Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
Chris002 · 19/01/2024 17:08

I wonder if it would be possible to do some remote working ? Does he have the type of job where he could do this - just thinking that may be he could
A. Move out of London so it is cheaper
B move a little bit nearer his daughter even if it gives him a longer commute daily to work it would make his commute easier at the weekend if he can't wfh
If he can't remote work - then maybe he try to make his hours more flexi - to give himself a long weekend ?
Or even use some annual leave to give himself an extra day for travel - an adult with Asd doesn't always look at all options that might be available without a little bit of guidance - hence he will stick to a familiar routine even if it no longer works for him maybe you could suggest different working/ or moving home options to him that might enable him to spend more time with his daughter ?

Bellyblueboy · 19/01/2024 17:04

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:58

I don’t think 300 a month for a child outside nursery is too little? Maybe I am old!!! 75 a week for food and clothes and going to a soft play or somewhere?

She also has to live in a house that is heated, her clothes need to be washed, her bedroom light switches on, she needs to be driven to and from nursery, she needs a TV you o watch and probably kids tv subscriptions. She may have swimming lessons.

you just sound jealous and unreasonable.

Allfur · 19/01/2024 17:04

It must have been a very ' good reason' to leave a 1 year old

freshstartfor2024 · 19/01/2024 16:57

What does he need that money for? To go out and do all the nice things on his evenings off which the mother can't do? What does she need the money for- to make sure her daughter has everything she could possibly need, as well as a well rested mum. I think I know where I'd want the majority of his disposable income to go- the same way the mother's would.

SayNoToDoorToDoor · 19/01/2024 16:43

If it not for her bearing the brunt of parenting he would not have been able to get a job 2 hours away. She is solo parenting, seeing child during day on a Sunday or part of Saturday isn’t stepping up and that’s not every weekend. Poor woman must be knackered.

StephanieSuperpowers · 19/01/2024 16:42

2ndMrsdeWinter · 19/01/2024 16:32

I never fail to balk at the number of people who think a bloke should pay the bare minimum CMS advise. Why shouldn’t the mother and child have an equitable, if not higher, standard of living when compared to the father?

I genuinely think that they don't realise that their attitude is that that men should really be able to pick up where they left off when their relationships break up and they have no responsibility, morally or legally, to do more than make sure there's a bare crust of bread for a child. All the real responsibility must lie with the mother and she really shouldn't expect any kind of a life of her own if it causes any kind of disruption for the man.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 19/01/2024 16:37

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:58

I don’t think 300 a month for a child outside nursery is too little? Maybe I am old!!! 75 a week for food and clothes and going to a soft play or somewhere?

What about the fact that if mum didn’t have a child she could live somewhere with 1 bedroom, but because she has a child she needs 2 bedrooms, so housing costs are higher. He needs to cover 50% of the cost of the difference between a 1bed and a 2 bed home.

Why do people seem to think a child just costs food and clothes.

theilltemperedclavecinist · 19/01/2024 16:35

£900pcm to buy bed&board, a full-time nanny, and a full-time housekeeper and chauffeur, for his daughter? What a saving!

I wish the ex was reading this so she could see the comments- including this one: things will get better, even though you might feel trapped right now.

Also, there's a good chance your daughter will grow up to think daddy's a bit of an arse (though she'll still love him, because that's human nature). So there's that.

Testina · 19/01/2024 16:34

I agree with @JadziaD that childcare at £1200 sounds low. With the salary you’re claiming and has, it sounds like she’s full time. Maybe that number already accounts for her tax relief. But if it’s lower because she’s part time - then he’s getting away with having a lower childcare with all the potential negative career impact on her. Plus her actual loss of earnings. And if it’s lower because her family help? Again, he benefits because she’s sorting something out - which possibly uses up her “favours credit”.
So much more to this morally than, “how much is his half of a packet of nappies”.

2ndMrsdeWinter · 19/01/2024 16:32

I never fail to balk at the number of people who think a bloke should pay the bare minimum CMS advise. Why shouldn’t the mother and child have an equitable, if not higher, standard of living when compared to the father?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/01/2024 16:28

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/01/2024 15:25

Have you actually read the thread?

He should want to put his niece first - spend a proper amount of time looking after her AND pay a real contribution to her needs - so both half of the childcare to allow both parents to work, and half of the rest of her costs.

I mean his daughter/ your niece

JadziaD · 19/01/2024 16:27

He's your brother so it's understandable that you're on his side but I think I would take pretty much everything he says with a pinch of salt.

£1200 for full time childcare seems pretty low. But okay, perhaps.

Putting that aside - ou think it only costs £300 or less per month for a one year old? What planet are you on?

For a start, she needs a two bedroom flat/house - no house shares or one room apartments. Which comes with additional rent but also more council tax, more heating, more gas etc etc etc.

Nappes, wipes, clothes, food etc etc et - relentless at this age.

What about any extras? if she wants a night out - what is the baby sitting cost? Around here, you're looking at minimum £11 per hour. MINIMUM. So either she doesn't spend the money but also never gets to go out.

He says he goes up when he can? What does that actually look like? Because I'm guessing it's not every week. And when he's there, is he ever taking the child over night? Or is it all at her house and if she's really lucky he takes the baby to the park for an hour?! So she gets no break ever unless she's able and willing to pay wifor it.

As for the £4500 per month... yeah, I think that his theory now hat she earns is as likely to be confused as the two of you are about the cost of childcare, rent, food, nappies, babysitters and more.

If he's genuinely paying more than the CMS amount then no, he doesn't have to give more money. But he needs to stop trying to pretend he's this great dad and man who is genuinely doing everything he can.

Dweetfidilove · 19/01/2024 16:26

@MandyMotherOfBrian I learn something new on MN all the time. Never heard this saying before- , then she’s not so green as cabbage like.

User5512 · 19/01/2024 16:22

MiddleParking · 19/01/2024 12:50

What are you talking about ‘every weekend he can’, ‘gets there as early as he can’? He’s her parent. Looking after her comes first and everything else fits around that, not the other way around. Christ.

Exactly!
He goes when he can, it means he doesn’t go when he can’t? sure!
what if she can’t! That can’t happen, can it?

Reugny · 19/01/2024 16:22

Sceptical123 · 19/01/2024 16:11

This

It is about his time not the money.

If he was there on Friday after work until Monday consistently then the child's mother wouldn't be asking for babysitter money.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 19/01/2024 16:19

Sceptical123 · 19/01/2024 16:11

This

Why? CMS is the bare minimum. He’s on almost GBP90,000 a year. He’s a deadbeat.

TheShellBeach · 19/01/2024 16:18

As I said, he had good reason to leave her

Did he also have "good reason" to abandon his child?

The breakdown of their relationship is entirely irrelevant, OP.
The needs of the child are not currently being met by her deadbeat dad.

I agree with the ex. And I don't care why they split up. As I say, it's irrelevant.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 19/01/2024 16:17

Testina · 19/01/2024 15:46

Given that other posters have explained that OP is wrong on the maths, I’d take his claim to be paying for than CMS with a pinch of salt.

Very true. And if the OP hasn’t bothered working out that a £750 CMS amount puts him on almost £90,000.00 a year, and still thinks he’s hard done by, then she’s not so green as cabbage like. Although I note the dripping in of ‘very good reasons’ he left - as if that would make any difference to how much he should be supporting his child.

StephanieSuperpowers · 19/01/2024 16:15

I find it so strange that the OP only wants the bare minimum for her niece. I can't understand families like that. Imagine supporting your brother to believe that his child should have zero input from him in terms of care and the bare minimum in terms of money. It's just lousy.

wronginalltherightways · 19/01/2024 16:15

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:53

He told me the nursery bill was 1,200 and that’s why he was contributing extra.

As I said, he had good reason to leave her.

He may have had good reason to leave her, but he left his child, too.

And nursery bills are insane. Most couples split them according to income; he's expecting her to use all of the child support money essentially to cover it leaving nothing left over to support the child's other needs. All while only seeing her 'when he can' which is very vague, and probably not often.

It's also none of your business. He needs to put his child first, not himself.

Sceptical123 · 19/01/2024 16:11

Sandtownnel · 19/01/2024 12:43

He should tell her to go via CMS arrangements and she will quickly change her tune.

This

Reugny · 19/01/2024 16:09

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:51

He is paying 75% of nursery cost and his ex pays the rest. Obviously niece isn’t costing much outside that at the moment.

Oh dear...

BoohooWoohoo · 19/01/2024 16:06

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:51

He is paying 75% of nursery cost and his ex pays the rest. Obviously niece isn’t costing much outside that at the moment.

If ex has a job where promotions include travel or weekend work then she may be turning down opportunities to earn more. Your brother only sees his daughter “when he can” so may be able to accept better jobs because his ex does the childcare.
Mum may be paying higher than average mortgage/rent because good schools are a consideration.

It’s strange that your brother is anxious about travel but lives so far away. I would have expected someone in his shoes to live somewhere much closer.

Waffle19 · 19/01/2024 16:06

Oh sorry, didn’t RTFT. Agree with @poetryandwine

Waffle19 · 19/01/2024 16:05

YABU. If my maths are right, your brother takes home around 3.5k a month so he’s not exactly poor. £900 a month isn’t much to hand over given that his ex does the vast, vast majority of parenting. Especially given the childcare costs!

Swipe left for the next trending thread