Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely hate heat pumps?!

140 replies

Rosesandstars · 18/01/2024 16:57

We moved into a house with a heat pump already set up. It is awful- it takes ages for the heating to get to any reasonable temperature and the hot water runs out after a 15 minute shower, it then takes over an hour to heat up again. Does anyone else find the same or AIBU?


Updated by MNHQ
Landed on this page in search of heat pump advice? Find our guide to installing a heat pump in your UK home here. HTH!

OP posts:
Happyhappyday · 19/01/2024 02:20

Heat pumps absolutely do not need to be installed in new homes and actually are NOT recommended for underfloor heating. Ours coped just fine with the 15f temps we just had here too.

Happyhappyday · 19/01/2024 02:17

We have both heat pumps powering mini split units (AC and heat) and hydroponic underfloor heating powered by a gas boiler. If I want the house to heat up fast, I use the heat pump.

TempestTost · 19/01/2024 02:16

CanadaNotAMum · 19/01/2024 00:12

No. I don’t know anybody who has that. Not common here at all. I’ve heard of it in some high end homes, but never seen it in person. Most common are baseboard heating (usually electric) or a furnace (the modern ones are electric, older ones could be natural gas or even oil).

Also, I’m curious about the people referencing hot water tanks being related to heat pumps. This is not a thing in Canada and it seems odd. The hot water tank isn’t connected to our heating system (unless people are using a furnace of some kind). Here a hot water tank is a separate appliance that is powered by electricity.

Edited

If you go way back, a lot of people here in Canada did use their wood stoves to heat hot water, there would be a tank attached to the cook stove.

At some point though we separated our hot water tanks from the boilers used for heating. Which seems odd in a way since we have our heat on so much of the year compared to the British, it seems like it would make more sense the other way around. They turn off the boiler but keep an electric hw tank, we use both most of the year. Though our summers can be hotter in some cases.

It's especially weird when people have hot water heating, plus a water heater, it seems a bit redundant. I wonder if it was when many people started to use forced air instead that it changed?

TempestTost · 19/01/2024 02:08

I find the British attitude to heat pumps odd. I live in Canada, and we get quite cold, and lots of people have heat pumps and usually rave about the money they save. And I don't mean only in nice, new, insulated homes, I mean in cottages, or old places too, sometimes with limited insulation, although obviously that's not ideal. I'm hoping to get one for my house which is 200 years old and rather cavernous - my limitations are going to be on the duct work required, which is an old house thing.

I've never heard anyone here say they need in-floor heating, and that doesn't seem ideal to me since both are slow. But we do normally use them with a second heat source. Occasionally (not often) a furnace, or a wood burner, often electric heat or even solar, whatever, for the dead of winter when the heat pump won't keep up. The heat pump is used through the shoulder seasons, and maybe the summer for cooling in certain areas. Most insurers here won't insure your house with just a heat pump.

We don't typically use the same ones you see in the UK. They are generally much smaller.

CanadaNotAMum · 19/01/2024 01:56

ohdeerohdear · 18/01/2024 21:28

You've got it set too high. With the freezing air outside, the heat pump will struggle to heat your home to 21. We have ours set to 16 upstairs and 18 downstairs. Got to keep doors closed and need well sealed windows.

A heat pump that is properly sized should not be struggling to hear a home to 21 degrees. OP, whatever the lowest rating is for the pump you have, it will start to be less efficient when the outside temp drops to about 7 degrees Celsius higher than the lowest rating. For example, mine is rated to -22 Celsius, meaning that once the outside temp is -15 or less, it does work harder.

I wonder if you’re not turning it high enough. The heat setting doesn’t always correspond to the room temp. If you’re setting it to 21, that’s the max temp of the air it’s forcing out. So if you actually want your rooms to feel 21, you should be setting the heat pump higher for a bit. 24 degree air will heat your home to 21 faster than air that is 21 degrees.

I keep mine set to 21 in the night, which usually results in most of the flat being about 19. In the morning, I turn it up to 26 for an hour or so, which brings the room temp to 20-23, depending on the room and distance from the unit. Once the place is warm enough, usually when I’m making my second cup of tea, I’ll turn it down to 24, which maintains the room temp of 21-22 degrees until I go to bed.

And this is not wasteful. Heating a home to 20-22 degrees is not extravagant. It’s also how you avoid “damp”, and is how your unit is designed to be used. Where I live, it’s a standard requirement for home insurance and apartment leases that you must maintain a minimum indoor temp of 17 degrees, so 18 degrees is cutting it close IMO. North Americans and their insurance companies do not mess around with mold.

Usou · 19/01/2024 01:37

Heat pumps work best in houses with a good Building Energy Rating (BER) of A1 to B3 - possibly C1, and underfloor heating. They are less effective if connected to older radiators.

