Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't even phone to book an doctor's appointment anymore, what is happening?

212 replies

GPbloodyWha · 18/01/2024 19:50

Recieved this text from GP.

Can no longer phone them to book an appointment.

So what happens? You send them a message and have to wait and hours and hours for them to decide if you're allowed to see them or not?

Is a GP sitting there reading hundreds of messages to see if they should allow a patient an appointment an improvement on their use of time??

Can't even phone to book an doctor's appointment anymore, what is happening?
OP posts:
tinkertee · 18/01/2024 20:22

Finbrek · 18/01/2024 20:11

We have this. It's shit. It's provided by a firm called Klinik Healthcare Solutions, none of whom are doctors. The "queries" are "triaged" by an algorithm, supposedly "overseen" by someone who is "medically qualified". If you don't include key words in your form, or if you say that it's an existing condition, you'll be categorised as routine. At our surgery that used to mean a six week wait for a doctor to even read your form; now you wait six weeks and then get a text asking if you still want a doctor to read your form in a further six weeks time. If you do include key words you have to be careful it doesn't sound too serious otherwise the form closes and tells you to go to A&E.

Dealing with this system is like dealing with the most incompetent gnarly piece of shit computer ever fucking invented. Like a 1970s fisher price doctor kit combined with 2001-level murderous intransigent intent. To add insult to injury, three pages in to the form you have to select your problematic body part from a fucking diagram. A diagram that goes straight from stomach to genitals. Yes, that's right. This healthcare model does not recognise female body parts.

Find another surgery if you can op.

Are you sure it's all done by algorithm? I ask because my surgery also uses Klinic and the info written in the form is definitely read by a clinician at the surgery. It does send you off if what you've written are red flags, just as the receptionist would if you explained that on a telephone triage. But if you don't agree you can start again and use a different description.

EBearhug · 18/01/2024 20:21

Ours has this and it works well. Filled a form in Friday morning, got a text to say they wanted to see me in person (which I hadn't actually expected- was just adking for advice,) with a link to make an appointment, saw GP Monday (the next working day,) but had quite a range of possible appointments.

You can still call them if you don't have a smart phone/Internet access.

Hunkydory99 · 18/01/2024 20:21

We have an e-consult system at ours and I can’t fault it. Whenever I’ve had to do one for the kids I’ve heard back within 3 hours. But we also have the option to call up if needed.

Newgirls · 18/01/2024 20:19

It’s working quite well for me. I left a message online and a GP rang me back same day. I was told a window when they’d call. That is easier than before and quicker. I worry though that they don’t look at patients now - don’t they need to see what you look like? Pale/thin/stresses/obese?

tinkertee · 18/01/2024 20:18

We also have this system alongside phoning and it's great. Unfortunately I've had to make quite a few contacts with our GP surgery recently for unrelated issues. I've used the online form each time and have had an appropriate contact each time. Either they've called me back within an hour or so to offer an apt, or I've had a telephone consultation.

I agree there needs to be a phone / face to face option for those who don't have the internet. My mum is not online in any capacity so this would be no good for her. But the surgery will have to demonstrate that they have something set up for those in that situation.

Honestly, don't knock it till you've tried it.

candlelog · 18/01/2024 20:18

This is a brilliant idea. Within a few minutes you can submit your concern rather than trying to call at 8.30 and not getting through.

CMOTDibbler · 18/01/2024 20:16

Ours has this and its brilliant. For those who can't do online you can ring the surgery and the receptionists will fill out the form for you, but everyone gets exactly the same method, and allows them to decide best what to do

Floralnomad · 18/01/2024 20:11

Our Gp has moved to this system and it’s way better than sitting on the phone for hours . Invariably ours get back to you within a few hours with either an appt date ( call or F2F) , or a prescription . If you aren’t satisfied you just fill out another form saying so - it’s brilliant . For people who can’t fill out the form you can still ring the receptionist and they go through it over the phone and fill it in for you . Don’t knock it until youve given it a go . It’s much better for people who can’t answer the phone at work as you can put set times on for contacting you etc .

Finbrek · 18/01/2024 20:11

We have this. It's shit. It's provided by a firm called Klinik Healthcare Solutions, none of whom are doctors. The "queries" are "triaged" by an algorithm, supposedly "overseen" by someone who is "medically qualified". If you don't include key words in your form, or if you say that it's an existing condition, you'll be categorised as routine. At our surgery that used to mean a six week wait for a doctor to even read your form; now you wait six weeks and then get a text asking if you still want a doctor to read your form in a further six weeks time. If you do include key words you have to be careful it doesn't sound too serious otherwise the form closes and tells you to go to A&E.

Dealing with this system is like dealing with the most incompetent gnarly piece of shit computer ever fucking invented. Like a 1970s fisher price doctor kit combined with 2001-level murderous intransigent intent. To add insult to injury, three pages in to the form you have to select your problematic body part from a fucking diagram. A diagram that goes straight from stomach to genitals. Yes, that's right. This healthcare model does not recognise female body parts.

Find another surgery if you can op.

SarcasmAndCoffee · 18/01/2024 20:08

Mine do this already and it’s absolute bollocks.

you have to submit the online form then they have 3 WORKING days just to call you to tell you when your appointment will be. I don’t even bother with them anymore I just go straight to 111

Mummyofthewildones · 18/01/2024 20:08

Honestly the surgery where I work does this and patients have really given nothing but positive feedback! Requests are seen by a clinician on the same day and you don't have to wait on the phone for hours.

Houseplantmad · 18/01/2024 20:06

It excludes the vulnerable - I’ve seen this first hand. I was at the GPs recently and two separate elderly people came in. One, whose husband has cancer and needed a blood test, had been sent a link to arrange this. She didn’t have a mobile phone so it had been sent to her landline so was useless.
The second said he was trying to make an appointment but didn’t have access to the internet. The receptionist, having told him he needed to make it online, eventually helped him but not with much grace.

Queenonfleek · 18/01/2024 20:06

I think we are at same surgery as I got an identical message .. I would say as someone who has tried ringing 150+ times at 8,30 to get an appointment, this makes it easier for us to register our need for an appointment.. does not create any more capacity for seeing a doctor but saves a lot of wasted time trying to get through .. the request system is not the problem .. it’s the capacity of doctors’ time that is

it works well for people who work - we don’t have time to make the calls and i would rather my request for one of the few appointments determined by a doctor on need rather than who wins the telephone lottery

Hollybelle83 · 18/01/2024 20:06

Our surgery does this and I have to say it works very well. Way more efficient. Often you get a text within the hour saying I've prescribed you X and you can collect today from y.

applesandmares · 18/01/2024 20:04

Our drs have this and it's great! Before, if you called up at 8:05am you'd be in a massive queue and any later you'd have no chance for a same-day appointment. Now as long as you submit the form before 12:30pm it's guaranteed to be looked at, so they can triage the more important appointments for that afternoon/next morning, rather than just giving them to the first people that get through.

Peggyblumquist · 18/01/2024 20:04

Our gp brought this system in a couple of years ago. To be honest it’s a better system than ringing. You have more chance of either being seen or getting a prescription. They get back to you quite quickly. It’s definitely a more efficient system in my experience of using it.

cosynightshome · 18/01/2024 20:02

Our drs has been like this a while, it's ridiculous.

Didimum · 18/01/2024 20:02

I think this seems very efficient. A good idea. There will be accessible differences for those who can’t use the service in that way.

Starhaf · 18/01/2024 20:00

They can more easily outsource the triaging using this method.

Aaron95 · 18/01/2024 20:00

They are trying to make best use of their resources and a GPs time is the most valuable resource they have. It won't be a GP sifting through the messages, that would not be efficient.

We simply don't have enough doctors to met the ever increasing demand for healthcare and no amount of money will solve the problem. It takes years to train a doctor and we should have started the process 10 years ago but didn't as nobody likes paying tax and it costs money.

Reddog1 · 18/01/2024 20:00

The scramble on the phones at 8am is a nightmare and people rightly complain. Patients are rude to the receptionists, who bear the brunt of their ire when the appointments have all gone. It’s good that your surgery is trying something new, I suppose. Who knows whether it will improve things, though. I doubt it. Seems like tinkering round the edges to me.

Tinkerbyebye · 18/01/2024 19:59

You can always call 111 I understand surgeries have to release some appointment slots to them

Generationawesome · 18/01/2024 19:58

My GP operates this system and it's brilliant. They still have a phone line but it's for people with complex queries or who can't use the online system. The system is open during opening hours and you get streamed into an appropriate care pathway by whoever is on duty, there's also an option to choose if your query is admin or medical related. I don't want to go back to the days without it.

Seeline · 18/01/2024 19:58

Ours you have to fill a full-on questionnaire with body maps, tick lists and goodness knows what else. The doctor then looks at them all and decides who can have a phone call, a f2f, an appointment in 4 weeks, appointment with nurse etc. you have to wait for a text to tell you and then wait for a phone call if you're lucky.
You can still ring in but the receptionist basically fills the online questionnaire for you.

mynameiscalypso · 18/01/2024 19:58

We have this system. It works very well. Enquiries are often triaged within an hour. If it's a routine thing, it's dealt with via text message (eg antibiotics for a UTI, repeat prescription). If not, they phone and sometimes get you down to the practice.