Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most incompetent person you ever worked with/hired

711 replies

Medsy · 20/01/2024 08:26

I've got a new colleague, he has been here for 2 months and I 100% understand it takes time to be eased/trained into a new role, but this is next level. It's actually making me wonder whether he lied on his CV or at interview. There are really, really basic aspects to the industry he doesn't seem to have heard of, the other day he was struggling to use a simple Word feature, and one of the requirements was a foreign language which he said he was proficient in.
Ultimately I am going to have to work with him as a pair and I am trying to be as helpful and generous as I can but a part of me thinks why have they hired him?@
Opening the floor....Have you ever worked with or hired someone where it went beyond just incompetence and you thought "WTF is going on!".

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Newname000 · 09/02/2024 20:21

Citrusandginger · 08/02/2024 22:23

I've a feeling I've just had the misfortune to inherit someone who could be a thread all by themselves.

So far I've had a long list of can't dos and a couple of emails delegating their work up to me. Next weeks 1:1 is going to be interesting.

Does his name begin with W? 😀

Citrusandginger · 09/02/2024 19:09

A factor than can lead to keeping crap healthcare staff is the recruitment freeze.
If a manager goes to the effort of managing someone out - and it's a huge effort - the chances are their post won't be replaced. If someone is OK 50% of the time, that's still half a person more than another vacant post.

I'm not saying it's OK. But it can disincentive team managers from dealing with issues.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 09/02/2024 17:36

Remembered someone who failed her nursing placement three times and is still trying.
Wrote to all the bodies involved after the first fail claiming she should have been passed. Took ages going back and forth and it's now going for 6 years and she still hasn't passed.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 09/02/2024 16:36

IcedPlum · 09/02/2024 08:56

*meant so called Manager not documentary 😂

Damn, I was going to ask you where I could watch the documentary: it sounds very satisfying!

LovedFedAndNoonesDead · 09/02/2024 14:14

Worked in a management role at a care agency where staff qualified for a 6 monthly bonus if they met the qualifying criteria. To get the bonus qualification you had to do 3 things which were all part of the job - hand in timesheets on a Monday before noon; not hand work back with less than 48 hours notice; and to complete all medication records correctly.

Prt of my role there was training and assessing staff competence in medication administration, auditing medication charts on a monthly basis and addressing reports of medication errors.

One member of staff completely messed up during their annual assessment and so failed and had to undergo retraining in the area they failed. Complained that they were being bullied by being assessed and they should have been allowed to pass irrespective of numerous basic errors because they worked lots of hours!

Another member of staff complained that she was being rejected for her bonus qualification every month because of the audit process - she routinely failed to sign for medication given, or would give the wrong medication for the time of day (so would give evening meds at lunchtime or in the morning). She didn’t grasp that it was her making errors that meant she didn’t get the email confirming she had qualified for the bonus. She then tried to claim it was discrimination and that she wasn’t getting the bonus because of her colour - except we were very careful to keep accurate records of errors and retraining and could show she was regularly called back in for 1-2-1 sessions.

One of them left our company and went to a care home before being taken down the competence route with our HR provider. The other still works for the same company and still
complains about bullying when she has complaints made about her.

Kittynoodle · 09/02/2024 10:22

Risun · 20/01/2024 10:48

@Testina London, Birmingham, oranges, trays, trays and more trays. Confused

I might have trouble with that.

Me too!
Have a degree but this boggled my brain 😀

KirstenBlest · 09/02/2024 09:53

@cromartyforties , that teacher sounds awful.
I know someone highly intelligent who has no understanding of geography. It's like she has a mental block with it.

cromartyforties · 09/02/2024 09:14

I used to be a teaching assistant. Frequently had to help teachers spell. Though I didn't expect this when I went into the role, it didn't really bother me as it became clear you can teach really well whilst struggling with spelling.

Teacher who did bother me had to be helped to find various countries on a map, in a geography lesson, and had to be corrected (privately) on the pronunciation of a major historical figure when we began a whole term topic on that subject. I wouldn't have bothered correcting her, but there were 6 year olds in the classroom who knew that she was wrong. It wasn't really the lack of knowledge that bothered me - everyone has blind spots - it was the fact that she didn't care about her ignorance and hadn't checked her slides/lesson plan before the lesson. She was condescending towards families, e.g. we had a girl with a family of Indian origin in the class and she became very annoyed at the mum who wanted her to pronounce her daughter's name correctly.
Told me she couldn't wait to get pregnant so that she could have a year's holiday. 🙄

Anyway, she was incredibly insecure and was fairly new and fairly young, and I think she'll probably grow into the job. I probably hated her because she was working above her competency while I was 15-20 years older and working well below mine (responsibility all mine) 😂

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 09/02/2024 09:00

3Tunes · 09/02/2024 08:15

IME people get away with it either because their manager is too ‘nice’ to do proper performance management or because their manager is up for it but knows they won’t be backed up by seniors and HR if / when the person raises a grievance or claims discrimination or does any of the other myriad formal and informal things that an employee can do to make their manager’s life unpleasant.

It's a calculation, is the huge amount of time, effort and stress involved in performance managing this person properly going to stop the manager from doing all the rest of their job? What is more important, dealing with one poor performer or the actual work for clients / customers?

This absolutely nails it! A cost benefit analysis.

IcedPlum · 09/02/2024 08:59

@SquashedSquashess

Wow you can see how people end up in prison or with a criminal record with incompetence like this .

IcedPlum · 09/02/2024 08:56

*meant so called Manager not documentary 😂

IcedPlum · 09/02/2024 08:52

Citrusandginger · 09/02/2024 08:06

How does someone get away with giving their workplace a list of "can't dos" if those are part of the job?