They need to run continuously and should not be turned on and off. They should go off automatically in summer when temperatures increase and then just heat water. They are slow to respond to big differences in temperature, ie if doors are left open - they cannot "ramp up" like a gas boiler.

They need to be serviced annually when refrigerant gas levels should be checked.

If all the above are in place, they should save loads of energy. The man who would not install one in an older retrofitted house probably has doubts about air-tightness and maybe wall and floor insulation.

kisstheblarney · 19/01/2024 01:18

Futb0l · 18/01/2024 22:03

Melmos ive never shampooed my hair twice in my life!

I only really shave my legs in summer and only once a week, and don't exfoliate or get skin off my feet either....

Which would a plain why you have short showers, but we're talking about the use that OP wants from a heating system.

15 mins is not enough for her.

kisstheblarney · 19/01/2024 01:11

Jovacknockowitch · 18/01/2024 17:11

Who has a 15 minute shower?

Me when washing my very long, very thick hair.

LovePoppy · 19/01/2024 01:09

CanadaNotAMum · 19/01/2024 00:12

No. I don’t know anybody who has that. Not common here at all. I’ve heard of it in some high end homes, but never seen it in person. Most common are baseboard heating (usually electric) or a furnace (the modern ones are electric, older ones could be natural gas or even oil).

Also, I’m curious about the people referencing hot water tanks being related to heat pumps. This is not a thing in Canada and it seems odd. The hot water tank isn’t connected to our heating system (unless people are using a furnace of some kind). Here a hot water tank is a separate appliance that is powered by electricity.

Edited

We heat very differently here in Canada I’ve learned.

re underfloor heating, after a fire demanded a Reno, my father had it installed in the kitchen. Height of luxury. Rest of the house is heated by radiators (oil furnace) and electric baseboard. House was built in the 1890s though

eta my house built in late 70s is baseboard only. Once we replace more windows we will get a heat pump

Charlize43 · 19/01/2024 01:07

ThingsgetbetterwithalittlebitofRazzmatazz · 18/01/2024 17:26

We have a heat pump and love it but it is a very different way of heating the house to a normal boiler. You need to keep the house warm all the time as it takes a long time to get the house warm again if it gets cold. We keep it at 18 overnight and 20 during the day when we're at home. The house is always lovely and cosy and it costs less to keep it warm than it used to with the gas boiler.

We don't have any issue with the hot water, all 4 of us can have a shower without a problem, you might need someone who is familiar with setting them up to come and help you get the settings right for you.

That doesn't sound very economical if you are running it 24/07.

Are they expensive to run in the long run?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/01/2024 00:48

15 min is a reasonable amount of time for a shower with the water running the whole time. Generally I can get in and out in 10 but it’s longer to shave my legs.

Even with high water pressure and no water saver on my shower head it takes at least 10 to rinse the shampoo and conditioner out of my hair.

Sorry OP, have no advice for your heater (but it does sound very underpowered) but the 4 min shower brigade annoyed me into commenting.

PickAChew · 19/01/2024 00:38

15 minutes of hot water is not a big ask if you have thick hair and are the 3rd person in the house to use the shower while someone is also washing the breakfast dishes.

It takes me a couple of minutes just to get my hair wet.

CanadaNotAMum · 19/01/2024 00:33

Futb0l · 18/01/2024 22:06

Before it was installed the house was tested and sealed for airtightness as that maximises efficiency of the heat pump.

But how do you air the house? Where does all the moisture go from condensation from showers, steam from iron/tumbledrier, cooking etc?

Bathroom ceiling fan, kitchen range fan? Maybe tumbledriers are different in the UK, but here, there is a duct from the dryer that vents the steam outdoors. There are some ductless ones (heat pump technology, I have one and I do hate it because it takes forever) and the grey water drains into my hose thing.

CanadaNotAMum · 19/01/2024 00:28

Ponderingwindow · 18/01/2024 19:21

You just set the temperature for your house and let the heat pump click on and off as needed to maintain temperature. Barring extreme weather, it will just run for brief periods of time throughout the day and night. You never want to let the house get very cold and then need to bring it back up as that is really inefficient and expensive.

we do use an electronic thermostat with a timer that lets us drop the temp a bit at night. Then it is programmed to bring the house back up to temperature before we get out of bed in the morning.

Unless you are going to be away for several days, don’t turn off the heat.

if you are running out of hot water very quickly you have one of three problems. 1) your tank is undersized for the house 2) the tank has built up sediment and needs to be drained 3) the tank has outlived its life expectancy and needs to be replaced

ill be honest and say we got tired of trying to balance multiple people wanting to shower in a row, while someone was also washing dishes. We put in a tankless water heater.

