Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comments on how I spend my own money?!

150 replies

spanieltrainer · 19/01/2024 10:24

This is my first post. I take my MIL shopping on a weekly basis, as she doesn't drive and can't carry a full week's shop on the bus. I have been on a seriously tight budget since September, but now everything has calmed down and I am mostly financially stable again. We went to the supermarket yesterday, and I always buy cheaper alternatives due to previously being on a budget. Anyway, I bought some brand name items and a few treats we don't usually have, and every time I put something in the trolley that wasn't a budget item, my MIL commented. "Ooh olives and meats? Fancy"
"Kelloggs brand coco pops? That's a luxury"
"You're buying steak?
At the till was the best one...."omg don't faint its double what you usually spend"
Not only is this totally embarrassing, but I feel its not her business what I do. So my question is, AIBU to tell her to shut her cakehole and concentrate on what's in her own trolley? She is very easily offended, so it will be a massive thing if I say something.

OP posts:
SisterMichaelsHabit · 19/01/2024 11:36

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 19/01/2024 11:09

You haven’t enabled voting, OP, although you have asked if you are being unreasonable.

Is this just an oversight? If it is, does that mean you are a scatterbrain to whom no one should ever pay attention again…..or does it just mean that ( like MIL) you are not perfect?

If you had said to her, ‘ oh , feeling a bit more flush today, going to get some treats when we go this week’, what do you think her response would have been?

Usually people on AIBU know they can reply with the letters in front of their computer screen (called a "keyboard") or below their phone screen: "YABU" (You are being unreasonable) or "YANBU" (you are not being unreasonable). No further explanation or comment is required but most people do write in complete sentences instead to explain their answer. The complete sentences usually carry meaning that the OP can decode (by "reading") to extrapolate whether people think they are BU or not.

Voting is not required when asking whether you're being unreasonable.
Otherwise it would be a redundant feature that we can ever disable voting in AIBU.

Therefore it is not an oversight and the rest of your comment is redundant.

HTH.

TheOriginalFrench · 19/01/2024 11:37

Tbh I think it’s perfectly natural for family members who are shopping together to comment on what they each buy - it’s normal human interaction.

But the OP doesn’t like this interaction - and it’s a bind to have someone relying exclusively on you to do it every week, so they should find an alternative. Weekly grocery delivery and different venues for socialising.

Bluetrews25 · 19/01/2024 11:37

For many people a trip around the supermarket is a rare chance to get out into the world, see a few other faces and maybe have some social interaction with them, or at least the person on the till.
I used to take my (now late) DM shopping weekly.
We'd go around separately and meet after paying.
We wanted different things and walked at different speeds.
That worked for us, maybe it could work for you, OP?

exttf · 19/01/2024 11:39

Does she need help to go around the shop or is it just the issue with carrying the bags on the bus? Because if it's the latter, I'd just say on the way in, ok MIL, let's meet at the bench over there at the exit when we are both finished our shopping, and then walk off and let her get on with it. That way she can't be commenting on every damn thing you put in the trolley. '
I would find it very annoying.
If she can't manage to go round the shop on her own then maybe you might have to consider shopping separately if it really annoys you.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 19/01/2024 11:42

I think there are some people on this thread who go through life oblivious to subtext and nonverbal communication.

Obviously if the OP's MIL had a smile on her face and a positive tone of voice while saying "Ooh olives and meats - fancy!" that's very different to a bumface and a raised eyebrow while saying it in a judgemental tone.

I think the answers are split down the lines of people who get subtext/NVC (social cues) and people who take things at their face value.

OP I'm assuming that if you're posting about this on AIBU that the subtext was not jolly and happy, in which case YANBU.

Jf20 · 19/01/2024 11:46

SisterMichaelsHabit · 19/01/2024 11:42

I think there are some people on this thread who go through life oblivious to subtext and nonverbal communication.

Obviously if the OP's MIL had a smile on her face and a positive tone of voice while saying "Ooh olives and meats - fancy!" that's very different to a bumface and a raised eyebrow while saying it in a judgemental tone.

