Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about my children starving to death in an emergency?

238 replies

Mnk711 · 19/01/2024 20:02

I have long been worried about what will happen to my toddler and baby if something happened to me at home e.g. a fall, a stroke etc. My DP works away a lot for long periods so we are often home alone, have no close neighbours, and no routines etc that anyone would notice us missing from. There's a good chance if I were to be incapacitated no one would come and help my children. The recent case in the news about a two year old starving to death has brought all my fears up again. AIBU to worry about this? Does anyone have any good suggestions of how to deal with this risk e.g. apps, technology, arrangements with others...?

OP posts:
Seasmoke7 · 20/01/2024 00:31

Agree · 20/01/2024 00:27

I haven't read the thread but I don't think it's irrational at all and it's a miracle it doesn't happen more often really. People are very isolated nowadays - it's one thing living alone and all that goes with it but quite another if with a tiny child who cannot ask for help or use a phone.

I don't know what the solution is. Soon your child will be a bit older and you'll be able to teach them some things to do in case of emergency.

It doesn't happen more often because parents of small children tend to be quite young themselves, and it's rare for young people to drop down dead without warning. The recent case in the news was awful but most 2 yr olds don't have 70 yr old fathers.

Barleysugar86 · 20/01/2024 00:30

Singleandproud · 19/01/2024 20:25

Teach the children to shout through the letter box.

Keep boxes of cereal /bottles of water in a low cupboard.

Instead of a phone you could buy a cheap tablet that is always plugged in and only has the phone icons with preprogrammed numbers, with photos so they know who they are phoning for an emergency
Very young children can be taught how to phone 999 in ab emergency, teach them your address.
Plenty of parents with medical conditions have to think like this.

I'm a single parent and Until DD was old enough to use a phone my parents liked me to send an emoji when I went to bed and another when I woke up. It wasn't intrusive but they knew we were ok and would ring if I forgot to check on us.

The address thing isn't as important as you'd think.

My two year old had the police round last week after phoning 999 on my mobile (nothing was wrong)- first I knew was when the police were on my door step!

She definitely doesn't know our address so they must trace the call.

Pookerrod · 20/01/2024 00:29

EmpressSoleil · Yesterday 20:38
**
@helpfulperson
I really wouldn't worry about your cats. They'd eat you before they starved to death!

😂 I was going to say this but worried I’d sound heartless. It’s very true though

Ladyj84 · 20/01/2024 00:28

So I had a worry because I have autism and epilepsy about this ages ago. We have a teen and 3 under 3..we decided to keep the landline because in an emergency our 3 year old knows how to work it and call grandma,grandad or daddy if our teen is away or out. We also made a snack drawer at there level which my hubby puts a day's worth of snacks in before he goes early to work each morning or they would eat a month's worth at once if they were allowed lol, but no they roughly know when they can go to it since I give them snacks same times each day. Also key safe we have one, only had to use it once when I had a fit, but was handy for ambulance guys to let themselves in and hubby just change pin after use. And the final thing I have a helper dog and she wil bark her head off on command or bark her head off if I have a fit and both sides of neighbours know that means there's something wrong because she's silent otherwise lol

Agree · 20/01/2024 00:27

I haven't read the thread but I don't think it's irrational at all and it's a miracle it doesn't happen more often really. People are very isolated nowadays - it's one thing living alone and all that goes with it but quite another if with a tiny child who cannot ask for help or use a phone.

I don't know what the solution is. Soon your child will be a bit older and you'll be able to teach them some things to do in case of emergency.

Midwinter91 · 20/01/2024 00:25

I’m thinking about this too. People are saying surely husband can call a couple of times a day but mine often works in remote areas with no signal.

Macramepotholder · 20/01/2024 00:21

I'm a very unanxious person but when the DC were small and I worked away a lot I did think about this a lot- especially because depending on the day of the week it could be several days before anyone noticed.

I rarely had a day when out of contact though. Dp is awful for never checking his phone so had to be told off a few times but is now good at responding. And the kids are much bigger so not to worry about any more.

I don't think it's an unreasonable concern and has reminded me to go over 999 with them again.

MeMySonAnd1 · 20/01/2024 00:15

Do you have friends that are in the same boat? Neighbours? Make sure you have a routine so if you are not seen you are missed. Building regularity is important.

My neighbours have keys to my house, I let them know if I am going away and up to a couple years ago, when my very retired neighbour got himself a lovely girlfriend, I was sure he would notice if we went off track with our routines. Now he is travelling all the time with her so, I hope the people at my office might be able to raise the alarm if they can’t find me for a day or two.

DS broke my heart when, at age 7, asked me to teach him to drive so he could get to the supermarket if something happened to me 🙁.

