Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
cherish123 · 20/01/2024 00:13

He would only have to pay half the nursery fees.
£900 does seem a lot. Child related expenses are not £1800 per month. If nursery was £1000, that leaves £800 for food, clothes etc. The fact she has 4k per month is irrelevant. She is entitled to the money regardless of what she earns.

ArnieLinson · 19/01/2024 23:52

Your brother is not doing any parenting. None of your brother’s family are bothering spending time with the child either. All a bit shit for her really.

where is he staying at the weekend and does he have sole care of her, including overnight?

kittensinthekitchen · 19/01/2024 23:46

I don't know why some of you are assuming he even sees his daughter one day a week. @frimscratxh 's deliberate omission of how often he bothers seeing her suggests it may be much, much less often.

Mumto2kids86 · 19/01/2024 22:06

I think the money is reasonable. The amount of time he commits to his daughter and helps raise her is pitiful. Not even 48 hours a week. I would tell him to say no to the money but start showing up and doing his bit!

Teder · 19/01/2024 22:01

He’s not a deadbeat, I agree. However, he could certainly do better.

Does he see her all day Sunday every weekend? Being generous and assuming he does, she is parenting solo for 6 days per week. That is costly in terms of time and money.

bringincrazyback · 19/01/2024 21:59

Quite honestly I think some of these exes (and possibly some of the MNers who post on these threads) wouldn't be satisfied unless their ex was left with little but the clothes they stood up in. (I speak from experience btw.) She sounds grabby to me.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 19/01/2024 21:40

Hii93 · 19/01/2024 18:36

They are not in the UK I think I read so they can't

Thanks, I'd missed that bit. Obvs not a helpful suggestion!

AllTheChaos · 19/01/2024 21:26

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 19/01/2024 19:30

More context needed. He gives £900. What is his monthly wage?

Is he paying 50% of a full time nursery place? Is he paying 50% of his childs rent, bills and food?

Has he formalised his split with his ex and agreed a financial settlement? If they have a mortgaged property costing £1000 a month he cant simply move out, refuse to pay it and expect her to fund it entirely, they need to agree a full settlement.

Op has said the brother clears £3,500 a month, and that nursery fees are £1,200 a month. So he pays half the fees then £300 a month towards all other child-related costs.

peppermintcrisp · 19/01/2024 20:45

Reverse

WristCandy · 19/01/2024 20:22

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 19/01/2024 19:36

What does "every weekend he can" mean? Does it mean every weekend? Monthly?

It comes across like hes upped sticks and is now whining that his responsibilities are still there. He plays dad, at best, once a week in person. She does 90% of they childcare, why shouldn't he cover 90% of the costs.

What if she had left for London and left him holding the baby in the town where he "couldn't get a job" and then moaned that he just wanted her money

Spot on. These guys and their handmaidens never even consider this.

Zanatdy · 19/01/2024 20:17

No he shouldn’t pay this, he should tell her to pay it from the maintenance

Dontbehorridhenry · 19/01/2024 20:08

He is your brother and you want to protect him, but he did choose to move away. Why did he have to move what was he working as before? It can't have been the only option.

He should live closer and help raise his child. He can't do it one day a week unfortunately. The problem would cease if he just stuck to set hours and made it a priority.

It sounds like a lot until you deduct childcare then it's nothing. That's a joint cost.

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 19/01/2024 19:36

What does "every weekend he can" mean? Does it mean every weekend? Monthly?

It comes across like hes upped sticks and is now whining that his responsibilities are still there. He plays dad, at best, once a week in person. She does 90% of they childcare, why shouldn't he cover 90% of the costs.

What if she had left for London and left him holding the baby in the town where he "couldn't get a job" and then moaned that he just wanted her money

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 19/01/2024 19:30

More context needed. He gives £900. What is his monthly wage?

Is he paying 50% of a full time nursery place? Is he paying 50% of his childs rent, bills and food?

Has he formalised his split with his ex and agreed a financial settlement? If they have a mortgaged property costing £1000 a month he cant simply move out, refuse to pay it and expect her to fund it entirely, they need to agree a full settlement.

Howmanymoreforms · 19/01/2024 19:18

Golden407 · 19/01/2024 17:43

Why should he pay all the nursery fees? Surely she's responsible for half?

