Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
wronginalltherightways · 20/01/2024 09:48

I suspect his 'good reason' to leave and abandon his child was very 'all about him' centred. Not dissimilar to a lot of men who just leave, but claim to be doing 'all they can'. Which is actually very, very little when it comes to the realities and daily slog and sacrifices it takes to actually raise a child and be there for him.

No doubt he'll be an occasional 'Disney Dad' when he deems to rock up a few weekends a year, and his sister will defend him and say he's a great dad. While his mum does ALL the sacrificing, caring, slogging, logistics, etc.

Place123 · 20/01/2024 09:46

My advise would be he first make a c100 application to the court to have his contact with his daughter secured. However he will have to commit to the days and times that are agreed upon in the hearing. Contact is ultimately the only power she has and if he starts rocking the financial boat, she might use her power. Once his contact is court ordered he can simply tell her she has two options accept the £900 or he goes to the CMS and it gets dropped to 750, and he can choose to pay through them so thats another 4-6% taken out of the 750 before she gets it.
However if she is struggling to look after his child alone, then he should think about that. It's all good and well saying he lives far away and he can't get back until late but if they both took that attitude to their responsibility to their child, where would the child be?. Could he not find a job with a 450 pay cut closer to his daughter? Where he would have more time for her and provide more hands on support to her mother instead of just throwing money at her to do it all on her own? That's what the "deadbeat" is all about, financial support is great but it's no comparison to physical & emotional support, especially when it comes to parenting.

wronginalltherightways · 20/01/2024 09:44

CatOnAMushroom · 19/01/2024 17:51

I could be the "ex" in this scenario (though with smaller salaries and cms amounts). I too am the "evil ex" and the cause of all relationship issues...

12 years on and DC has seen his dad as and when his dad has time. Sometimes not for 6 months. Cancellations are frequent so planning anything is impossible.

My career has stalled as I can't stay away from home for further training or take opportunities that require weekends/evenings and offer more pay. My social life is almost non-existant. I have been unable to date as who wants to date someone who has sole responsibility for their child every day, night and weekend? I'm skint despite working as much as I can. I had a mental breakdown several years ago due to all of this.

All my annual leave for 12 years has been for school holiday cover and very occasional fun stuff for me like being able to attend a smear test...

2 hours of planned babysitting per week would have been amazing

ExH meanwhile "does what he can"

Are you starting to get that the real problem is your brother, @frimscratxh ?

OneMoreTime23 · 20/01/2024 09:36

The maths is wonky.

He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month.

CMS would be 20% of gross salary for one child. £750 a month indicates gross salary if £45k per year. Take home on that is £2885 per month if no pension contributions.

If mum makes the same then £2885 + £900 is £3785 maximum.

AliceA2021 · 20/01/2024 09:33

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 19:04

He wouldn't see a solicitor.

Why not?

Because she screamed down the phone at him if he goes anywhere near a solicitor he wouldn't see his children again. She was abusive, physically, financially and emotionally. Some women are. Not all are sweetness and light. I witnessed her abuse myself.

EmeraldA129 · 20/01/2024 09:31

Surely as his sister & his DC’s Aunt you should be having a word with him about how he needs to step up as a parent, and highlight all the wonderful things he is missing out on. He is a big boy with a big salary & should be able to sort out his own finances.

EmeraldA129 · 20/01/2024 09:29

I put YANBU as your brother is contributing more than he legally needs to, but in terms of your brother’s attitude to having a child, it stinks! I don’t care why they split up as a couple, he isn’t taking ownership of the fact he is a father.

the last year it so there have been tonns of jobs available across the country. I simply don’t believe he can get a high earning job in London & can’t get a decent job near his family. I also don’t believe he can’t be there more at the weekends because of his job. Does he really work 6 days a week? Does he stay at his ex’s house when he does bother to visit his kid?

just to put this in perspective, my DD’s Gran (my DM) wants to see her all the time but has committed to having her one day a week no matter what. DD’s Gran is taking more parental responsibility for my DD than your DB is taking for his own DC.

haze46 · 20/01/2024 09:21

My Ex has a very well paid job and I take £250 a month, £900 is an awful lot. I'd make a formal arrangement via CSA.

Jomasell · 20/01/2024 08:45

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 19:05

It's dependent on income, not number of children.

Of course its dependant on number of children. Number of kids AND income. 3 kids is 19% of your net. Also nights spent with other parent.

Redcar78 · 20/01/2024 08:42

It's none of your business and you don't know the truth only what your brother told you. Get on with your own life 🤷‍♀️

Popcorn42 · 20/01/2024 08:41

Do you actually know that "he had good reason to leave her" or are you another one of them families who take his word for everything and don't get the other side of the story?
I'd say if it was a different way round and say she was your sister and he'd done what he did Ie left her holding the baby...moved away and sees the child when he can .. then your perspective would be very much the opposite.....

Jomasell · 20/01/2024 08:40

Sorry but 900x 2 £1800 for one child? More than enough and having solo care of 1 child isnt difficult. I had 4 with very little support and minimal maintenance. He might not see his child as much as he could but hes paying over and above. If mam wants to go out and lets face it thats the only reason to get a babysitter, you dont need a babysitter to catch up on home stuff, she should pay. If shes had young child in childcare all week maybe she should stay with her on a saturday

Itsbeginingtolookalotlikexmas · 20/01/2024 08:31

It’s funny how many men have no choice but to see their children very rarely. I know Zero mothers who see their child once a week for an afternoon.

elizzza · 20/01/2024 08:25

I suspect the request for £30 isn’t actually about the money. She’s trying to point out to him that the agreement is that he comes up every weekend and when he doesn’t arrive until late Saturday that affects her. She’s done all the childcare every week - every single drop off, pick up, sick day, call from nursery because their child has a temperature, time off for appointments, all while working full time. When he’s late on a Saturday that impacts on her already very limited free time.

