Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying teens new cars

156 replies

Lippitymoo · 18/01/2024 12:38

I’ve been with my partner for 3 years. He has twin 16 year olds (mum isn’t around at all she upped and left them all). Ae don’t live together but are very serious, just won’t live in while our children are at home (I have a 15 year old).
His kids birthdays are in a few months. He’s told me he is planning to buy them both a brand new Hyundai i10. He says he just wants to get new as he hopes it will last them until they are financially independent and beyond that way. He also said he wants to be able to get the bigger engine for the sake of motorways and get them an automatic, so getting new will save the faff of finding something situ the requirements that they both like.
AIBU to think this is totally ridiculous?

OP posts:
ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 18/01/2024 15:41

I'm 45 and a couple of companies declined to quote me on my 6 year old BMW (just a regular 2l!) when it came for renewal this year. I've got over 25 years no claims too!

He's really going to struggle to insure them. I'd kindly suggest to him that he look in to that first before he commits to buying a car that they can't actually drive.

That said, it's likely cheaper to insure them on a car that is new but has excellent safety features, than a clapped out banger that has none. DH was dreading changing his insurance when he changed cars, but they actually gave him a refund, even though he'd just bought a £40k car compared to one that was worth about £10k.

He's obviously got plenty of disposable cash, so in the scheme of things it might be a drop in the ocean.

He refers to having £300k each, so there's at least £600,000 around. If he's financially savvy he's probably getting a return of at least 3% a year on that at the moment, so £18,000 in interest ("free" money) would almost cover one of the cars. Taking a further £22k hit in to the savings that would be recouped within another year or so really isn't much of a hardship.

Is it what I would do? Probably not, because I'd be pissed off if they bumped it in a car park.

He can afford it though and obviously thinks it's a nice thing to do and the cost isn't an issue for him, so I'd let him get on with it.

User1775 · 18/01/2024 15:39

Good luck with the insurance is all I can say. I bought 2x10 year old Aygos and the insurance was double the price of the cars!

RitzD · 18/01/2024 15:37

The numbers you are mentioning clearly illustrate that £40k is pretty much like £4k for most people. He is pretty loaded if he made £800k on moving house and are you saying he took some of the money from the £600k the kids are inheriting?

The one thing he does have is certainty of income in retirement which most people don’t have the luxury of. As a GP I would hazard a guess that his pension will be in excess of £50k a year and he will have the state pension on top.

it sounds to me like he can afford it.

RedPony1 · 18/01/2024 15:29

Malarandras · 18/01/2024 14:22

It would not be me doing it that’s for sure! Nobody bought me a car, I worked and saved for it. Unless he’s going to buy them everything throughout their whole lives then he’d do them a bigger favour teaching them to pay their own way.

Give over. My parents bought my first car, and all my ponies until i was 21 (when i finished education)
It has not remotely hindered me on learning about money, or paying my way.

gardenfoundry · 18/01/2024 15:27

Seems like a nice gesture to buy brand new, but for a small hatchback what's the point? Buy 3 or 4, years old and it's half the price... especially with the insurance!

Nicebloomers · 18/01/2024 15:26

FionnulaTheCooler · 18/01/2024 12:41

Good luck to him affording insurance for two teenagers on brand new cars.

This

Catapultaway · 18/01/2024 15:23

bellinisurge · 18/01/2024 14:58

I'd say he's fiddling his taxes or in secret crippling debt if he can afford to throw money around like that on a GP salary

🤣 it's £40k not £4m, how little do you think a GP earns

TheTigerWhoCameToEatMyHusband · 18/01/2024 15:17

Fruitflylady · 18/01/2024 13:22

It astonishes me that so many people buy cars for their kids. Teenagers don’t ‘need’ their own cars. What kind of lesson is this teaching them? Sure, we’d all love someone to just gift us a nice free car to use, but in the real world if you want a car you go out and earn the money to buy it.
I think it’s irresponsible parenting to do this; you’re not teaching your kids the value of things, and on top of it you’re adding yet more unnecessary cars to our already overcrowded roads.

I got bought an old banger when I was 17 and I will be doing the same for mine. I grew up i work hard, I saved and have bought many other cars since. I'm not spoilt and I know the value things. As a teen I did need a car to get to work and back and my parents wanted me to have one. Before that we had motorbikes 😂 mum and dad weren't running us around for anything on the road from 16

C00k · 18/01/2024 15:16

It's his private business and irrelevant if you think it's extravagant. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Lippitymoo · 18/01/2024 15:14

DPotter · 18/01/2024 15:11

Watch the engine capacity.

Was very surprised to find my 1.8 boring ol' ford considered a 'high performance vehicle' when trying to add DD, aged 17, on to my insurance and every company I contacted refused to even give a price, let alone a quote.

1.2 I believe.

OP posts:
Lippitymoo · 18/01/2024 15:14

bellinisurge · 18/01/2024 15:11

Op, I live "in the North". Doesn't save you that much

Well that’s not true at all. The whole reason he is mortgage free is because he moved from London to the Lakes when his kids were about 11.
He has a lovely house worth about £500,000 mortgage free, he told me his London home sold for £1,350,000 - that’s a massive difference!!

OP posts:
DPotter · 18/01/2024 15:11

Watch the engine capacity.

