Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
Muchof · 19/01/2024 16:04

poetryandwine · 19/01/2024 15:59

I agree with the way @Frostyloz did the maths. The mum ends up with £4400 pcm and DB ends up with £2600 pcm. Financially that exceeds his legal obligation and seems okay, esp given his London expenses. (Not great, but okay)

I agree the mum is really after a commitment from her DD’s father. The situation is complex with many unknowns: does DB work Sat mornings, or have a lie-in? Why exactly did he need to move to London for work? There are professions where the move would be almost a necessity, but perhaps he is missing some options?

I think DB and his ex would be well advised to go to mediation and work out something structured in their DD’s best interests that they can both live with.

The maths was ok based on what OP said.

However if CMS is calculated as £750 then the OP is wrong about his earnings and take home pay. To be required to pay £750 the ex must be earning about £87,000 which would result in take home pay of £5,000 per month so he has £4,100 to live on

Dweetfidilove · 19/01/2024 16:04

Gobolina · 19/01/2024 15:33

Or he could move back to where the DD lives, have no job or a very poorly paying one and let the kid live in poverty.

Or is he supposed to move back, be a SAHP and allow the mother to work and reap in the money while he lives on UC?

😂😂😂

Why would he need to do any of these far-fetched things?

He lived and worked there when he was in the relationship.

Mom still lives and works/earns well there, as he did.

He could be there for his child and remain employed, just as mom has 🤦🏾‍♀️.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/01/2024 16:04

zendeveloper · 19/01/2024 15:48

OP, this is an excellent question.

If you're not trolling but genuinely want opinions on situation, try to imagine and honestly answer this. Your brother has £10 extra per day to cover everything related to your niece, and is a solo parent to her as well.

He's late to collect her from the nursery? £10 lateness fee, and he's in the red for the day.

D&V episode, and the nursery excludes her for 48 hours? Very sad, very sad, the emergency nanny starts at £150 / day. Alternatively, your brother's patients don't get their surgeries (substitute with whatever his profession is).

He wants to go and watch football with mates? £40 in babysitter cost to cover the match time, getting there and back. No-no to a pint after, the clock is ticking.

A smoothie and a sandwich in the softplay? £10.

Invited to a birthday party? Another £10.

Grew out of her car seat or buggy? £300 boom, that's the months budget gone.

Something seems wrong with her teeth as they start growing? The NHS dentist will see her when she's 45. Or £150 a visit for a private one.

And ALL of the above will be only his problems to organise, pay and follow through.

Exactly. Very good post.

Support your niece by telling your brother to step up and be an actual parent

Dweetfidilove · 19/01/2024 15:59

Gobolina · 19/01/2024 15:22

He needs to take it to CSA and pay her the 750 and nothing more. Reward her greed with fuck all.

Edited

What would be better is if the morally bankrupt fucker looked after his child 50% of the time, then he could actually keep all his money, and the mom would get a break.

Far better than moving so far away he can only parent ‘when he can’ 🙄

poetryandwine · 19/01/2024 15:59

I agree with the way @Frostyloz did the maths. The mum ends up with £4400 pcm and DB ends up with £2600 pcm. Financially that exceeds his legal obligation and seems okay, esp given his London expenses. (Not great, but okay)

I agree the mum is really after a commitment from her DD’s father. The situation is complex with many unknowns: does DB work Sat mornings, or have a lie-in? Why exactly did he need to move to London for work? There are professions where the move would be almost a necessity, but perhaps he is missing some options?

I think DB and his ex would be well advised to go to mediation and work out something structured in their DD’s best interests that they can both live with.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 19/01/2024 15:57

Namenamchange · 19/01/2024 15:52

Well it a good job her other parent is available to parent all the time rather than just when she can, otherwise your niece would be in care.

^^ This, your brothers ex is the only thing keeping your niece out of care, and bar a day here and there 'where he can' the only one caring for and raising your niece. Your disdain for her wanting your brother to pay a fair amount towards her upkeep (because CMS isn't anywhere near even half the cost of raising a child) is pretty grim.

CharlotteBog · 19/01/2024 15:56

I got as far as "He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work."

You see, I have a child I am responsible for. I can't just decide not to take that option and put work above that.
My professional life has suffered due to me being a lone parent and unable to travel to conferences where I would further my career (nb it's not essential, i.e. I am fulfilling the requirements of my contract).

You see that a lot - 'they had no choice'. Of course they did.

kittensinthekitchen · 19/01/2024 15:54

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:48

I appreciate I am coming from his perspective. I guess he does need to do more. He is definitely not going out at weekends etc as a poster suggested, he gets very anxious about travel and so on, he has ASD. I will encourage him to do more if he raises it with me again. Thanks for input.

So how often is your 'brother' actually seeing her then?

Namenamchange · 19/01/2024 15:52

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:45

He spends all day with my niece on a weekend and gets there as early as he can but sometimes ends up being late Saturday. I think he is being pushed around but I don’t know how things work in the UK as not lived there in over two decades now

Well it a good job her other parent is available to parent all the time rather than just when she can, otherwise your niece would be in care.

zendeveloper · 19/01/2024 15:48

Howmanymoreforms · 19/01/2024 15:22

Would you be saying he has a good deal if tommorow she ups sticks, leaves brother to look after his child full time and pays him £900 per month?

OP, this is an excellent question.

If you're not trolling but genuinely want opinions on situation, try to imagine and honestly answer this. Your brother has £10 extra per day to cover everything related to your niece, and is a solo parent to her as well.

He's late to collect her from the nursery? £10 lateness fee, and he's in the red for the day.

D&V episode, and the nursery excludes her for 48 hours? Very sad, very sad, the emergency nanny starts at £150 / day. Alternatively, your brother's patients don't get their surgeries (substitute with whatever his profession is).

