Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
saffy2 · 21/01/2024 11:45

Hecate01 · 21/01/2024 11:32

I wouldn't call him a deadbeat dad. In my personal experience a deadbeat dad is someone like me ex who has never ever had my dd overnight, never paid maintenance, went on several holidays a year, spent every spare waking moment in a pub.

Yes he needs to spend more time with his child but if the trade off for that is he earns less and pays less maintenance will the ex wife be happy with that?

This father also doesn’t have his daughter overnight.
which by the way for all those belittling the ex means in the eyes of
the law and cms that his ex does have full time custody of the daughter.

pollymere · 21/01/2024 11:43

I've lived on about half that. I'd be saying he can only afford the £750 and then happily hand over the £30 on top of that. She is calling him a deadbeat in front of his child when in fact he is giving a huge sum to support her.

Perhaps he should offer to swap custody too? So his ex pays him £900 a month and only sees the child on Sundays?

kittensinthekitchen · 21/01/2024 11:37

ellyeth · 21/01/2024 10:44

I think it's really unfair to agree that he's a "deadbeat". He is financially supporting the mother and child, over and above what the CMS estimated. He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I expect there are many women who receive little or nothing from their exes. Of course, that is disgusting but it does seem that this man is doing the best he can.

LOLz

Hecate01 · 21/01/2024 11:32

I wouldn't call him a deadbeat dad. In my personal experience a deadbeat dad is someone like me ex who has never ever had my dd overnight, never paid maintenance, went on several holidays a year, spent every spare waking moment in a pub.

Yes he needs to spend more time with his child but if the trade off for that is he earns less and pays less maintenance will the ex wife be happy with that?

Beezknees · 21/01/2024 11:21

ellyeth · 21/01/2024 10:44

I think it's really unfair to agree that he's a "deadbeat". He is financially supporting the mother and child, over and above what the CMS estimated. He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I expect there are many women who receive little or nothing from their exes. Of course, that is disgusting but it does seem that this man is doing the best he can.

Bollocks. One day a week "when he can" is NOT making an effort. What is stopping him doing 50/50? And work is NOT an excuse, I'm a lone parent and work full time, the mother in this scenario also works full time from the sounds of it. It is only ever men that cannot possibly change their schedules to spend more time with their children. You are part of the problem for excusing it.

Boomboom22 · 21/01/2024 11:19

ellyeth · 21/01/2024 10:44

I think it's really unfair to agree that he's a "deadbeat". He is financially supporting the mother and child, over and above what the CMS estimated. He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I expect there are many women who receive little or nothing from their exes. Of course, that is disgusting but it does seem that this man is doing the best he can.

He pays slightly over the minimum and makes almost zero effort to see the child, not even every week. How is that anything other than deadbeat? Often he doesn't even bother arriving in the morning, probably likes a lie in. Diddums.

Muchof · 21/01/2024 11:18

ellyeth · 21/01/2024 10:44

I think it's really unfair to agree that he's a "deadbeat". He is financially supporting the mother and child, over and above what the CMS estimated. He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I expect there are many women who receive little or nothing from their exes. Of course, that is disgusting but it does seem that this man is doing the best he can.

He does the bare minimum. He moved several hours away for a start, which was not essential, there are jobs in the UK outside London. You don't often hear of women abandoning their children to take up a job several hours away do you? And if a woman did to do this she would be utterly vilified. The father left behind, would be celebrated, elevated to near sainthood no doubt.

PeachyPeachTrees · 21/01/2024 11:01

As he is not prepared to put in the effort to see his daughter much, he should pay the £30 for babysitter. Ex needs it because he isn't around to help. Choosing to see his daughter only 4 days a month does make him a crap dad, why can't you see that?

wutheringkites · 21/01/2024 10:49

ellyeth · 21/01/2024 10:44

I think it's really unfair to agree that he's a "deadbeat". He is financially supporting the mother and child, over and above what the CMS estimated. He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I expect there are many women who receive little or nothing from their exes. Of course, that is disgusting but it does seem that this man is doing the best he can.

If a mother did this would you say the same?

Doppelgangers · 21/01/2024 10:45

He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I must have missed that update... How the fuckety fuck did you arrive at that conclusion???

ellyeth · 21/01/2024 10:44

I think it's really unfair to agree that he's a "deadbeat". He is financially supporting the mother and child, over and above what the CMS estimated. He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I expect there are many women who receive little or nothing from their exes. Of course, that is disgusting but it does seem that this man is doing the best he can.

Katemax82 · 21/01/2024 10:39

He could always live right near her, take a lower paid job, share custody

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/01/2024 10:27

wutheringkites · 21/01/2024 10:10

I really hope that at least some of the posters on here saying the mother is greedy because they managed on little to no financial contribution are just MRAs, otherwise this thread is very depressing.

The site is crawling with them these days, and quite a few give themselves feminine usernames.

In a way, it's good to know a single female-oriented forum is so threatening to them.

wutheringkites · 21/01/2024 10:10

I really hope that at least some of the posters on here saying the mother is greedy because they managed on little to no financial contribution are just MRAs, otherwise this thread is very depressing.

Bellyblueboy · 21/01/2024 10:03

Something strange happens on these threads. Women who have been wronged by the fathers of their children get really angry about other women getting more child support than them. This attitude of I managed on £30 a month and no contact, so anyone getting more should be grateful and anyone pushing for more is just a greedy little madam!

awful.

this is a man earning c £90k a year whose child is in full time daycare! Why should the child’s lifestyle not be reflective of two high earning parents?

