Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?

487 replies

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 12:39

My brother ended things with his partner a year ago when my niece was 1. He took a job in London, several hours from my niece as he had no option to secure work. He comes back every weekend he can to see her. He’s currently paying more than cms would dictate and gives ex 900 a month, cms calculates it at 750. Last her knew she earned the same as him and after tax, with his 900, she has around 4,400 a month. She is now putting my brother under pressure to give her 30 pounds a week for a two hour babysitter on a Saturday so she can ‘keep on top of things as he’s a deadbeat.’ My brother can’t get up from London until late Saturday afternoon due to his work, so she is saying she is solo parenting all the time and needs a break to catch up. I get this but also see the huge financial strain my brother is under and she is often quite rude to him. AIBU in thinking she should be told enough is enough now? I was a single parent a long time ago so I KNOW it is hard but this seems to be taking the piss out of my brother who is trying his best. I am overseas as are our parents so can’t provide practical help.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Onabench · 26/01/2024 09:19

If he can’t afford it, he’ll have to say no. But I think you’re over estimating the position she is in. Full time childcare where I live (cheap area) is £1100 a month. She could use all his maintenance, still have a £300 bill, and then still cover 100% of the other costs of having a child herself. Adding on the mental pressure of being a sole parent - having to organise absolutely everything…play dates, clothes, appointments, last minute days off work when LO is ill, the bed times and tantrums. I wouldn’t feel well off if I were the ex. Money isn’t everything

Sianywoo · 26/01/2024 09:14

Sianywoo · 20/01/2024 12:09

My ex earns more than that, we have 2 kids he lives a mile away, never has them overnight. I would say pay via cms and put the rest into savings. Is an extra £30 a week going to make a signigicant difference?

Meant to add he pays less much less. I literally pay for everything. Unfortunatly cms is very low and doesn't cover childcare costs but thats why she not he can apply for universal credit to help with childcare.

Caffeinette · 23/01/2024 14:22

JoyeuxNarwhal · 23/01/2024 10:26

Thanks. Someone else pointed out to me 4 days ago. Did you just post on the thread so you could correct me?

No, was trying to be helpful 😊 but take it as you will

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/01/2024 13:25

Dweetfidilove · 23/01/2024 10:43

Nope. I’m not championing you having more than me, so shut up and stop complaining about your £900 when I only get £200 for 6 children.

I mean, if we stopped this competitive struggle and held men to higher standards, we would likely receive more universals support- physical and financial.

I can bet this woman doesn’t even need the £30 and it’s more a - pay for the time that your hopeless ass should be here doing your ‘when you can’ service.

Yes exactly.

It reads much more as it’s about the time than the £30 - she’s saying “if you’re not going to get here reliably when you say, can you therefore pay for a babysitter “. Not “I want £30”

Dweetfidilove · 23/01/2024 10:43

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/01/2024 10:33

I know! You’d hope women in this situation would be championing other women but clearly not.

Nope. I’m not championing you having more than me, so shut up and stop complaining about your £900 when I only get £200 for 6 children.

I mean, if we stopped this competitive struggle and held men to higher standards, we would likely receive more universals support- physical and financial.

I can bet this woman doesn’t even need the £30 and it’s more a - pay for the time that your hopeless ass should be here doing your ‘when you can’ service.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/01/2024 10:34

whatsitcalledwhen · 23/01/2024 09:59

Oh and other question OP, if your brother's ex had said she didn't want to be the primary, resident parent and that she was moving to london to find a higher earning job so he would need to have their daughter live with him, get a local job and manage all childcare, drop offs, pick ups, homework, day to day parenting etc etc but that she would visit Saturday afternoon until Sunday evening, would you honestly hand on heart call her a good mum and think your brother was unreasonable for saying otherwise?

Would love your thoughts on this.

Because a man in the scenario above would be seen as making huge sacrifices, being an amazing dad, being inspirational... while the woman in the scenario above would be called a shit parent.

It’s not even everyone weekend, it’s every weekend he can

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/01/2024 10:33

Dweetfidilove · 21/01/2024 20:14

Every single time. It’s depressing ☹️.

