Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 22/01/2024 08:55

autienotnaughty · 22/01/2024 05:29

In terms of money it sounds like he's doing enough. Often the parent who leaves does eow or one night at weekend and one night in week. It sounds like he's roughly doing similar although does he have her over night? I think it would be fairer if they can to an arrangement of set times and he stuck to it.

I'd suggest they go through cms. If they can't agree.

There is an option to just read the OP's posts if you can't be bothered to read the thread.

He provides no care at all. He has chosen to move out of the area for work and is free to do so because he has assumed the mother will be the default 24*7 parent with him just visiting for a few hours "when he can" aka when its convenient.

Frankly parents who do this should be compensating the other parent for the care they provide and the massive hit they take on their own job and pension prospects. She is also doing his share of all parenting and home based work for the child and not being paid for it.
The absent parent who dumps their responsibilities on the resident parent is exploiting the resident parent for their own benefit. The resident parent should be compensated for that.

autienotnaughty · 22/01/2024 05:29

In terms of money it sounds like he's doing enough. Often the parent who leaves does eow or one night at weekend and one night in week. It sounds like he's roughly doing similar although does he have her over night? I think it would be fairer if they can to an arrangement of set times and he stuck to it.

I'd suggest they go through cms. If they can't agree.

Codlingmoths · 22/01/2024 05:20

RootVegAndMash · 19/01/2024 12:54

He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work

Yes. No jobs at all between where they were and London, several hours away. None.

Don't be so dense. He moved out of choice. He prioritised a job ahead of being near his child. He should own that.

Quite. She’s a single mum with full time custody who has to work between childcare hours and she has a job that pays just as much as his London job.
Is he frantically looking for work more local to his daughter op? Cheaper cost of living, and he will be able to see her regularly, even have her overnight! Surely this is his top priority? Unless he’s a deadbeat.

PennyEffie · 22/01/2024 03:35

There are lots of people explaining why the minimum and occasional visits isn’t good enough. If you can’t be convinced then just go with the comments that take the view that because they did it tough or were able to make do with less back in the day then everyone should. You say you were a single parent once; surely you advocated for your child/ren or would have appreciated more assistance? Just because it can be hard doesn’t mean it needs to be and ultimately it’s the child who suffers.

ComfortableAtLastTookLongEnough · 21/01/2024 23:14

It is a long time since I was tempted to go looking under bridges....Cold and wet and windy out there.... So I won't, I might TRIP and fall into a TRAP, or at the very worst meet a hairy handed trucker. 😂

whatsitcalledwhen · 21/01/2024 23:00

@haze46

Why not go through CMS and if you really don't need the extra he would be paying, save it for your children's future?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/01/2024 22:54

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 19/01/2024 13:06

He may have had good reason to leave her but that has bupkis to do with his daughter's needs. He left her too. Step up. Show up. He needs to own his permanent role as dad. It's not leaving him anytime soon. And welcome to the expensive world that is having kids. He just needs to keep paying what he's paying. She can't force him to pay more. £900 a month isn't bad considering the fact that he's earning around £4k a month. I'd say he's gotten off easy. He'd spend that on nursery fees and the rest anyway if he were still with his ex. So.. get used to it. Meanwhile, he has freedom to shag, party, work, do as he pleases on his watch and on his dime. His ex has lost his hands on support and is forced to outsource the care that your brother has willingly abandoned. He sounds like a deadbeat. And your enabling this? Pull the other one, OP. It's got bells on.

This

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/01/2024 22:51

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:53

He told me the nursery bill was 1,200 and that’s why he was contributing extra.

As I said, he had good reason to leave her.

He didn't just leave the relationship he literally left her to do all the parenting too

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 21/01/2024 22:49

JollyJanuary · 19/01/2024 12:45

He left her, moved two hours away, goes on weekends when he can but not until Saturday evening. She is solo parenting isn't she.

I agree. Her whole world has been turned upside down. she is probably paying 1-1400 in nursery fees and a whole household alone which she won't have budgeted for after presumably taking unpaid maternity leave with lost pension too. She will be paying for all the formula food nappies clothes etc. babies grow fast. And doing absolutely all of the mental and physical load. I would give her the extra £30 and putup with a bit of name calling if it helps her relieve some stress then the baby will benefit from having a happier care giver. I saw this as someone whose baby's father only gives me the minimum CPS and bitches and moans about that.

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · 21/01/2024 22:03

I think she's just making a point. All the money in the world doesn't change the fact that she is parenting alone practically 100% of the time. He's not available to call on in an emergency. If his daughter is being difficult, as babies tend to be occasionally, she can't call on him to come in and take over for an hour to give her a break etc. A babysitter doesn't compensate for a parent.

He moved several hours away, because he couldn't secure work? Any work? Anywhere within an hours drive? The mother has zero practical support from anyone on her daughter's father's side. It has to be difficult.

He chose to move several hours away. Maybe if he lived closer, in a lesser paying job, ok he wouldn't be able to afford the high rate he is paying at the moment, but he'd be able to offer practical help and support and build a better relationship with his daughter which might actually be more valuable.

Bellyblueboy · 21/01/2024 21:45

haze46 · 20/01/2024 09:21

My Ex has a very well paid job and I take £250 a month, £900 is an awful lot. I'd make a formal arrangement via CSA.

Why are you taking significantly less than your ex should be paying?

how does this impact on your children’s lifestyle?

