Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was inappropriate?

184 replies

NoCoat · 18/01/2024 18:40

We’ve just had someone come up to us as we’re getting our 2 year old into the car to be told that we need to think of our child as it is -5 degrees (it’s actually 3 degrees but not really the point) and they’re not wearing a coat or socks and she is a social worker and couldn’t not say something… we have literally just come out of a warm shopping centre and their shoes and coat are clearly under the pram and they had a blanket that they have put behind them. I thought you were supposed to put children in the car seat without coats on anyway??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
peakygold · 22/01/2024 13:45

I would love to hear the other side of this story though.

T1Dmama · 21/01/2024 09:08

Take no notice.
im betting she wasn’t a social worker and just some interfering busy body!
I’d have responded by thanking her for the information and then turning away and continuing to strap my child in the car while ignoring her!….
People like that usually just walk off muttering!

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 20/01/2024 12:57

If she's a social worker, I'm a monkey's uncle.

Of course, it was inappropriate. Toddlers remove socks and shoes all the time. Trying to get them back on instead of just getting into a car and cranking the heat would have taken longer.

Ignore people like this; they want to validate themselves and end up doing the opposite.

MsSquiz · 20/01/2024 11:41

My child was out in no socks/shoes yesterday on the walk from shopping centre to the car because she had taken her shoes and socks off while in the pram! In fact, we went to the car without DH because she chucked a shoe somewhere but her socks and 1 shoe were in the pram!

If someone came up to me, they'd be told to butt out! A 1 second snapshot of our day does not give an indication that my child is neglected!

Addled1 · 20/01/2024 10:27

I would put money on her not being a social worker as it would be extremely unprofessional to come up to you that way. If she is a social worker she wants reporting for misguided opinions as social workers frequently transport kids in their cars and should know that coats must not be worn in car seats

Lennon80 · 20/01/2024 09:55

Social worker is a protected title it’s against the law to claim to be one. This person clearly wasn’t one so I’d have reminded them purporting to be one is a criminal offence.

Bravest · 20/01/2024 07:38

I understand no socks as my children used to take them off all the time

Retiredfromearlyyears · 20/01/2024 07:19

Was this supposed social worker an older lady? I only ask as different child care advice would have applied to her perhaps. My daughter always had her coat or jacket on in the car seat.We simply weren't aware then that it was dangerous. Also if I had seen a bare footed child in winter weather, I would have been worried about that too. I know my little granddaughter pulls her socks off indoors all the ,time,but, she has shoes and socks on outside. When I worked in Early Years I used to ask " Can they have a hat and spare gloves to nursery please. They will be outdoors at certain points today" It was never a problem although parents did tell me often ,they had those items in the child's bag but the child refused to keep them on! Sometimes it's the child's choice too. Being a parent isn't easy ,but I don't really think the 'maybe social worker' did or said anything untoward really. Better than folks who don't notice or just don't care about children at all.

Butterandtoast · 19/01/2024 23:25

Just ignore people like this op

Going from a warm shopping center to what will very quickly be a warm car is absolutely fine. Its not neglectful, red flag etc..

My 18m old strips off at any opportunity he can even in these freezing temperatures. House isn't massively warm but he wants to be just in a nappy and vest. Most of my day is spent trying to get clothes back on him.

Anyone commenting on socks and coats would just get back an eye roll at most from me.

Justus6 · 19/01/2024 22:34

Clearly not a social worker or she'd know it dangerous to put a coat on in the car seat.

Also taking a short walk from the shop to the car is not going to harm them especially with the blanket come on people!

Montegufoni2017 · 19/01/2024 22:32

Did you also have your coat and socks off? Would you have in 3 degree weather?! I certainly wouldn’t. Yes, no puffy coats in car seats but that doesn’t mean they go without, even if it is just that couple of minute walk to the car from a shop. It’s FREEZING. I have a car coat for my daughter which is a thin zip up fleece type thing and then her big coat which we do a mega fast swap over of at the car door. And no shoes/socks!!! I don’t even want my DD without socks at home in this current weather!
Thinks it’s good this woman has the balls to come and speak to you, hopefully you’ll listen to this thread too.

Trishthedish · 19/01/2024 22:32

When my son was small he would not keep socks or shoes on. Some mum in Waitrose had a go at me. I said if you’re so clever you put them on him. He’s 38 now and still goes barefoot whenever he can.