I've a feeling I'm about to find out. So far, I've had can't send emails due to dyslexia, can't phone clients because she gets flustered and can't answer the department phone as she's a manager and it's not her job. Seriously. This is a woman in her forties paid £36k to manage an office team. First job this morning is to speak to her previous line manager. Wink.

Because they are lazy delegators who can't actually do their jobs but are clever at manipulating others into doing it for them . I watched a documentary called Manager do it until her two lynchpins retired and weren't replaced. That's when the wheels fell off the bus and she was sacked for incompetence. It took 18 years .

lieselotte · 09/02/2024 08:43

The story above about the public school boy who got away with being a useless trainee solicitor doesn't surprise me at all, but I bet if he'd been female, even attractive, public school educated, it would have been a different story!

Someone suggested a redlist of people not to employ - I suspect a lot of pretty competent women would be on it, due to the fact that women have to be twice or more as good as men to be treated as competent.

3Tunes · 09/02/2024 08:15

IME people get away with it either because their manager is too ‘nice’ to do proper performance management or because their manager is up for it but knows they won’t be backed up by seniors and HR if / when the person raises a grievance or claims discrimination or does any of the other myriad formal and informal things that an employee can do to make their manager’s life unpleasant.

It's a calculation, is the huge amount of time, effort and stress involved in performance managing this person properly going to stop the manager from doing all the rest of their job? What is more important, dealing with one poor performer or the actual work for clients / customers?

Citrusandginger · 09/02/2024 08:06

How does someone get away with giving their workplace a list of "can't dos" if those are part of the job?

I've a feeling I'm about to find out. So far, I've had can't send emails due to dyslexia, can't phone clients because she gets flustered and can't answer the department phone as she's a manager and it's not her job. Seriously. This is a woman in her forties paid £36k to manage an office team. First job this morning is to speak to her previous line manager. Wink.

SquashedSquashess · 09/02/2024 06:44

A paralegal in our team who threw a load of original medical records (which we were due to return to the practice, we were reviewing in the course of litigation) in the shredding bin.

And then lied about it.

All employees in law firms are regulated by the SRA, and lying is THE number one thing you mustn’t do as a lawyer. The mistake might be excruciating, but the lying could have you disciplined, or even struck off.

Thankfully he told other paralegals that he’d lied, and was quickly reported. He spent a day on his hands and knees searching through the shredding bins to retrieve those medical records.

I also overheard him telling a client that signing a declaration of truth is just a formality. It isn’t, it’s a criminal offence to sign a declaration of truth without being confident the content of what you’re signing is true. I explained this to him. 2 days later he gave the same “advice” to another client!

He got a training contract at another law firm. I won’t be surprised to one day hear he’s been struck off.

Untethered · 09/02/2024 05:51

TheLogicalSong · 20/01/2024 11:59

You're a bit younger than I am, but I would suggest you are probably the exception rather than the rule. The cost of Mac computers alone would have ruled them out for most people back then, if they'd even heard of them.

I agree. I remember being at college in London in the late 90s and quizzically looking at the one computer in the library as people were whispering it had the ‘internet’.

Nanaof1 · 09/02/2024 04:10

Citrusandginger · 08/02/2024 22:23

I've a feeling I've just had the misfortune to inherit someone who could be a thread all by themselves.

So far I've had a long list of can't dos and a couple of emails delegating their work up to me. Next weeks 1:1 is going to be interesting.

How does someone get away with giving their workplace a list of "can't dos" if those are part of the job?

Citrusandginger · 08/02/2024 22:23

I've a feeling I've just had the misfortune to inherit someone who could be a thread all by themselves.

So far I've had a long list of can't dos and a couple of emails delegating their work up to me. Next weeks 1:1 is going to be interesting.

grumpypedestrian · 08/02/2024 21:20

icelolly12 · 20/01/2024 10:01

I do think interviews aren't always helpful in finding the most competent candidate, instead they are a test of who can bullshit the best.

This. The company I work for has a rating system when deciding which temps to keep. It’s based on the interview and not the candidates proven ability to do the job. Lazy staff get kept on because they ‘rated higher’ in the interview than the hard working and more competent employees who were nervous in interviews. I hate it.

sanferryanne · 08/02/2024 21:16

Had, not was

sanferryanne · 08/02/2024 21:06

@Puzzledandpissedoff I came across a senior manager in my former employers (now retired!) who claimed to have been at the same university as I was, albeit some years later. During the course of a conversation he was having one time with a group of people including me, it became crystal clear that he had never been to my university, in fact I don't think he'd ever set foot in the place. He didn't know that I'd gone there, and the look on his face when I mentioned that I had was priceless.

NeelyOHara1 · 07/02/2024 18:50

As someone who is usually very self-critical, I'm actually a bit in awe of how some of these people sail on regardless 🙃

SergeantZbornakFoodPolice · 07/02/2024 18:27

In my last job we had a trainee who, although very nice, was completely unteachable. He’d ask someone a simple question, they’d take the time to not only provide the answer but explain how to reach that conclusion, however if it differed from the answer he was expecting he wouldn’t accept it. Instead he’d wait a while, then ask someone else and when they gave the same answer, he’d repeat the process. Eventually he’d end up asking management his question who really weren’t pleased to bothered by easily answerable questions. The whole process could last for most of the day, meaning some days he got almost nothing done and the entire team were taken away from their work for no reason.

He ended up having to move to a completely different department as his stubbornness prevented him from progressing.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/02/2024 21:27

logo1236 · 03/02/2024 16:49

If he was foreign it is possible he falsified his degree

They wouldn't need to be foreign for that, though admittedly weird and wonderful bits of paper from unheard-of Unis can complicate things

Sadly I've seen too many fakes for UK ones, even Oxbridge