Was very surprised to find my 1.8 boring ol' ford considered a 'high performance vehicle' when trying to add DD, aged 17, on to my insurance and every company I contacted refused to even give a price, let alone a quote.

bellinisurge · 18/01/2024 15:11

Op, I live "in the North". Doesn't save you that much

tootrueblue · 18/01/2024 15:09

Your DP sounds clueless about cars to be fair. You don't need big engines to drive on motorways and generally speaking, the smaller the engine, the more affordable insurance will be. Additionally, new cars do a lot of depreciation in the first couple of years so being sensible, a 2 year old car is a much better idea - let the previous owner take the bulk of the initial depreciation.

OMirrorBall · 18/01/2024 15:05

Lippitymoo · 18/01/2024 15:02

I very much doubt that (he’s so not that type of person).
He’s mortgage free and his parents left money to them when they passed so I guess it’s mainly that helping. They also live in the north so his house was much more affordable.
I can’t say wholeheartedly he wouldn’t get into debt or do anything to avoid tax, he’s very reserved normally and financially savvy, but would do anything morally questionable.
I just think it’s extravagant!

If he doesn't regularly spend extravagantly then this seems like a reasonably practical thing for him to make his one expensive exception, given the practical and safety value and that they'll appreciate the gift and use them for years. I wouldn't personally, I'd think like you that a slightly older car would be better value. But I certainly wouldn't argue with a partner with separate finances and good savings about his decision to do so.

WishesPromises · 18/01/2024 15:03

If you don't live together and it doesn't impact you - then it's not really any of your beeswax is it?

This is why kids don't like step parents.

HairyQueenofSnots · 18/01/2024 15:03

Good luck to him.

The first car my brother had, he backed into a lamp post within a fortnight and spent the rest of its life driving around with a badly repaired dent all along the side panel.

Thank god it was just a £400 polo.

Catza · 18/01/2024 15:02

Fruitflylady · 18/01/2024 13:22

It astonishes me that so many people buy cars for their kids. Teenagers don’t ‘need’ their own cars. What kind of lesson is this teaching them? Sure, we’d all love someone to just gift us a nice free car to use, but in the real world if you want a car you go out and earn the money to buy it.
I think it’s irresponsible parenting to do this; you’re not teaching your kids the value of things, and on top of it you’re adding yet more unnecessary cars to our already overcrowded roads.

We live in a large-ish city in the South West and our public transport is virtually non-existent. It's hilly and it rains 9 months a year so cycling is out of question on longer routes. True, my teenager wouldn't die without a car but her having one means we, adults, can work and have a life rather than ferrying her around to college, sport and social outings.
In London, I wouldn't entertain a car for a second. I managed fine on public transport myself for 20+ years but when we moved it quickly became clear that neither of us would simply be able to manage without a car. I have to take two busses to get to work which would take 1,5h IF they came (and they frequently are cancelled due to driver shortage). We also had multiple bus routes cancelled last year as they were deemed not profitable. So I got a car.
If you are prepared to give your life up to be your teenager's taxi driver, have at it but in most parts of the country having a car is absolutely necessary.

Lippitymoo · 18/01/2024 15:02

bellinisurge · 18/01/2024 14:58

I'd say he's fiddling his taxes or in secret crippling debt if he can afford to throw money around like that on a GP salary

I very much doubt that (he’s so not that type of person).
He’s mortgage free and his parents left money to them when they passed so I guess it’s mainly that helping. They also live in the north so his house was much more affordable.
I can’t say wholeheartedly he wouldn’t get into debt or do anything to avoid tax, he’s very reserved normally and financially savvy, but would do anything morally questionable.
I just think it’s extravagant!

OP posts:
RosemaryDill · 18/01/2024 15:01

I wouldn't get them automatics but apart from that why not. Plus you imply it's their money anyway?

skippy67 · 18/01/2024 15:00

If he can afford it, why not? It's not as if he's asking you to chip in.

SkulkHollow · 18/01/2024 14:59

If they haven't even passed their tests yet, it's a complete waste of money. Wait until they pass at least.

The cars will need to be taxed, insured and maintained and for what? To sit on a driveway until the kids pass their tests?

BoohooWoohoo · 18/01/2024 14:59

If he has the money then why not buy a car? People on my street with more money than me seem to have gone for cars that are 2-5 years old and their teens/young adults are happy

bellinisurge · 18/01/2024 14:58

I'd say he's fiddling his taxes or in secret crippling debt if he can afford to throw money around like that on a GP salary

Angrymum22 · 18/01/2024 14:58

Brand new automatic cars that are around 1L are actually really cheap to insure.
Two reasons:

  1. very few teenagers drive automatic cars so the stats on teenagers having accidents are favourable leading to lower premiums. The worst car to buy a teenager is a manual 1L Ford Fiesta because it is the most popular teenage car and the one that most accidents are recorded in.
  2. New cars have far more safety features the most important one as far as far as the insurance companies are concerned is collision avoidance. This automatically applies the breaks if the sensors detect that you are not breaking early enough. Very useful in urban driving, they tend not to be as effective at speeds above 30 but prevent a lot of rear end shunts, probably the most common accident insurance companies pay out.

If he can afford new cars then that’s his decision. But as far as insurance is concerned it’s not necessarily more expensive.

Also the car is likely to be more reliable and maintenance costs low in the first three years.
DS 19 drives a VW Polo1L. I pay less than 1k for insurance and apart from a service it has cost very little to run. The car was 10mnth old when I bought it and since I drive it from time to time it is an automatic so it’s easier swapping from my car to his. He is the main driver on the insurance so is building up no claims. I may add him as named driver on our family car because it would be handy if he could drive it occasionally. It is a 3L though so may not be possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread