Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wits end with everything

261 replies

Isurrender · 19/01/2024 23:50

I live up North with my two kids aged 18 and 24. Hubby works away and only home every few months. We have no family.

We have just come through the most horrific financial crisis as a family and have pretty much been left with nothing after a two year court battle. I am 54 and my husband is 60.

My son and I both work full time, but my daughter only works 11 hours a week in her own business which she is building up. I pay for her horse, phone and car tax each month. She did have a part time job but gave it up as she fell out with her friend who worked in the same shop and it was awkward, so now does 11 hours work only.

AIBU to expect help in the house? If I specifically ask her to clean a room she will, but if not she does nothing. I spend my weekends shopping, trying to tidy up and walking our dogs. She would never walk them unless asked. If I leave any washing up I mostly come home to it as she will say it wasn’t her mess. She has washed up three times this week and I’m still hearing about it. I’m really struggling with a bad back but she doesn’t notice. The bathroom floor is piled high in her dirty washing but it waits for me. Neither of them would put on a wash unless asked. Last night I was so tired and my back was agony. I left a bowl full of dishes and stuff on the sides, today she had no work and said she’d do them. She sent me a message at work saying she’d wash everyone else’s stuff up later. She had a lie in and went to her horse. I got home to dog poo all over the path and the same mess I’d left last night. She got home after me, telling me she’d wash up later. I said she should have done it earlier and she said her brother doesn’t wash up often. He’d got home and gone to the gym.

My son doesn’t do much but he works 11.5 hour days. If I want a job doing I have to ask over and over. Our garden is completely overgrown as he won’t do it, despite me practically begging him all summer. No one will empty bins unless I ask and if I don’t drag the dustbins out they don’t get emptied. They will see me go outside to fill coal buckets with a bad back and only do it if I ask.

I have nothing for myself, no time, no money, no outings. When the kitchen bin is full the stuff is left on the side for me to take out. My daughter now leaves makeup all over my nice table on the landing and won’t move it unless I ask. Then it’s back the next day. No one will clean the bathroom. The bathroom bin overflows onto the floor until I empty it. If I mention my daughter’s mess she says all I do is moan. I have asked her to get a second job but she doesn’t want to do any job I suggest. She owes her brother £600.

We went through an awful time and she moved out for 5 months to stay with her boyfriend. I admit I was horrible due to all the pressure but now she throws this at me and I feel guilty for asking for her help because I upset her a lot during the court case.

Should they do equal amounts or should she do more as she barely works? I’m at the end of my tether.

OP posts:
Fern95 · 20/01/2024 10:17

If your son lived independently he would have to clean his own house/flat after work so his job is not a reason for skipping the chores.

washing up; put most of the cutlery and plates/dishes somewhere else and just leave 3 or 4 of each in the kitchen. This actually does work I've tried it!

Laundry; put daughter's clothes from the bathroom in a plastic bag and plonk them back in her room. Do the same for anyone else who leaves their items slovenly strewn across the house. This works too.

Bins; put the things on the side in a plastic bag and only take those things out. Don't carry heavy bags of rubbish when you have a bad back. They will soon get bored of not having a bin! Or even better put the bag in their cars/bedrooms.

Money/work; don't ask your daughter to get more work but stop paying for anything expensive. Her phone should be something she's bought outright so she can have a £10 SIM only contract. You shouldn't be paying for a £30+ ee contract or anything silly like that every month.

Rudeness/laziness; change the password to netflix etc. Don't buy any luxury food just get the basics. If they don't help you do the weekly shop then don't take suggestions etc. Do not cook them dinner!! Don't make their lives easier because they have no compassion for you.

Sadly my sister (21) who still lives with my mum tries to get away with similar behaviour.

Isurrender · 20/01/2024 10:13

Isheabastard · 20/01/2024 10:04

Both your children should be helping out at home. If nothing else they should clear up their own mess.

You don’t mention if either of them pay rent? If not, then the son working longer hours doesn’t get a free pass to not do anything.

Your Dd should want to help you out because you are helping her out financially. If she is only working a few hours, then presumably she can’t afford to live anywhere else.

Sibling rivalry can be intense and her point about her brother doing nothing (and presumably keeping all his wages) is valid.

You could start asking for rent and use that to pay a cleaner.

Or your son has money but ‘no time’, your Dd has time but no money. Get him to pay her to clean up after him.

Neither pay rent! Daughter obviously doesn’t earn enough. Son is on 10K more than me and has never paid rent. That’s because he was at uni until he was 21 and has been working the past three years but living rent free. I told him I wouldn’t expect rent because daughter has the horse and it seemed unfair. He does often buy shopping and doesn’t ask for the money.

He has taken out a 20K loan to help us through the court issues so I cannot expect rent. He also lent me 2K for a car so he does help.

OP posts:
zingally · 20/01/2024 10:09

"Horrific financial crisis", but "pays for her horse."

Clearly not THAT bad, is it?

There's a whole host of things you can do in terms of dealing with your useless young adults. But setting some ground rules and following through would help.

