Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
PinkArt · 20/01/2024 19:57

BirthdayRainbow · 20/01/2024 18:21

Why should he pay all the nursery fees? If she's working all week why doesn't she want to spend Saturday morning with her child ?

Why doesn't he want to spend any time with his child? Sorry, sorry apart from 'when he can'.

Boomboom22 · 20/01/2024 19:53

Why are so many saying the cms is the correct figure? Its the absolute bare minimum the gov says you should pay not a target. Really on top of that should be 50% of any childcare or 100% on their day as it were. Plus more generally, it is an arbitrary figure set as a low % so low earners can still afford to give.

Anyone earning say 28k or more can give more thsn the cms minimum if they care about their child.

Jadoreroxx · 20/01/2024 19:44

@Bellyblueboy lol please tell me how it's a depressing sad outlook ? He pays £900 a month that's amazing the fact he doesn't see her isn't... we ain't here discussing me and my kids i do what I do I don't need to talk to strangers about it I just nearly pointed out for my kids I would love a break and contact for them with there dads ... Are men and women nit equals now ? Or are men ment to pay for everything and do everything? I mean it would be nice but come on its takes 2 to have a child not just one

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/01/2024 19:41

Babyroobs · 19/01/2024 12:43

Tell him to tell her to pay out of the £900. Honestly that's a huge amount for one child and he is already paying more than he needs to.

It probably only covers half the nursery fees

OldPerson · 20/01/2024 19:41

Do not get involved in their marriage or break up. Your opinions do not count and you're very biased. Your only responsibility is to be the best aunt you can or want to be. Stay out of it.

Bellyblueboy · 20/01/2024 19:39

Jadoreroxx · 20/01/2024 18:25

Wait hold up ... 900 a month which would be half towards nursery please remember they made a child together not just him 🙈 so 300 a month for everything else the only thing I see wrong here is he doesn't have her and hardly spends any time with her which is the major thing here ... mum's need a break I have two children one I get nothing for and no contact and my youngest I get £25 a week for and no contact either I would be very happy with just the break. I would tell him to say no to the extra money but maybe think about work and getting abit more time of to spend with his daughter x

Please don’t keep lowering the bar for all parents because both your exes are deadbeats.

it is awful that these two men treat their children so poorly. Absolutely dreadful. I am angry on your children’s behalf.

but please don’t raise your children to expect so little from men. Men can be wonderful, involved parents who ensure their children have a lifestyle commensurate with their income. Your picked two stinkers - they aren’t all like that and telling women to be pleased with whatever they can get because it’s better than what you have is a depressing outlook on life.

Zodfa · 20/01/2024 19:21

Spends one whole day a week with his daughter?! Father of the year!

jrc1071 · 20/01/2024 18:53

Yes, he should pay old nursery keys because he is not parenting. Seeing the child on the weekend it’s just a visitation and not parenting time.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 20/01/2024 18:43

If she’s working full time nursery could be costing her £2000 a month! And she’s got all other childcare bar a few hours on a Saturday. £900 a month is not a fortune. I do think your brother has virtually abandoned his daughter so I’m not surprised his ex is rude to him.

Futb0l · 20/01/2024 18:42

Like a pp, id focus less on the money and more on how he can see more of his child.

Lots if people work in london & travel back friday night. Maybe he can do that?

jrc1071 · 20/01/2024 18:41

Sounds like he’s just showing up whenever it suits him… There’s absolutely no excuse why he can’t show up at the same time on a regular schedule every weekend.

Her asking for a babysitter is not unreasonable because it’s very clear that he’s not doing his job for visitation on a consistent and reliable basis.

He should be doing everything for his child and it’s very clear that he is not.

Nothing wrong with her expecting him to pay for Babysitter because he pretty much abandon his family left her truly is a solo parent .

By the way, visitation is just a visitation.

It is not shared parenting

Beezknees · 20/01/2024 18:41

BirthdayRainbow · 20/01/2024 18:21

Why should he pay all the nursery fees? If she's working all week why doesn't she want to spend Saturday morning with her child ?

The child's father doesn't see her all week but I don't see you commenting on that? Why are you slating a mother for wanting a bit of time to herself?

Futb0l · 20/01/2024 18:40

So taking the childcare bill and splitting it, he's giving £300 a month after that. To cover everything else a child needs

Its not that much.

And actually, time is precious, and she gets very little of it.

Maddy70 · 20/01/2024 18:26

Tell him to tell her to contact cms and they will sort the correct figure. But you really shouldnt be getting involved...

MrsKnows · 20/01/2024 18:25

Let the CMS sort it out. She can manage on the 750 they assess.