Cudbu · 21/01/2024 21:36

Well I wouldn't say deadbeat 100% but I sure would tell him to tell her no and only pay what was told of him ..also he needs to keep receipts of the extra he been paying her. Both parents supposed to contribute 50/50 to child/children financially. So even if he can't see the kid as often he still doesn't need to pay extra for that..

Dweetfidilove · 21/01/2024 20:21

ellyeth · 21/01/2024 10:44

I think it's really unfair to agree that he's a "deadbeat". He is financially supporting the mother and child, over and above what the CMS estimated. He makes a great deal of effort to spend time with his child. In what way is he a deadbeat?

I expect there are many women who receive little or nothing from their exes. Of course, that is disgusting but it does seem that this man is doing the best he can.

You’re not even funny, so put your phone away 😳

Dweetfidilove · 21/01/2024 20:14

Bellyblueboy · 21/01/2024 10:03

Something strange happens on these threads. Women who have been wronged by the fathers of their children get really angry about other women getting more child support than them. This attitude of I managed on £30 a month and no contact, so anyone getting more should be grateful and anyone pushing for more is just a greedy little madam!

awful.

this is a man earning c £90k a year whose child is in full time daycare! Why should the child’s lifestyle not be reflective of two high earning parents?

Every single time. It’s depressing ☹️.

Thecatmaster · 21/01/2024 19:08

This really is absolutely nothing to do with you. You should remain neutral should you wish to respect your niece's mother and maintain a relationship with your niece. She sounds quite reasonable to be honest. Your brother isn't around much and she feels as though she should receive additional help. He probably could come down on a Friday night. It was his decision to move further away. If he lived closer, he would earn less, but also probably have to contribute less if it's means tested and he could spend more time with his daughter. Either way the csa payments are a minimum. Leave the pair of them to sort it out and be supportive of her. That way, you will be helping her to raise your niece in the best way possible. Your niece should be the centre here.

randomusernam · 21/01/2024 17:56

Cms is the bare minimum a person should pay towards their child. So the fact he pays a few hundred over this isn't some amazing feet. Your brother has the child for a few hours at the weekend? That is hardly anytime. What you are not addressing here is the mother has no option but to have a job which can fit in the child. She doesn't have the chance to swan off to London. He should have taken a job closer to home so he can equally look after the child they jointly decided to have as part of a marriage. I think asking for some money towards a baby sitter isn't that much to ask. You say she works too and has a high paying job but what you haven't addressed is how much she needs to pay for her childcare. Is she still in the same home to try and provide her child with a bit of stability as her dad has basically vanished from her life. Therefore paying huge bills? This is so one sided. Just because you allowed solo parenting to happen doesn't mean this lady should just accept it.

Boomboom22 · 21/01/2024 16:46

Op also said they earn similarly. Not so hard to find these jobs that a ft mum can't do it and all the childcare, then put up with her ex likely staying over some weekends so his family can say he's a great dad. Ffs

StephanieSuperpowers · 21/01/2024 16:42

ftp · 21/01/2024 16:16

I read this in the original question
" He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work."

And how does that indicate that she doesn't want him to do proper, regular childcare, even if he pays less maintenance?

Doppelgangers · 21/01/2024 16:21

ftp · 21/01/2024 16:16

I read this in the original question
" He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work."

Just because that's what he tells people to convince them he didn't basically abandon his child doesn't make it true.

I mean if it were true what do you think everyone outside of London including his ex does, sit at home with no job? Hmm

Tandora · 21/01/2024 16:18

wutheringkites · 21/01/2024 15:25

Do you parent to the basic minimum standard determined by the govt and no more?

Is that the standard we should all work to?

This!!!

ftp · 21/01/2024 16:16

StephanieSuperpowers · 21/01/2024 15:30

Literally nothing the OP has said indicates that in any way whatsoever.

I read this in the original question
" He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work."

Beezknees · 21/01/2024 16:11

ftp · 21/01/2024 15:26

It says he HAD to move. I have been there, nothing where I live at all. Dropping to half wages and commuting 45 miles each way for a temp job. The child's mother would not be happy if he said that he would spend more time but would halve her maintenance.

How do you know? Do you know her?

Beezknees · 21/01/2024 16:10

ftp · 21/01/2024 14:57

I was answering just the question asked. OP asked was he paying too much, not was he a good parent. Please also read that he had to go into London just to get a job to pay that. Jobs are still scarce.

Nah, poor excuse. He must have been working before that while he was in a relationship with the child's mum. There's no way that he was finding it impossible to get a job anywhere other than London, the rest of us living outside London manage to find jobs. It might not be as well paid as a City job, but by the time you take into account the amount of living costs he must be paying to live there plus maintenance I bet he wouldn't be any worse off taking a lower paid job nearer to his child.

Pherian · 21/01/2024 15:58

Why are you involved in this ? I take it your brother is confiding in you that he has a crappy situation to deal with and he's not asking you to solve his problems.

Mind your own business and stay out of your brothers affairs would be the best advice I can give you.

StephanieSuperpowers · 21/01/2024 15:30

ftp · 21/01/2024 15:26

It says he HAD to move. I have been there, nothing where I live at all. Dropping to half wages and commuting 45 miles each way for a temp job. The child's mother would not be happy if he said that he would spend more time but would halve her maintenance.

Literally nothing the OP has said indicates that in any way whatsoever.