As others in this thread, he had full instructions on how to ask for help, how to escape the house and details or who he should go to from a very early age.

amoobaa · 20/01/2024 00:12

@maddiemookins16mum I was never anxious about things like this (despite having almost died three times, in really unexpected ways)… until (for a 4th time I almost died at home, again completely unexpectedly- all these near death experiences were entirely separate and unrelated), and the fourth time I was alone with my 1 year old.

I guess what I’m saying is, none of us really know how life will unfold. the fourth time it happened, it was nurse strike day… so when I called 999 I was put on hold. Then when I got through (the first time) they essentially told me nobody was coming for a very long time as they were only attending the most critical life threatening emergencies (didn’t realise at this stage that I was a critical life threatening emergency).

But there was a moment when I realised my life was really in danger and I was alone with my almost 2 year old, having tried to call my spouse, my Mum and my best friend (all of whom didn’t pick up- which never happens!) and it dawned on me that if nobody came, my child would be all alone for countless hours and nobody would know and nobody would be following up for a long time.

So for those of us who could go under the radar- I have no family or close friends living nearby, they would all need at least an hour and a half to get to me, it’s reasonable to want a plan in place.

In the end I just left my flat, without any shoes! And hobbled about knocking on doors… thinking to myself, I just need to find another human being so somebody knows I’m potentially dying and my child needs safeguarding until someone picks up the bloody phone!

We are in the process of moving house, to live nearer to my mum. It wasn’t the reason we’re moving but I’ll be a lot happier with her close by and I don’t consider this ‘anxious’. I think it’s sensible.

I’m still optimistic and it doesn’t keep me up at night- I’m aware these things are rare.

However, contingency plans are sensible… Unless the anxiety is so great that no amount of planning will calm the nerves (or it impacts on your day to day functioning) then plans are undoubtedly a good idea and they only become a drama if you need one and you don’t have one.

I wouldn’t say I don’t need a fire alarm because I’ve never been in a house fire and I doubt I’ll ever actually need one (I have actually been in a house fire). But I wouldn’t decide not to get life insurance because I don’t expect to die. You plan for the worst so you can put all your energy into hoping and striving for the best.

These things aren’t a problem at all, until they are.

@Mnk711 All that being said. I realise my experience might not be average and excess worry isn’t healthy. I’m just of the opinion that a bit of worry is sensible and can be easily managed with a sensible plan. So I hope you can create a plan that puts your mind at ease.

One thing I have done is learn how to activate a 999 call on my iPhone without the need to unlock it or press the number buttons. I’ve also made a note of people I think I could turn to if it happens a 5th time!

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 20/01/2024 00:09

@NoisyDachshunddd Terminology like "Who in their right mind" and "predatory corporate poaching" didn't convey the same sentiment as your later message does.

Kittylala · 20/01/2024 00:05

theduchessofspork · 19/01/2024 23:40

She does have connections - just not necs people who’d notice if they hadn’t seen her in 3 days. This is perfectly normal

@Mnk711 - what you need is a checking in app like this https://www.snugsafe.com/

that means your contacts will be notified if you don’t check in of a morning - so your kids are never going to be stuck for more than 24 hours. Plus have a low food cupboard as PPs say, an easy to get to water supply, and a spare phone somewhere low with 999 and contacts pre-programmed and teach the 3 year old to use it.

Back to my point - you need to strengthen those relationships. I did the same. BTW the app you suggested is also a good idea.

NoisyDachshunddd · 20/01/2024 00:03

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia yes of course, some people may not for whatever reason have a wide range of regular social contacts and would benefit from digital monitoring of whereabouts and status.

I would find this intrusive, dehumanising, and just .... not for me.

I've got two ND children and their experience is different from yours. One loves tracking apps, the other does not and feels no need for them.

That doesn't mean tech like this doesn't have a place, but I imagine for the majority of people (include many ND people) a technological solution like this isn't necessary or warranted.

If it works for you, go for it.

There are probably other solutions out there that work for other people with worries like this, is all I am saying.

Futb0l · 19/01/2024 23:53

I keep some food in low cupboards that my children can access in an emergency - boxes of cereal, jars of peanut butter. There are cups they can reach and a step stool by the sink so they can get their own water.

When eldest was about 3 i started teaching him that if mummy ever fell down and he was struggling to wake me, he is allowed to go and knock on neighbours.

The story about the little boy horrified me. Those types of stories are why i chose to live in a village that has a very lively community where people check on neighbours etc.

MariaLuna · 19/01/2024 23:51

Unless you have a medical condition it seems unlikely to happen tbh.

No, accidents happen all the time to all kinds of people.

I know of someone who tripped coming down the stairs and died.

I think it's good to be aware of this and take suitable precautions. (But not become paranoid). Like any other safety checks you would have at home to prevent accidents.

Try to widen your social circle too OP.

Breaks my heart what happened to that little boy.

