Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so devastated by tragedies involving children

82 replies

StolenCookie · 19/01/2024 21:57

I’m feeling really devastated and broken by the recent story of the poor little boy in the news. I burst into tears when I read the headline, and can’t stop imagining his last days, his confusion, how he was found cuddling his dad’s leg. I have tears in my eyes writing this!

Does anyone else struggle in the same way? I was doing some child safeguarding training the other day and the story of Baby P came up and I couldn’t stop myself from reading more about the details and feeling so disturbed that these things happen to babies and children. I even researched where his grave is to see if it would be possible for me to visit it (I’m not going to! It was just an impulse).

I’m a normal, functioning person in real life, I promise! I work with vulnerable children and have a 17 month old boy. I think having my own baby has made this all worse for me but when I read about these dreadful events I find it hard not to fall apart knowing some children are just born to suffer.

I’ve been in therapy for years so sadly that won’t make a difference to me. I would really just like to know if anyone else gets as deeply affected as I do? I feel so so sad.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lamenao · 21/01/2024 22:46

I went through a stage a while back when I read a lot of misery lit and I did get a bit affected by it all. But to be honest I know there was controversy about some of those stories (doubts about their veracity) and I think I became a bit numb to it all. Now I read stories in the news and I am not even surprised at the stuff that happens, there seems to be a new tragedy every day and I don't have the energy to get emotionally affected by it any more.

I've also had family members who have been hounded a bit by social services on spurious grounds, and I sensed they only spent so much time on them as it was an easy case since my relative was fearful and quite compliant - something that always comes to mind when I read about social workers having unmanageable caseloads.

MorrisZapp · 21/01/2024 22:36

I went down a rabbit hole a few years ago about historical abuse of little boys in institutions. It was started by something that came up at work, but then I couldn't stop reading about it, researching etc, even though it was traumatic. Like a pp, I felt I had to bear witness and couldn't turn away. It affected my mental health and I had to force myself to stop reading. In weak moments I would go back to it, only to regret it every time.

I can cope better with it now, I seem to have processed it somehow. It has absolutely no personal connection to me whatsoever so it isn't my story and it isn't my pain. But somehow I let it in until it consumed me. Be careful.

TheTimeIsNowMaybeNow · 21/01/2024 22:22

I work for Crown Court and read awful stuff every day, I try not to dwell on it all

Boomboom22 · 21/01/2024 22:18

Oblomov23 · 20/01/2024 13:13

@Bitterbum, I don't know what failings. The investigation will take time. But I suspect there are some. By all agencies. Police called 3 times. Neighbour reported it to nspcc. Father previously begged SS for help. He was supposed to be under a weekly check. I don't know the last time a sw'er actually saw him. But sw'er last contact was Dec 27th. Was that a phone call? Then sw'er couldn't get access, despite trying twice on 2nd and 4th, I think, until 9th Jan. They can't just gain access, but no next step? Chasing police again, or magistrates, to gain entry? That's 13 days. The weekly check didn't occur, because that's nearly 2 weeks.

The social.worker clearly went above and beyond. 27th to 2nd is 6 days. The police are not meant to do a welfare check for 1 missed appt. She did push for it as it was unusual for him but technically I believe services didn't do wrong this time. The mother on the other hand, where was she?

Oblomov23 · 20/01/2024 13:13

@Bitterbum, I don't know what failings. The investigation will take time. But I suspect there are some. By all agencies. Police called 3 times. Neighbour reported it to nspcc. Father previously begged SS for help. He was supposed to be under a weekly check. I don't know the last time a sw'er actually saw him. But sw'er last contact was Dec 27th. Was that a phone call? Then sw'er couldn't get access, despite trying twice on 2nd and 4th, I think, until 9th Jan. They can't just gain access, but no next step? Chasing police again, or magistrates, to gain entry? That's 13 days. The weekly check didn't occur, because that's nearly 2 weeks.

StolenCookie · 20/01/2024 12:36

Darkdiamond · 20/01/2024 10:57

I don't get affected like this. Any death is sad, regardless of how old the deceased is.

There is something about a child, so young and trusting, with so much potential ahead of them, so dependent on their caregivers and so lacking in maturity that makes cases with children particularly heartbreaking. By nature, children are more easily frightened and haven't developed any kind of resilience to make sense of a terrible situation. The cases that are the most heartbreaking are those where the death was preceeded by a period of abuse, in which the child was helpless due to the very nature of their young years. The ultimate power imbalance.

Little children are scared of loud noises that we, as adults, know are caused by the bin lorry, or strange shapes on the wall which we know are just caused by odd shadows. The abuse and murder of a child is driven by an evil which relies on the vulnerability of a child. We are hardwired to want to protect these little ones, or should be. Their maltreatment leaves a sense of horror that reflects the hellish experience, and ultimate demise, of those young children. It just gets me in a different way to anything else.