Jadoreroxx · 20/01/2024 18:25

Wait hold up ... 900 a month which would be half towards nursery please remember they made a child together not just him 🙈 so 300 a month for everything else the only thing I see wrong here is he doesn't have her and hardly spends any time with her which is the major thing here ... mum's need a break I have two children one I get nothing for and no contact and my youngest I get £25 a week for and no contact either I would be very happy with just the break. I would tell him to say no to the extra money but maybe think about work and getting abit more time of to spend with his daughter x

BirthdayRainbow · 20/01/2024 18:21

CinnabarRed · 19/01/2024 12:47

Chances are that the £900 hr pays won’t even cover all the nursery fees. And it seems pretty rich that he can’t travel to get to his DD sooner than late Saturday.

Why should he pay all the nursery fees? If she's working all week why doesn't she want to spend Saturday morning with her child ?

DoughBallss · 20/01/2024 18:12

I would say £4400 is enough money to pay for a sitter herself yes, but from her point of view I would resent your brother thinking he is doing enough because he pays a decent amount.

Regardless of the reasons they broke up he decided to move away and spend less time with his daughter. If he wanted to be around he could have taken another job… if it meant temporarily doing a different job to stay close that would be what I would have done personally

Beesevenoaks · 20/01/2024 18:04

Sandtownnel · 19/01/2024 12:43

He should tell her to go via CMS arrangements and she will quickly change her tune.

Agree 100%

CantFindMyMarbles · 20/01/2024 18:01

Absolutely not. He’s paying excess already.

AllTheChaos · 20/01/2024 17:08

Jomasell · 20/01/2024 08:40

Sorry but 900x 2 £1800 for one child? More than enough and having solo care of 1 child isnt difficult. I had 4 with very little support and minimal maintenance. He might not see his child as much as he could but hes paying over and above. If mam wants to go out and lets face it thats the only reason to get a babysitter, you dont need a babysitter to catch up on home stuff, she should pay. If shes had young child in childcare all week maybe she should stay with her on a saturday

That wouldn’t even cover full time nursery for one child where I am. Plus, it’s not a race to the bottom. As stated before, after his half of the nursery costs he is paying £300 a month towards feeding, housing and clothing the child, whilst doing none of the parenting. The mother is not the problem here.

Totallymessed · 20/01/2024 16:49

GenevièveSapha · 20/01/2024 10:15

'Deadbeat' - a person who deliberately avoids paying debts or neglects responsibilities...

He is not avoiding his finacial responsibility to his daughter, nor is he refusing to see her. People... he is NOT a 'Deadbeat'.

4400£... that's 90,000$ (CAD) a year. C'mon... that is more than enough to provide for one adult and one child...

Dad is paying more than his share financially... Mother has some cheek to ask for additional £££ for a babysitter. He shouldn't be paying for her R&R. They are separated people... he is not responsible for her getting some 'me' time. Besides, he is there every Sunday correct... ? So that is when she should be taking a few hours for herself.

What they should be doing is finding out what he is legally reqired to pay for child support, and how much of his personal time he needs to contribute... if any. Beyond this... she is SOL.

Gen... 🇨🇦

Edited

He might be meeting his financial responsibilities but he is neglecting to do any actual parenting. I have no idea why men get away with just walking away from their parental responsibilities when they break up with their child's mother. It's incredibly rare for women to do it, and they get ripped apart when they do.

Savedpassword · 20/01/2024 16:21

StephanieSuperpowers · 20/01/2024 14:43

Well for those who wonder why society supports men to be thoroughly inadequate parents, this thread is how.

Yep utterly depressing on a parenting forum to see women queuing up to justify yet another deadbeat opting out of parenting his child. OP you should be embarrassed of your brother.

StephanieSuperpowers · 20/01/2024 14:43

Well for those who wonder why society supports men to be thoroughly inadequate parents, this thread is how.

Bellyblueboy · 20/01/2024 14:17

MrsMarzetti · 20/01/2024 10:56

He made a mistake in one way when he agreed to pay more than CMS says he should. His ex has seen this as green flag to ask for more. He needs to pay what CMS calculated and not a penny more. He either stands up to her now or she will continue to take the mick

Oh God this is depressing. Why do people have such low standards and expectations of men?

As others have said if he had to pay for the child full time he would have the childcare costs, plus any additional babysitting, the cost of an additional bedroom, more heating; more electricity, food, nappies, medicine, toys, books, swimming lessons, birthday parties, car seats, buggies, baby milk, shoes, baby proofing, petrol, clothes, etc etc. his sister wouldn’t be arguing for the minimum payment in this case! She wouldn’t be saying babies don’t cost anything to keep or clothe!!!!

the child should also have a lifestyle commensurate either both parents earnings and lifestyles.

advising men to pay the minimum and taking the attitude that women should be happy with this really stinks.

In this case it’s the mum that gets the call to leave work every time the baby has a temperature - it’s the mum who has to manage her work hours around childcare, it’s the mum who has to stay in the area and can’t move at the drop of a hat for a better job.

this dad shows up when he can - he isn’t reliable and he isn’t parenting. He sounds like a ware of space.