Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd shouted and hit me

112 replies

Ffswhatshappenednow · 18/01/2024 16:28

How would you deal with this?

Dd, 5.5 is generally a very sweet, fun and bright girl, but often finds her hard to control her temper.
We’ve just had a nice time making brownies, sat down with hot chocolate and read stories. All was fine until she saw i
was drinking out of her cup (she’s not normally territorial or fixed on certain things) we both recently bought new cups with dogs on and said only for us to use (bit of a joke as Dh uses all the cups and loses them)
Dds and I new cups are v similar, I was drinking from hers by mistake. She just completely blew up, shouted and hit me.

Ive just switched off the show she wanted to watch and said no more tv and she’s got more upset and said she doesn’t like me anymore and wants me to stay at work forever when I go (saying unkind things is fairly new too)

Is this all normal behaviour?

How would you deal with it?

OP posts:
rainbowsparkle28 · 18/01/2024 22:28

Mariposistaaa · 18/01/2024 17:23

Straight to bed and any parties she was going to at the weekend cancelled. Horrible behaviour.

🙄 At that age she is not going to see the connection with something that happens days later to her behaviour right now so is pointless other than just upsetting everybody. As others have said a clear management of it at the moment it happens with appropriate consequence like they have done will be more effective.

DyslexicPoster · 18/01/2024 22:22

My kids who blow up have SEN so this might help you but....

Think of the fire triangle. If you feel she is escalating. Remove the oxygen. If this carry on, I'm going to stop talking to you until you calm down, I'm not saying anymore now until your calm. Then totally ignore her until she is calm.

Then once she is calm, give her food and a drink then do the " when you did x it made me feel y. What was going on in your head / what was you thinking"

Obviously no good in a sudden lashing out of course. I just don't argue with my kids.

NeedToChangeName · 18/01/2024 22:20

Alwaysalwayscold · 18/01/2024 16:54

Nobody on here will agree but I am a very strong believer in teaching to hit back. I want my kids to know from an early age that if you take it upon yourself to hit someone then they can/will hit back. Same applies if someone hits them they are within their rights to defend their self.

I would give a tap on the wrist.

Oh wow, I am surprised that in 2024, people are still advocating hitting children

@Alwaysalwayscold would you support a man hitting his partner if he felt she was out of line?

goodkidsmaadhouse · 18/01/2024 22:17

@Nestofwalnuts That was horrible to read and shows a total lack of understanding of child brain development.

OP I think you handled it just fine. I wouldn’t stress about it any further. Regardless of what PPs say, a lot of 5 year olds lash out now and then. I work with this age group and I can tell you that the ones who actually come to school and lash out are NOT the ones whose parents are disciplining them with boundaries and love, which is what sounds like you’ve done here.

Ffswhatshappenednow · 18/01/2024 22:14

@CurlewKate I didn’t get much chance as she reacted so quickly and I hadn’t even realised I had picked up her cup (both ours were next to each other and v similar with a dog on) After she’d calmed I said it was an accident as I hadn’t even realised it was hers, I didn’t apologise because at that point I was so angry about her reaction

OP posts:
Ffswhatshappenednow · 18/01/2024 22:12

@Noicant Yes, that’s exactly what I said

OP posts:
Ffswhatshappenednow · 18/01/2024 22:12

@Nestofwalnuts Reading that approach just made me feel really uncomfortable 😳

OP posts:
Secondstart1001 · 18/01/2024 19:58

Please put a stop to it … I’m talking from experience and I didn’t manage it well. She’s 17 now and she’s bite me, hit me and bruised me pretty badly at her worst and can be abusive if she doesn’t get her own way.

Noicant · 18/01/2024 19:20

I think the key is regardless of how you feel you don’t hit. Thats the lesson I’m trying to teach my DC, I get angry but I don’t hit people, kids need to understand that. Object loudly by all means but hitting is crossing a line.

Mumof2NDers · 18/01/2024 19:18

I think you handled it perfectly. I would thank her for her apology and move on.

CurlewKate · 18/01/2024 19:05

Did you quickly apologise for using her mug? That might have diffused the situation before it started.

Noicant · 18/01/2024 19:04

DD loses something like TV for a day for behaviour like hitting. Generally we are pretty laidback parents but DD is a very strong personality and needs firm boundaries around hitting specifically (she’s a lovely cheerful kid but has a temper) It has massively reduced negative behaviour. But I warned her of the consequences in advance so she knows what the deal is so it’s fair.

Bookist · 18/01/2024 18:58

I wouldn't care if they were tired, or over-hyped on sugar. At 5 they have already been in formal school for a year and know damn well that hitting is totally unacceptable (or they should know). I would take a very dim view of this behaviour and would tell DD so, in a very stern voice. No TV tonight. Nothing else nice either. Only a perfunctory bath and bedtime.

They need to know in their bones that their behaviour is totally unacceptable. No ifs or buts. You then accept their apology, share a hug and life goes on. But the line has been drawn and they'll be very wary of crossing it again.

All this mealy mouthed, ineffectual tutting and gentle explanations about 'how it makes Mummy sad' is why some parents end up with older children who are still hitting, who are still verbally abusive to the parents and are insufferable brats.

Mariposistaaa · 18/01/2024 18:54

HelpMeGetThrough · 18/01/2024 17:35

How would you deal with this?

Off to bed she would be going and she could have a tantrum in her room for as long as she wanted.

Finally a parent who actually does some parenting.
oh but on MN this would be abuse. You would have to ‘have a chat’ about her behavior, acknowledge her feelings, and give countless undeserved cuddles. And probably apologise for making her angry.
It’s no wonder so many children are feral.