WagWoofWalkMeeoow · 19/01/2024 22:30

MrsR87 · 18/01/2024 20:55

Before having my own children I’d have probably raised an eyebrow but certainly not said anything. Now I have my own children, I wouldn’t even notice/bat an eyelid.
When I drop my one year old and three year old at nursery in a morning, I know I get judged by other parents for taking them out the car to the nursery door without a coat on but there’s not a cat in hells chance I would allow them to wear a coat in a car seat and to put a coat on the one year old once out the car would take far longer than just heading straight to the nursery door! Instead we have mittens, hats and also woolly blankets that they have over them in the car that I then wrap round them to head inside.

@MrsR87

people get confused when someone uses common sense!!

vjmousey · 19/01/2024 22:28

If you were wearing a coat and socks, maybe your child might need them too?

WagWoofWalkMeeoow · 19/01/2024 22:27

fourlambbhunas · 18/01/2024 20:52

@WagWoofWalkMeeoow I'm not bellyaching about them putting her in a buggy 🤣 you've completely misread my message. In what world would I be saying put the pram in the car seat? How many wines did you have with dinner??

@fourlambbhunas

you wrote Why don't you put her in the pram.

I think it was you that had been drinking!

helpihaveateen · 19/01/2024 22:22

@NoCoat i haven’t been wearing socks this week!
I’ve been wearing little shoes.
I’ve not walked far! Car - shop - car - office
I tend not to wear a coat because it’s too damn hot inside with one on and I’m taking 20 steps outside so don’t really need it!

if your child is warm enough, they are fine.
some people are precious for precious sake with an overwhelming desire to follow daft rules for rules sake !! With a greater concern that they might be judged by a stranger than actually what is best for their child!

the number of times I walked out of a supermarket with a small pair of socks sticking out the back pocket of my jeans is uncountable! They’d start with them on and be off within minutes! - just simply not worth the effort if they’re staying in the trolley.

the child has a blanket in the car and is presumably safely restrained in their car seat and not in a padded coat, which (for the benefit of the judgy people!) could cause life threatening injuries if you had a bump.

you do you OP! There’s nothing wrong with what you’re doing.

Loramora · 19/01/2024 22:19

The child didn’t have a coat whilst getting into the car, it’s hardly ‘ how dare people see a child with bruises and welts and didn’t say anything’.

I hope going off the comment everytime you see a rough as arsed mom scream at their kids in the street you go up to said mother and feel it’s your duty to point out the abuse.

Loramora · 19/01/2024 22:17

No social worker would actually say this. Just a busy body making her feelings known.

Abbyant · 19/01/2024 22:13

If a stranger comes up to me and tells me they are “insert person of authority” I always ask for proof because so many people lie. You are not wrong children shouldn’t have coats on I a car seat.

Charm24 · 19/01/2024 20:42

You’re right, it’s not safe to put them in a car seat with coats and bulky clothes on. Shocks me how many times I see this. And kids take socks off all the time. If you are going from somewhere warm and getting them straight in the car then I don’t see the problem. I do the same and my little one is fine. I put a blanket on him once he is in the car and get the heating on and we are good to go. Social worker or not, it’s not necessary to comment when she doesn’t know the full picture

xxxjanxxx · 19/01/2024 20:09

@NoCoat their shoes and coat are clearly under the pram and they had a blanket that they have put behind them
If that was my child, the blanket would have been tucked around my child when we went from the warmth of the shopping centre to the cold outside.

However, I'm more concerned about posters here apparently saying that people should never interfere when they feel uncomfortable about how a child is being treated.

In a situation like this, how do you know if you're speaking to a parent who looks after their child properly, or if you're speaking to a parent who is neglecting their child?

People usually just want to help and their instinct is to look after the most vulnerable - i.e. children. And that's the way the world should work - so please don't take offence because someone is just trying to look out for a child's welfare

ElonsPsychic · 19/01/2024 20:08

Yanbu that's really inappropriate.

BrizzleMaverick · 19/01/2024 19:31

I feel your pain with the sock situation. Today my two year old took her shoes and socks off while we were in Aldi. No problem as we were inside.
However she then refused to put them on including the socks. I wasn't going to have it turn in to a full tantrum because I wanted her to have shoes and socks on for the 30 second walk back to the car where we would then have the heater on.

I'd ignore this person and think nothing more of it.

Peanutsnanna · 19/01/2024 19:18

She meant well. I wonder how many children have suffered because we looked the other way and.minded our own business.

Grimfoxx · 19/01/2024 19:16

A short trip from the shop to the car with no socks on isn’t going to kill the child.

Mine kept chucking his gloves off in similar temperatures. He wasn’t upset by the fact that his hands were cold. He didn’t get ill or die.

what exactly do people think the harm is here?

Swipe left for the next trending thread