Isurrender · 20/01/2024 10:07

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 20/01/2024 09:08

I agree with an earlier PP.
Sell the horse.
Stop paying for her phone and gym membership.
Sell your house and move into a one-bed flat.

I don’t pay for her gym membership. I love my home. We have dogs and there’s no way I’d live in a flat with dogs. I just want some respect and for them both to help.

last summer I practically begged my son to help with the garden but he refused. It’s now an overgrown jungle of embarrassment and we can’t even sit in it.

OP posts:
Isheabastard · 20/01/2024 10:04

Both your children should be helping out at home. If nothing else they should clear up their own mess.

You don’t mention if either of them pay rent? If not, then the son working longer hours doesn’t get a free pass to not do anything.

Your Dd should want to help you out because you are helping her out financially. If she is only working a few hours, then presumably she can’t afford to live anywhere else.

Sibling rivalry can be intense and her point about her brother doing nothing (and presumably keeping all his wages) is valid.

You could start asking for rent and use that to pay a cleaner.

Or your son has money but ‘no time’, your Dd has time but no money. Get him to pay her to clean up after him.

Isurrender · 20/01/2024 09:42

mrsplum2015 · 20/01/2024 01:13

To be honest your daughter doesn't sound that bad if she does your washing up! I think everyone doing their own washing up would be the best solution and agree a time frame that you all stick to.

Everyone does their own laundry and tidying up.

And get a cleaner with the rent your son is paying.

Your son can do the garden and you can do the food shop online, then share the cooking. But if your daughter doesn't eat dinner she shouldn't have to cook and clear up.

My son doesn’t pay rent. He never has because I felt guilty about my daughter’s horse and her being given more.

I can’t expect him to pay now because he has taken out a loan to help us with the court case.

OP posts:
Isurrender · 20/01/2024 09:38

leighh88 · 20/01/2024 01:36

Your son sounds exactly like all the terrible lazy husband posts ive seen on here, just because he works doesnt mean he shouldn't have to clean up after himself, but your enabling him by giving him excuses. Your expecting your daughter to be a maid, no wonder she is pushing back. They both need to clean up after themselves and empty the bins etc equally, and stop paying for her phone and tax, your also enabling her.

Maybe I haven’t made it clear. I’m honestly so fed up, exhausted and stressed I cannot think. There are so many rows about housework and jobs it just plays round and round in my head. I feel like running away tbh but my back is agony so I can’t even bend properly atm.

Daughter isn’t expected to clear everyone’s mess up nightly. I do it myself! I’m talking about the rare occasions she is asked to do it. My son works 57.5 hours a week. I work 45 but also do some weekend work. Daughter works 11. My thinking is it won’t hurt her to do housework if she is home a lot more, particularly as I pay for horse, phone, car tax. If I ask her to do something she will do it but will leave it all day and I come home to it. Her dirty washing is piled high in the bathroom on the floor. It’s getting bigger and bigger but she won’t wash it. I have to bend over pick it all up and wash it. I asked her why she didn’t do it and she says she’s not in when wash finishes to take it out. She has an excuse for everything

OP posts:
OldTinHat · 20/01/2024 09:32

Go in hard. Do not do their laundry. Do not cook for them or wash up/clean after them. The make up on your nice table? Sweep it up into a carrier bag and throw it into the bin. Rinse and repeat.

Tell them it will be that way until X date by when they will have to move out or start contributing. On X date, if they've not changed, take them and their stuff to the Housing Officer at the Council and say they're homeless and walk away.

Stop paying for their bills like the phone. I get what you're saying about the horse, but stop everything else.

If you don't toughen up and be firm, they will carry on walking all over you.

Nicole1111 · 20/01/2024 09:26

Strike strike strike strike strike. Tell everyone in the house you’ve asked for a small amount of help multiple times and been ignored and now they lose all help. Don’t do their washing up, put it in a bowl in their room, don’t cook them dinner, don’t do their washing (a pile in their room) and stop cleaning completely. It’ll be tough but they need to physically deal with the consequences of their actions and not have you swooping in to sort things so there’s no real consequences accept having to be challenged by you. Ideally you should also contact a friend and see if you can go and stay with them for a few days so they’ve got more time to reflect on how they’ve been treating you. Let them know what day you’re coming back with advance notice and hopefully they prepare the house accordingly. If they do you can sit down and negotiate what support you’re willing to provide after your return and what they need to do. If them stepping up stops you go straight back to a strike. If they still don’t help you tell them they’ll lose any privileges (your daughter’s horse for one) or will have to find alternative accommodation. They need boundaries and consequences they believe will happen to motivate them to change.

Russooooo · 20/01/2024 09:20

I think it’s family meeting time.

I know you say you’ve tried rotas, charts, etc, but have those been written by you or them?

“Right guys. We need to work out a better system to keep this house under control. We’re meeting at 7pm on Sunday evening.”

Then discuss everything. Like a PP said, accept that it’s been a hard few years - and difficult for all of you, but don’t get into who it’s been worse for. Then list (together) everything that needs doing, and discuss how that could be split.