Doppelgangers · 21/01/2024 09:49

saffy2 · 21/01/2024 09:39

🤦🏽‍♀️ why is the bar so fucking low for deadbeat dads.
he is not a good dad op. And you defending him just makes you look crap. His ex is not being unreasonable. And he’s a shit for not seeing that.

Honestly it's just bloody depressing that anyone let alone women would be advocating that this bloke is going above and beyond just because he pays more than the minimum required of him.

Also can all those who struggled on less please stop bitterly spouting their viewpoints that he's doing more than their exes ever did so she should put up and shut up. It's not a race to the bottom, you should be advocating for others to get more not dragging them down and raging that they are greedy.

Anyone thinking this bloke (and I say bloke because he's certainly not earning the title of dad) is anything other than a deadbeat is delusional.

ThinWomansBrain · 21/01/2024 09:44

why is it anything to to with you?

saffy2 · 21/01/2024 09:39

🤦🏽‍♀️ why is the bar so fucking low for deadbeat dads.
he is not a good dad op. And you defending him just makes you look crap. His ex is not being unreasonable. And he’s a shit for not seeing that.

Boomboom22 · 21/01/2024 09:22

Also no nursery is less than 50 per day for the very cheapest, most are around 80. So 1k to 1.6k per month.
I don't believe its possible to get a cm for 500 per month, cm are 6 to 8 pounds an hr so even 1 full day is 60 so a full week even with taking some early days 250 so again 1k minimum. 800 with tax free childcare. In a fairly cheap area in kent. Go into Surrey and cm are 10 a day and nursery 120 to 180.

Boomboom22 · 21/01/2024 09:19

@ftp are you for real? He doesn't even see his child once a week. He's taking the piss and of course paying too little. Unless you think her parenting is worth literally fuck all and is the same as him living the single life like a student in London.

Beezknees · 21/01/2024 06:35

ftp · 20/01/2024 22:06

She, as a single parent will get a childcare financial help from the state. If she is paying for child care, one of them needs to set up a childcare account - this gives them 25% additional money (https://www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare)
She will not get help with free child care until the child is 2, so if he pays more now, he could reduce then.
You are talking average £550 pcm for childminder and about £100 more for a nursery for under 2s depending on where you live, so his share, if they earning the same, is less than £350, but you are talking c£600 for other costs (baby calculator), so she is expecting him to cover more than she does. She may be working reduced hours of course, but she also gets over £100 pcm family allowance.
As to travel, if he works in London, his travel time will vary from week to week, and commuting out is a nightmare and can take hours ( OP does not say how far this is and I know for East Coast mainline that weekend works mean cancelled trains, & longer journeys), and if he is driving, his costs will also vary to traffic, but public transport here is ridiculous. Weekend return tickets are at a premium, so he may vary times to actually get an affordable price. I do not expect that she has factored in the additional costs of travel in her demands.

Edited

He has chosen to move away, his travel costs are not her concern.

Justmehere2500 · 21/01/2024 05:09

I would suggest for him to drop the payments that he's giving her at 900 to what the courts would give her at $750, and then take 30 of the 150 to give her the extra that she's asking for and then see how she likes her little attitude. You want to be greedy you can get less. Don't get me wrong, I was a single mom who raised both of her kids with no child support. But there's a point where people become greedy instead of thinking of the kids. As far as his visitations go, he needs to kick it in gear. That baby will not be small forever and she's going to know her dad was not there. Seriously when he gets around to it, that ain't cool that child needs a dad all the time not when he gets around to it. If he doesn't have time for a child, he should have kept it in his pants or covered it up. Not to sound rude but really isn't this between your brother and his ex. I understand caring for your siblings but really they're adults they can handle it themselves.

rocket power nicksplat GIF
Drosera · 21/01/2024 00:26

Sandtownnel · 19/01/2024 12:43

He should tell her to go via CMS arrangements and she will quickly change her tune.

This

whatsitcalledwhen · 20/01/2024 23:06

Why did he choose to move far away from his daughter?

Howmanymoreforms · 20/01/2024 23:05

ftp · 20/01/2024 22:06

She, as a single parent will get a childcare financial help from the state. If she is paying for child care, one of them needs to set up a childcare account - this gives them 25% additional money (https://www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare)
She will not get help with free child care until the child is 2, so if he pays more now, he could reduce then.
You are talking average £550 pcm for childminder and about £100 more for a nursery for under 2s depending on where you live, so his share, if they earning the same, is less than £350, but you are talking c£600 for other costs (baby calculator), so she is expecting him to cover more than she does. She may be working reduced hours of course, but she also gets over £100 pcm family allowance.
As to travel, if he works in London, his travel time will vary from week to week, and commuting out is a nightmare and can take hours ( OP does not say how far this is and I know for East Coast mainline that weekend works mean cancelled trains, & longer journeys), and if he is driving, his costs will also vary to traffic, but public transport here is ridiculous. Weekend return tickets are at a premium, so he may vary times to actually get an affordable price. I do not expect that she has factored in the additional costs of travel in her demands.

Edited

Where are you finding full time nursery for £650 per month? I pay a little under that (after the tax free childcare) for 2.5 days a week.

When the 15 hours kicks in from April I will recieve 8 hours a week if not taken term time only.

The mother won't qualify for child benefit on her wage as she presumably earns over £50000 per year.

She doesn't need to factor in the cost of his travel, as he is the parent that moved he is responsible for that.