of these things that applicants frequently lie about. It’s such a waste of company time and money to call them in for full scale interview and then find out on the day that 75% are completely unsuitable.

Another thing that I’ve found they often lie about is their ability to travel (an essential part of our job). We put on our person spec that the job involves being based in an office in X city ( where they will need to come into the office at least 2 days a week) and to travel in the Uk and overseas up to Y weeks a year.

We get people at screening interviews who say that yes that are totally flexible, they can travel anywhere in eg London ( the job is based in Preston) as long as they are home in London every night. When one candidate told us this, we looked bemused and ask her if she had read the job spec. She then said “ Yes but look !! “ and held up her left hand to show us her engagement ring with a Ta Da !

This was in the last few years, not in 1940. For a job that requires a post graduate degree and a min of 5 years work experience. 😲

There was a thread on here years ago about a role that specifically required every team member to work one Saturday in four. This had been made very clear at the start (OP was the hiring manager), but the candidate had airily stated in the interview that she couldn’t possibly do that, as she had children. When told it was a condition of the job, she stormed out crying “I can’t believe you don’t have any flexibility on this for a MOTHER!!”

I suppose at least she didn’t lie and then pull that shit when she got the job…

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 12:36

fetchacloth · 21/01/2024 12:25

Many finance jobs are advertised like this too. Some extra skills are part of the advertised job such as HR management and Health & Safety both of which are completely unrelated to finance.
Recently I saw a job advert which was advertised under the banner of Finance Manager requiring all three of these skill sets and in addition to EDI management, all for the princely sum of 33k per year.
I can't take job ads like that seriously. 😫

I hate that kind of set up and any jobseekers should run a mile from those kinds of ads because the job is bound to be a nightmare and the organisation unprofessional.

Each of those areas require highly specific expertise and professional qualifications, there is just no way that one person can combine them all. It is like eg expecting a doctor to simultaneously be a gifted lawyer.

StockpotSoup · 21/01/2024 12:35

CameltoeParkerBowles · 21/01/2024 09:32

You would be amazed at the number of employers (including LAs), who are terrified of putting anything remotely negative into a reference for fear of a legal challenge, I suppose. In one of my old jobs, we had a team member who never worked on a Friday, because her boss had Fridays off as part of his contract. She would say she was working from home on Fridays, and then just not bother even logging on. She was a work-dodger even on the days when she turned up. They somehow got her to leave, and her boss wrote a fairly accurate reference, which he was forced to change, fundamentally, by the head of HR, on the grounds that she may sue for discrimination.

I’m always shocked at how many MNers don’t get this. If there’s ever a thread where someone has said something like “My boss has been treating me like shit for years; AIBU to coast through my notice period?”, there will be horrified cries of “But what about your reference?”, with no concept that most just say “I can confirm person X worked in role Y between [insert dates]”.

fetchacloth · 21/01/2024 12:25

Jovacknockowitch · 20/01/2024 19:56

Excellent point - so many jobs I see advertised in my niche area of IT are actually the work of 3 people......

Many finance jobs are advertised like this too. Some extra skills are part of the advertised job such as HR management and Health & Safety both of which are completely unrelated to finance.
Recently I saw a job advert which was advertised under the banner of Finance Manager requiring all three of these skill sets and in addition to EDI management, all for the princely sum of 33k per year.
I can't take job ads like that seriously. 😫

EvilElsa · 21/01/2024 12:21

I've had a few twats as bosses, but my boss when I was 20-21 was the most irritating because he was useless but also super arrogant and egotistical.
Everyone hated him. The site staff, the admin, other management. He did the minimum he possibly could handing loads off to me which he then took credit for. I remember once I was on the phone to a client and he was having a loud panic in the background because he didn't know the answer to something (which he would have if he actually did anything) and he interrupted my call. I asked him to wait a minute so I could finish my call and he EXPLODED. He did later apologise but the arrogance was outrageous -even then he blamed me for his anger.
Once he called a group of contractors "illiterate neanderthals" which got back to them. They were nothing of the sort and ran a hugely successful business and were a fantastic group of guys who we all loved working with. The contractor boss was furious and phoned my boss saying he was coming in now to have a word. Boss absolutely shit himself and left immediately, leaving me on my own, to deal with the situation. I remember him saying 'calm him down' and legging it to his car!
He eventually retired thankfully and none of us were sad to see him go. I can't recall one useful thing he did. I was, at 21, quoting major engineering jobs while he sat on his arse talking about his many holidays and how he was much better at doing everything than any of us. If you had done it he had done it better. I assume he got away with it because he had been there forever and wasn't long off retirement but god he was an utter cunt.