I think the answers are split down the lines of people who get subtext/NVC (social cues) and people who take things at their face value.

OP I'm assuming that if you're posting about this on AIBU that the subtext was not jolly and happy, in which case YANBU.

I disagree, I think the thread is split between those who sweat the small stuff and are easily offended and those who don’t; and aren’t.

everyone understand the underlying connotation.even though I’ve joked I fully understand what she’s saying, I am pointing out how ludicrous and petty it is.

AgentJohnson · 19/01/2024 11:49

Tell her that her commentary is wearing and you’d rather not hear it and if she persists, the arrangement will need to be reviewed.

2024Hackathon · 19/01/2024 11:50

Obviously if the OP's MIL had a smile on her face and a positive tone of voice while saying "Ooh olives and meats - fancy!" that's very different to a bumface and a raised eyebrow while saying it in a judgemental tone.

Agreed. DH does something like that with some items but it's a reference to a former landlord of mine whom we both liked enormously. My landlord would say, "That's a bit posh" about rice. He wasn't brought up with it so thought rice was an exotic food and would get quite thrilled about a rice pudding I brought him. Or if I put cinnamon in some crumble I gave him.

My MIL's partner is similar. And he says things like, "I used to think that was fancy but [MIL] showed me the error of my ways".

Stuff like that, shared memories and humour.

Other times, it can be obvious when somebody is offering a judgment. (It took me some time, years ago, to persuade someone that fresh salmon was cheaper than tinned (or it was then). They always rabbitted on about the extravagance of fresh salmon but were using memories of their youth when it had been very expensive.)

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/01/2024 11:50

Jf20 · 19/01/2024 11:28

Honestly I’d interact but as you have been posting that it’s critical to say olives are fancy and cocopops luxury and she’s not allowed to make that decision, then I shall pass..😄

You don't think it could be seen as critical to offer unwanted views on someone else's shopping?

Tinkerbyebye · 19/01/2024 11:51

Just ask her to stop commenting. If she doesn’t then your husband can take her shopping

Blueisacolour · 19/01/2024 11:51

I get it, OP. I like my MiL and we get on well, but she used to be a bit like this, years ago. She is extremely frugal and when I took her shopping she would comment negatively on things in my basket, because she considered them wasteful and would say so. From her point of view, drawing attention to my 'unnecessary' purchases was being helpful. But it became very wearing because I was taking it as criticism and I felt uncomfortable to the point that I'd start to make separate trips to the same shop - one with her and one without. What changed was when I decided to stop feeling uncomfortable at her comments and have conviction in what I was buying. When she commented negatively on something I responded enthusiastically about it, every single time, explaining exactly why I liked/wanted it ("no, this thing is actually really great because...", "we tried these and they were SO much nicer - DH/DC really really loved them and said..."). When I started enthusing happily about everything she commented negatively on, she soon stopped criticising, and hasn't done for years now. We still get on well and happily help each other with shopping, without any comments at all! It's an approach that might be worth a try :)

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/01/2024 11:54

SisterMichaelsHabit · 19/01/2024 11:42

I think there are some people on this thread who go through life oblivious to subtext and nonverbal communication.

Obviously if the OP's MIL had a smile on her face and a positive tone of voice while saying "Ooh olives and meats - fancy!" that's very different to a bumface and a raised eyebrow while saying it in a judgemental tone.

I think the answers are split down the lines of people who get subtext/NVC (social cues) and people who take things at their face value.

OP I'm assuming that if you're posting about this on AIBU that the subtext was not jolly and happy, in which case YANBU.

I wasn't there, obviously, so I'm taking my views from the fact that these comments are bothering @spanieltrainer enough to make a post about them. Why does MIL even need to comment on shopping she isn't buying or paying for?

Harrietsaunt · 19/01/2024 11:57

Jf20 · 19/01/2024 11:31

Op, in all seriousness, just tell your husband you’re out, she has home deliveries or he takes her, as you find it unacceptable if she says things like your olives are fancy, I don’t see why it’s your job to take her. Do you do it on the weekend?

This is what you should do.

