Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my aunt, in a care home, should be allowed more than one shower a week?

140 replies

LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 15:36

My aunt is 92 and has been in a care home for 4 weeks for respite care. The fees are £1300 a week. It emerged this morning that residents are only bathed or showered once a week. She washes herself with a flannel and soap every day- no help is available for this.

I asked the question of the 'senior' on duty and was told it is all they can manage and there is a rota. Some residents have alzheimers/dementia and can be difficult and some have medical conditions so must have more baths/showers. In the month she has been there she has never had a bath- not enough time for that and has only had 4 showers.

I was horrified. I thought they must be short staffed but apparently not.

AIBU to think if you are paying £1300 a week for a care home, you should have the choice of a bath or shower every day?

OP posts:
TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 20/01/2024 02:37

14 years of the Tories. A general narrative in the press that all immigration is bad. An aging population. This is the result. Votes matter.

DespairingandDesperate · 20/01/2024 01:00

Surely the standard of care should be that patients/residents are kept clean. For some that may require one bath per week; for others that may require daily bathing.

Is your aunt unclean OP?

LuluBlakey1 · 20/01/2024 00:54

Peanutsforthebluetit · 20/01/2024 00:29

“I have no idea how many staff they would need. It must depend on residents' needs- physical and mental and medical conditions. I have no idea how staffing is rota'd- are there more staff on at key times? 7-9.30am, 6.30-9pm? That must be the biggest demand I would think. Do they overlap rotas then? I don't know. Do you? Can you explain how it works?”

@LuluBlakey1 ,No they tend to work 12 hour shifts, usually 8am to 8pm but it varies from home to home.

Some staff can be on for an early shift eg 8 til 13.00 or late shift such as 13.00 til 20.00. Extra staff can be brought in for the half shift if needed but it won’t be to provide showering specifically.
Also, If a staff member is owed hours, they may work a short shift instead of 12 hours and that would leave the unit short staffed so it works both ways.

I did work at a nursing home and they had a reg nurse and 2 carers for 22 residents.
Majority of residents needed 2 staff to wash them, dress and up in chair.
Nurse would do meds/ dressings /GP round/ update care plans/ order blister pack meds etc

The 2 carers would finish getting people up by about 11.(Several would have breakfast in bed)
If they had to give even most a bath or shower it would take all day and nothing else would be done. The residents already up would be neglected.

Sometimes family would come in and help with showering if that’s what their relative wanted. That’s why I asked.
I get why you don’t want to do this.

This one has about 45 residents over two floors- the top floor is a dementia unit. There seem to be more patients up there with about 18 on the ground floor, some of whom also have dementia. There are 4 staff on the ground floor at any one time. Two seem to be more senior and two more junior. No idea if they only work on that floor.
My aunt needs no nursing care and could be showered by one member of staff- she is at home and has to sit on a bath seat for the shower. Here there is a proper wet room and she sits in a chair. She can dress herself.

OP posts:
margegunderson · 20/01/2024 00:35

Shoppingfiend · 19/01/2024 17:29

It can take ages to get patients to the shower , into shower, clothes off, helped to wash,out,dried ,dressed, helped/wheeled back to room. Will need someone with them most likely all the time for the majority.

Rellies could pop in and do it I’m sure if they needed .

My dad isn't able to shower without help. I don't believe it would be good for his dignity to have his daughter help with this.

Peanutsforthebluetit · 20/01/2024 00:29

“I have no idea how many staff they would need. It must depend on residents' needs- physical and mental and medical conditions. I have no idea how staffing is rota'd- are there more staff on at key times? 7-9.30am, 6.30-9pm? That must be the biggest demand I would think. Do they overlap rotas then? I don't know. Do you? Can you explain how it works?”

@LuluBlakey1 ,No they tend to work 12 hour shifts, usually 8am to 8pm but it varies from home to home.

Some staff can be on for an early shift eg 8 til 13.00 or late shift such as 13.00 til 20.00. Extra staff can be brought in for the half shift if needed but it won’t be to provide showering specifically.
Also, If a staff member is owed hours, they may work a short shift instead of 12 hours and that would leave the unit short staffed so it works both ways.

I did work at a nursing home and they had a reg nurse and 2 carers for 22 residents.
Majority of residents needed 2 staff to wash them, dress and up in chair.
Nurse would do meds/ dressings /GP round/ update care plans/ order blister pack meds etc

The 2 carers would finish getting people up by about 11.(Several would have breakfast in bed)
If they had to give even most a bath or shower it would take all day and nothing else would be done. The residents already up would be neglected.

Sometimes family would come in and help with showering if that’s what their relative wanted. That’s why I asked.
I get why you don’t want to do this.

DesiredAffect · 20/01/2024 00:24

Sorry to say it’s normal now and takes much more time to shower or bath someone then a flannel wash does.

LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 23:48

lookingforMolly · 19/01/2024 20:08

To the pp who made the comment about it being good all the carers in a particular home were 'white' with local accents - sorry but can black & Asian carers not be British with British accents too?? How racist!
And also I know many good foreign carers & nurses with foreign accents actually!!

It was me, I was responding to someone who asked about staffing difficulties, commented on how they work in a home with foreign carers who barely speak English which causes problems and don't actually want to do the job of caring. I was saying none of that is an issue here- they are fully staffed with local people who all seem very nice to the residents.

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 23:42

Peanutsforthebluetit · 19/01/2024 22:09

YANBU for thinking this should be ideal.

However, if there are 20-30 residents who all need assistance from one or two staff and they all need a daily bath or shower, how many staff members do you think that would require ?

No, they are not short staffed to provide care but that can’t include a daily shower for all, unfortunately.
Would you be able to help with showering ?

I have no idea how many staff they would need. It must depend on residents' needs- physical and mental and medical conditions. I have no idea how staffing is rota'd- are there more staff on at key times? 7-9.30am, 6.30-9pm? That must be the biggest demand I would think. Do they overlap rotas then? I don't know. Do you? Can you explain how it works?

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 23:38

MereDintofPandiculation · 19/01/2024 22:21

@redheadsaregreat It was explained above how self-funders are in effect subsiding those placed and funded by the LA. It's estimated that the typical self-funder pays 40% more than the LA rate.

Interestingly, in the conversation with her social worker about her options, the social worker was very quick to say they would not fund a continuing place in this care home if she remained and her savings ran out, because of the costs.
She didn't think anyway it is the right place for my aunt long-term and my aunt does not want to stay there. I can see she is more frail in the few weeks she has been there because she is just sitting all day.

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 23:32

Peanutsforthebluetit · 19/01/2024 22:09

YANBU for thinking this should be ideal.

However, if there are 20-30 residents who all need assistance from one or two staff and they all need a daily bath or shower, how many staff members do you think that would require ?

No, they are not short staffed to provide care but that can’t include a daily shower for all, unfortunately.
Would you be able to help with showering ?

I have no intention of showering her. She is an aunt by marriage (she married my dad's brother) and we have never been close. She has always been quite a difficult person. I don't have a great deal of affection for her but, as she is now alone (apart from a sister who is elderly, lives some distance away and they don't get along at all) I have helped her. I do her shopping, take her to medical appointments, the dentist, out for coffee/lunch , organise her house repairs, wash her bedding, ask her here for lunch, but I have no intention of helping with personal care. And if she is paying £1300 a week, I don't think there should be any expectation that anyone would.
I would have helped my mum- I would have done anything to help my mum and did but this woman is not someone I have ever been close to and she has caused difficulties in my dad's family throughout her marriage.

I could- as well as having a full-time job, 3 small DC and a house to run- but I don't want to and shouldn't have to. She is paying £1300 a week for respite care for herself.

OP posts:
Peanutsforthebluetit · 19/01/2024 23:31

If there are 20 or 30 residents and they pay 13 hundred a week, then yes, they should have enough staff to provide more than a shower a week.

@ChardonnaysBeastlyCat, agree, but the reality is most don’t and they have 2-3 care staff for 30 residents, use supermarket own brand for food and most of the time residents get a poor deal.
Profit comes first unfortunately.

LuluBlakey1 · 19/01/2024 23:21

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 19/01/2024 19:28

do you have anything like "home instead" in your area they are more expensive but do hour long visits and will get proper meals etc

This is sort of what she has when she is at home. 3 x 30 minute visits or 3 x 45 minute visits.

OP posts:
MereDintofPandiculation · 19/01/2024 22:21

@redheadsaregreat It was explained above how self-funders are in effect subsiding those placed and funded by the LA. It's estimated that the typical self-funder pays 40% more than the LA rate.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 19/01/2024 22:21

Peanutsforthebluetit · 19/01/2024 22:09

YANBU for thinking this should be ideal.

However, if there are 20-30 residents who all need assistance from one or two staff and they all need a daily bath or shower, how many staff members do you think that would require ?

No, they are not short staffed to provide care but that can’t include a daily shower for all, unfortunately.
Would you be able to help with showering ?

If there are 20 or 30 residents and they pay 13 hundred a week, then yes, they should have enough staff to provide more than a shower a week.

Peanutsforthebluetit · 19/01/2024 22:09

YANBU for thinking this should be ideal.

However, if there are 20-30 residents who all need assistance from one or two staff and they all need a daily bath or shower, how many staff members do you think that would require ?

