Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never move from my starter home?

59 replies

namechange59482 · 18/01/2024 11:56

We bought our house 6 years ago as a starter home. It's a 3 bedroom terrace with a garden. The third bedroom is a box room so is tiny. Since we have moved in we have had two DC a girl and boy.
It's in a good location for us very close to schools and reasonable distance to both our parents.
With it being an old house there have been a few issues and we have had to spend more than we wanted. We have now discovered another issue which is going to cost us.
I have looked at the market if we ever move we atleast would want 3 reasonable sized rooms and to stay within the area. The issue is whilst we could possibly afford the mortgage of a bigger house it would be our absolute maximum. At the moment we have managed to spend on this house because we have the equity to occasionally borrow abit and also have been able to save. We will definitely need to borrow for this latest issue.
I feel it has come to the point now we either move or spend. I do feel really we have no choice but to stay here. If we choose to sell the buyer would probably try to knock a lot off the price. I'm also concerned if we did move there is no guarantee the new house wouldn't have its own new set of issues.
The thought of how much we have may now spent on this house to move in a few years also seems ridiculous.
Would stay put in these circumstances?

OP posts:
Lindy2 · 19/01/2024 09:14

A 3 bed house isn't a starter home. For many people that's their long term family home. Starter houses are usually 1 or 2 beds.

Your issue is the small box room. Could a loft conversion be done at some point? Put a larger bedroom and wc in the loft. The box room could be an office/spare room/have the loft stairs in it - depending on your layout.

Your home sounds fine to me particularly as you like the location.

GOODCAT · 19/01/2024 09:06

We stayed in our first place for a very long time. We only moved to be closer to where we were spending our lives, but that was more expensive. Hopefully we will only move once more when I retire.

Moving is expensive and pointless unless you are making a massive gain from doing it. I would have paid off the mortgage long ago if we hadn't moved and would have far more saved for retirement which becomes a much bigger focus as you get closer.

OvercookedSmile · 19/01/2024 08:57

@BeaRF75 This is exactly what we did, it’s not a teeny starter home it’s a 3 bed semi but we could have moved to a big detached. Been here for 25 years and paid the mortgage off about 15 years ago. Now we are looking at early retirement and should be able to by the time we are both 59, we could now at both 55 but seems a bit young. Four of us lived here, now three. Next door raised three children in their house. Our actual road is such a nice road. Longest resident has been here since 1932 as it was her parents house that’s exceptional but many people that are immediate neighbours have been here at least 20 years, next door are at 40 years.

It’s really who’s in a house that makes a home and not the bricks and mortar.

Athrawes · 19/01/2024 08:52

Attic extension?

IggOrEgg · 19/01/2024 08:48

Stay put for now, if something changes in the future, you can always move then. There’s no law that says you have to move house every X amount of years/once you’ve had Y amount of children!
DPIL are still in the (2 double and a box room!) home they bought as their ‘starter home’ just before they married, over 35 years ago. It’s seen them have and raise three sons, who’ve now all moved out of course, and they’re still very happy there.

Urcheon · 19/01/2024 08:44

TraitorRoundTable · 18/01/2024 13:00

You are a new build, marketing persons dream! Starter home, ie you must move to the next level up with us.

Exactly.

Ask yourself who benefits from the idea of the ‘starter home’ and the perceived obligation to move up the ‘housing ladder’ and then ‘downsize’ like it’s some kind of compulsory life process, like ageing and taxes?

Live where and how suits you. Move house because you want or need to, not because you think you’re ’supposed to’.

Hankunamatata · 19/01/2024 08:32

We got stuck in our starter home during the housing crash a few years ago. I'm glad we stayed put tbh. Much cheaper to run, mortgage nearly paid off.

Runnerduck34 · 19/01/2024 08:30

I think I would move given that one child has the Box room.
Assuming box room is really small and only big enough for a bed and chest of drawers.
Box rooms aren't really suitable for bedrooms once DC hit school age.
Of course there maybe differ definitions of box rooms!
If you can't afford it it would be different but it does sound like moving is an option so I would look at moving unless you can go up into the loft.

BiddyPop · 19/01/2024 08:17

In our case, dd lived in the box room until we converted the attic and she moved up there - we needed the larger room for visitors. She was very happy there and has her bed pushed into a tiny corner in the attic.

Our house is worth more than - but is less than half the size and less than 1/3 the size respectively, of DBIL and DSIL's houses in the countryside (were in the capital city). So I feel that pain.

I would try and look at either making the box room work better with tall storage, cabin bed with study desk under it, etc. Or else seeing if the house can be adapted through moving walls, converting the attic etc to get more space in individual rooms or more rooms in total.

Shaunthesleep · 18/01/2024 14:00

It's always great to have wriggle room to deal with the unexpected.like redundancy, ill health or unplanned for expense.

Unless it was very achievable financially, I'd be thinking hard if your current home provides everything you NEED and you love the area. A new home is a step into the financial unknown.

I understand the box room isn't ideal. But many children have them. I did until I left home and I'm very tall!

Having options and breathing room can make life's hardships a bit more bearable. Which will impact your children more than a bigger bedroom.

Tittyfilarious81 · 18/01/2024 13:54

We still live in our first home and I don't think I'll ever move . We have a box room but there's ways to maximize the space to make it work really well , my DD has a box room and when empty it looks so small but with the right furniture it's great and she loves it .