We can all see it would be mildly irritating but you clearly can’t cope with MIL at the moment and your reaction seems out of place.

It is someone else’s turn to take her.

Mezzamix · 19/01/2024 11:58

Jf20 · 19/01/2024 11:18

God can you imagine 😂😂😂

Mil ooh your olives are fancy
Op Your bread is gorgeous!
Mil ooh branded cocopops what a luxury !
op your mr Kipling Bakewell tarts are such a treat

😂😂😂

😂 I would have to follow them round the store just to hear that exchange while stifling my giggles.

Itsagreatdaytosavelives · 19/01/2024 11:59

can her son take her moving forward?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/01/2024 12:00

Jf20 · 19/01/2024 11:46

I disagree, I think the thread is split between those who sweat the small stuff and are easily offended and those who don’t; and aren’t.

everyone understand the underlying connotation.even though I’ve joked I fully understand what she’s saying, I am pointing out how ludicrous and petty it is.

Here's another perspective - maybe it's split between those who are clearly happy to offer their often unwanted opinions and those who realise that not every thought has to be voiced.

Lindjam · 19/01/2024 12:01

Fucking hell!!

Go NC with her immediately and don’t allow your DC anywhere near her!

What a total fucking bitch. Commenting on your shopping as you wander around together? She’s clearly got NPD.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 19/01/2024 12:40

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/01/2024 11:54

I wasn't there, obviously, so I'm taking my views from the fact that these comments are bothering @spanieltrainer enough to make a post about them. Why does MIL even need to comment on shopping she isn't buying or paying for?

Exactly.

Crumpleton · 19/01/2024 13:00

I want to go shopping, and buy what I want without her attempting to make me feel guilty for buying her son treats.

This would be my ammo...

"Jeez, right, I know MIL, your dear boy doesn't know how lucky he is having me buy him the good stuff"
Leave it at that.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 19/01/2024 13:27

spanieltrainer · 19/01/2024 11:09

This is what I mean. I don't offer random opinions on the shite she buys, I was brought up to know its rude to comment in such a way. I want to go shopping, and buy what I want without her attempting to make me feel guilty for buying her son treats.
She has been my MIL for over 20 years so it's not like it's a new thing. I'm perimenopausal and have a lower tolerance for her bullshit these days.

Why do you think she's trying to make you feel guilty? She's just commenting that it's very different from your usual shop. I mean, if she'd said "don't buy those otherwise you won't be able to pay the gas bill and my poor darling boy will catch cold" you might have a point. But otherwise I think YABU.

the80sweregreat · 19/01/2024 13:36

It all depends on how it was said
My late in laws always had a manner of saying things which made you feel bad about doing anything or buying anything
If it was in a jokey manner or lighthearted then that's different
Some people are just judgy as a default setting

BobbyBiscuits · 19/01/2024 14:14

I feel for you. It seems judgemental and nosy but probably just jealous. I had a 'friend' who would lean over the screen at the cash machine when I was using it (on payday) and say "oooh, your in the money, pints on you then, woah you are loaded etc'. I stopped speaking to them. I earned just above min wage at the time.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/01/2024 14:33

BobbyBiscuits · 19/01/2024 14:14

I feel for you. It seems judgemental and nosy but probably just jealous. I had a 'friend' who would lean over the screen at the cash machine when I was using it (on payday) and say "oooh, your in the money, pints on you then, woah you are loaded etc'. I stopped speaking to them. I earned just above min wage at the time.

Why do some folk think it's ok to be that nosy and/or make such stupid comments?

Fionaville · 19/01/2024 14:38

My mum and dad talk like this, but then we talk about the price of stuff when we're shopping. If my MIL commented, it would probably annoy me more. Which is unfair on MIL, as I'd take it more as a criticism from her. With either of them, I'd just joke it off. Maybe you're just being touchy because it's the MIL.

Verv · 19/01/2024 14:42

Honestly just ignore it.
Yes its long, yes its annoying, yes its shite, but the easiest method of dealing with it is in one ear and out the other with a disinterested mhm punctuating their dialogue.