No, they are not short staffed to provide care but that can’t include a daily shower for all, unfortunately.
Would you be able to help with showering ?

greengreengrass25 · 19/01/2024 22:05

I don't think I would want to see my dm naked, I'm too prudish let alone help her shower

Isn't that the whole point of the care home

hashbrownsandwich · 19/01/2024 22:01

It's down to whether the person wants a shower/bath. Good care is formed from patient choice and clinical expertise.

Vettrianofan · 19/01/2024 21:59

NewYear24 · 19/01/2024 17:32

Rellies could pop in and do it I’m sure if they needed

My DM’s home costs £1600 per week, I’m not popping in to shower her.

At least you would know it was done properly, and with care.

MedSchoolRat · 19/01/2024 21:34

Bathing is quite a flash point with a lot of older adults in care homes, some of the residents get quite violent in their resistance.

redheadsaregreat · 19/01/2024 21:28

MILTOBE · 19/01/2024 20:55

Yes, my mum showered daily in her 80s but when she has a shower now it takes about 40 minutes. In a care home there would be two carers doing it. They haven't the staff to spend 40 minutes x 2 on one-to-one care like that.

But it wouldn't take 40 mins with carers. Patient sits on stool in shower cubical. Carers use hand held shower head to wash patient. Its quick. It has to be to ensure patient doesn't get chilly

PinkflowersWhiteBerries · 19/01/2024 21:25

@redheadsaregreat - fellow ginger, love the name. Sorry this is long, but my understanding of the current position where I live.

As I understand it , with care homes here, there is a headline price; the newly opened one in my town is £2300 per week.
You can book yourself in at that rate , plus extras for hairdressing etc. if you can prove you have 2 years worth of capital to pay for your place.

If you are subject to a care assessment, your contributions will be assessed based on your available funds. In Scotland if you have more than £32750 in savings/ house value, you will pay the £2300 less whatever the care assessment says you need for personal care, which is free in Scotland. It’s about £200. So you are then paying £2100, and the council pays the balance.
if you need nursing care, the council pays another £100 , so you pay £2000. The home will get your state pension so you end up paying £1900 or so per week.while the state pays about £100, and the council £300. Home will still get its £2300

But if you have zero savings above £32750,, the council pays whatever their agreed rate is - it’s about £850 per week. So in that case the home gets the £850 plus the £100 ( circa £950) or so state pension, for the very same type of room that the private funder pays £2300 per week for. Home gets the £950. Swallows the ‘loss’ or basically subsidises the funded residents.

It has recently been an issue locally as the NHS and council needed to buy space at several local care homes, for palliative care and dementia care to free up hospital beds, and that is the maximum they can pay.

All numbers are approximate by the way.

I am not in this field but had to do my research for a relative.

MILTOBE · 19/01/2024 20:55

Yes, my mum showered daily in her 80s but when she has a shower now it takes about 40 minutes. In a care home there would be two carers doing it. They haven't the staff to spend 40 minutes x 2 on one-to-one care like that.

KitchenSinkLlama · 19/01/2024 20:30

I've never heard such nonsense about elderly people having one bath or shower a week as what they are used to. My parents (80's) showered daily when I was a child and my mother still does. My father who died a couple of years ago was bathed daily in his care home. The home was wonderful and ensured his dignity to the very end.

redheadsaregreat · 19/01/2024 20:29

PinkflowersWhiteBerries · 19/01/2024 16:28

I am in Scotland and would echo that once a week is pretty standard ime. However that’s still one more per week than MIL managed on her own. She wasn’t in the home for long, in a dementia ward, and DH requested that she be helped to shower, but the staff just nodded and nothing changed.

They really were very busy from what I could see and many patients needed multiple visits every day, for toileting, clean up, help with food etc.

£1300 per week may seem like a lot. But it’s less than £200 per day for bed, board, and physical care and assistance, and many of the residents will be paid for by the council at a lower rate for the same week, for the same load on staff resources- MIL was assessed at less than £300 per week plus her state pension as her contribution.

We really do need to do a better job of understanding the needs of the elderly and what we each need to do to provide for ourselves, and what we need to be prepared to sacrifice by way of taxes, to meet the needs of those vulnerable people who cannot pay those fees.

I am sorry for your aunts situation Op. It is heartbreaking witnessing the care system at close hand.

So people paying are subsidising other residents? That can't be right. Why would some people be paying for other people?

redheadsaregreat · 19/01/2024 20:27

Stanislas · 19/01/2024 16:13

My friend 88 in a care home may have grown up with a weekly bath but I’m pretty sure that in her own home,three bathrooms for the last 55 years was used to two showers or baths a day until she had to move into the care home. I would want a bath every day ,hate showers as I don’t feel clean. I would prefer a flannel wash.

Why wouldn't you feel clean after a shower? This is the weirdness thing I've read on mumsnet. People who shower don't just stand limp under running water. They use soap and a flannel, sponge and/or hands to rub