He wants to go and watch football with mates? £40 in babysitter cost to cover the match time, getting there and back. No-no to a pint after, the clock is ticking.

A smoothie and a sandwich in the softplay? £10.

Invited to a birthday party? Another £10.

Grew out of her car seat or buggy? £300 boom, that's the months budget gone.

Something seems wrong with her teeth as they start growing? The NHS dentist will see her when she's 45. Or £150 a visit for a private one.

And ALL of the above will be only his problems to organise, pay and follow through.

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 15:48

MandyMotherOfBrian · 19/01/2024 15:42

MRA ploppers probably don’t do a lot of childcare tbf…

And yet they're the experts on everything.

They're really starting to get on my nerves. They're crapping all over the place.

Winnading · 19/01/2024 15:47

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:51

He is paying 75% of nursery cost and his ex pays the rest. Obviously niece isn’t costing much outside that at the moment.

Have you ever met a child?

You actually think they cost next to nothing outside of nursery?
What they dont require new clothes at an alarming rate, no toys, still in nappies likely, you never ever take them anywhere on weekends?
Not even mentioning the larger house, with the associated heating costs, water use, mortgage, etc.

If the mother was child free, she could buy or rent a smaller space just for her. Bet it would cost less than the nursery fees alone.

Testina · 19/01/2024 15:46

Given that other posters have explained that OP is wrong on the maths, I’d take his claim to be paying for than CMS with a pinch of salt.

Iwannabeacrocodilehunter · 19/01/2024 15:44

Let’s be honest, he’s left his partner and he’s left his child. He’s not particularly interested in either of them. He’s paying something because he has to. Are you sure he hasn’t also inflated how much he pays to you, to make himself look better?
It’s really sad. Gets there late Saturday. Sees his daughter ‘if he can’. I hope one day, his daughter is there for him as much as he’s been there for her.

CharlotteMakepeace · 19/01/2024 15:44

Taking a job and moving in London or nearby is fine if you have no commitments but he does have commitments and would be better off being near to his child in a lower paid job so that he can coparent and he wouldn't have to pay her as much and she wouldn't need to fork out for childcare as much as he would be present in the child's life by living nearby.

Jk8 · 19/01/2024 15:42

Surely he'd just go through cms & spend the extra hiring his own person to take his child out a couple of weekends a month if he can't visit as that would create happier memorys (£200+) then full time mum who needs a break ?

ActDottie · 19/01/2024 15:42

Your brother shouldn’t have moved away. I can’t imagine moving that far away even if it was for work I’d just take a lower paid job to be able to see my child more regularly.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 19/01/2024 15:42

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 15:38

Why would he have to be a SAHP? He can arrange childcare while working, like his ex does, while she moves several hours away to live and work as if she has no child and come up to see the child when she can.

Tell me you've never been responsible for sorting out childcare as a working parent without telling me...

MRA ploppers probably don’t do a lot of childcare tbf…

Doppelgangers · 19/01/2024 15:40

Gobolina · 19/01/2024 15:33

Or he could move back to where the DD lives, have no job or a very poorly paying one and let the kid live in poverty.

Or is he supposed to move back, be a SAHP and allow the mother to work and reap in the money while he lives on UC?

😂😂😂

He obviously had a job at one point and yes actually in this situation I'm sure his ex would think it preferable if he earnt less and saw his child more. The child isn't going to be living in poverty even if he doesn't contribute because fortunately she has a mother who puts her first.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 19/01/2024 15:40

Gobolina · 19/01/2024 15:33

Or he could move back to where the DD lives, have no job or a very poorly paying one and let the kid live in poverty.

Or is he supposed to move back, be a SAHP and allow the mother to work and reap in the money while he lives on UC?

😂😂😂

Yeah, why not?
Only he wouldn’t have to live on UC, he could work full time in a different job. The mother manages it apparently. Though if you’re saying he’s far less adequate than the mother, then I agree with you. That is what you’re saying isn’t it?

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/01/2024 15:38

Gobolina · 19/01/2024 15:33

Or he could move back to where the DD lives, have no job or a very poorly paying one and let the kid live in poverty.

Or is he supposed to move back, be a SAHP and allow the mother to work and reap in the money while he lives on UC?

😂😂😂

Why would he have to be a SAHP? He can arrange childcare while working, like his ex does, while she moves several hours away to live and work as if she has no child and come up to see the child when she can.

Tell me you've never been responsible for sorting out childcare as a working parent without telling me...

JoyeuxNarwhal · 19/01/2024 15:37

Are you close to your niece? Could you take her for the day on a Saturday maybe if you're not wanting your brother to pay out more?

TheShellBeach · 19/01/2024 15:35

Gobolina · 19/01/2024 15:33

Or he could move back to where the DD lives, have no job or a very poorly paying one and let the kid live in poverty.

Or is he supposed to move back, be a SAHP and allow the mother to work and reap in the money while he lives on UC?

😂😂😂

He must have had a job when he still lived with the baby's mother, so presumably there are suitable jobs available.

Nobody has suggested that he should claim universal credit. You've made that bit up.

clpsmum · 19/01/2024 15:33

JollyJanuary · 19/01/2024 12:45

He left her, moved two hours away, goes on weekends when he can but not until Saturday evening. She is solo parenting isn't she.

This.

Gobolina · 19/01/2024 15:33

Doppelgangers · 19/01/2024 15:26

Or you know he could put his daughter first and actually realise he's doing fuck all parenting and his 'contribution' is ridiculous.

He comes across as not giving a crap about his daughter to be honest.

Or he could move back to where the DD lives, have no job or a very poorly paying one and let the kid live in poverty.

Or is he supposed to move back, be a SAHP and allow the mother to work and reap in the money while he lives on UC?

😂😂😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread