Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying teens new cars

156 replies

Lippitymoo · 18/01/2024 12:38

I’ve been with my partner for 3 years. He has twin 16 year olds (mum isn’t around at all she upped and left them all). Ae don’t live together but are very serious, just won’t live in while our children are at home (I have a 15 year old).
His kids birthdays are in a few months. He’s told me he is planning to buy them both a brand new Hyundai i10. He says he just wants to get new as he hopes it will last them until they are financially independent and beyond that way. He also said he wants to be able to get the bigger engine for the sake of motorways and get them an automatic, so getting new will save the faff of finding something situ the requirements that they both like.
AIBU to think this is totally ridiculous?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SingingSands · 19/01/2024 12:24

I can see both sides. My friends leased each of their 17yr olds a new car - they have 4 kids and can afford to.

We haven't done this as we can't afford to. We let our DC use my car temporarily when home from uni - and they pay towards the insurance and diesel.

I used to think it was a huge extravagance to buy teenagers cars, but I can see it gives them independence and responsibility, as well as freedom and opportunities (eg they can take jobs further from home or don't have to rely on night buses/trains).

MRSMTO · 19/01/2024 10:35

@user14699084788

Couldn't agree more with this. Exactly the same in both mine and my husbands family. I don't want to be dead before I see my son comfortable if I can help make him comfortable.

user14699084788 · 19/01/2024 09:19

Lonelycrab · 18/01/2024 21:40

Regardless of if he can afford it or not, I think it send out the wrong message. What’s next, buy the children a house each? Even if I was on a massive six or seven figure salary I wouldn’t do that.

There’s nothing wrong with driving something a few years old with low mileage.

As has been said, it’s not really your decision, but I think to voice how unreasonable it is, isn’t necessarily a bad thing, because it is.

If you could afford to buy, or help them buy a house (or indeed a car) why on earth wouldn’t you? In our family money has always flowed downwards, you need money when you’re young, not much use inheriting when you’re in your dotage!

Boomboomshakeshaketheroom · 19/01/2024 00:46

OP you could have started a (potentially) interesting debate about setting up teens with cars, without practically identifying your partner in your post.

We know where he lives, where he used to live and when he moved, that he's a GP, he has twins turning 17 soon and the girl plays competitive sport, he has a live-out partner of 3 years with a 15yo, his parents are dead and he's in a half-a-million dollar house... anyone who knows him IRL will recognise him in what you have written and see that you think he's ridiculous. You'd better hope the media doesn't pick this up!

Aquamarine1029 · 18/01/2024 23:54

I just think it’s extravagant!

Good for you. Your opinion is completely irrelevant. Not your kids, not your money.

Why you even started this thread is beyond me.

novocaine4thesoul · 18/01/2024 23:54

Whereas you are entitled to think what you like (so you are not being unreasonable), he has explained his reasons (or at least some of them), it is his money, his children, and his decision. Lots of posters have explained why his decision might not be the best. Doesn't help though unless he is prepared to mull through options with you. If you have an otherwise good relationship and you don't share parenting or resources, then maybe this isn't the (admittedly rather expensive) hill to die on. I am sorry though for the lack of parity in what your child will get and what his children will get, this is difficult for every parent to have to explain this, whether it is christmas presents, holidays or whatever. Wishing you the best xxxx

PickAChew · 18/01/2024 23:47

And use cars don't necessarily break down. We've just replaced a 12 year old card that we've had from nearly.new. Mechanically sound but showing the signs of aging you'd expect from doing over 100k in the good old British weather.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 18/01/2024 23:37

Lippitymoo · 18/01/2024 16:54

This is a non issue - the kids have probably met all of 6 times in the last 3 years, we aren’t a blended family, we don’t do family holidays etc.
I parent my way, he parents his.

So you just answered your own question. He’s parenting his way.

GellerYeller · 18/01/2024 23:33

I have a small engined newish car. My insurers did not want to quote to add a newly passed teen as a learner driver to my policy. They recommended some specialist insurers who would. It was still more cost effective to buy a small second hand car and insure a newly qualified driver in their own name. Sadly. It’s not always a case of parents being extravagant. Most of our friends have done the same.

Fizbosshoes · 18/01/2024 23:30

Im surprised that so many posters are comparing brand new v old banger....theres literally a whole range of cars in between...if you buy brand new will you replace in 2 years in case its unreliable ...in which case why would a 2 year old car not be ok?