Doyoumind · 21/01/2024 12:05

IlsSortLaPlupartAuNuitMostly · 21/01/2024 11:38

It's difficult to assess your own abilities somehow. We recently hired a graduate who thought he was good at Excel, and by some people's standards, yes he probably was, in that he could set up basic formulae. After sitting next to me for a morning as I assembled a model at speed using a fair range of functions and all the keyboard shortcuts he said "ah, I realise that there exists a spectrum of "good at Excel" which somewhat exceeds my previous frame of reference." I said "just you wait until you spend a morning with my colleague who is properly good at Excel. Your head will explode"

There's a great quote "mediocrity knows nothing better than itself, but talent instantly recognises genius". I find it widely applicable in the workspace although it was probably not originally written about MS Office use though.

Despite all of this, I'm shit at Word, mostly through lack of practice. I know that I should use track changes, and am familiar with the basic concepts but it never comes naturally.

"Mediocrity knows nothing better than itself" is the perfect definition of my workplace. I've worked with some truly inspirational, talented, innovative and effective people during my career but don't really see it where I'm working now and I miss it.

Doyoumind · 21/01/2024 11:59

Years ago there was a man who did the rounds in my sector, moving from one place to another very quickly and often managing a promotion as he moved. He seemed to pop up everywhere. He was very much a public schoolboy type. He sounded like he knew what he was talking about but there was no substance to it. He was absolutely incompetent and totally relied on those around him to do the actual work before eventually coming unstuck when they complained about him.

I think employers were reluctant to admit they had been fooled by him so happily let him move on without raising a flag that he was useless. He likely managed to sweet talk them too. That was probably one thing he was good at.

He now has a very senior role in the US where I'm sure his accent and background have even more of an impact and he doesn't have to do much actual work.

Wherearewe2001 · 21/01/2024 11:56

Hearing about all of these people who don’t know the alphabet and can’t file, makes me feel newly very bitter about the time I temped for a company and spent 5 full days straight filing hundreds of documents. I made one minor error (something like I filed an Li before an Le, complete oversight and human error) and the woman in charge spoke to me like I was a fucking moron and incompetent idiot because of it. For one misfile out of hundreds. I was very young and new to the professional world and she made me feel like shit.

So I suppose this fits this thread, as she was totally incompetent at managing people!

Medsy · 21/01/2024 11:47

ilovepixie · 21/01/2024 11:41

A manager writing a phone number on an office wall as she couldn't find any paper, and when pulled up about it said sure it's only a fucking wall!

I quite like the sound of her actually!

OP posts:
Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 11:43

I was useless in my first job as a department store assistant. I was really shy when I was young so didn't want to engage with customers, tried to stick to tidying & stacking shelves and hoped I wouldn't be noticed by anyone.

One customer said to me 'This job isn't your forte is it?'

Once another customer approached me & said she had spotted someone shoplifting. I freaked & didn't know what to do, far too scared to tell my supervisor. I think the thief escaped.

Horrible knowing that you are doing a rubbish job and being desperate to avoid being disapproved of or sacked.

ilovepixie · 21/01/2024 11:41

A manager writing a phone number on an office wall as she couldn't find any paper, and when pulled up about it said sure it's only a fucking wall!

27Mankinis · 21/01/2024 11:41

G5000 · 21/01/2024 11:35

Anyway, nothing can apparently be done because her ethnicity is a protected characteristic and we must “tread carefully”

We have one of those. She's paid a ton and is utterly useless, making massive mistakes, plus generally a toxic and unpleasant colleague. But has told the GM directly that she'll go straight to press with discrimination allegations if anything is done..