DO NOT REFER TO IT AS ‘HELPING’ YOU. This is everyone’s responsibility. DH should be on board with this too. He needs to pull his weight in the house. DS needs to be treated the same as DD. Working out of the home is not a reason to not do household tasks (as you well know!) Horse care does not count as house care. That is an extra, which DD is responsible for as well as household tasks.

Ask them what would help (table/mirror in DD’s room so that her make up doesn’t need to be in your hallway? Separate laundry bins and drying racks?)

Ideally, I’d be working towards everyone taking responsibility for one meal a week - including washing up so that if you choose to make a faffy meal, you choose to wash up all those pots/pans. Those that work outside of the home could make use of a slow cooker, or fund a take away.

Good luck.

Silverbirchtwo · 20/01/2024 09:14

He does the washing up, she does the bins (since she doesn't like washing up). They each do their own laundry. She does the bathroom in lieu of not working much. They each tidy their own rooms. You do the general cleaning when you are able, if you are not able due to your bad back then they muck in.

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 20/01/2024 09:12

Any stuff left lying around the house, throw it out in the garden, in the bin, or dump it on their beds.
You have two seriously ungrateful and disrespectful children.

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 20/01/2024 09:08

I agree with an earlier PP.
Sell the horse.
Stop paying for her phone and gym membership.
Sell your house and move into a one-bed flat.

Isurrender · 20/01/2024 09:04

Totupthenumberspls · 20/01/2024 00:09

Is she 24 or 18?

She’s 18

OP posts:
JellyWellyBoots · 20/01/2024 08:59

Why not tell them you are selling up and moving to a one bed?
Even if you don't do it could give them a kick up the arse.
I personally would move into a one bed and tell them both politely to get fucked. They are adults now and you are being completely taken advantage of. They don't respect you.
I was in a similar situation to you, two grown adults who lived off me and in my home but had no respect. They no longer live here :)

Isurrender · 20/01/2024 08:58

How do I reply to individual messages please? I’m getting so confused.

OP posts:
Isurrender · 20/01/2024 08:53

I’m really confused about how mumsnet works. I’m hitting reply on individual messages but they don’t appear with the person’s name on when they post???

OP posts:
Isurrender · 20/01/2024 08:49

Because he took out a loan to help us financially.

OP posts:
Isurrender · 20/01/2024 08:48

The horse is a very much loved part of our family. Hard to explain but he will never be sold. She has been told she has to start paying for him.

OP posts:
Isurrender · 20/01/2024 08:43

I probably haven’t made it clear as my head has literally gone and I’m so worn out. I mostly wash up myself. I’m talking about the few times I ask her to help it seems to be a huge issue and causes arguments about who should do it. We eat very simple meals so it’s rarely a six pan job. It’s a 20 min job at most.
I think the answer is three separate bowls in the kitchen. We tried washing our own stuff but everyone argues about who left what.

OP posts:
AceofPentacles · 20/01/2024 08:28

Why can't the 24 year old move out? That would stop the he said she said stuff.

Also your daughter should sign on - extra money for her and they will hassle her about getting a job

If rubbish is left on the side PUT IT ON THEIR BEDS. I think you need to grow a pair

AndThatWasNY · 20/01/2024 08:10

Isurrender · 20/01/2024 00:34

My son has helped financially so him moving out isn’t an option. I’m just sick of it all. I thought about getting a cleaner and making them pay

I did this with my 3. They were younger (,11, 14 and 15). Gave them the option to help more. They failed so they all lost some of their allowance (went from 60 to £40 a month) which doesn't quite cover the cost but helps pay for a cleaner.
If they fail to tidy their room on the day the cleaner comes they lose another £10 that day.
When DS leaves school I will expect him to chip in or clean.
I work full-time, have a chronic health condition and also think they need to learn. They do other chores (cook once a week each, wash up, dishwasher, walk dog but I have to cajole and it's so annoying).

HowNice23 · 20/01/2024 07:54

If you're financially struggling the horse has to go. It's a luxury.

Hiddenvoice · 20/01/2024 05:38

I would stop paying for everything for your dd. I understand you love the horse and you’ve given her a cut off date of March. I would repeat this to her and make her understand that in March, if she cannot pay then the horse goes. I would stop paying for her phone and car tax. She needs to get another job, she needs to realise that working isn’t about working with friends.

I would start making your own meals and cleaning up after yourself only. This will mean the house will get very messy but you need to make a stand that they are both adults. I understand your son works long days but he will soon move out and will need to do it all for himself anyway so he needs to start now.

I would also be asking them both for rent. My parents asked my siblings and I for a small amount each month when we were working (not studying). It seems fair as they should contribute to bills and food.

Octavia64 · 20/01/2024 05:30

What might be successful is moving towards more of a shared house situation.

So for example putting laundry bins in each of their rooms and buying them a drying rack each and saying that they are now responsible for their own laundry.
You then only do yours.

If they don't do theirs then they just run out of clean clothes.

You can also stop paying for your DD's phone bill.

Something I did as well was putting a sign up sheet on the fridge for the meals for the week. I deliberately left out two days as my "days off" so on those nights everyone got their own or did takeout or whatever. I usually had cheese sandwiches to be honest.
And for meals I was cooking they had to sign up by the morning to say if they would be in and wanted it.