Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my aunt, in a care home, should be allowed more than one shower a week?

140 replies

LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 15:36

My aunt is 92 and has been in a care home for 4 weeks for respite care. The fees are £1300 a week. It emerged this morning that residents are only bathed or showered once a week. She washes herself with a flannel and soap every day- no help is available for this.

I asked the question of the 'senior' on duty and was told it is all they can manage and there is a rota. Some residents have alzheimers/dementia and can be difficult and some have medical conditions so must have more baths/showers. In the month she has been there she has never had a bath- not enough time for that and has only had 4 showers.

I was horrified. I thought they must be short staffed but apparently not.

AIBU to think if you are paying £1300 a week for a care home, you should have the choice of a bath or shower every day?

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 18:51

EmmaEmerald · 19/01/2024 18:09

I think this is dreadful!

We paid similar for mum's respite and they asked residents every day if they needed help with showering or washing.

That's one of the major reasons for the fees. That option should be available, surely.

Are they understaffed generally, is it a commercial thing or they can't get staff? If the latter, that's one thing but if they are taking that fee and choosing to be understaffed, that's dreadful.

I don't think there were any rooms with baths though. Mum was in that home twice.

What's it like otherwise?

Edited

The Senior said they are not under-staffed. The staff all local and all were white that I have seen and speak with Tyneside accents- no language difficulties. The staff I have seen are patient and kind . Perhaps the staffing ratios are low.

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 19/01/2024 18:47

I would think that warrants complaints.

We're in the SouthEast so it was slightly more than that. Furniture was fine. There was a phone and a TV. The carers were lovely but also lots of them.

Mum eats very little and has a lot of stomach issues. The people who took the food order used to ask if she needed adjustments to food.

Interestingly, the building next door was a care home. A couple of staff had left there after very short periods and told us it was not nice for staff or residents. Presumably a problem with senior mgmt that trickled down and affected everyone. I asked if it was understaffed and got a tight lipped "they just have a very different approach to care".

There was a six month gap, maybe more, between mum's stays and we saw mostly the same staff, which is a good sign.

In her circle, we've known four other people use that care home and they've all said the same, that it was good, that staff were kind. I know the nurse who did mum's second assessment for admission was quite abrupt but mum said after that she was lovely. They have a waiting list so she probably had to really justify each person she admits as being "in need", one person's money is the same another.

They have dementia patients on another floor, with coded exit and entry to prevent wandering. I presume those patients pay a lot more though.

I saw three care homes in the area though, and that was the only one I liked.

tokesqueen · 19/01/2024 18:33

That equates to £7.70 an hour. For 24/7 care plus food, heating, lighting, maintenance, equipment, laundry, staff wages, insurance, council tax, uniforms, entertainment, gardening etc etc.
I paid more than that per hour in nursery fees twenty years ago.
I was in and out of care homes for many years as a district nurse. The quality of care was massively variable but I don't know any that had the capacity to bathe patients every day.

Nervousaboutholidays · 19/01/2024 18:32

LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 18:26

She would like a shower every other day- that's what she has at home with paid for care coming in 3 x a day. She is paying the whole £1300 herself.

If I had known earlier I would have been more pushy but she is returning home mid-week . She has spinal problems that make washing herself difficult other than her hands and face but is not being helped at all.

There is a hairdresser and she has been having her hair washed and blow dried once a week at a cost of an additional £20.00.

£1300 a week is very expensive for a care home up here in the north-east. The room is very small with a single bed and a rickety chest of drawers that the knobs fall off when you pull the drawer, and a small rickety fibreboard wardrobe. There is one grubby looking chair and that's it. No tv in her room, no phone in her room. The other residents are clearly less compos mentis than she is and either sleep or wander the corridors not speaking to anyone, in a world of their own. She says her food is often presented cold and she was humiliated by the chef being called out because she commented on it being cold. A carer over heard and asked 'Are you complaining?' She said she was commenting rather than complaining. The carer brought the chef who she said asked 'What's your problem?' She explained and his response was 'I'll see what I can do next time to keep it warmer.' Didn't take it away and heat it up. She says it hasn't been any better.