RogueFemale · 19/01/2024 23:50

I think this is a totally reasonable worry. I have it myself about me and my cat, as I live alone, and can't teach him to call 999 if mummy didn't wake up.

Winter2020 · 19/01/2024 23:47

Hi OP,
It certainly seems like there is a market for a check in service to me - a bit like the service an older person can get with call buttons but with a check in each day and a plan if you remain not contactable.

I know where you are coming from. My husband has taken my eldest on holiday before and left me with my little one and I have thought if something happened to me no one might know for a couple of days leaving my little one at risk. My husband and eldest son might phone or Whatsapp but might not think anything was amiss if I didn't reply.

It could be a business opportunity for someone and a possible solution to avoiding further tragedies.

I have always thought it is strange that when you have a child in school them not turning up one morning without letting the school know is a safeguarding concern but our little ones can go months or even years without checking in with any kind of authority.

RedHelenB · 19/01/2024 23:42

Minglingpringle · 19/01/2024 20:16

But I think you’re being over-anxious. It’s super unlikely.

This. If you're really worried make sure there are water bottles dotted around the house. Would your dh really not contact you at all in 2 weeks?

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 19/01/2024 23:40

NoisyDachshunddd · 19/01/2024 23:23

@TeaGinandFags Who in their right mind is tapping the email link several times a day to notify the ether they are still alive? This is crazy-making stuff, and unsustainable.

Just have normal social contacts. There's no need for this predatory corporate poaching on people's ultra-rare tragedies.

The fact that several posters have mentioned this very specific tech on a single thread makes me a bit... suspicious. Vultures. Everywhere.

I'm autistic with several ADHD traits, so having "normal social contacts" isn't a thing for me, nor is remembering to send a daily message unprompted.

The relative I'd be messaging is also autistic and loses track of the day of the week, so probably wouldn't notice if I didn't message for a few days.

IT workers are familiar with watchdog timers and it makes sense for them to apply that principle to monitoring people. Autistic people are overrepresented amongst IT workers so it's likely that the developers of these "predatory" tools were motivated to meet the needs of themselves and their friends and families.

Watchdog timer - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watchdog_timer

theduchessofspork · 19/01/2024 23:40

Kittylala · 19/01/2024 20:36

Why not start making friends and creating connections yourself?

She does have connections - just not necs people who’d notice if they hadn’t seen her in 3 days. This is perfectly normal

@Mnk711 - what you need is a checking in app like this https://www.snugsafe.com/

that means your contacts will be notified if you don’t check in of a morning - so your kids are never going to be stuck for more than 24 hours. Plus have a low food cupboard as PPs say, an easy to get to water supply, and a spare phone somewhere low with 999 and contacts pre-programmed and teach the 3 year old to use it.

Snug Safety - Free Daily Check in service for seniors living alone

Have peace of mind that someone will know if you need help. Over 1,000,000 check-ins so far.

https://www.snugsafe.com/

PyongyangKipperbang · 19/01/2024 23:39

Inastatus · 19/01/2024 22:58

@Seasmoke7 - not for service families. My nephew works on a submarine and can be non communicative for months.

My Uncle at the height of his career would regularly spend 6 months on a sub with absolutely zero contact, my aunt said that the worst thing about it for her was knowing that he could have died on day one and she wouldnt know until 6 months later. He said the same thing about her.

Tbry24 · 19/01/2024 23:36

Teach the toddler 999. Mine knew how to do it by about 18 months.

DrFoxtrot · 19/01/2024 23:35

I thought about this when mine were little so cereal was always accessible. Although, if they're very little that's still not ideal! A good support network of people who regularly check in and will notice your absence quickly is essential.

Magixx · 19/01/2024 23:26

OP do you have an Alexa? I believe if this is connected to a phone on the alexa app you can call an ‘emergency contact’ through there. My 3 year old regularly asks alexa to play music she likes so this may be easier to teach than using the phone. You could set up an emergency contact e.g. family member and teach 3 yo to say “alexa call for help” and it should send a message to the contact.

PSEnny · 19/01/2024 23:26

I have worried about this. 6 months is young but your 3 year old could be shown some basic things like using the phone in an emergency. I always keep easy access food in low cupboards and leave 2 full water bottles out for my nearly 7 year old just in case.

Rockmehardplace · 19/01/2024 23:25

This was my biggest fear living alone with a pre verbal child whilst waiting for a heart transplant. I had a plan tho. I always always took the key out of the door once I locked it at night so someone with a key could let themselves in. I arranged with a few family members that if they didnt see me log into messsenger by say, 11am, they would call (I didn’t have to send them a message, just open the app). I asked nursery to call my emergency contact if I didn’t bring my child to nursery and didn’t call to say they wouldn’t be in. And taught my child how to dial my mums number on the landline, even if he couldn’t speak to her.