Other things do get me, by the way, but the thought of anything happening to children leaves me disgusted and distraught on another level.

Thanks for this, it captures exactly how I feel. The abuse and murder of adults is horrific of course, but the emotional and physical abuse of a child is something different entirely. They are completely reliant and helpless. They can’t resolve to make a plan to escape. They can’t hide money and make a run for it. They can’t problem solve. There are no options open to them at all if the adults around them decide their fate. I think having my own baby drives home how it’s just a roll of the dice of which family you’re born into, and some babies just don’t stand a chance. It sounds like Bronson at least experienced some love and happiness in his short life, but others are born only to suffer, and the thought of that makes me so angry and saddened with the world.

OP posts:
ADoggyDogWorld · 20/01/2024 11:18

I would recommend setting your devices to non autoplay so that videos don't play as you scroll. It is a really simple thing to help you choose whether to watch awful things.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 20/01/2024 11:11

*love

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 20/01/2024 11:11

@RobertaFirmino I disagree entirely with the notion that any death is sad. You can't possibly equate the death of an elderly person who goes gently in their sleep after having lived a full and happy life, to the death of, for example, the 2 young students last year who were so grotesquely murdered just at the time when they were entering adulthood, or the teens, children and toddlers who are killed by the people who are meant to live them the most. To me there is no comparison at all.

Darkdiamond · 20/01/2024 10:57

I don't get affected like this. Any death is sad, regardless of how old the deceased is.

There is something about a child, so young and trusting, with so much potential ahead of them, so dependent on their caregivers and so lacking in maturity that makes cases with children particularly heartbreaking. By nature, children are more easily frightened and haven't developed any kind of resilience to make sense of a terrible situation. The cases that are the most heartbreaking are those where the death was preceeded by a period of abuse, in which the child was helpless due to the very nature of their young years. The ultimate power imbalance.

Little children are scared of loud noises that we, as adults, know are caused by the bin lorry, or strange shapes on the wall which we know are just caused by odd shadows. The abuse and murder of a child is driven by an evil which relies on the vulnerability of a child. We are hardwired to want to protect these little ones, or should be. Their maltreatment leaves a sense of horror that reflects the hellish experience, and ultimate demise, of those young children. It just gets me in a different way to anything else.

Other things do get me, by the way, but the thought of anything happening to children leaves me disgusted and distraught on another level.

Bitterbum · 20/01/2024 10:14

@Oblomov23 What ‘failings’ do you mean? I have read the reported details of this case but I’m struggling to see how this social worker failed in her duties?

FallingStar21 · 20/01/2024 09:23

RobertaFirmino · 20/01/2024 01:14

I don't get affected like this. Any death is sad, regardless of how old the deceased is.

My observation is that people talk of their devastation but nobody seems to express sadness for those left behind. Arthur has a DM but I've never read anything along the lines of 'His poor mother must be heartbroken'. Star Hobson has a dad but nobody seems to sympathise with him. The deceased are at peace whilst those left behind will probably never know true peace again.

And did Star's dad do anything at the time? I think the grandparents circulated her photo (with the giant bruise) on SM and he'd probably seen it. Either way, he was obviously not involved in his daughter's life, else he'd have taken immediate steps.
Arthur's mum was in jail for killing someone. She was a violent drug addict, so I can only imagine the type of life he had with her too.

Oblomov23 · 20/01/2024 08:47

It doesn't affect me in this way. I don't cry, I just feel frustrated that the system let them (yet another one to add to the list pp's have listed) down. The police has reported itself to the watchdog. I fear that won't do much. And the social workers failings. That too won't change. Sad.

SecondHandFurniture · 20/01/2024 08:06

Saschka · 19/01/2024 23:08

I’m the same, purposefully avoided seeing the Arthur Labinjo-Hughes video because I knew it would make me cry, and sobbed over Baby P and Victoria Climbie. James Bulger still makes my blood run cold.

I can’t imagine how anyone could hurt a little child, I just can’t imagine it. I steer well clear of all stories like that because they disturb me so much.

Same on all of these. I followed Arthur's trial via a Birmingham paper because I was scared his bastard father was going to get off but I have never watched that video. I have a 5 year old DS.

Prior to having a child, animal abuse cases upset me the most.

TheWelshposter · 20/01/2024 08:01

OP I feel the same way. It's extremely upsetting. I can't even post much about it but hearing things like this stay with you.