I used to work with one as well. 20 odd years ago. She was given a warning due to her laziness, immediately claimed discrimination, our boss was hung up to dry and had a nervous breakdown during the process and as far as I am aware was never able to work again in the sector. Meanwhile she failed upwards, was a nasty bully and was finally got rid off by a whopping great golden handshake.

Springcleaninginsummer · 21/01/2024 11:38

Yetmorebeanstocount · 21/01/2024 10:53

I believe it was Gove who scrapped IT lessons from the secondary curriculum. That subject used to teach the children MS Office and some other popular programs like photoshop or animation. I believe Gove though that "digital natives" would somehow magically just know this stuff.

I am not at all surprised that school/uni leavers don't know MS Office, or much about laptops at all. Many don't have laptops at home, as they only use smartphones these days.
They would not have had much/any experience of Office at school. Some Uni courses may not have need most Office programs, except perhaps for basic typing up of assignments, which some students pay someone else to do.

So don't expect your employee new-out-of-school/college/uni to know Office without training!

As for not knowing the alphabet - we had one of those. Totally wrecked the filing system (going back a few decades - who has paper filing these days?)
If you didn't learn the alphabet as a pre-schooler, when do you ever get the chance to catch up? Is it explicitly taught in primary? How would you learn except for the song?

It should be taught in upper KS2 as part of library skills, so some kids might miss it if their school prefers to concentrate on SATs to the exclusion of anything not expected on that year's papers.

IlsSortLaPlupartAuNuitMostly · 21/01/2024 11:38

It's difficult to assess your own abilities somehow. We recently hired a graduate who thought he was good at Excel, and by some people's standards, yes he probably was, in that he could set up basic formulae. After sitting next to me for a morning as I assembled a model at speed using a fair range of functions and all the keyboard shortcuts he said "ah, I realise that there exists a spectrum of "good at Excel" which somewhat exceeds my previous frame of reference." I said "just you wait until you spend a morning with my colleague who is properly good at Excel. Your head will explode"

There's a great quote "mediocrity knows nothing better than itself, but talent instantly recognises genius". I find it widely applicable in the workspace although it was probably not originally written about MS Office use though.

Despite all of this, I'm shit at Word, mostly through lack of practice. I know that I should use track changes, and am familiar with the basic concepts but it never comes naturally.

G5000 · 21/01/2024 11:35

Anyway, nothing can apparently be done because her ethnicity is a protected characteristic and we must “tread carefully”

We have one of those. She's paid a ton and is utterly useless, making massive mistakes, plus generally a toxic and unpleasant colleague. But has told the GM directly that she'll go straight to press with discrimination allegations if anything is done..

Livingtothefull · 21/01/2024 11:33

An effective selection process can identify incompetent candidates but it can't unfortunately weed out candidates with a bad attitude; they are effectively incompetent as they have no intention of doing the work they are being paid for.

One ex-employer hired an overnight security guard. It came to light that instead of guarding the workplace as he was paid to do, he was just bedding down for the night on the couch in the sick room; even brought a duvet and pillow from home which he kept tucked away in the office.

GettingStuffed · 21/01/2024 11:27

AnneLovesGilbert · 20/01/2024 09:53

I worked with someone who couldn’t stuff an envelope. She kept taking the strip off the sticky bit before putting the magazine in. Lost a handful of expensive magazines which had the back torn off, got in a strop and walked out.

There are some things you can’t help people with if you’ve shown them several times and they don’t get it.

I can't stuff envelopes even cards can outfox me. I have dyspraxia. I wouldn take a job that involved putting anything in envelopes though

EekGoesTheBaby · 21/01/2024 11:18

cloudsdrifting · 20/01/2024 12:23

The retired teacher who uses a permanent marker on the whiteboard sign for today's date. Despite the notice we've put up saying PLEASE use ERASABLE pen on this sign. Lovely guy with other great qualities but honestly...we're on our fourth sign in two weeks and running out of replacements.

He was Head of English in a secondary school for twenty years.

It doesn't always work, but often you can write on top of permanent marker with dry erase marker (tracing it) and then it will erase. I've saved many white boards in classrooms this way.