Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
Bellyblueboy · 20/01/2024 22:58

celticprincess · 20/01/2024 20:46

Wow CMS calculated £160 a month for my 2 kids. Dad wasn’t particularly well paid. Not seen a penny of that in the last year though as he’s now self employed and can’t organise his finances and never seems to have any money. It sounds like the ex has plenty of money. She might need to cut her cloth accordingly. My income plus my tax credits is less than half hers.

This dad must earn around £90,000. He should be paying a relatively large amount.

Mumof3confused · 20/01/2024 22:39

Also unless you’ve heard her side of the story of course you will continue to believe he had ‘reason to leave her’ - and move several hours away from his 1-year-old to boot!

Mumof3confused · 20/01/2024 22:38

He’s palmed all of his parenting duties off to her for a paltry £900pm. Her mortgage, nursery, food and bills probably eat up almost all of her available income. Then she’s got to consider clothes, clubs, holidays which surely your brother doesn’t want the little one to go without?

And what does he do with his income which is so much more important than raising a child? I assume he makes a decent amount of CMS calculated £750pm

ftp · 20/01/2024 22:06

CinnabarRed · 19/01/2024 12:47

Chances are that the £900 hr pays won’t even cover all the nursery fees. And it seems pretty rich that he can’t travel to get to his DD sooner than late Saturday.

She, as a single parent will get a childcare financial help from the state. If she is paying for child care, one of them needs to set up a childcare account - this gives them 25% additional money (https://www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare)
She will not get help with free child care until the child is 2, so if he pays more now, he could reduce then.
You are talking average £550 pcm for childminder and about £100 more for a nursery for under 2s depending on where you live, so his share, if they earning the same, is less than £350, but you are talking c£600 for other costs (baby calculator), so she is expecting him to cover more than she does. She may be working reduced hours of course, but she also gets over £100 pcm family allowance.
As to travel, if he works in London, his travel time will vary from week to week, and commuting out is a nightmare and can take hours ( OP does not say how far this is and I know for East Coast mainline that weekend works mean cancelled trains, & longer journeys), and if he is driving, his costs will also vary to traffic, but public transport here is ridiculous. Weekend return tickets are at a premium, so he may vary times to actually get an affordable price. I do not expect that she has factored in the additional costs of travel in her demands.

Tax-Free Childcare

What Tax-Free Childcare is, eligibility and how to apply

https://www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/01/2024 22:00

How many weekends does he realistically see her and for what hours?
how much notice does he give of his visit so that the ex can plan around it?

Stoptheworld1000 · 20/01/2024 22:00

So what does he actually do when he goes to see her? You've said he turns up at whatever time on the Saturday. Why can't he commit to being there at a certain time? Then what happens? Does he have her overnight? Where does he stay - hotel or ex's home? What time does he leave on the Sunday to get back to London? Does mum actually get anytime to herself? How many hours would you say mum gets to herself on the weekends your brother goes to see his daughter?

Genericusername3 · 20/01/2024 21:38

MrsMarzetti · 20/01/2024 10:56

He made a mistake in one way when he agreed to pay more than CMS says he should. His ex has seen this as green flag to ask for more. He needs to pay what CMS calculated and not a penny more. He either stands up to her now or she will continue to take the mick

Yes how dare she ask for more than the bare minimum in finances, when he isn’t willing to give more than the bare minimum in effort 🙄

Chelseagirl64 · 20/01/2024 21:25

Yup DEF

Jf20 · 20/01/2024 21:14

Sounds like a deadbeat dad to me, leaves when his kid is one, moves several hours away, only spends a Sunday, supposed to do sat but often turns up late. He’s not getting father of the year any time soon is he,

Dotchange · 20/01/2024 21:13

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:58

I don’t think 300 a month for a child outside nursery is too little? Maybe I am old!!! 75 a week for food and clothes and going to a soft play or somewhere?

And heat, utilities, extra bedroom, taking time off for illness. What about the impact it would have on her career? Having to work between nursery hours? Not being able to travel for work ( if required).

What do you think it’s worth that she can never go out? Or that she has to accommodate all illness, dr visits etc. All night wakings- her. Most behaviour issues.

Honestly OP, you’re being a bit obtuse here

ArnieLinson · 20/01/2024 21:12

@frimscratxh
What does he do with the child when he has her? Where does he take her? If he doesnt live nearby, what does he do?

Jf20 · 20/01/2024 21:10

Sorry if I missed it, why does he not go up on a Friday after works. And where does she live that it’s several hours. You can do Manchester in about 2.5 from London, but he only gets there late sat and she needs a baby sitter as he’s not there?

if he is supposed to have his child and doesn’t get there till late and misses his time, then yeah he should,pay.