However, the place is clean (if dated and very tiredand cheaply done) and most of the carers are very nice. She says there are two who are very abrupt and speak to her as if she is a child. Mind you she's no pushover and will speak up and can be very awkward if she sets her mind to it. She has complained about other residents going into her room and taking things (not from malice but she said once it happened at night and it's quite disturbing - they just pick up stuff.) My friend's mum is there and is one of the wanderers- she si very difficult to deal with.

I'm unimpressed with it . And it terrifies me that this is where and how we end up.

She is moving into an extra care setting near where she lives when a flat becomes available.

Edited

This needs flagging to CQC and social services. There are some major safeguarding issues going on here.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/01/2024 18:28

Flopsythebunny · 19/01/2024 18:23

They must have been rich then. we didn't even have a bathroom until 1973, just a tin bath hung in the scullery that was filled every Sunday for everyone to bath in. My mother would wash her hair in the kitchen sink.

Not that she used it that often, but my mother's council (so originally Corporation) house that was built in the 1930s had a bathroom from construction, as did all of the houses in the street, irrespective of their layout. All downstairs, as that was preferred for workmen coming straight in and going to wash before entering the living room or kitchen, but richness had nothing to do with it.

LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 18:26

She would like a shower every other day- that's what she has at home with paid for care coming in 3 x a day. She is paying the whole £1300 herself.

If I had known earlier I would have been more pushy but she is returning home mid-week . She has spinal problems that make washing herself difficult other than her hands and face but is not being helped at all.

There is a hairdresser and she has been having her hair washed and blow dried once a week at a cost of an additional £20.00.

£1300 a week is very expensive for a care home up here in the north-east. The room is very small with a single bed and a rickety chest of drawers that the knobs fall off when you pull the drawer, and a small rickety fibreboard wardrobe. There is one grubby looking chair and that's it. No tv in her room, no phone in her room. The other residents are clearly less compos mentis than she is and either sleep or wander the corridors not speaking to anyone, in a world of their own. She says her food is often presented cold and she was humiliated by the chef being called out because she commented on it being cold. A carer over heard and asked 'Are you complaining?' She said she was commenting rather than complaining. The carer brought the chef who she said asked 'What's your problem?' She explained and his response was 'I'll see what I can do next time to keep it warmer.' Didn't take it away and heat it up. She says it hasn't been any better.

However, the place is clean (if dated and very tiredand cheaply done) and most of the carers are very nice. She says there are two who are very abrupt and speak to her as if she is a child. Mind you she's no pushover and will speak up and can be very awkward if she sets her mind to it. She has complained about other residents going into her room and taking things (not from malice but she said once it happened at night and it's quite disturbing - they just pick up stuff.) My friend's mum is there and is one of the wanderers- she si very difficult to deal with.

I'm unimpressed with it . And it terrifies me that this is where and how we end up.

She is moving into an extra care setting near where she lives when a flat becomes available.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/01/2024 18:25

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 19/01/2024 16:39

Hair wash 2/3 times a week? Why?

Care homes are usually very hot, so there's sweat.

Being less mobile means that pressure can cause sores on the back of the head - which need to be checked (and preferably prevented or stopped before they deepen or get infected).

It reduces the likelihood of tangles developing into matts that have to be cut out or stressful brushing.

Older people can still get nits. They can also have skin conditions such as eczema and psoriasis, both of which can leave the scalp vulnerable to infection (from MRSA, for example), splitting and burning/itching sensations.

It soothes the scalp, preventing itching, which can drive anybody to distraction.

It involves close care, which enables the carer to observe any changes, perhaps in vision, whether facial muscles have dropped to indicate a stroke or TIA, neck strength, coordination and bruising (for any cause, including medical, accidental or even non-accidental ones).

It can be soothing and relaxing. It's gentle, positive and safe contact with another human being, warm water, shampoo and conditioner, an element of scalp massage

And residents are still entitled to dignity, which will mean being clean & fresh, which includes their hair.