Yes! I’m learning through this thread that in the UK it’s common to have no heat on at all for large portions of the day or night in cool weather. Here in Canada, once it gets cold enough in the fall to require heating, we turn on the thermostat (at least in the main area of the house) and we don’t turn it off completely until the spring. We might adjust the temperature, but there is always some heat.

It’s essential to have a certain amount of heat on from late Oct-end of March. Not just to avoid frozen pipes, but to avoid getting mold (damp). People in the UK seem to talk about having issues with damp (aka mold and mildew) a lot compared to here, now I’m thinking this might be why.

CanadaNotAMum · 19/01/2024 00:12

Futb0l · 18/01/2024 22:41

Canada

Do you have underfloor heating

No. I don’t know anybody who has that. Not common here at all. I’ve heard of it in some high end homes, but never seen it in person. Most common are baseboard heating (usually electric) or a furnace (the modern ones are electric, older ones could be natural gas or even oil).

Also, I’m curious about the people referencing hot water tanks being related to heat pumps. This is not a thing in Canada and it seems odd. The hot water tank isn’t connected to our heating system (unless people are using a furnace of some kind). Here a hot water tank is a separate appliance that is powered by electricity.

BatteryPowerGnat · 19/01/2024 00:11

melmos · 18/01/2024 21:51

100% not the point of this thread but who has their big shower without it taking 15mins?! I am pretty low maintenance but once you've covered a double shampoo, conditioner, super glam feet dead skin removal (i need a revolting sort of foot grater), exfoliating, washing and shaving I am normally at 20 mins!

Surely you don't have the water running all the time?

CanadaNotAMum · 19/01/2024 00:10

No. I don’t know anybody who has that. Not common here at all. I’ve heard of it in some high end homes, but never seen it in person. Most common are baseboard heating (usually electric) or a furnace (the modern ones are electric, older ones could be natural gas or even oil).

Bythefireside · 18/01/2024 23:12

Me too

Truebee · 18/01/2024 22:56

Did they upgrade the radiators when the heatpump was put in? they should look about 30- 40% bigger than normal rads.

Mardyybum · 18/01/2024 22:55

My husband’s job is to train heat pump surveyors and installers. He has a lot of experience with them over the last few years.
We are currently renovating a property to live in and he said under no circumstances would we get a heat pump, so go figure 😂

RidingMyBike · 18/01/2024 22:48

Metallicant · 18/01/2024 21:48

We have one at work and I hate it. It gets oppressively hot and then the moment the room reaches a certain temperature it starts blowing out freezing cold air to get the temperature down. It’s never just right.

That's an air con unit, surely? Doesn't sound like a heat pump! Heat pumps heat either radiators or under floor heating. And a hot water cylinder. They don't have a cooling function ie they don't lower the temperature.

Futb0l · 18/01/2024 22:41

Canada

Do you have underfloor heating

CanadaNotAMum · 18/01/2024 22:36

Maybe the terminology is different in the UK, but I live in a poorly insulated 100 year old flat in Montreal, Quebec. We can have 30 c in the summer and our average daily low temp for Jan-Feb is about -14 c not counting wind chill.

I have electric baseboard heaters that were there when I bought the place, but I had a mini split heat pump installed about 6 years ago. It’s my primary heat source now. Some cold days in January I will turn on the baseboard heater that’s furthest away from the heat pump wall unit, but overall it’s great. The only times when I’ve had to turn on more than 1 baseboard were during a 3 day cold snap last year where it was -30 c. Overall, my electricity costs are about 30% less than they were previously. I’m baffled at the hate!

it’s possible you guys aren’t getting the right size or type heat pumps for your home, or that the terminology is different and we are talking about different things entirely,

Potatodreams · 18/01/2024 22:22

melmos · 18/01/2024 21:51

100% not the point of this thread but who has their big shower without it taking 15mins?! I am pretty low maintenance but once you've covered a double shampoo, conditioner, super glam feet dead skin removal (i need a revolting sort of foot grater), exfoliating, washing and shaving I am normally at 20 mins!

I get in the bath if I’m going to do all that.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 18/01/2024 22:14

Trouble is the system isn't regulated unlike gas where you have to be gas safe. Anyone can claim they know what they're doing and lots of cowboys have mis-sold them.

It sounds like your system was poorly designed for the property.

However, there is a registered verification scheme for installers which shows a level of skill and expertise, it's voluntary not compulsory, because - unregulated.
https://mcscertified.com/

I would contact one of the registered installers and get the system reviewed. Maybe a replacement water tank could be all you need.
But a well designed system should perform to good comfort and heat demand requirements, so I think while your experience is not a good one, that doesn't mean great pumps are rubbish generally.

MCS Certified | Giving you confidence in home-grown energy

Working with energy installers and manufacturers, MCS defines, maintains and improves quality – certifying low-carbon technology.

https://mcscertified.com