Trickedbyadoughnut · 18/01/2024 13:42

Me and DH have moved around because of work, but my parents stayed in a three-bed with box room and financially, it's worked really well - enough money saved for early retirement.

Kaleidoscope2 · 18/01/2024 13:27

We brought our 3 bed home as our planned starter home knowing it needed full renovation which we did in tandem with becoming parents, now looking at prices and what we would get for the money im increasingly convinced staying here long term is the way forward. Even with nursery costs, we have been able to go on holidays, pay our mortgage and save a little. Like you our issue is the 3rd bedroom being tiny, but we have done extensive work on the rest of the house and have a large kitchen diner and snug, utility and downstairs toilet which we didn't have originally so it fits us as a family. My view is we go into the loft for a bigger bedroom and lose the tiny box room as access and make it a cubby study too (which works as I'm permanently wfh) so still a 3 bed but a 3 bed that works for us.

EffieGraysDisappointingWeddingNight · 18/01/2024 13:10

Stay for now. It sounds like it suits your current financial circumstances.

Nothing to stop you from re-visiting the idea of moving in two or three years time.

Converting the attic space, if possible, sounds like a good idea.

MatildaTheCat · 18/01/2024 13:09

You aren’t making a decision now that has to be permanent.

How old are your children and do you have the potential to build up or out? Moving is so expensive and also unpredictable in terms of work you might need to do on a different house. It often makes sense to max out your first house and decide later if you need to move or not. Finances are typically better when the children are a bit older.

we started in a 3 bed terrace. Dated. After 6 years we extended the back and replaced the kitchen. A few years later we were able to do the bathroom. A bit later the windows and finally after 11 years we extended into the loft with an en suite. So then it was maxed out but a very different house.

After 13 years we were in a position to move and bought our ‘now’ house and have upgraded that over the years. Been here 22 years now. Probably should downsize now but we like it.

worth considering what you could do?

SingingSands · 18/01/2024 13:06

We are still in our first home - two double bedrooms and a box room. Raised our two children here. DD now has a single bed in the box room when she visits home from Uni, DS moved into her old bedroom when she went to Uni. He had the box room for 14 years.

If we moved now we'd have to start again with a big mortgage and I'd rather not as current mortgage only has five years left. I love my house, my garden, my street and my neighbours. Walking distance to all local amenities and beauty spots. I can sacrifice a bigger bedroom for what I gain here.

namechange59482 · 18/01/2024 13:05

Thanks everyone for your comments. I think doubt arises because of how we first saw it/ it was sold as a good first home. Also we often get comments from family about when are we moving 🙄.

I get the comments about a 3 bedroom not being a starter home. Which is true I think it's the box room that makes me see it as such. Also we are from the north in an area where we do get a lot more property for the price. I imagine this house being 3 times as much in other areas of the country!

I do like the house it will definitely need more work doing if we stay. Remodelling the bedrooms or an extension is a potential one day aswell.

OP posts:
BiddyPop · 18/01/2024 13:05

We moved from our starter house - a newbuild 3 bed semi with extended kitchen and long garden - to a 20 years old 3 bed semi with half the garden, no extended kitchen and slightly smaller rooms.

But better overall location by far.

We have extended into the back garden to get a decent 2nd reception space, closed utility cupboard with wm/td, and downstairs toilet/shower (had only 1 bathroom - had 2 and en suite in 1st house).

And converted attic, taking about 4inches from box room to make a proper staircase. Very good sized attic room, and box room could have built-in platform bed but we use it as a decent office/study.

We're there more than 20 years now and have no plans to move (unless we downsize to a cottage in the next "village" - we're in the outskirts of a city).

If it suits you, don't be afraid to get an architect to visit and give you ideas on how to use the space better (which may involve knocking/moving walls - think Kirstie in "Love it or List it"). Building work is messy but very doable and well worth making somewhere that works for you externally work even better for you internally.

TraitorRoundTable · 18/01/2024 13:00

You are a new build, marketing persons dream! Starter home, ie you must move to the next level up with us.

Kendodd · 18/01/2024 12:49

I thought you were going to talk about a one bed flat

cadburyegg · 18/01/2024 12:47

Your house sounds lovely. The only issue I would have is that a box room may not be big enough for a teenager. Whether or not it is worth moving for that is up to you.

Tiredalwaystired · 18/01/2024 12:44

We bought sixteen years ago. It was never intended to be our forever home. It was meant to be somewhere we could easily afford if I went part time for a few years after having kids (which I did). Unfortunately the market ran away in the first few years and I can’t justify the hundred (possibly hundreds) thousand pounds more for a few more square feet, especially when you factor in stamp duty. So we’ve done our best to make the house fit our needs and we have built an en suite attic room, a garden office and knocked through a kitchen diner. Is it what I would chose in a dream world? No. Is it comfortable enough for us to afford and works for us as a family? Yes.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 18/01/2024 12:42

I guess it depends. If the third bedroom is tiny and there's nothing to do to improve it then it's worth doing.
When we sold our last house, the buyers didn't have anything but a bare minimum survey. The issues you are worried about might not come up.
You can pay for a proper survey on your purchase. With experience you probably have a better idea of what to look for.
I'd get an agent to value yours and have a proper think about pros and cons.

TitaniasAss · 18/01/2024 12:39

Why would you be unreasonable to stay in a home that you like? Of course, stay.

persisted · 18/01/2024 12:38

My parents still live happily in the first house they bought in 1982.
If it suits you and it meets your needs why wouldn't you stay?
Moving is a pain in the neck.