Bellyblueboy · 20/01/2024 21:06

Jadoreroxx · 20/01/2024 19:44

@Bellyblueboy lol please tell me how it's a depressing sad outlook ? He pays £900 a month that's amazing the fact he doesn't see her isn't... we ain't here discussing me and my kids i do what I do I don't need to talk to strangers about it I just nearly pointed out for my kids I would love a break and contact for them with there dads ... Are men and women nit equals now ? Or are men ment to pay for everything and do everything? I mean it would be nice but come on its takes 2 to have a child not just one

It’s not amazing that a man pays a little over the minimum he legally has to to support a child he barely sees. The £900 covers half of day care plus a £300 contribution towards the child’s lifestyle. That isn’t just food, clothes, toys, heating, housing, transport, nappies, medical, it also has to include the extras that higher earning parents would provide for their children.

Yes both parents are equally financially responsible for providing a decent lifestyle for their children. Swimming classes where I live are £18 a week - and it’s pretty common. Birthday parties with kids from daycare, play cafes have already be mentioned.

this man never has to leave work early because his baby has a temperature. Never has to pay for or find emergency daycare if he has a sick child or work emergency. He never has to pay for an overnight nanny if he has a work trip.

I doubt his costs would increase by only £900 a month if he had the baby full time. He would probably have to pay higher rent, higher bills, and work less hours. His career would slow down, his employer would be pissed off at him, and he would have significantly less disposable income.

If men and women were equal men would be able to walk away.

and you raised your personal circumstances not me!

Gummybear23 · 20/01/2024 21:03

Talk to the ex and come to an agreement.

Think very hard about having children.

It is damn hard work.

Gummybear23 · 20/01/2024 21:02

Parents shouldn't call each other names.

It really does not benefit anyone.

Really damages the children.

Tandora · 20/01/2024 21:01

A full time place at my child’s nursery in London is 2,200 £ month. So, yeh, 900£ wouldn’t even be half that, let alone going towards any of the other household expenses. And she’s doing almost all the labour/ parenting. YABVVVU.
Butt out.

notameangirlhun · 20/01/2024 20:56

Beezknees · 20/01/2024 13:10

Again, just because you've accepted the bare minimum doesn't mean everyone should. Good for her for actually standing up for herself. My ex isn't involved at all with our DS, that doesn't mean I begrudge others going after what they should do.

Couldn’t agree more.

The bar is so low for deadbeat fathers and it’s quite often women that are keeping it so low.

It isn’t a race to them bottom.

hellsBells246 · 20/01/2024 20:54

He left her then moved a long way away so she is now doing the vast majority of childcare, so I can see why she's upset. Parenting is not just about money.

But this is up to your brother to sort. He should go to CMS, or ideally try to talk to his ex and come to some agreement.

celticprincess · 20/01/2024 20:46

Wow CMS calculated £160 a month for my 2 kids. Dad wasn’t particularly well paid. Not seen a penny of that in the last year though as he’s now self employed and can’t organise his finances and never seems to have any money. It sounds like the ex has plenty of money. She might need to cut her cloth accordingly. My income plus my tax credits is less than half hers.

payens · 20/01/2024 20:27

It's not your business

Hagpie · 20/01/2024 20:14

YABU from the jump for sticking your nose in. Nursery will cost more than that little less feeding her and all the rest. Stop fluffing up his contribution. On the weekend “when he can”??? Bloody hell parenting is full time not part time as your brother seems to think!

Jadoreroxx · 20/01/2024 20:11

I did say he wasn't doing the parenting or did you not read that part 🙈 if nursery is £1200 like she said £600 of the £900 he sends goes towards nursery am I not correct ? Ans the mum oays the other £600 which makes £1200 and not even sure is she getss 30 free hours. My son was in nursery 50 hours a week and I payed £1000 a month without funding. What has having a d got to do with it ? It could be the other way round and I would say the exact same thing

BlueFlowers5 · 20/01/2024 20:08

He's not parenting he's visiting. Some of one day if it's convenient is not sharing parental responsibility.

AllTheChaos · 20/01/2024 20:05

Jadoreroxx · 20/01/2024 19:44

@Bellyblueboy lol please tell me how it's a depressing sad outlook ? He pays £900 a month that's amazing the fact he doesn't see her isn't... we ain't here discussing me and my kids i do what I do I don't need to talk to strangers about it I just nearly pointed out for my kids I would love a break and contact for them with there dads ... Are men and women nit equals now ? Or are men ment to pay for everything and do everything? I mean it would be nice but come on its takes 2 to have a child not just one

But he isn’t paying half the costs for his child OR doing half the parenting, let alone both. Why is it not equally his responsibility? Because he has a penis? Jesus.

Vasf23 · 20/01/2024 20:01

Yeah but did he have a good reason to leave his child?

Swipe left for the next trending thread