It’s all very well to say he “can’t” be there until late “because of work”, but resident parents don’t have that luxury. I simply cannot get stuck at work, or my children don’t get picked up. That pressure can impact the way you’re viewed at work, and so can affect your career prospects. To be dealing with all that and then waiting around for a parent who can turn up whatever time they want because they have you filling the gaps must be incredibly frustrating.

Kyliemichelletaylor · 20/01/2024 08:12

Nursery fees for me for two full time in London is £4K! I know she has one and it won’t be as costly as London, but you can expect she’s paying at least £1500 for full time care if she’s working full time. She’ll also be utterly depleted. I’m sure your brother is suffering financially but he’s in a far better position than her seeing as the nursery fees are coming out of her wages and his contribution won’t cover it. Plus she then has to clothe, house and feed the baby…. Not to mention solo look after. I think that your brother doesn’t need to pay the £30 but I also think he’s the ‘lucky’ one in all this.

NonPlayerCharacter · 20/01/2024 08:09

Doppelgangers · 20/01/2024 08:01

Indeed and the very frustrating thing is in a site predominantly used by women almost half of those voting think how he is behaving and the fact he pays a little extra each month but hardly sees his child is absolutely fine!

I think women are not as strong a majority on here now as they used to be. You can't move for MRA whiners these days.

Doppelgangers · 20/01/2024 08:01

Boomboom22 · 20/01/2024 01:03

From your posts he sounds like a shit dad who abandoned his child to earn more money. Weirdly his ex is able to earn the same as him but he had to move to London and pay extortionate bills whereas she can stay rural and earn the same 90k even with the glass ceiling.
Poor man tries so hard to visit on the weekend that 30 pounds extra a week to help mum who does literally everything is too much.

Indeed and the very frustrating thing is in a site predominantly used by women almost half of those voting think how he is behaving and the fact he pays a little extra each month but hardly sees his child is absolutely fine!

SpongeBob2022 · 20/01/2024 07:55

I think the issue as always is that going from living together to run two homes is always going to be hard for both parties.

e.g. the parent who feels they've been 'left' may feel like 'costs' include general living costs for house etc. rather than just the costs of bringing up the child. The parent who has left often doesn't factor in the childcare costs of the remaining parent, or feels aggrieved that what they're paying is going towards their exes rent or mortgage and not the child and that they're effectively paying two lots of rent/mortgage.

I don't think anyone on here knows what went on in their relationship so we can't really judge that.

I guess I'm on the fence though. On the one hand he is well within his rights to say go through CMS and pay less. On the other, if they were still together and sharing childcare costs then the leftover he is giving (£300 a month) doesn't seem much to (morally) compensate for the fact he doesn't do much parenting at all.

Mittemucci · 20/01/2024 07:40

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:41

He won’t stand up to her properly (IMO)

So what? You going to call her up from overseas and tell her what’s what? In laws like you are the worst

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 20/01/2024 07:37

PurpleBugz · 19/01/2024 15:26

OP I think you maths is wrong.

Recommend child maintenance of £750 means he is on about £87000 yearly income. Take home pay on that is around £4850 a month? So he's got close to £4K left for his own bills and luxuries each month after paying his £900 to ex.

You said including his £900 ex had about £4,400 a month and from this she is paying full time nursery fees and supporting the child. With no time off or support from the child father.....

This.

AllTheChaos · 20/01/2024 02:45

scorpiogirly · 20/01/2024 00:58

Tell him to tell her to take the 30 quid out of the extra 150 he gives her.

Tell to start actually looking after his own child, too?

Boomboom22 · 20/01/2024 01:03

From your posts he sounds like a shit dad who abandoned his child to earn more money. Weirdly his ex is able to earn the same as him but he had to move to London and pay extortionate bills whereas she can stay rural and earn the same 90k even with the glass ceiling.
Poor man tries so hard to visit on the weekend that 30 pounds extra a week to help mum who does literally everything is too much.

scorpiogirly · 20/01/2024 00:58

Tell him to tell her to take the 30 quid out of the extra 150 he gives her.

AllTheChaos · 20/01/2024 00:56

cherish123 · 20/01/2024 00:13

He would only have to pay half the nursery fees.
£900 does seem a lot. Child related expenses are not £1800 per month. If nursery was £1000, that leaves £800 for food, clothes etc. The fact she has 4k per month is irrelevant. She is entitled to the money regardless of what she earns.

Op had already said the nursery is £1,200 a month. So he pays half, then chips in another £300 towards feeding, clothing, and housing the child. Whilst parenting for less than a day a week, when he feels like it. I agree her earrings aren’t the issue, but £900 isn’t a lot under the circumstances. The £300 a month left after his share of nursery probably doesn’t even cover the costs of a home with more space than the mother would need without a child, let alone all the other costs. Plus she does all the the parenting.

Ladyj84 · 20/01/2024 00:47

As a mum he is paying fair I would say but as a dad he isn't great

Swipe left for the next trending thread