I know! You’d hope women in this situation would be championing other women but clearly not.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 23/01/2024 10:26

Caffeinette · 23/01/2024 06:53

OP stated that she’s not in the same country

Thanks. Someone else pointed out to me 4 days ago. Did you just post on the thread so you could correct me?

to think this is enough for brother’s ex to live off?
whatsitcalledwhen · 23/01/2024 09:59

Oh and other question OP, if your brother's ex had said she didn't want to be the primary, resident parent and that she was moving to london to find a higher earning job so he would need to have their daughter live with him, get a local job and manage all childcare, drop offs, pick ups, homework, day to day parenting etc etc but that she would visit Saturday afternoon until Sunday evening, would you honestly hand on heart call her a good mum and think your brother was unreasonable for saying otherwise?

Would love your thoughts on this.

Because a man in the scenario above would be seen as making huge sacrifices, being an amazing dad, being inspirational... while the woman in the scenario above would be called a shit parent.

whatsitcalledwhen · 23/01/2024 09:53

OP put yourself in her shoes.

Would you honestly, honestly think that an ex contributing the time and finances your brother is was a great dad making the necessary sacrifices and compromises to have a strong relationship with his daughter?

Would you honestly not feel that the disproportionate hit on your career, leisure time and mental load was completely unfair and indicative of him being selfish?

Really? As if.

Codlingmoths · 23/01/2024 09:30

Thecatmaster · 23/01/2024 09:21

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:54
I mean it leaves her paying 300 for nursery and then 300 towards niece’s costs? So she’s still contributing less overall that my brother which I agree should be the case given she is with her all the time and he is not.

And who is paying for her mortgage for having to have a larger house in order to provide a roof over your niece's head. That alone will gobble up a huge amount of money.

and she can only work around the childcare hours. That would severely limit my career, or dhs if it were him. What about the opportunity cost of that, which is 100% on her and zero on him? Dh and I both have to limit our hours around the pick up for him, and the drop off for me as it is. Every day. This top dad however can’t manage leaving on time on Saturday. Ok maybe he’s got a crappy job, but his ex working regionally earning regional pay earns as much as him even though she can only work around child care hours, so why can’t he find a decent job in London? And if he can’t surely that’s incentive to move back? The more I process this thread the more I think the op should recognise her brother is a bit of a dud?

Thecatmaster · 23/01/2024 09:24

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · Yesterday 21:01

"I'm surprised at who I assume are mostly women and mostly mothers basically excusing the father telling him to pay what's required, not a penny more!"

I actually assume that many of the posters objecting are men. Quite often you see misogynistic posts which are quite obviously from men on this site.

Thecatmaster · 23/01/2024 09:21

frimscratxh · 19/01/2024 14:54
I mean it leaves her paying 300 for nursery and then 300 towards niece’s costs? So she’s still contributing less overall that my brother which I agree should be the case given she is with her all the time and he is not.

And who is paying for her mortgage for having to have a larger house in order to provide a roof over your niece's head. That alone will gobble up a huge amount of money.

Mandmarsh · 23/01/2024 07:32

Hey , I obviously don't know your brother or ex partner - but paying rent in London and travelling back and forth at weekends . Paying £900 month ! Surely it would make sense to move back closer to his DD .If this is an absolute priority to him - he would move heaven and earth to make it happen. The proof is indeed in the pudding.

Caffeinette · 23/01/2024 06:53

JoyeuxNarwhal · 19/01/2024 15:37

Are you close to your niece? Could you take her for the day on a Saturday maybe if you're not wanting your brother to pay out more?

OP stated that she’s not in the same country

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · 22/01/2024 21:01

I'm surprised at who I assume are mostly women and mostly mothers basically excusing the father telling him to pay what's required, not a penny more! He doesn't contribute anything practical towards actually bringing his daughter up.

So people are ok with 50/50 financial aspect to being a parent and 100/0 contribution to the actual parenting aspect of being a parent. OP says he's anxious about travel yet moved "several hours away" from his daughter because he couldn't secure work.

I sense OP is either telling fibs, or is blinded by her loyalty to her brother, who lets face is it not being any sort of "father" to the child. Money can't substitute for an actual hands on relationship and support for the mother of his child.

Missingmyusername · 22/01/2024 10:54

It sounds like this £30 is to cover your brother’s lateness OP?

Why can’t he get there on time?

Missingmyusername · 22/01/2024 10:51

@wutheringkites I never said she was in the wrong.
But really, where does it get her to keep vilifying her ex. She can call him all the names under the sun if it helps her.
You can’t force someone to parent, you simply can’t.

Just going to make her bitter.

Codlingmoths · 22/01/2024 10:13

autienotnaughty · 22/01/2024 09:33

@C8H10N4O2 I did read the op's posts?
Did you?