MarshmallowWorld · 20/01/2024 07:36

@Darkdiamond That's an excellent post. I react similarly too and completely understand your point about feeling like you have to bear witness

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 20/01/2024 07:30

@Darkdiamond what a brilliantly expressed post. Empathy is key. There was an incident of horrific abuse and torture some time ago that still haunts me now. It can just pop into my head when I'm having a perfectly alright day and I have to work really hard to reset my brain back to normal function. I think I'll always remember what I read and hold a thought in my heart for that poor person for the rest of my life. It also really resonates with me what you said about the affect it has on your own parenting and at least being the best mum/ dad you can be to your own kids kind of helps somehow. It even works for me with animals. I currently live in a country where animal welfare is not a priority and I've seen some horrible sights. Me knowing how much love and care and snuggles my own little doggie gets makes it a bit easier to deal with somehow. ( sorry I went on a tangent there. But I'm trying to explain my way of dealing with distressing things.)

Daley22 · 20/01/2024 07:09

Perhaps because if their parents were more involved it would never have happened. Arthur’s mum was in jail for murdering someone, why would you do that especially if you had a child?

Darkdiamond · 20/01/2024 07:09

OpalOrchid · 19/01/2024 22:17

It's not about you though. It's normal to feel sad about these tragedies but don't make them all about you.

The whole point of empathy is that someone else's experience affects you. We are supposed to be moved by the suffering of others, or else we'd all be stepping over people who have collapsed in the street or telling our colleagues that they have got fat over the holidays.

Children being hurt should evoke a visceral, disturbed and horrified reaction. It should be, at least on some level, upsetting. Most normal people with small children are acutely aware of how innocent, sweet, helpless and worthy of love they are. It should hit home, hard.

Op, I've been like this all my life. My little brother was the same age as James Bulger when that terrible tragedy happened. I remember crying and crying as I read the details in the paper. Through the years, there have been a saddening amount of cases which broke me.

Now I have my own kids and the cycle continues. I followed the court cases of both Arthur and Star (they were around the same time). I remember feeling like I had to hear about it because their abusers deserved to be exposed for the true extent of their crimes. Those kids deserved justice and I wanted to be witness to it, for their sake. Sometimes when I'm tucking my own kids in at night, I think about those children and somehow feel like I can channel that compassion for them into my own kids and hug then more tightly, speak more softly to them or tell them how much I love them. I try, subconsciously, to bring them into my own parenting. It just helps me make sense of it.

Babyblackbear78 · 20/01/2024 06:53

thechangling · 20/01/2024 06:37

I felt awful and very upset about Baby P. My DS was about 18months at the time. He's now 18. I don't find the stories quite so over-whelmingly upsetting now, although they are truly awful situations. I think hormones do play a part when you have really small DCs and have an impact on your emotions. I think it's probably programmed into us for very good reason- we're communal, social mammals who look out for the young and vulnerable. You're a highly evolved human!

I'm the same. Found them so difficult when my dc were the same age but find them easier to manage now. However, mine are now 18 and 23, so they are independent, driving, go to work and are at university, but I found it difficult when those young lads were found in their car after going missing before Christmas. That really upset me and made me cry. Again because I had children of similar age.

thechangling · 20/01/2024 06:37

I felt awful and very upset about Baby P. My DS was about 18months at the time. He's now 18. I don't find the stories quite so over-whelmingly upsetting now, although they are truly awful situations. I think hormones do play a part when you have really small DCs and have an impact on your emotions. I think it's probably programmed into us for very good reason- we're communal, social mammals who look out for the young and vulnerable. You're a highly evolved human!

Teder · 20/01/2024 06:29

ATJ · 20/01/2024 00:38

Some people feel more empathy than others.

Empathy is not making it about oneself and one’s own feelings and reactions.

(Again not the OP but I’ve seen it a lot on social media. )

inigomontoyahwillcox · 20/01/2024 01:55

I remember having a similar reaction to the April Jones disappearance/murder. I was disproportionally devastated about it and could hardly concentrate on anything else whilst they were looking for her. I can only put it down to my DD being of a similar age.

RobertaFirmino · 20/01/2024 01:14

I don't get affected like this. Any death is sad, regardless of how old the deceased is.

My observation is that people talk of their devastation but nobody seems to express sadness for those left behind. Arthur has a DM but I've never read anything along the lines of 'His poor mother must be heartbroken'. Star Hobson has a dad but nobody seems to sympathise with him. The deceased are at peace whilst those left behind will probably never know true peace again.

FallingStar21 · 20/01/2024 00:49

OP, I understand completely. I dont know what's "normal" to feel but I haven't been the same since reading about one of the poor children mentioned on here. It really broke me and I'm still struggling. There were other children in the news for similar reasons, also horrendous but none affected me anywhere near.

I have kept away from the news since then anyway as I can't stomach anything, not even headlines sometimes. I try to know "roughly" what's going on in the world, usually just let my partner fill me in.