Why wouldn't you want a vulnerable person to be given that level of care? The alternative is leaving them feeling itchy, looking dirty, perhaps with ratty hair or headlice, infection, never feeling a pleasurable touch, of nice scent and warm water and possibly something serious being missed.

viridiano · 19/01/2024 18:23

There are not many people living in the modern UK who would only shower/ bath once a week, so elderly people in care homes shouldn't be expected to be OK with this, either.

I would hate to only bathe once a week.

Sadly it's the state of care, but it's not good enough.

We all need to try and work to make this better - because we will all be there one day.

Flopsythebunny · 19/01/2024 18:23

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 19/01/2024 17:34

Was this really normal for that generation?

My parents (boomers), grandparents (born between 1908 and 1921) and great grandparents (youngest born 1895) all bathed daily and seem to think it was normal. No showers though, and hair washed once a week.

They must have been rich then. we didn't even have a bathroom until 1973, just a tin bath hung in the scullery that was filled every Sunday for everyone to bath in. My mother would wash her hair in the kitchen sink.

Savedpassword · 19/01/2024 18:21

How often would your aunt like to have a shower? Speak to the Home Manager rather than a care assistant and see what can be agreed.

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 19/01/2024 18:20

When I was in hospital recently, I noticed that the ward residents (some there for weeks, some days) weren't offered hairwashes almost ever, but a strip wash daily. It wasn't enough, as people get older they can leak urine more easily, find it hard to reach round the back, and that's without mentioning the poor incontinent people. I don't think many of them were clean at all, and some had ulcers/things that really needed to be kept clean to stop skin problems, rashes, irritation at the very least.

I had my visitors help me with a hairwash twice, by asking for bowls/water, and had a full strip wash every day, again, asking for lots of water, bowls, soap, there was no issue if you asked, but it wasn't encouraged. I also quickly had a hairwash prior to surgery by kind of insisting. They did change the beds every day and did a good job mostly, but the more you ask, the more you get.

No-one would think aged 50 or 60 it would be fine to have one shower a week, and just wave a cloth around at other times (fine if you really can wash yourself thoroughly but many can't) so why at 75 or 80?

2023forme · 19/01/2024 18:16

oOiluvfriendsOo · 19/01/2024 17:42

Things are only going to get worse, if the people being brought in are anything to go by.
The government and the NHS are to blame at the state the NHS is going to be in in the next 5/10 years.
We have 3 new staff and not 1 of them has a caring bone in their body. Ignore patients asking for toilet, ignore buzzers, fraudulently fill in care rounding charts, fall asleep at the nurses station is just the tip of the iceberg.

So getting paid the same as us to do very little.

Oh and openly admit they don't want to be there.

Every staff member has complained as they are a danger to patients. They have been spoken to by ward manager multiple times, nothing changes. It's like they're doing it on purpose.
Any other job you would be sacked, not the NHS.

A simple 3 month trial would root out those not suited to the job but no, let's just give everyone a contract and you core staff will just have to like it or lump it.
Anything to up the numbers but will in effect cause the good staff left to look elsewhere.

Something needs to change.

Indeed. I spoke about care homes but I know hospitals are in the same position. Foreign staff with limited background checks and training. In the hospital where a friend works, one of the agency carers was getting booked in for the night shift and the nurse co-ordinator noticed the person gave a different name to what was on the ID - turned out they were not the carer but rather their friend was and had given them their ID. A bit like uber drivers swapping their IDs. It’s quite frightening.

EmmaEmerald · 19/01/2024 18:09

I think this is dreadful!

We paid similar for mum's respite and they asked residents every day if they needed help with showering or washing.

That's one of the major reasons for the fees. That option should be available, surely.

Are they understaffed generally, is it a commercial thing or they can't get staff? If the latter, that's one thing but if they are taking that fee and choosing to be understaffed, that's dreadful.

I don't think there were any rooms with baths though. Mum was in that home twice.

What's it like otherwise?

