Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
Frostyloz · 19/01/2024 14:36

Choux · 19/01/2024 14:28

And needs to provide a warm house with extra space for DD, all clothes, food, activities, childcare outside of nursery etc etc etc.

I didn’t make any comment about the validity of it? I was just stating the facts (at least as I’ve interpreted them).

DreamItDoIt · 19/01/2024 14:32

I wish the rules changed so that both parents need to be responsible for parenting. Having children overnight, doing the school run, leaving work when child is sick.

Essentially men, like your brother, are paying for the luxury of not having to do things like the above. Society needs to sit up and start expecting more from men as regards parenting and childcare - it might just help fix the birth rate problem.

So, imo, your brother is getting off lightly here. He actually needs to step up and start being a father.

BoohooWoohoo · 19/01/2024 14:31

Frostyloz · 19/01/2024 14:24

I may be wrong but I think people are misunderstanding the sums here. I read it as they make the same after tax - £3,500. He gives her £900 so he’s got £2,600 and she’s got £4,400. She then pays for childcare so she’s got £3,200.

I read it like you too.
The title is that ex should be able to live off £4400 which others have pointed out isn’t ex’s gripe. It sounds like she’s after a father who turns up consistently which isn’t a financial matter. Ex isn’t unreasonable to want to be able to plan some child-free time because she’s working when her child is in childcare and won’t want to let down people that she wants to make plans with.

jeaux90 · 19/01/2024 14:30

Another woman with internalised misogyny.

LadyLapsang · 19/01/2024 14:30

So he left his partner about the time her maternity leave was ending (I’m guessing he didn’t do shared parental leave based on his current behaviour). You think they earn about the same, yet he is not constrained by looking after a child / nursery drop offs and pick ups during the working week and he also works in London where salaries and career opportunities are generally better. Why did he have to move to London, was he unemployed? Why couldn’t he prioritise his baby when considering career opportunities?

I’m most intrigued by the when he can - why can’t he travel back after work on Friday evening at least every second week to spend time with his child for the whole weekend?

kittensinthekitchen · 19/01/2024 14:30

He comes back every weekend he can to see her.

How often is this? Is he reliable? Is he consistent?

Choux · 19/01/2024 14:28

Frostyloz · 19/01/2024 14:24

I may be wrong but I think people are misunderstanding the sums here. I read it as they make the same after tax - £3,500. He gives her £900 so he’s got £2,600 and she’s got £4,400. She then pays for childcare so she’s got £3,200.

And needs to provide a warm house with extra space for DD, all clothes, food, activities, childcare outside of nursery etc etc etc.

Algorhythum · 19/01/2024 14:27

StopTheBusINeedAWeeWeeAWeeWeeBagOChips · 19/01/2024 12:46

He buggered off hundreds of miles away and visits "when he can". He's paying an additional 15-20% on top of his legally required minimum and she is doing almost 100% of the parenting.

He can say no, especially if he can't afford it, but let's not pretend he's dad of the year.

This, absolutely. Plus shes working full time I assume, in order to house, feed and clothe her daughter, which will mean huge wrap around childcare costs, no life or time for herself, plus all the parental guilt of working ft and being constantly knackered. And then your brother swans it When it suits him and gets the fun weekend time with his child.

Depending on where she lives £900 is not an unreasonable amount at all for full time care of a child on top of full time work. And its widely regarded that the CMS amounts are woefully out of date and insufficient and a MINIMUM figure.

If someone was looking after my kids whilst I opted to live miles away and turn up when it suited me I’d be paying them every penny I could.

OrigamiOwls · 19/01/2024 14:27

So his contribution doesn't even cover the childcare bill, she's doing majority of the parenting, his visits are "when he can".
It's good he is making some form of contribution, but let's not pretend he's father of the year here.
You clearly don't like the ex, fair enough, but this isn't your business.

Nonomono · 19/01/2024 14:26

Financially he’s providing, which is good.

The mum can easily live off that money.

But he’s not parenting his child in any way.

It sounds like a grandparent or family friend who just visits the child - that’s very different than being a parent.

He did not have to move several hours away, that was his choice.

He should be driving up on a Friday evening and staying in a nearby hotel and having the child until Sunday.

He should also be having the child during half of the school holidays at his home.

Didsomeonesaydogs · 19/01/2024 14:24

I don't think this thread is turning out the way OP imagined it would...

Frostyloz · 19/01/2024 14:24

I may be wrong but I think people are misunderstanding the sums here. I read it as they make the same after tax - £3,500. He gives her £900 so he’s got £2,600 and she’s got £4,400. She then pays for childcare so she’s got £3,200.

Newtt · 19/01/2024 14:23

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:53

He told me the nursery bill was 1,200 and that’s why he was contributing extra.

As I said, he had good reason to leave her.

He’s not paying £600 a month extra to cover half of the nursery fees though is he?

So whatever the cause of the split, she is paying more both financially and in time and effort…

Haydenn · 19/01/2024 14:21

I think sometimes as well there can be a bit of a retaliation/control element in partners behaving like the brother here. He obviously feels like she treated him badly and like he is the injured party. But now the ex can’t have a life because she is picking up the majority of the childcare, and even when she isn’t scheduled to, she can’t really plan because she never knows when on a Saturday he is going to turn up.

she can’t just plan to do something and involve her child incase he arrives, but if she plans to do something with out the child she can’t be 100% sure he is going to turn up. Seems quite petty and controlling to me.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 19/01/2024 14:19

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:53

He told me the nursery bill was 1,200 and that’s why he was contributing extra.