Of course its up to the individual, and people buying second hand cars rely on a certain amount of people buying new but theres some very black and white thinking here eg if its not brand new its liable to break down or be unreliable!

iamjustwinginglife · 18/01/2024 23:25

"I parent my way, he parents his"

Then it's none of your concern. His money, his kids, his business.

SleepQuest33 · 18/01/2024 23:21

I’m with you OP, ridiculous sounds like the right assessment

Bouledeneige · 18/01/2024 23:15

It does sound very extravagant.

The average insurance for a teen is now £3K - that's without adding a big engine. I think it's quite irresponsible to give young men fast cars..... there's a reason why the insurance is astronomical.

Klcak · 18/01/2024 23:15

did i read they'll still have 300 grand each?
I don't think a new little car costing 20 grand is much of an issue, if that's the case!!

Paw2024 · 18/01/2024 23:04

I had a small engine, Fiat uno as a first car. Safe but cheap
My dad said if I drove it for a year with no speeding tickets, no crashes, no parking tickets, basically nothing then we would look at changing it
Probably the best thing as I drove incredibly safely! Then I got another car but that's a whole other story

Lonelycrab · 18/01/2024 21:40

Regardless of if he can afford it or not, I think it send out the wrong message. What’s next, buy the children a house each? Even if I was on a massive six or seven figure salary I wouldn’t do that.

There’s nothing wrong with driving something a few years old with low mileage.

As has been said, it’s not really your decision, but I think to voice how unreasonable it is, isn’t necessarily a bad thing, because it is.

AliMonkey · 18/01/2024 21:36

I agree. Much more sensible to buy one used car for them to share, that itself plus driving lessons would still be generous. We could absolutely have afforded to buy DD a new expensive car but did the sensible thing of buying a used small car (as ours not suitable to learn in) as a family car that she could use. If she doesn't come home after uni and a car makes sense then she can use her child trust fund to buy one, or we might help her out to buy one then, but makes no sense to do it when they start off!

ExtremelyJoyous · 18/01/2024 21:34

Anyone buying a brand new car is silly imo! A few years old makes more sense and a smaller engine is better for a 17 year old!

Boomboomshakeshaketheroom · 18/01/2024 21:30

If I could easily afford to buy my teens lovely new cars I would have done it.

Unfortunately the only option was old cheap ones with the small amount of money they and I were able to scrape together, and they've been nothing but trouble.

Also, if I found my 'partner' outlining my personal situation and slagging off my parenting decisions on a forum like this, I'd dump him.

phoenixrosehere · 18/01/2024 21:26

Unless he’s using shared finances between you two for it, which it reads like he’s not, it’s really none of your concern.

You parent your way and he parents his way and neither of you are involved with each other’s kids nor live together and are not a blended family. You’re welcome to see it as ridiculous but it is his money and he is welcome to do what he wants the same way as you are.

Mumof1andacat · 18/01/2024 21:24

Who will pay for the lessons and the insurance?

Lonelycrab · 18/01/2024 21:18

And as for bigger engine for a newly passed teen? Look at insurance per year- it’ll be crippling.

Lonelycrab · 18/01/2024 21:17

No I don’t think buying a new car for a teen that’s just passed is reasonable- they’re really bad value anyway regardless of your age or if you’ve just passed.

RM2013 · 18/01/2024 21:11

I guess lots of divided opinions on this . Eldest DS is 19. Passed his test last week. We paid for a chunk of his lessons, he funded the rest. He’s on a gap year so working full time at the moment. We weren’t financially in a position to buy him a car but his grandparents gave all the GC some money a few months ago from some inheritance they had. DS is using his money to buy a car and insure it. Funnily enough he’s bought a Hyundai i10 but it’s a few years old.
I probably would have bought them a car if I could but don’t think I’d have bought new.

personally I think it’s better to get a cheaper car to start off with and then they can work their way upwards if they want to do so.

hellsBells246 · 18/01/2024 21:10

It's a nice gesture but with such a big purchase, I'd tell my Dc so they can choose the car they'd like! And they might like different cars.

I'd also buy second hand for better value, and I'd think about insurance costs. Has he checked how much they will be to insure?

An automatic isn't a great idea. A manual is more practical.

But he sounds very generous, and as if his heart is in the right place.

Swipe left for the next trending thread