Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
JustMarriedBecca · 19/01/2024 13:26

He should compress his hours using a flexible working request with earlier starts and finish Mon - Thurs, shorter lunch breaks, finish at lunchtime on a Friday and have his daughter from Friday evening through to Sunday so Mum gets a rest.

Unless he works in a bar and doesn't finish until 4am on a Saturday and can't drive back late, he's choosing his own conscience of a lie in and an easy Saturday morning over seeing his daughter.

I'd be irritated too.

betterangels · 19/01/2024 13:26

StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 19/01/2024 12:46

He buggered off hundreds of miles away and visits "when he can". He's paying an additional 15-20% on top of his legally required minimum and she is doing almost 100% of the parenting.

He can say no, especially if he can't afford it, but let's not pretend he's dad of the year.

I mean, quite. Seems he took the easy way out of parenting.

Dervel · 19/01/2024 13:26

Whilst I don’t think you are unreasonable I think it’s wise for your brother to be as accommodating as he can. I would personally recommend going through the CMS and get it formalised, also when he’s coming up he needs to do an assessment as to what time he can realistically make it up and be on time rather than risk frustration.

I’ve lived through some of what your brother has and trust me it’s best to drop any resentments and focus on the child. Make sure he makes logs of when he sees his daughter and try to get to overnights if at all possible. It’s really nice and important for him to forge a strong bond with his child. I promise it makes being a walking atm machine for mum only a mild annoyance against that.

Tell him to keep logs of how much he sees her and when, and any receipts of money he gives. Hopefully mum will grow up once the bitterness of the breakup fades, but it really it’s best to avoid fuelling it. Just tell him to keep his head down for the first few years. It will get better.

KombuchaKalling · 19/01/2024 13:25

StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 19/01/2024 12:46

He buggered off hundreds of miles away and visits "when he can". He's paying an additional 15-20% on top of his legally required minimum and she is doing almost 100% of the parenting.

He can say no, especially if he can't afford it, but let's not pretend he's dad of the year.

Well, this. He isn’t covered in glory. Sounds like she is solo parenting the majority of the time while he does his own thing. Ex is probably tired and burnt out realistically

BoohooWoohoo · 19/01/2024 13:22

Mum isn’t unreasonable to ask but is unreasonable to call him deadbeat and abuse him.

Your brother isn’t as great as you think. Seeing his dd once a week isn’t really parenting? I hope that he is continuing to look for work in a location between London and his ex’s home. He might not earn as much but he’d be able to be a better dad by seeing his dd more. I have an ex who does 24 hours a fortnight. He’s reliable with sending maintenance and always turns up but it’s not really parenting. (Before you ask that’s all he can do and he moved away)

I know you said that you managed on half of what ex earns but CoL means life is much more expensive eg utilities and she’s at an income where she won’t be getting topups. You don’t say how many years ago you lived in the UK but that’s something to bear in mind when you wonder why she’s complaining.

You know that £900 probably doesn’t cover nursery right? She may get a discount if the child is over 3 and tax free childcare of 20% but UK childcare is the priciest in the world and she probably doesn’t get top ups from the taxpayer either.

The ex might not know that she is getting £150 more than CMS. Your brother wouldn’t be unreasonable to point this out and tell her that she should use it towards the babysitting. It’s not enough for every week but would for every other week.

Your brother would have done the sums and decided that London salary, London rent and high cost of travelling to see his dd is better than his DD’s town salary/rent/availability to see her more. If he decided to maximise salary to maximise maintenance because he thinks that contributing financially is more important than contributing in person then that’s not ex’s fault because your brother made that decision.

I’m not saying that ex is an innocent victim but if he lived locally then her outgoings might be less and he’d be available to look after his dd with the added bonus of being much less stressed. Dads are increasingly asking for 50% contact at court and being granted it because they recognise that dads can improve the lives of their kids too.