As I said, he had good reason to leave her.

Why he left the mother is irrelevant, the issue is he needs to step up and do more for his child.

Keeva2017 · 19/01/2024 14:13

He is a deadbeat dad. He doesn’t parent. She does everything. He’s a complete failure of a parent, throwing money at his ex does compensate for the fact that she is a full time working single parent.

DodgyDiagram · 19/01/2024 14:13

Does he ever have his child overnight? Or away from his ex? Does she get any time to herself?

stemmedroses · 19/01/2024 14:08

If the ex has such an amazing life, why doesn't your brother go for full custody and he can live the high life on the maintenence he gets from the ex?

The cheek of him to abandon his child. What if the mother decided to do the same, just up and move away and come back when she can?

What does your brother do after work every evening? Does he have any thought for his ex who is tied to bed-times, night wakings every night?

What time does he get up for work? Has he imagined what it would be like if he had to get a child up, breakfast, dressed, nursery drop off (after waking how many times during the night) before he goes to work himself? Then rush from work at the end of the day to pick up, get home, make dinner, bath, bedtime before it starts all again the next day.

And he can't be arsed to get up on Saturday morning to see his child. The ex is right; he is a deadbeat.

Beezknees · 19/01/2024 14:08

"No option to secure work" other than in London? Do you think those of us living outside London don't have jobs then? I'd have moved to a different line of work if necessary rather than move away from my child.

Flatulence · 19/01/2024 14:03

People split up and sometimes they need to move away from where their child(ren) lives.
However, their obligations as a parent don't change.
While your brother does seem to be providing a reasonable amount of money, without knowing all the ins and outs it's impossible to judge if it truly is reasonable.
Regardless, your brother's obligation to his child is more than just financial. And frankly, spending most of a Sunday most weeks isn't a lot of contact time and does mean his ex is solo parenting almost all the time.
Is it not possible for him to travel on a Friday night and return early on a Monday morning? Or even just leave at c.5am on Saturday so he gets more time with his daughter? Can he not do compressed hours/a nine-day fortnight so he gets long weekends with her? Does he take her for weeks at a time when he has leave? Perhaps there are clear reasons why none of this is viable, but it doesn't sound like he's moving heaven and earth to spend consistent, quality, time with his child and that's not acceptable. At all.
Ultimately this is something your brother and his ex need to sort out themselves. However, paying 15pc more to his ex than he has to and spending what effectively amounts to c.12hrs a week with his child really doesn't make your brother sound like Dad Of The Year.

C8H10N4O2 · 19/01/2024 13:55

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:53

He told me the nursery bill was 1,200 and that’s why he was contributing extra.

As I said, he had good reason to leave her.

Its not "extra" - he's the child's father and should be paying half the nursery fees and frankly acknowledging that his ex is the 24 hr carer six days a week with all the hard graft and leaving him to do the Disney dad day.

If he doesn't like the arrangement then he needs to change something to spend more time caring for his own child.

The reasons for the split are irrelevant and frankly both partners will have their own views. The child is entitled to proper support and time with her parents. Its depressing that you promote the bare minimum as if she isn't his flesh and blood.

Excited101 · 19/01/2024 13:55

So what job was he doing before? Presumably they lived together before they split?

it’s great he gives more than the legal minimum of money that he has to… but the set up sounds utterly utterly shit for his ex and his child.

AllTheChaos · 19/01/2024 13:54

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:53

He told me the nursery bill was 1,200 and that’s why he was contributing extra.

As I said, he had good reason to leave her.

So he pays half the nursery fees, plus £300 a month towards the cost of housing his child (as a bigger property will be needed), food, clothes, shoes, nappies, activities, holidays, extra childcare when the child is ill and can’t go to nursery, time for his ex to have a break given that your brother looks after his child for maybe one day a week? And the other six days a week the mother is the sole parent, with the whole mental and physical load? Yet you think he is the one being hard done by?!

Choux · 19/01/2024 13:54

The correct thing for the dad to do is:
Set regular times he will be there and stick to them. No excuse. Or at least a month or two's notice if he is eg going on holiday / to a wedding etc.
Pay 50% of the nursery fees to enable the mum to work.
Pay the £750 CMS amount on top.

So be reliable about when going to be there and pay £1,350 a month. Sounds a lot but this would allow the mum to get a cleaner and babysitter when needed to compensate for the dad being so far away 90% of the time. And will reduce when the nursery ends as the girl goes to school.

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 13:52

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:53

He told me the nursery bill was 1,200 and that’s why he was contributing extra.

As I said, he had good reason to leave her.

He hasn't got good reason to piss off away from his child all the time, though. The nature of his split from their mother is irrelevant.

She is solo parenting and presumably she isn't able to go to another city all week so she can work and play as if she has no child.

It's nothing to do with you anyway. By all means support your brother but this isn't your fight.

Swipe left for the next trending thread