She said he has her every Sunday and part of Saturday. That's not nothing. He also pays above what he has to. He's also disabled and the op has implied although not directly said that his ex was abusive.

I think it's understandable the ex is frustrated with his lack of continuity re arrival time. I'd be annoyed if I spent my Saturdays waiting around too. And it's not fair on his dd. I think he needs to have a set pick up time on a Saturday so everyone knows where they are.

Or he could pay what cms states and then pay a babysitter.

It’s not nothing but it’s also been far too vague to say he does this. He comes sometimes late Saturday, so has her for.. maybe a couple of hours? Maybe not at all if 6pm is dinner and bed? Then Sunday … we would get a better picture if the op were more clear, and she is firmly team brother is an awesome dad so if he had his daughter from 6:30 am to 6pm Sunday I feel she’d tell us that! No sleep ins or nights off ever for the mum who’s a full time parent doing 100% of the nights and it sounds like 100% of the mornings and bedtimes.

wutheringkites · 22/01/2024 10:12

Missingmyusername · 22/01/2024 09:25

@wutheringkites But this thread is about money, not his parenting skills. It’s pointless foisting a child on someone who does not want to parent. I really don’t see how an extra £30 is going to compensate (and she is already getting more than that).

I’d be more concerned about my child not having a relationship with the father than cash/ but there we are.

So he is a bad parent but she's complaining about the wrong aspect of his parenting and that means she's in the wrong?

That has to be the biggest stretch to make something the woman's fault that I have ever seen.

Also, the very fact that our society thinks men do not have a responsibility to raise their own children and it's ok for them to move hours away from them is bullshit. These men should be vilified in just the same way as a woman would be if she did this.

Howmanymoreforms · 22/01/2024 09:58

autienotnaughty · 22/01/2024 09:33

@C8H10N4O2 I did read the op's posts?
Did you?

She said he has her every Sunday and part of Saturday. That's not nothing. He also pays above what he has to. He's also disabled and the op has implied although not directly said that his ex was abusive.

I think it's understandable the ex is frustrated with his lack of continuity re arrival time. I'd be annoyed if I spent my Saturdays waiting around too. And it's not fair on his dd. I think he needs to have a set pick up time on a Saturday so everyone knows where they are.

Or he could pay what cms states and then pay a babysitter.

She said he comes back 'every weekend he can' not every weekend.

Nowhere did she say the Mum was abusive. She said he had 'a very good reason for leaving her'. To loser men a very good reason could be not having tea on the table when he got home every night, even though she was on maternity leave, not wanting sex every day, not being the 'fun girlfriend' anymore, asking him to 'help' with the baby. We have no idea what the reason was and whether or not it was a good reason, but it doesn't give him the right to abandon his child.

Given how much misinformation this man has told his sister, it is highly likely he doesn't pay anything above CMS.

Beezknees · 22/01/2024 09:33

Missingmyusername · 22/01/2024 09:25

@wutheringkites But this thread is about money, not his parenting skills. It’s pointless foisting a child on someone who does not want to parent. I really don’t see how an extra £30 is going to compensate (and she is already getting more than that).

I’d be more concerned about my child not having a relationship with the father than cash/ but there we are.

I'm sure she is concerned about that but what is she supposed to do when he's the one who moved away?

autienotnaughty · 22/01/2024 09:33

@C8H10N4O2 I did read the op's posts?
Did you?

She said he has her every Sunday and part of Saturday. That's not nothing. He also pays above what he has to. He's also disabled and the op has implied although not directly said that his ex was abusive.

I think it's understandable the ex is frustrated with his lack of continuity re arrival time. I'd be annoyed if I spent my Saturdays waiting around too. And it's not fair on his dd. I think he needs to have a set pick up time on a Saturday so everyone knows where they are.

Or he could pay what cms states and then pay a babysitter.

StephanieSuperpowers · 22/01/2024 09:29

She's looking for the money to book a baby sitter so she can guarantee a couple of hours off duty a week even if he isn't bothered showing up. Presumably she wants to have the occasional baby free lunch with friends or get her hair done sometimes but can't, because he doesn't always show when he's supposed to.

Missingmyusername · 22/01/2024 09:25

@wutheringkites But this thread is about money, not his parenting skills. It’s pointless foisting a child on someone who does not want to parent. I really don’t see how an extra £30 is going to compensate (and she is already getting more than that).

I’d be more concerned about my child not having a relationship with the father than cash/ but there we are.