PinkArt · 19/01/2024 13:21

If he was still with her he'd be paying £600 a month alone for his share of the childcare bill. An additional £300 a month for every single cost related to his ex single handedly raising their kid sounds like an absolute bargain.
Unless he had to leave because she was abusive - in which case why the hell would he leave his kid behind - relationships break down for all sorts of depressing reasons. Parents who give a shit about their kid don't then move hours away and turn up for contact 'when they can'. He clearly doesn't care about his child and his ex clearly knows that too. The bare minimum he can do therefore is make sure that the parent who does care has enough money to do so.
Stop enabling his poor choices and behaviour.

Zombiemum1946 · 19/01/2024 13:21

This isn't entirely surprising given the very erratic nature of his visits. Put yourself in her shoes and how your niece must wonder why she doesn't see daddy. Regardless of how bad the ex is his daughter deserves him around routinely and reliably not just as and when.

Lovingitallnow · 19/01/2024 13:21

good reason to leave his ex or his child? Maybe he should do 50:50 if that would be cheaper for him.... if you could so could he surely.

Hellogoodbyehello4321 · 19/01/2024 13:20

So he pays 75% of nursery & she pays 25% of nursery and everything else and gets little time away from parenting.

It's good he's paying more than the minimum but it doesn't make him less of a dead beat imo. Any parent moving miles away from their child is a dead beat as far as I'm concerned.

Sick of all these dads thinking giving some money makes them a good parent. That's just a basic expectation. Can you imagine the situation we'd be in if mothers thought it was acceptable to see their children once a week ffs - the whole country's children would be in care

Superscientist · 19/01/2024 13:20

Is the £30 babysitter request a passive aggressive jibe that he needs to start turning up at a predictable time?

Fast forward a few years does he what his child to be the one that is sat at the window for hours waiting for dad to show up if it doesn't inconvenience him too much? My sister's dad cleared off not long after my parents got married but only once did my sister wait for him watching out of the window for him. The next week when he also didn't turn up they went out after an hour.
When there is a nativity play or a parents evening the child will care if they get there on time or after it finishes

It's easy now as a 1 year old can't tell the time and doesn't know that they are waiting for their father to step back into their life for a day but he is setting the seeds for that relationship in the future and getting there when he can won't cut it.

MrsSucculent · 19/01/2024 13:20

How frustrating it must be for her to parent all week and then dad just shows up when he can. She can’t make plans. I think he should not give more money but he has to commit to being there at the same time every week.

Mewtwoo · 19/01/2024 13:19

So nursery is about £1.2k pm
Rent mortgage could reasonably be AT LEAST £1.5kpm
Factoring in Council tax, gas and electric, Internet, phone bill, car finance, food, clothes and stuff for their child, suddenly £4400pm doesn't actually go that far, does it really?

Choux · 19/01/2024 13:18

Choux · 19/01/2024 13:16

So they each earn £4,400 after tax. He pays half the nursery cost of £1200 a month and then on top of that gives her £400 to house, clothe and feed his daughter. That isn't much.

He is also only there to see her for 'most Sundays' (and you haven't specified if this is 10-5 or a full 8-7 toddler day) so is pretty much an absent father. Dropping by for an hour on Saturday if he gets there early enough is not really regular visiting. He has no overnights from what you say so when does his ex get a break? But if she wants a break you think she should pay for the babysitter all by herself? Even if she could afford it that doesn't mean it's right that he makes her pay for it.

I think you and your brother are trying your best punish the ex for the mysterious reason the relationship broke down. Your niece deserves to have a mum who isn't exhausted and has time to herself. Your brother should be helping facilitate that by either being the active parent more often or paying for his ex to get a break.

Actually I calculated wrong. He's only giving her £300 on top of his half of nursery fees. Not enough.

FleetwoodName · 19/01/2024 13:18

So he's basically paying towards the childcare and nothing else. Child's mum pays the rest of the childcare costs, and then absolutely everything else that the child needs. Doesn't sound great put like that, does it?

Doyoumind · 19/01/2024 13:18

roarrfeckingroar · 19/01/2024 13:13

She's paying for all the childcare and has the child for 90% of the time it seems. It's the least he could do.