Christmasisalmosthere · 19/01/2024 18:02

I've a young relative in a nursing home due to a serious neurological issue and unfortunately have had to complain on numerous occasions about his treatment. He's seriously underweight and I was shocked to see the meal he was given on an occasion when he was too unwell to go to the dining room. He has brain damage and what it did uncover was that they asked him what he wanted to eat and if he said he wanted one fish finger that was what he got. This is despite the fact that he'd have forgotten 2 minutes after ordering.
Numerous other issues which I won't go into but put complaints in writing and it's surprising how quickly they act upon it. The photograph of the single fish finger on a large dinner plate was hard to argue with.

KimberleyClark · 19/01/2024 18:01

If people have dementia they can be highly resistant to having a shower at all. My mum was like this.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 19/01/2024 17:58

Same happened to my DM and I requested an extra shower which was added to her care plan. She is washed down twice a day though. We also pay for her to have a wash and blow dry with the visiting hairdresser.

MILTOBE · 19/01/2024 17:54

Does she actually want a shower more frequently? My mum is in her 90s and has one shower a week - she is exhausted afterwards and sleeps for a couple of hours. She would hate to have that every day.

MILTOBE · 19/01/2024 17:53

Stanislas · 19/01/2024 16:13

My friend 88 in a care home may have grown up with a weekly bath but I’m pretty sure that in her own home,three bathrooms for the last 55 years was used to two showers or baths a day until she had to move into the care home. I would want a bath every day ,hate showers as I don’t feel clean. I would prefer a flannel wash.

Use a flannel to wash yourself in the shower!

Nervousaboutholidays · 19/01/2024 17:51

If her wish is for a daily shower the home should be making that happen without excuses.

SapphireEyes88 · 19/01/2024 17:49

I've worked in care homes and sadly this is standard. They should be offering help with personal care... We used to give a full strip wash in the morning at the sink and then freshen face and hands at night. If there were incontinence issues we would wash them as and when necessary.
Unfortunately the law at the time was 1 carer to 10 residents or 1 to 8 residents with dementia. If chronically low staffed it would be impossible for us to fit in baths and showers, at one point I stayed on an extra 4 hours and bathed 6 residents without pay because they hadn't been bathed in months...
In short, it sucks and the carers will wish they could do more, but the owners give us 8 minutes to wake someone up, wash and dress them and get the to the breakfast table - they don't care about allowing for having a nice hot bath and a soak for aching joints.
I'm sorry that it sucks so much and I truly wish it were better.

helpfulperson · 19/01/2024 17:45

My Dad with dementia had one a week and that was a stressful event for all. My mum has 2 or 3 but wouldn't care if she didn't. If your aunt wants more that should be facilitated

kerstina · 19/01/2024 17:45

I do feel there should be a bit of a partnership with care home staff and relatives. If I am visiting mum I would always take her to the toilet myself not just expect a carer to take over. I can see they are busy. I try and help them out not just criticise. I try and pop in as much as I can as she needs a lot of encouragement to drink. In an ideal world I think staff ratios should be much higher for dementia patients especially.

oOiluvfriendsOo · 19/01/2024 17:42

Things are only going to get worse, if the people being brought in are anything to go by.
The government and the NHS are to blame at the state the NHS is going to be in in the next 5/10 years.
We have 3 new staff and not 1 of them has a caring bone in their body. Ignore patients asking for toilet, ignore buzzers, fraudulently fill in care rounding charts, fall asleep at the nurses station is just the tip of the iceberg.

So getting paid the same as us to do very little.

Oh and openly admit they don't want to be there.

Every staff member has complained as they are a danger to patients. They have been spoken to by ward manager multiple times, nothing changes. It's like they're doing it on purpose.
Any other job you would be sacked, not the NHS.

A simple 3 month trial would root out those not suited to the job but no, let's just give everyone a contract and you core staff will just have to like it or lump it.
Anything to up the numbers but will in effect cause the good staff left to look elsewhere.

Something needs to change.

Rocknrollstar · 19/01/2024 17:38

DM had carers three times a day, paid for mainly by social services, and had a shower every morning.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · 19/01/2024 17:34

Was this really normal for that generation?

My parents (boomers), grandparents (born between 1908 and 1921) and great grandparents (youngest born 1895) all bathed daily and seem to think it was normal. No showers though, and hair washed once a week.