Why shouldn't he? Nurseries are generally open around 10 hours a day, 5 days a week. Closed Bank Holidays and don't accept DC when ill. There are 24 hours in a day and 7 days a week so even paying the full amount he is providing less than half a weeks childcare.

Howmanymoreforms · 19/01/2024 19:15

Whatthefuck3456 · 19/01/2024 19:01

Wow OP, ignore all the posts about he’s a deadbeat. We don’t know the facts, maybe she is a deadbeat mum who uses the child as a weapon and all for money. Mums net all one sided. We do not know the facts, if her childcare is £1k a month she only has to put £100 towards it, maybe she should make her child her priority?? Just saying! Mums net are always the first to put people down when I guarantee the people jumping to conclusions are miserable and put their misery on others.

Given that she hasn't done the same and abandoned the child and that he trusts her to look after the child full time suggests he believes she is a decent Mum.

Klcak · 19/01/2024 19:13

It’s hard to say really what’s gone on - but I am surprised that he decided to move hours away from his baby. Really odd decision. And stops him from really doing any real parenting - all he’s doing is a bit of babysitting really.

KinS24 · 19/01/2024 19:08

I wouldn’t call him deadbeat. Save that for the ones who completely abandon their DC and pay nothing. He’s just your average selfish dad.
I’d be asking what was going through his mind when he applied for the London job. What was the plan? Obviously having a child wasn’t factored in. The child was someone else’s problem.
Is he looking for a job closer to the child? Didn’t think so.

Doppelgangers · 19/01/2024 19:07

Whatthefuck3456 · 19/01/2024 19:01

Wow OP, ignore all the posts about he’s a deadbeat. We don’t know the facts, maybe she is a deadbeat mum who uses the child as a weapon and all for money. Mums net all one sided. We do not know the facts, if her childcare is £1k a month she only has to put £100 towards it, maybe she should make her child her priority?? Just saying! Mums net are always the first to put people down when I guarantee the people jumping to conclusions are miserable and put their misery on others.

What the fuck?? Gosh just when you think the bar for men couldn't get any lower...

What facts do you need? The dads own sister is the one giving the information were all responding too.

He sees his kid for a few hours a week at most sometimes not at all.
He moved hours away from his tiny daughter without even a second thought.
He prioritised a high paying job over being near his child

It's a bloody good job her mum isn't as self centred.

Hii93 · 19/01/2024 19:05

Chris002 · 19/01/2024 17:08

I wonder if it would be possible to do some remote working ? Does he have the type of job where he could do this - just thinking that may be he could
A. Move out of London so it is cheaper
B move a little bit nearer his daughter even if it gives him a longer commute daily to work it would make his commute easier at the weekend if he can't wfh
If he can't remote work - then maybe he try to make his hours more flexi - to give himself a long weekend ?
Or even use some annual leave to give himself an extra day for travel - an adult with Asd doesn't always look at all options that might be available without a little bit of guidance - hence he will stick to a familiar routine even if it no longer works for him maybe you could suggest different working/ or moving home options to him that might enable him to spend more time with his daughter ?

Don't blame ASD he was very happy to change his routine and move away from his daughter

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 19:05

Bertiesmum3 · 19/01/2024 19:04

£900 a month for one child??

my friend gets £600 for 2 children a month!!

It's dependent on income, not number of children.

Savedpassword · 19/01/2024 19:04

What does he do for a living OP? And how soon after the split did he move to London?

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 19:04

AliceA2021 · 19/01/2024 18:31

My brother had an ex wife that was vile to him. He was kicked out when she met someone else, paid the mortgage and bills whilst he just about scrapped by in a bedsit.

He did it because she threatened to stop him seeing their children. She felt she held all the cards as a mother. He wouldn't see a solicitor. Years later he has met a lovely new partner, although not recovered financially yet. He says he was worried he would not see his children if she didn't get her own way. Maybe your brother is worried too?

He wouldn't see a solicitor.

Why not?

Bertiesmum3 · 19/01/2024 19:04

£900 a month for one child??

my friend gets £600 for 2 children a month!!

StephanieSuperpowers · 19/01/2024 19:03

Yeah, I'm going to say that if he left his baby in the sole care of a "deadbeat mum", he's worse again.