It's more than 90% of the time. She's a completely lone parent to all intents and purposes. She's paying out a fortune for childcare. CMS doesn't allow for that. And she has 100% of the mental load and life admin associated with being a parent.

Your DB is a loser.

HairyQueenofSnots · 19/01/2024 13:18

If I understand, his contribution is to cover the cost of half the things the child needs (a portion of housing, heat, food, clothes, etc etc) plus the cost of taking care of the child for 3.5 days a week - as he is unable to do this in person.

£750 sounds like an absolute bargain to be honest. An alternative might be for him to look at changing his job so that he can provide childcare for 1 of the weekend days and 2.5 weekdays. Then he'll just need to pay for half the other stuff his child needs?

His ex is not a single parent (or shouldn't be), as the baby has 2 parents but your post makes it sound like he is not really contributing any childcare (just a once a week visit) and leaving her to pick up the full slack of raising their baby. Which is shitty of him, tbh.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 19/01/2024 13:18

It's difficult to say whether she's unreasonable because you've left our rather key information.

Does your brother work Monday - Friday? If he's a couple of hours away, why is it sometimes Saturday evening when he gets there? Why doesn't he see her until Sunday? Why doesn't he have her overnight?

Choux · 19/01/2024 13:16

So they each earn £4,400 after tax. He pays half the nursery cost of £1200 a month and then on top of that gives her £400 to house, clothe and feed his daughter. That isn't much.

He is also only there to see her for 'most Sundays' (and you haven't specified if this is 10-5 or a full 8-7 toddler day) so is pretty much an absent father. Dropping by for an hour on Saturday if he gets there early enough is not really regular visiting. He has no overnights from what you say so when does his ex get a break? But if she wants a break you think she should pay for the babysitter all by herself? Even if she could afford it that doesn't mean it's right that he makes her pay for it.

I think you and your brother are trying your best punish the ex for the mysterious reason the relationship broke down. Your niece deserves to have a mum who isn't exhausted and has time to herself. Your brother should be helping facilitate that by either being the active parent more often or paying for his ex to get a break.

Doppelgangers · 19/01/2024 13:16

She sounds like superwomen to be honest. She's single handedly doing everything and is still mature enough despite him fucking off to live a nice bachelor lifestyle hours away to facilitate spending her weekends waiting around for her daughter's disorganised deadbeat dad to see if he decides to finally grace her with his presence.

I'm sure she'd much prefer less maintenance and him to do some actual parenting!

AgentJohnson · 19/01/2024 13:16

So he sees his child 4 days or max 96 out of 720 hours a month and you think he’s doing his best.

Winnipeggy · 19/01/2024 13:15

Unfortunately it has to be between them, there's really nothing you can do about it. Time for him to stand up to her.

Is she paying for full time nursery fees?

BananaSpanner · 19/01/2024 13:15

Take your rose tinted glasses off re your brother OP.

They earn similar amounts, both will have mortgages/rent and bills. She has childcare costs on top of all other child related expenses. She is doing ALL of the parenting. I think he should either cough up and pay the extra but more desirably, have the child overnight one night a week, away from mum. Yes that might mean forgoing a night out or getting up early but he’s playing at parenting at the moment and still moaning.

BlastedPimples · 19/01/2024 13:13

Not sure why you're sticking your beak in, op.

roarrfeckingroar · 19/01/2024 13:13

She's paying for all the childcare and has the child for 90% of the time it seems. It's the least he could do.

Dweetfidilove · 19/01/2024 13:12

The crab in a barrel mentality always shows up on these threads.

£900 is a good sum of money - he earns reasonably well and finds that a good salve for his ‘when he can’ conscience, so pays it.

If he had 50/50 care however, he’d be paying £600 for nursery +food, housing, energy and other child related costs. Mom would then have equal opportunity to clean, work, socialise etc, freely, and would be just fine especially given she earns as well as he does.

As it stands, he’s quids in on child expenses and has none of the time restraint from being a present parent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread