Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't even phone to book an doctor's appointment anymore, what is happening?

212 replies

GPbloodyWha · 18/01/2024 19:50

Recieved this text from GP.

Can no longer phone them to book an appointment.

So what happens? You send them a message and have to wait and hours and hours for them to decide if you're allowed to see them or not?

Is a GP sitting there reading hundreds of messages to see if they should allow a patient an appointment an improvement on their use of time??

Can't even phone to book an doctor's appointment anymore, what is happening?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bearbookagainandagain · 19/01/2024 12:48

Our surgery uses a messaging system for non-emergency queries, it's much better than the phone system and I think it should be used for all appointments.
The triage system works the same as the phone line, so first by the receptionist, then a GP. Although it says it could take up to 48h to respond, I have never waited more than 1-2h top when it was a medical query, and I imagine it's purely because the GP needs to review it. Usually I got a same day appointment or GP call back.
For the rest (repeat prescription or small questions that don't need a conversation), I usually have a written response within 24h.

[Edit: obviously anyone with disability or special needs should be able to use the phone or go in person, that's a given]

bakebeans · 19/01/2024 11:10

@Bargello most Gp practices allow for those who are elderly/learning needs/urgent child/no technology to still phone. It's been this way at my surgery since covid. It has its faults don't get me wrong. Eg some people going the online route for stroke or heart attack symptoms instead of a&e and then others demanding a GP appointment for a tooth filling because they haven't got a dentist

VicSynix · 19/01/2024 08:50

I work at a GP surgery and we recently brought this system in. You can either go online and answer 6 very simple questions, or you can phone up and the receptionists ask you the same questions. The results go on your medical record, a GP assesses them usually within an hour or so, and you'll then be contacted either with an appointment, or advice, or a prescription.

It means that the people who can't go online are still able to phone and they don't have to wait on the line as long. It's also meant, apparently, more calls from men who found it easier to detail their symptoms online rather than talking about them with a receptionist, which is interesting.

It's working very well for all concerned.

Clearv13w · 19/01/2024 08:31

Sounds fairer. Those that can’t ring dot on 8.30 are currently being penalised.

Boomer55 · 19/01/2024 08:29

GPbloodyWha · 18/01/2024 19:50

Recieved this text from GP.

Can no longer phone them to book an appointment.

So what happens? You send them a message and have to wait and hours and hours for them to decide if you're allowed to see them or not?

Is a GP sitting there reading hundreds of messages to see if they should allow a patient an appointment an improvement on their use of time??

We’ve had to use the E-Consult form system since Covid. You fill out a hefty form, state your problem and then it’s triaged by the receptionist, a nurse and if considered a worthy problem, a doctor gets it.

They promise to either text or phone within 48 hours, which could be a doctor, a nurse or a pharmacist, although that doesn’t always happen.

Any patient just turning up is told to sit in reception and use the surgery IPads to fill out the form - whether they are computer literate or not.

The result of all this is that increasing numbers of people are just rocking up to urgent care or the local A&E.🙁

mambojambodothetango · 19/01/2024 08:29

Our surgery has been doing this for years. Works fine. The few times I've used it I've twice had a text within the hour offering me a same morning appointment and once or twice got a phone appointment offered for the next day where they gave advice over the phone.

RoseAndRose · 19/01/2024 08:19

Shaketurn · 18/01/2024 19:53

What about people who can't use online methods? My grandad can use a phone to ring but can't do anything online.

They will have to have a work around for patients who cannot access online services

It's clear they want to minimise the number of phone calls

But I think this is another barrier to accessing healthcare, which falls hardest on those most vulnerable. And that it's not fair

cinnamonbiscuit · 19/01/2024 08:07

My GP has the phone option and you can also submit an econsult request between 630 and 930. The other day my 5 month old was unwell and I phoned as early as I could (0805) and was met with an automated message to say they were at capacity for the day. Went onto the website and econsult requests were also closed for the same reason.

Thankfully they made space to see her once I spoke to reception due to her age, but no idea what I do about myself or my older DC in future - when toddler had an issue a few months ago I was told there were 'no routine appointments available' and I would need to phone again in a few days 🤦 the whole system seems broken where I live!

kelsaecobbles · 19/01/2024 08:00

But they have to do something

Demand is too high for the number of GPs in many regions

And that means they have to ignore people they could otherwise help

kelsaecobbles · 19/01/2024 07:59

The poeple who don't have any internet access include a lot of people in poverty

and there are also a lot of people who have limited mobile data and no fixed line who often have no data by the end of the month

So As well as elderly this is particularly hitting the less well off, and disporopirtionatly the disabled

EBearhug · 19/01/2024 07:58

The thing is I don’t think they openly say you can phone.

Ours does. They clearly prefer online, but it's obvious phoning is an option if that doesn't work for you.

Gonners · 19/01/2024 07:56

@CarrotsAndCheese Unfortunately, they have thrown the baby out with the bathwater and removed the ability to book any appts that way, whether urgent or routine. It was so easy to book routine appts on Patient Access - I could select the doctor, day and time, with no complicated form and without having to battle with a receptionist on the phone.

I've just checked and ours is still working, though they seem to have changed the menu layout to baffle the unwary. I was offered the option of 4 appointment times this morning, between 10 and 11:30, all with my own GP. They are doing something very right there, bearing in mind that where we live, 20% of the population is over 70!

Bargello · 19/01/2024 07:52

Shaketurn · 18/01/2024 19:53

What about people who can't use online methods? My grandad can use a phone to ring but can't do anything online.

My mum is the same. She doesn't even own an internet connected phone, ipad or laptop. She;d have to ring me and ask me to fill the forms in for her.

I think adding the option of online appointments or similar is a great thing. Having it as the only option is not a good thing.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 19/01/2024 07:49

Fliopen · 18/01/2024 21:54

Well are they capable of learning to use it?

My elderly uncle would be capable of learning but why should he? It would involve buying a laptop or tablet and paying for internet/data that he would only use to contact the GP.

You can message on behalf of someone else so you could message on behalf of an elderly relative.

Why should the elderly have to share their medical information with someone else? To use my Uncle as an example, he's 88 and quite capable of sorting out his own appointments without sharing information with me.

Agnes12 · 19/01/2024 07:46

I did read somewhere that if a GP doesn’t allow phone appointments as well as online form then they are breaching their GP contract with the NHS. The thing is I don’t think they openly say you can phone. They do try to funnel everyone through the online route.

Oldsu · 19/01/2024 03:18

I have always said I might have been dead now when just telephone appointments only were offered, with this new way of doing things I now think I actually would have died, I have posted this before so will be brief, basically I had been unwell two GP appoints hadn't helped first said reaction to anti biotics second a week later said virus, 5 days after the virus diagnosis my DH took me to A&E the triage nurse refused even to let me see a Dr and threw me out, I got an emergency appointment with the practise nurse who immediately fetched the GP the same one who had seen me less than a week before, because I was in front of him he could immediately see how much I had deteriorated got me back to A&E, I had SEPSIS my body was at the point of shutting down I nearly died.

A phone appointment would not have alerted the GP to how much worse I was, he wouldn't have seen how much weight I had lost in less than a week it would have been even worse under this scheme.

bossasstwitch · 19/01/2024 00:57

My gp surgery is great, our phone lines are open for 2 1/2 hours in the morning and again in the afternoon. You wait in the queue and speak to the doctor directly over the phone. We are kept informed of our queue position while we are waiting and I have never waited longer than 15 minutes. Most of the time if you need antibiotics or something they just leave a prescription at reception without being seen and if you do need to see the doctor , you are seen the same day.

EBearhug · 19/01/2024 00:27

I'm pretty sure you can make in-person appointments at our surgery still.

PoptartPoptart · 19/01/2024 00:14

I had a similar experience to @plominoagain.
The pharmacist couldn’t help me and told me to see a doctor asap. I walked across the street to my doctors, stood at Reception near to tears as I was in a lot of pain. The Receptionist told me that I couldn’t make an appointment in person and I had to go home to book an appointment online. Bonkers.

TooTrusting · 18/01/2024 23:55

My GP has had this for over 2 years now - you have to use a platform called AskMyGP. But you have to be very quick off the mark because once they have x number of requests it closes for the day automatically.

However what they don't tell you is that if you do not have computer access you CAN still telephone. Otherwise they are breaching the Equalities Act for those who have protected characteristic, such as the elderly, by not making reasonable adjustments (the reasonable adjustment here being allowing phone calls).

I was unable to sign by elderly parents up to AskMyGP so when they need an appointment I just telephone, or they do. Although the recorded message that you have to listen to before being put through to a human also tells you that you cannot make an appointment by phone, you can.

I quite like AskMyGP, in general it's worked well for me and the DCs, you can attach photos and there's space for an explanation and it often allows them to sort out what you need without an appointment.

CarrotsAndCheese · 18/01/2024 23:45

Boomboom22 · 18/01/2024 21:18

But @101Nutella the current system favours people out of work with no kids so is more discriminatory. I'd think most people can access online and certainly more than have hours free at 8.30am on the dot every morning. As long as calls can still be taken. Most retired people do use the Internet! My dad is 77 and been using the Internet since it started. Anyone who has been at work in the last 25 years can use an Internet form. Plus they are thr same as paper forms online but easier, as you can't miss a box, and you can zoom in etc which again is more accessible for more disabilities. Its much more accessible for autistic people who have to psych themselves up to make a phone call and cope with gp receptionists who come across as very rude gatekeepers, same for any mh issue. It also avoids receptionists triaging which means cancer symptoms and other red flags are leas likely to be missed.

I'm sorry but it's not true that the new system is more accessible for those with disabilities. Lots of fairly common conditions, both individual conditions or co-morbid ones, can cause someone to have difficulty with completing forms and also have trouble making phone calls. For example, depression, autism, anxiety. So if you can't access the online form for whatever reason, phoning the surgery is not necessarily an accessible alternative.

Luckyduc · 18/01/2024 23:34

We have this and it works superbly. Best thing they did. It means that people who need the appointments actually get seen.. Dr's can also prwscive what you need based on symptoms etc.

Agnes12 · 18/01/2024 23:28

We have this system now. You are given a time for the Doctor to call. I had a telephone appointment after completing the form. It was supposed to be between 9-10 am on a particular day. Call didn’t come until 12.00 by which time I was in an area with terrible signal. I don’t know how people who work full time manage as you can’t now pre book an appointment. When I was working, if it wasn’t urgent, I’d just book the earliest appointment in the day I could get even if it was 3 weeks away and then go into work. You can’t do that now. You just are given a day/time by text message if it is deemed you need an appointment after completing the form.

CarrotsAndCheese · 18/01/2024 23:13

EmmaEmerald · 18/01/2024 23:05

Ah, that's what it was, Patient Access! No notification that it was no longer in use either. Was v good.

Indeed. I kept looking for routine appts on Patient Access and it kept saying none were available at this time. After a couple of months, I contacted the surgery, who said "Oh yes, the new Klinik triage system applies to both urgent and routine appts" 🙄

PeskyPotato · 18/01/2024 23:09

This sounds amazing!! I've been trying the 8am rush for an appointment every day this week so far!

Swipe left for the next trending thread