HarrietPierce · 18/01/2024 18:53

Nestofwalnuts Chilling response.
OP - beautifully handled

pointythings · 18/01/2024 18:50

I think you handled it just right, OP. Ignore the posters basically calling for the firing squad, they're ridiculous.

ChimbarasiKotapaxi · 18/01/2024 18:43

Nestofwalnuts - ghastly
OP - beautifully handled

MeinKraft · 18/01/2024 18:39

Some of the advice on this thread is completely mental.

Your approach was great OP. Have a nice evening with your kid.

Snowydaysfaraway · 18/01/2024 18:34

Witching hour isn't just for babies... After school until bedtime is awful with small dc... Ime.. Wrap up the brownies and tomorrow is a new day.

3WildOnes · 18/01/2024 18:34

FloraMacDonaldsFancy · 18/01/2024 18:13

I see ageism is still alive and well on MN then. There really was no need for this comment was there?

None of us have perfect memories! Most of us struggle to remember everything from decades ago, I know I certainly do.

LightSwerve · 18/01/2024 18:32

Nestofwalnuts · 18/01/2024 17:55

I would be very cross without raising my voice. In a calm, controlled voice, get down to her level, look her in the eye and say: Mummy loves you, Mummy bought you that mug, made you that hot chocolate, helped you make brownies, read you that story.All day long, I was doing lovely things with you because I love you and you repay me by hitting me? How dare you be so rude and cruel to someone who shows you love?

And that is a real question, not a rhetorical one. Make her answer it. How dare she be so cruel and rude? What was going on? Help her process it. Stay firm: "I was being a tiger' 'No, that's an excuse.' 'Sorry mummy' 'Thank you for your apology but it doesn't answer my question. How dare you be so rude and cruel? Why do you think you have the right to hurt people who love you? I love you. Do I have the right to hurt you if I want to? How would you feel if I did?'

Again, not rhetorical questions. Make her answer them.
End the discussion by asking, 'You didn't like me drinking from your cup. What could you have done to stop me, that isn't cruel and rude?'
This encourages her to process ways to handle anger in an appropriate way.

Finally, some kids get sugar rage. Brownies and hot choc aged 5 could lead to a blood sugar spike that causes anger. Tell her this and tell her you both need to watch out how she feels when she has sugar.

Edited

This is really weird.

Don't do this.

3WildOnes · 18/01/2024 18:31

Petrine · 18/01/2024 18:05

Nope, I may be older than you but my mental faculties are still sharp.

I can honestly say that my children never, ever raised a hand to me at any age and certainly would never have said hurtful things to me.

i don’t understand why, on the one hand, a teacher is reported by a mother for separating two girls in the playground using her hands (at the request of the parents) yet it appears to be ok for children, not just on this thread, to hit and abuse parents.

the playground issue was on a recent thread in case you’re wondering what I’m referring to.

I'm pretty sure I posted on that thread in support of the teacher! I remember small children lashing out at their parents years ago. I remember my little friend biting his mum and another throwing an apple at hers. Ive heard numerous older family members talking about biting their children back when they bit them. Maybe you were blessed with perfect children though!
Bullying and child on child violence have both decreased in the last few decades.

ShoePalaver · 18/01/2024 18:26

Nestofwalnuts · 18/01/2024 17:55

I would be very cross without raising my voice. In a calm, controlled voice, get down to her level, look her in the eye and say: Mummy loves you, Mummy bought you that mug, made you that hot chocolate, helped you make brownies, read you that story.All day long, I was doing lovely things with you because I love you and you repay me by hitting me? How dare you be so rude and cruel to someone who shows you love?

And that is a real question, not a rhetorical one. Make her answer it. How dare she be so cruel and rude? What was going on? Help her process it. Stay firm: "I was being a tiger' 'No, that's an excuse.' 'Sorry mummy' 'Thank you for your apology but it doesn't answer my question. How dare you be so rude and cruel? Why do you think you have the right to hurt people who love you? I love you. Do I have the right to hurt you if I want to? How would you feel if I did?'

Again, not rhetorical questions. Make her answer them.
End the discussion by asking, 'You didn't like me drinking from your cup. What could you have done to stop me, that isn't cruel and rude?'
This encourages her to process ways to handle anger in an appropriate way.

Finally, some kids get sugar rage. Brownies and hot choc aged 5 could lead to a blood sugar spike that causes anger. Tell her this and tell her you both need to watch out how she feels when she has sugar.

Edited

Ugh what a load of guilt tripping cringe. Have a read about why shaming children is counter productive

Happyhappyday · 18/01/2024 18:17

my DC unfortunately does this pretty often. She is always very sorry afterwards. We’ve had a lot of success with waiting until everyone is calm. Helping to name feelings and what will we do next time. Plus natural consequence, so mugs and hot chocolate go away. We do DC has to stay in room until she’s calm and ready to apologize rather than a timed time out. We put her back in if she’s not actually calm. I am also careful to apologize if I reacted badly. Ie, if she hits me and I yell, I would say “I’m sorry for yelling, I was startled and it hurt, next time I will use my words to saying being hit really upsets me.”

We’ve seen a decrease in hitting but more importantly an increase in DC saying things like “mommy I know you didn’t mean to drink out of my mug but I really wanted to drink it and I’m mad you took my hot chocolate”

FloraMacDonaldsFancy · 18/01/2024 18:13

3WildOnes · 18/01/2024 17:35

Might just be your memory!

I see ageism is still alive and well on MN then. There really was no need for this comment was there?

Swipe left for the next trending thread